|
Post by wildfire2099 on Dec 1, 2016 21:23:51 GMT -5
I think I meantioned this a while back when I read this in Showcase, but I really didn't like this issue. Perhaps it was because I didn't buy the villain was a threat, or the supernatural imagery was too much for me, but I found it to be ponderous and hokey.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 1, 2016 22:36:07 GMT -5
But, encountering these as an adult, it's sort of my hope that writing these reviews will eliminate the need for anyone to track down an omnibus and read them I've been contemplating the recent omni, but this thread is making me wonder. I really love Teen Titans, but my favorite members aren't around back then so maybe I'll hold off. And then regret it once the omnibus goes OOP and they don't do a TPB version.
|
|
|
Post by Prince Hal on Dec 2, 2016 11:18:14 GMT -5
What a great review, Shax@admin! I haven't reread this in ages, but am going to dig it out from whatever box it's in and reread it.
You touch on something here that is so key in reading Silver Age comics. For many reasons beyond the control of the creators, the readers had to fill in the blanks, read between the lines, extrapolate, whatever you want to call it, to square the stories we read with the world we lived in. Thus this story was aveiled attempt to write about the emotional swings of adolescence and the very real presence of teen suicide in a time that these kinds of topics were not talked about.
Like fairy tales, and movies made before the mid-60s, which were essentially forced to rely on symbol and archetype to touch us on a deeper level, comics relied on a sub-text the readers supplied for their long-term effect. Many recent comics are far less allusive and more explicit in both style and theme, and we have become more used to that. Those who judge older films, comic stories and fairy tales by contemporary standards often fail to realize that and regard what went before as juvenile, naive and/or simplistic. That's painting with far too broad a brush.
Thanks for using a fine-point pen here, Shax!
|
|
shaxper
CCF Site Custodian
Posts: 22,874
|
Post by shaxper on Dec 2, 2016 13:49:01 GMT -5
Thanks for using a fine-point pen here, Shax! It's the English teacher in us, Hal. We can't help it
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 5, 2016 16:51:40 GMT -5
For anyone interested, in addition to the current silver age omnibus that is available now, a bronze age Teen Titans omnibus is available summer 2017. Just saw it on amazon! In addition to wrapping up the original run of Teen Titans, it says it will include World's Finest 205, Brave and Bold 94, 102, and 149. Wish they'd include Showcase 100 (not really a Titans comic, but they appear), Batman 241-242 (Robin back up story where he teams up with Lilith. Kid Flash briefly appears), and Wonder Woman 265-266 (Wondergirl back up story with a Mr. Jupiter cameo).
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 8, 2016 0:29:50 GMT -5
For anyone interested, in addition to the current silver age omnibus that is available now, a bronze age Teen Titans omnibus is available summer 2017. Just saw it on amazon! In addition to wrapping up the original run of Teen Titans, it says it will include World's Finest 205, Brave and Bold 94, 102, and 149. Wish they'd include Showcase 100 (not really a Titans comic, but they appear), Batman 241-242 (Robin back up story where he teams up with Lilith. Kid Flash briefly appears), and Wonder Woman 265-266 (Wondergirl back up story with a Mr. Jupiter cameo). I'm planning on picking that up this Summer and already pre-ordered it (about 4 days ago) and I'm looking forward seeing it.
|
|
|
Post by Prince Hal on Dec 17, 2016 16:59:23 GMT -5
shaxper, don't know if this question came up in any of those early Titans issues, but if it did, I know you would have mentioned it. But you or someone else may know: Was there ever an "official" explanation of why Supergirl never was a member of or even appeared with the Teen Titans. I'm assuming it was because she belonged to Mort Weisinger, but I wonder if any letter column or article you've read ever dealt with her omission. For whatever reason, i always saw Supergirl as jsut a little older than the original Titans were menat to be, maybe because Linda Lee Danvers was in college. So, if she was like 19 or 20, you can see why she wouldn't be hanging with 13- and 14-year-old kids. But this is my conjecture. I don't recall any explanation ever being offered. Then again, maybe no fans ever asked? Sorry to add to your workload. Between this thread and your excellent Nick Fury reviews, and everything else you do, you're a busy man.
