|
Post by thwhtguardian on Dec 7, 2014 21:11:04 GMT -5
Hellboy: Pyramid of DeathHellboy Animated: The Black Wedding(2007) Written by Tad Stones Art by Fabio Laguna colors by Michael Mason Year: 1947 Summary: Kicked out of the Proffessor's office Hellboy goes back to his room to listen to the latest episode of the Lobster Johnson radio program. In the Lobster's latest adventure a fiend known as the Crimson Pharaoh is holding New York ransom with the threat of his uranium fueled Pyramid Bomb, but the Lobster is having none of it and leaps through the highrise window to dispense the harsher justice of the Lobster's claw! However, despite the Lobster's best efforts the Pharaoh manages to escape at the end of the episode, ispiring the young Hellboy to don a pair of flight goggles and take to the night in search of justice. In his search for adventure Hellboy stumbles across an experiment that hopes to extract the consciousness out of a mummy. As the apparatus powers up the mummy begins to speak revealing tantalizing information about using levitation to build the pyramids, but seeing the pyramid shaped engine and the mummy Hellboy thinks its the work of the Crimson Pharaoh and so before the reanimated mummy can devulge his secrets Hellboy bursts through the window and destroys the machine powering the mummy and ruining the experiment in the process leaving Hellboy to be escorted back to his room by a pair of MP's.
Review: While the other little Hellboy stories gave us equal measures of humor and plays on characterization this story skewed more towards action and I think it made for a forgettable chapter. We don't learn anything new about Hellboy, and there are no easter eggs about the larger Hellboy universe so it ends up feeling empty which is sad as Hellboys early years are perfect canvas for bridging gaps in the universe. The art is fun though, and I love Hellboy's home made Lobster costume so it isn't a total loss.
Grade: C+
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Dec 8, 2014 13:37:22 GMT -5
Were going to be in a bit of a sticky wicket in a short while here, as the new on going Hellboy and the BPRD has started which takes place in the past(starting in 1954) so there may be a little jumping around time wise as I'll review those books as they are published. There are 5 issues set in 1954, the first of which just came out last week(and it was awesome!), and around this time next year there will be another 5 issue mini set in 1955.
|
|
shaxper
CCF Site Custodian
Posts: 22,860
|
Post by shaxper on Dec 8, 2014 16:19:24 GMT -5
Were going to be in a bit of a sticky wicket in a short while here, as the new on going Hellboy and the BPRD has started which takes place in the past(starting in 1954) so there may be a little jumping around time wise as I'll review those books as they are published. There are 5 issues set in 1954, the first of which just came out last week(and it was awesome!), and around this time next year there will be another 5 issue mini set in 1955. I'd imagine one of the unique challenges you'll face with this thread is that there will always be stories that go back to the past, especially as Young Hellboy is so damn much fun. Yes, Young Hellboy, this project really is turning out to be a circus
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Dec 8, 2014 19:32:33 GMT -5
Were going to be in a bit of a sticky wicket in a short while here, as the new on going Hellboy and the BPRD has started which takes place in the past(starting in 1954) so there may be a little jumping around time wise as I'll review those books as they are published. There are 5 issues set in 1954, the first of which just came out last week(and it was awesome!), and around this time next year there will be another 5 issue mini set in 1955. I'd imagine one of the unique challenges you'll face with this thread is that there will always be stories that go back to the past, especially as Young Hellboy is so damn much fun. Yes, Young Hellboy, this project really is turning out to be a circus Ha yeah, I had a bit of forsight on this topic though so I've been labeling each story by year so when things start to go back and forth the order will be clear. One thing I'd like to do over the the next couple of weeks is to try and make the specific blurbs on the time line on the first page actually link to their corresponding reviews, I know you could do that at CBR but I haven't really played around enough here to know if I can do the same here. And yes, the circus is coming soon!
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Dec 10, 2014 22:48:31 GMT -5
BPRD: 1947 #4Written by Mike Mignola and Joshua Dysart Art by Gabriel Bá and Fábio Moon Colors by Dave Stewart Edited by Scott Allie
Summary: In an epilogue of sorts we get a flash back of Bruttenholm hiring Anders after his military discharge where we get the story he refused to tell the others in the first issue of how he survived being stranded at sea. This flashback is broken by a telephone ringing in the present, it's Stegner calling Bruttenholm who tells the professor about the chateau and the coffins with the twin girls. Bruttenholm tells Stegner to hold position while he consults his books, and as he tries to uncover where the Breznia sisters and hopefully Anders might be Varvara appears out of no where to taunt him while recounting the story of the twin vampire princesses. Hellboy however interrupts the story, barging into the office and wondering why his father is talking to himself, but instead of answers he just thrown out of the office. And finally on the last few pages we see Stegner lead a party of soldiers on a raid in Austria where they stake the sisters who appear as little more than skeletons but find that Anders has been bitten many times. And so they race him back to the US hoping Bruttenholm can save him from becoming a vampire. Review: After the hyper compressed story telling we got last time this was a much needed respite. With the rest of the team dead we finally get some time devoted to developing Stegner and Anders, which was sorely needed. Both men are very much haunted, but both remain unique as Stegner is haunted by the lives he took as a soldier while Anders is troubled by his own self degredation that he faced while surviving in the life raft at sea. Though both are internal wounds suffered during the war there is a definite contrast between them, a sort of internal/ external play that adds a lot of pathos to the characters with out feeling cliche. On top of that you get a look at why Bruttenholm seems to favor these "damaged" soldiers and the weight that he feels on his shoulders when placing them in the field, it's very human and definitely the highlight of the story so far. Of minor note we also meet Archie Muraro, who is an airman who befriends Hellboy and becomes a mentor down the line. Grade: A
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Dec 11, 2014 18:42:27 GMT -5
BPRD: 1947 #5Written by Mike Mignola and Joshua Dysart Art by Gabriel Bá and Fábio Moon Colors by Dave Stewart Edited by Scott Allie Summary: With the sisters slain and Anders safe back in the States, Professor Bruttenholm discovers that despite all his learning he is out of his depths in oractical knowledge such as how to heal Anders from his multiple vampire bites and so he summons his old mentor Father Ota Benga who is a skilled exorcist. Stegner is dismayed that Bruttenholm is entrusting Anders' life to a priest mumbling prayers and shaking talismans rather than a skilled physician but Ota points out that because of the supernatural nature of the injuries that there must then be a supernatural cure. As Ota chants over Anders' prone body his spirit mingles with Anders' own and he sees that the though their bodies were destroyed their spirits live on in Anders where they continue to torture him. As the prayers continue Ota produces a flaming sword and begins to force the spirits of Katherina and Annaliese through a door that he cuts into the void of Anders' spirit. However, just as it seems to be going Ota's way Hellboy enter's the room and his presence causes Ota to lose his focus and in the spectral plane the sister press their advantage and strike back at Ota, tearing off his hood and scratching at his face which causes wounds on the physical plane as well but with Hellboy scolded and escorted out by the Professor Ota regains control and forces the vampire sisters into the door way sealing them in with a stange symbol which also becomes carved onto Anders' chest. The exorcism complete Bruttenholm and Ota retire to the professor's office where Ota reveals that the exorcism was not wholly successful as he only managed to cage them and he wasn't sure how long it would last. As they discussed the slippery slope of battling the supernatural with the supernatural Ota brought up Hellboy and his comments eerily mirrored Varvara's own from 1946 causing some concern for the Professor. However, as Ota's car left instead of shunning Hellboy as he had in both earlier occasions Bruttenholm went out and played baseball with his son.