|
|
|
Post by wildfire2099 on Dec 17, 2016 17:06:27 GMT -5
I think she's definitely older pre-crisis. Not so post-crisis, where Linda Danvers is a member of the Arsenal-led Titans.
|
|
shaxper
CCF Site Custodian
Posts: 22,874
|
Post by shaxper on Dec 17, 2016 21:03:57 GMT -5
shaxper, don't know if this question came up in any of those early Titans issues, but if it did, I know you would have mentioned it. But you or someone else may know: Was there ever an "official" explanation of why Supergirl never was a member of or even appeared with the Teen Titans. I'm assuming it was because she belonged to Mort Weisinger, but I wonder if any letter column or article you've read ever dealt with her omission. For whatever reason, i always saw Supergirl as jsut a little older than the original Titans were menat to be, maybe because Linda Lee Danvers was in college. So, if she was like 19 or 20, you can see why she wouldn't be hanging with 13- and 14-year-old kids. But this is my conjecture. I don't recall any explanation ever being offered. Then again, maybe no fans ever asked? Sorry to add to your workload. Between this thread and your excellent Nick Fury reviews, and everything else you do, you're a busy man. No problem at all. Fans asked all the time and, yes, it was answered. As you pointed out, she was in college at the time and thus DC considered her too old for the Teen Titans.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 19, 2016 10:56:24 GMT -5
Regarding the Titans' ages: My personal thoughts were that during the earlier stories (maybe Teen Titans 1-24ish) they were around 14/15/16. Teen Titans 25-53 (17/18--especially since Robin is mentioned as going off to college). Of course when NTT came along, I believe they were all around 18/19.
|
|
|
Post by Farrar on Dec 19, 2016 15:38:38 GMT -5
shaxper , don't know if this question came up in any of those early Titans issues, but if it did, I know you would have mentioned it. But you or someone else may know: Was there ever an "official" explanation of why Supergirl never was a member of or even appeared with the Teen Titans.... Then again, maybe no fans ever asked? Readers asked for Supergirl all the time (via the letter columns), as shaxper . noted. They also wanted Beast Boy, Speedy and--almost as soon as she was introduced in the Aquaman comic--Aquagirl to join the TT (never mind that she like, her beau, didn't actually have any "powers"). Readers wanted almost any DC teenage superhero who was in the 20th century to join the Titans. As a kid it seemed so simple back then: we want so-and-so to join the team. We didn't take into consideration that perhaps the artists didn't want to draw more than an XX number of regular characters; or we had only a vague awareness of the DC editorial territorial fiefdoms. But boy those lettercols were full of suggestions! I don't recall the first issue number of TT I ever read, but I distinctly remember the letters were about Speedy. I hadn't the slightest idea of who he was or what his power-set was--I mean, Speedy? What kind of superhero nom de plume was that?
|
|
|
Post by Prince Hal on Dec 19, 2016 16:04:36 GMT -5
shaxper , don't know if this question came up in any of those early Titans issues, but if it did, I know you would have mentioned it. But you or someone else may know: Was there ever an "official" explanation of why Supergirl never was a member of or even appeared with the Teen Titans.... Then again, maybe no fans ever asked? Readers asked for Supergirl all the time (via the letter columns), as shaxper . noted. They also wanted Beast Boy, Speedy and--almost as soon as she was introduced in the Aquaman comic--Aquagirl to join the TT (never mind that she like, her beau, didn't actually have any "powers"). Readers wanted almost any DC teenage superhero who was in the 20th century to join the Titans. As a kid it seemed so simple back then: we want so-and-so to join the team. We didn't take into consideration that perhaps the artists didn't want to draw more than an XX number of regular characters; or we had only a vague awareness of the DC editorial territorial fiefdoms. But boy those lettercols were full of suggestions! I don't recall the first issue number of TT I ever read, but I distinctly remember the letters were about Speedy. I hadn't the slightest idea of who he was or what his power-set was--I mean, Speedy? What kind of superhero nom de plume was that? I remember the cries for Speedy, too as well as Beast Boy, now that you mention it. Guess the calls for Supergirl slipped my mind. So true about the readers' complete lack of understanding about how things worked in those days. Like don't you think if for some reason, Supergirl had not been under Mort Weisinger's aegis that she would have at least made a guest apearance in an issue of TT? Come to think of it, she made very few appearances outside of Action. Occasional guest appearances in WF, LL, and Jimmy Olsen. Off the top of my head, the one B and B appearance with Wonder Woman is the only non-Superman family title I can recall. She was not even a frequently used Legionnaire; Superboy was the headliner and two "Super"-types was probably thought to be too much and possibly confusing.