Review: This is by far the best issue of the bunch; I loved the switches in the art between Ba' and moon, the way it switched from panel to panel as Ota prayed in the physical and did battle on the spiritual was amazing. We had seen the subtle changes early on, and clear divisions in the middle but here we get to see the two styles side by side and the contrast is very cool to see. Narrative wise I absolutely loved Mignola's take on vampirism, in the original lore the spread of vampirism is due to the simple exchange of blood and in modern stories its been shown to be both a virus and a parasite but in Mignola's version we see that people are turned by means of spiritual conquest. Where as a lot of modern story tellers try to bring science to Dracula Mignola goes against the current which not only creates a novel approach, but also adds a new layer to the mythos while still making it feel an old thread by adding a religious current to the story. On top of that we also got more on Hellboy's nature; though he denied Varvara's assertions at the end of 1946 he was shown to be distant from Hellboy through out 1947 and with Ota's further comments on Hellboy being dangerous it seemed that Bruttenholm might further distance himself but as Ota leaves we see father and son together again which provided a nice balance of light against all the darkness in this story.
Issue grade: A Story grade: B+
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Dec 12, 2014 21:26:08 GMT -5
In the previous leg I did reviews of short stories between issues of 1947 which was fun as it gave a definite change of pace and gave me some time to reflect. In the next leg I'm thinking of introducing a new book into the mix though and I wanted to get your opinions:
how would you feel about reading about Lobster Johnson?
Though he becomes rather important later on, his adventures at this point do not affect the events of BPRD 1948 so they would not compliment the reviews in the way the little Hellboy stories did.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Dec 17, 2014 23:03:07 GMT -5
After going back and forth with myself over whether or not to include the spin offs I've decided that if I was I should start at the beginning with Edward Grey: In the Service of Angles.
Witchfinder In the Service of Angels #1Dark Horse,2009 Written by Mike Mignola Art by Ben Stenbeck Colors by Dave Stewart Year:1879
Summary: A series of grizzly murders is occurring on the streets of London and with the bodies piling up and no explanations for what is mangling these poor souls the Queen calls in her Witchfinder General, Sir Edward Grey to investigate the murders. Appearing at the scene of the latest murder, which the officers at the scene believe to have been perpetrated by either a tiger or an ape but Grey is undecided, noting only that despite the high level of violence the lack of blood shed was troubling. From the crowd gathering around the body however Grey spots someone who may be able to shed some light on the situation; a man named Lord Wellington. Back at his apartment Wellington explains to Grey that he and all the other murder victims were members of an archaeological expedition that had recently returned from a dig in the Sahara that uncovered a city that predated all known human cultures. Wellington believes that the deaths are due to a curse that they incurred by removing a strange ape like skeleton from the city and that they attempted to give away the bones in an attempt to free themselves but they have continued to die. As he is about to tell Grey who they gave the bones to though Wellington suddenly stops and as Grey turns toward him he sees a demonic ape perched on Wellington's chair with Wellington looking like a withered corpse. The demon ape attacks Grey and seems impervious to Grey's gunfire and it is only when Grey grabs up a strange bladed weapon from Wellington's desk that he is able to drive the creature away.
Review: Witchfinder #1 is a fairly straightforward tale here with an almost Rue Morgue-esque murder investigation. While this almost police procedural feeling story could feel boring it actually feels utterly entrancing. While Hellboy is often billed as the World's Greatest Paranormal Detective we seldom see any kind of footwork so seeing an investigator working the beat, asking questions and consulting with other experts feels novel. On top of that the way the Victorian crime feel of the story melded so easily with a penny dreadful horror story of a forbidden city with a curse was a joy to see. That black and white clarity of a historical drama shouldn't work with a supernatural bend but it just feels so right here.
On the art front Ben Stenbeck proves himself a very competent artist, though perhaps not quite as adept at conjuring Mignola's style as artists like Guy Davis or Duncan Fegredo. His style, though ripe with shadows has clearer lines and is much more photo realistic which stands in contrast to most of the other Hellboy stories which tend to be much more stylized. That said I think that contrast of reality and the supernatural elements is very interesting even if it different than the look we are used to.
All in all though what I find that I like the most about this issue is that the story stands on its own very well. Regardless of your past experience with Hellboy or the BPRD you can jump right into Witchfinder and not feel lost in the least.
Grade:A
|
|
Confessor
CCF Mod Squad
Not Bucky O'Hare!