|
|
|
Post by Farrar on Dec 19, 2016 16:59:40 GMT -5
I remember the cries for Speedy, too as well as Beast Boy, now that you mention it. Guess the calls for Supergirl slipped my mind. So true about the readers' complete lack of understanding about how things worked in those days. Like don't you think if for some reason, Supergirl had not been under Mort Weisinger's aegis that she would have at least made a guest apearance in an issue of TT? Come to think of it, she made very few appearances outside of Action. Occasional guest appearances in WF, LL, and Jimmy Olsen. Off the top of my head, the one B and B appearance with Wonder Woman is the only non-Superman family title I can recall. She was not even a frequently used Legionnaire; Superboy was the headliner and two "Super"-types was probably thought to be too much and possibly confusing. Yes, Supergirl could have conceivably appeared as a guest star anyway had she not been yoked to Weisinger. Though--as you then pointed out--on the whole she doesn't seem to have been a very popular character (outside of her insular Action Comics back-up world). But as a full-fledged, regularly-appearing TT member? Nope. Her power-set was much too similar to Wonder Girl's. Now had Supergirl been thrown into the mix from the start, who knows? The WG who was concocted for the TT may never have existed! Back then the convention was typically one female per team, though the Metal Men and the Avengers at the time had more than one. I for one loved it when Superboy and Supergirl together appeared in the Legion; I bought the explanation, hook line and sinker.
|
|
shaxper
CCF Site Custodian
Posts: 22,874
|
Post by shaxper on Jan 8, 2017 14:00:18 GMT -5
Teen Titans #15 Script: Bob Haney Pencils: Lee Elias Inks: Nick Cardy Colors: ? Letters: Morris Waldinger grade: c- For the first eleven issues of this magazine, all under the editorial oversight of George Kashdan, the Titans followed an extremely regimented format and scope in which, adventure after adventure, some government agency would call upon them to help wayward youth see the wisdom of the adult status quo and turn away from the forces of corruption that were manipulating them (always an adult criminal). Only now do I realize this formula began to relax and change at exactly the time that editor George Kashdan began writing for The Superman Aquaman Hour animated series out in California (where Filmation was located). I'd imagine Kashdan was no longer as present/involved at DC once that work began. And now, with Dick Giordano taking over for Kashdan as of this issue, everything changes once more. In one respect, this new approach includes a return to the old structure, rejecting the potential of new criminal menaces in favor of the Titans setting out to (once more) find and help a wayward teen who is trying to grow up too quickly and is falling under the influence of adults with shady motives as a result. But beyond that, there is a sense of utter newness in this issue. While hippie culture had been presented in previous issues as a sort of abstract ideal -- teens talked like them, and a few dressed like them, but that was the full extent of it -- Hippieism is a real and tangible thing here, the Titans and the teen they seek out both little more than tourists in an utterly exciting but foreign world of counter-culture: That tangibility permeates the very pages of this issue, infusing Elias' panel arrangements with a far-out hippie flow that is only violated once the bad guy shows up at which point the panels revert to (ironically enough) squares. The hippie culture further permeates the book with the poet-guide we are given, framing the entire tale in place of the traditional narration. Most fascinating of all, though, is Haney's treatment of the hippies themselves, portraying the riskier, cautionary elements of the counter-culture movement along with examples of upstanding hippies who live by their ideals and radiate a clear sense of right and wrong: Haney isn't interested in judging this movement, either positively or negatively. Instead, he provides an even-handed exploration and leaves us with a surprising moral by the close: Hippieism isn't good or bad; it's right for some people. But if it isn't right for you, you can always turn back. Bold and unexpected stuff. So where did all of this come