Posts: 10,197
|
Post by Confessor on Dec 18, 2014 12:32:50 GMT -5
After going back and forth with myself over whether or not to include the spin offs I've decided that if I was I should start at the beginning with Edward Grey: In the Service of Angles. Will you be following this up with the Witchfinder: Lost and Gone Forever mini-series? I only ask because those comics are the only Hellboy-related comics I own and I'd like to re-read them and contribute my thoughts to this thread when you get to them.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Dec 18, 2014 16:48:54 GMT -5
After going back and forth with myself over whether or not to include the spin offs I've decided that if I was I should start at the beginning with Edward Grey: In the Service of Angles. Will you be following this up with the Witchfinder: Lost and Gone Forever mini-series? I only ask because those comics are the only Hellboy-related comics I own and I'd like to re-read them and contribute my thoughts to this thread when you get to them. I shall indeed. I mean, its John Severin so how could I skip that? I'll be doing the spin off issues in between doing Hellboy and BPRD just to break things up. In the Service of Angles will run through BPRD: 1948, then I'll be doing the Edward Grey one shot from Dark Horse Presents and then I'll probably get to Lost and Gone Forever in between issues BPRD: Vampire...so probably some time in January if I keep to a semi regular pace and I'd love to read your thoughts on it.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Dec 20, 2014 19:30:02 GMT -5
BPRD : 1948 #1Written by Mike Mignola and John Arcudi Art by Max Fiumara Colored by Dave Stewart Dark Horse, 2012 Summary: It's 1948, one year after the rescue of Agent Anders, and he is restless in the new base of operations for the BPRD in Fairfield Conneticut; fighting with other members of the team and generally being maladjusted to his post vampire attack life. Meanwhile, at a military testing facility deep in the Utah desert a group of scientists is testing a way of launching a craft into space using the power of an atomic bomb. After the first practical test of their theory the team of scientists is elated at the apparent success...except for Dr. Anne Rieu, who believes she saw something off just after the bomb detonated and because of that she refuses to go out and celebrate with the rest of her team; which in hind sight turns out to be fortuitous as the car that contained some of the celebrating scientists is found torn to shreds on the side of the road. As a team of MP's survey the scene of the crash the perpetrator returns to the scene: a giant, furry, tentacled flying monster which makes quick work of the MP's. This attack by a strange creature of course means the BPRD is called in to investigate and so Professor Bruttenholm decides to go out and head the team himself. Meanwhile, back at headquarters we find Archie Muraro, Hellboy's new found friend from 1947, searching the base for the man who stole his cigarettes. Tracking their distinctive smell he finds the culprit... and it's Hellboy! Archie smacks the cigarette away from Hellboy telling him they'll stunt his growth before explaining that if he really wants to be more adult he should try being more responcible rather than trying to smoke. The lecture delivered the two go off to play some basketball. Review: Once again, this book starts off at slow pace getting the reader re-familiarized with the different characters and the current post World War II situation. But while the slow pace was infuriating in 1947, here it feels slightly more balanced as there is some action with the moster and some great mystery involving what Dr. Anne Rieu saw and a really great scene with a now four year old Hellboy who now thinks pancakes are "kid-stuff". What's probably the most interesting part of this issue, at least plot wise, is its focus in America and it's almost 50's B-Movie sci-fi vibe. Which is an interesting departure from 1946 and 1947 which took place in Europe and had a pulp adventure vibe and a classic Hollywood horror vibe respectively which makes the sci-fi twist a play on the shifting tastes seen in pop culture during the time these books are meant to take place The art of this book by Max Fiumara is what I’ve come to expect from this series, sketchy lines and pale colors give the book an eerie black and white sci-fi horror feeling while still being in full color which speaks to the skill of Dave Stewart. This earthy, muted color pallet not only gives it that b movie feel, but it really helps both the monster and Hellboy stand apart as both of them are presented in bright vibrant colors establishing their other-worldlyness that is just as subtle as the differences created by the brothers Ba' and Moon in 1947, while still creating a very unique look. So while this is a slow start there is enough meat to it for you to really bite into and the pacing isn't so slow as to make you flip forward impatiently but rather it is suspenseful to the point where you almost don't want to turn the page and spoil the surprise. Grade:A
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Jan 2, 2015 18:30:51 GMT -5
Witchfinder in the Service of Angels #2Dark Horse,2009 Written by Mike Mignola Art by Ben Stenbeck Colors by Dave Stewart Year: 1897 Summary: After surviving his last encounter with the strange creature Grey is brought to the scene of yet another murder, only this one is different than the others; while the other victims were merely drained of all their fluids this victim was ripped apart and strewn about the room. Sir Edward Grey is baffled by this new development until a voice in the dark tells him that he can take him to a person who can shed some light on the situation.
Thus invited Grey gives his police escort the slip and follows his guide into a shady area of London where he meets a strange man calling himself only the "Captain". The Captain is a man who seems to have his fingers in many pies, knowing all about Grey and his various secret missions along with a great many other supernatural things he claims to have learned in the 200 years he has been alive. Although, all that said the Captain claims he doesn't know who or what is behind the killings he claims he has a contact who might; a medium named Mary Wolf. Grey is suspicious of this at first, having seen a great many "table thumpers and charlatans" but as Mary enters one side of a wooden confessional a spirit appears out of the other door and when Grey opens the first he finds Mary to be a withered corpse which gives him a start but he's soon quieted as the spirit says that she merely "borrows" Mary's essence and returns it when she departs.
The spectral woman first gives Grey a riddle filled warning about his future before calling forth the spirit of Donald Blackwood who was charged with destroying the bones. Grey is perplexed by the warning about a hooded figure but is not to be deterred and so demanded his answer from Blackwood but before an answer can be gained a great knocking is head and another creature bursts onto the scene, similar to the one Grey encountered earlier only much larger.
Review: Mignola goes for an all out penny dreadful feel here complete with whispers in the dark, a mysterious benefactor and a spiritual medium. And while all those trappings are fun what I truly enjoy about the issue is the celebration of story telling we get for at its heart that's what this issue is; there's action, true, but mostly its two men sitting in a dimly lit room telling a story. It's like a class on how to tell a story by Mignola; picking your stage, establishing your credibility with your audience before wrapping them up into a world that you build before their very eyes. It's a simple thing but it's fun none the less.
On top that we get a fun bit of Victorian culture with their beliefs in spiritualism, which Grey writes off only to see for himself in the flesh. And that spirit was beautifully rendered. While the color pallet for the rest of the issue was on the muddy side, and the inks thick and moody, Zora(the spirit) was bright and the line work thin and delicate, clearly setting her apart from the rest of the world around her. That line between the natural and the supernatural is not metaphorical in the art of Mignola's books, it's a clear point of departure and the many different ways that he and his team continually employ to illustrate that point is always fun to see.
Grade: A
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Jan 2, 2015 23:09:16 GMT -5
BPRD:1948 #2Written by Mike Mignola and John Arcudi Art by Max Fiumara Colored by Dave Stewart Dark Horse, 2012 Summary: The issue starts out with Stegner and Anders on the hunt for more of the strange monsters that have been plaguing the nuclear base. As the group fires on a pack of purple, rat-lions Anders goes rogue and charges them, crossing over into the team's line of fire causing Stegner to have to tackle him out of harms way. When they get back to base Stegner attempts to get Bruttenholm to send Anders back east before he injures himself or the others but the professor brushes him off to meet with the object of his infatuation, Dr. Rieu.
To see if there might be a connection between the test blast and the plethora of monsters now swarming the dessert. They are calmly collecting soil specimens at the blast site when out of no-where a giant hulking monster appears and attacks the pair who are only saved at the last minute by the military escort that had secretly been tailing them. Back at the base they examine the creature and find that its organs are completely unknown to science; the other Doctor's look to Bruttenholm for a supernatural explanation but he tells them that the creature doesn't conform to any known demonic creature which leads to another scientist positing it might be an alien but Rieu drops the bomb, that she believes it is actually from another dimension.
Meanwhile little Hellboy and Archie are playing basket ball when Archie is called away and informed that Eisenhower is coming to the base and that he wants to meet Hellboy.
Review: Although the issue starts out with a serious action beat overall the story is much more focused on characterization. The developing relationship between Bruttenholm and Rieu is really fun to see, the two academics fumble around each other awkwardly in a beautifully natural way that feels all the more real against the back drop of the strange creatures. I don't usually go for romance plots, it's just a genre that has never appealed to me and so when it's included in other genres of fiction I usually roll my eyes feeling that it comes off as cliche and ham handed but some how Mignola convinces me to pay attention to the point where I care more about how Bruttenholm and Riue interact than either the plot about the atom bomb opening up a door to another dimension or the continuing fall out from the botched exorcism of Anders.
That isn't to say those two other plots aren't exciting, the idea of atomic explosions opening up doors to other worlds as a reason to fear the atom is a fun take on the familiar cautionary tale made famous by Godzilla and Stegner and Anders dealing with how to cope with a death wish is interesting on a much more psychological level. Is suicide truly a better option for Anders considering what he has the potential to become? And what does that imply about what Bruttenholm should be doing with Hellboy? Is that why Trevor keeps trying to save Anders, ignoring the harm he may be doing?
It's three very different plots thrown together and it shouldn't work, but it does and I love it. It's a huge departure from what came before and indeed just about every other book Mignola has ever put out but its a great read in its own right.
Grade:A
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Jan 7, 2015 22:49:40 GMT -5
Witchfinder in the Service of Angels #3Dark Horse,2009 Written by Mike Mignola Art by Ben Stenbeck Colors by Dave Stewart Year:1879 Summary: As the creature attacks Edward Grey notices that the scarring on the beast matches the wounds he inflicted in his last battle, meaning this isn't just a similar creature but is rather the same creature only mysteriously larger. Although Grey, Salt, the Captain and Dan press the attack on the beast, it simply tosses them aside seemingly set on killing Mary Wolf but by using the strange sword he uncovered earlier Grey is able to drive the beast away. As the team recuperates they learn that not all of them have made it; Mr. Salt had his arm torn off by the fleeing beast and died before anyone could get to him.
The mission to see Mary wasn't a loss though, as her spirit guide was able to locate the bones and so they hire a team to dredge them out of the river. As the diver returns to the surface with the bag of bones Grey and Mary surmise that the reason the creature was so intent to kill Mary was because she knew the location of the bones which they now believe belong to the creature. As the two stand their piecing together how the creature manifests itself a man named August Swain comes forward claiming to represent a group called the Heliopic Brotherhood of Ra which wishes to buy the bones and then threatens Grey when his offer is rebuffed.
Review: This issue probably has the best balance of action, character development and world building out of any I've yet reviewed. In a single issue we get a battle with a giant creature, we see a softer side of the hulking Dan as he mourns the passing of Mr. Salt and we get a great look at the deductive mind of Edward Grey as he draws a connection between the withered look of the explorers after being attacked and the way Mary looked as she released her spirit contact. And strongest of all we got a look at hyperborea and the difference between the usual view of Shembala and how the creature says it actually was; which was a subterranean hell rather than a paradise. These three elements are all equally strong and they work together in a very fluid way with out any one part over shadowing another.
Of note, when the captain mentions that he has been observing the Brotherhood of Ra and other such cults we also see files labeled "L.E. Caul" which was Abe Sapien's former identity.
Grade:A
|
|
Confessor
CCF Mod Squad
Not Bucky O'Hare!
Posts: 10,197
|
Post by Confessor on Jan 8, 2015 10:56:12 GMT -5
I'm thinking I might have to pick up the first Witchfinder mini-series. Some of the interior artwork that I've found in a Google Images search looks genuinely creepy. As I mentioned a few posts back, I have the Witchfinder: Lost and Gone Forever mini-series, but this first series passed me by at the time.
|
|