from? In the letter column, new editor Dick Giordano seems hesitant to make any bold new decisions right away, so was this Haney simply taking advantage of Kashdan's absence, or was there something larger at play at the DC Offices? Could it be that the publisher was finally moving away from the idea that their target audience was a 12 year old boy living in Dayton Ohio? Maybe they were finally noticing the amount of readers Marvel was picking up by catering to a somewhat older audience -- an audience that wanted less lectures on how to be a good citizen and more exploration of the forbidden counter-culture that fascinated and enticed them. Consider that this idea of treating Hippieism like a fascinating foreign culture, deeply embedding our characters within it along with motorcycle-riding skinheads whose only motivation in life seems to be hurting hippies, all feels weirdly prototypical of Brother Power The Geek, a DC series that will debut three months later, even though it shares none of its creative team with that of the Teen Titans and is edited by a different office. Sure seems like there was a larger shift in scope occurring at DC; a desire to engage an older readership that was beginning to turn away from simplistic books written for 12 year olds; a readership that might well have been fascinated by the forbidden temptations of the counter-culture movement. As for the plot itself, it's entirely forgettable. The teen seeking coolness/independence and getting caught up in a corrupt world of danger and doom has been done to death in these pages, and I don't recall Captain Rumble even having anything to do with the A plot. Seems like he just showed up to cause havoc and eventually got stopped. Honestly, the plot was so painfully boring that my attention wandered several times, so I can't be entirely sure of this. Still, this issue's approach in general, that was pretty bold and respectable. Minor Details: - Giordano acknowledges the old fan complaint that Aqualad is too conveniently served bodies of water most issues, as well as the old fan request that Speedy join the team. He will solve both matters within the year by (finally) replacing Aqualad with Speedy on the Titans' roster. - Captain Rumble literally shatters the Teen Titans logo on the cover. Gaspar Saladino will spend the next three issues toying with new logos before settling upon a new one in issue #19. Plot synopsis: The Titans are called upon to track down a missing runaway teen who has left home to join the counter-culture movement and has fallen in with criminals in the process. The criminals are trying to find and kill him after a botched delivery of goods, and the Titans must find and save him while also dealing with Captain Rumble and his Hippie-hating biker gang. Surprise; It all works out in the end.
|
|
shaxper
CCF Site Custodian
Posts: 22,874
|
Post by shaxper on Jan 8, 2017 21:15:43 GMT -5
Teen Titans #16 "The Dimensional Caper!" Script:Bob Haney Pencils:Nick Cardy Inks:Nick Cardy Colors:? Letters:Joe Letterese grade: A- Whereas last issue felt like the beginning of a new direction for the Teen Titans title, this one feels like a return to the kind of extra-dimensional scope and tone achieved in #14. Coincidence that both issues were penciled by Nick Cardy? Don't get me wrong. If I were working with Cardy, I'd let the man do whatever he wanted too, but I'd always assumed the writers called the shots at DC. So this issue feels a lot like a previous one, and that's fine since #14 was probably the best Titans issue to date. This one is nearly as strong, with Cardy's layouts continuing to mature and pioneer new approaches to visual storytelling: and his own inking over his pencils eliciting the murkiest of possible tones: It's just so damn beautiful, in a spooky sort of way. And yet, this story borrows more from #14 than just Cardy's visuals. For the first time EVER in Teen Titans history, we have a significant (not just incidental) reference to past continuity, coincidentally enough stemming from issue #14: Robin has not forgotten the most devastating and solitary adventure he's ever experienced, and he's clearly changed by it as well, recalling the pain he felt when the Titans made unfair judgments about him in that story. WOW. Beyond all of this, in spite of a ludicrous plot about aliens trying to infiltrate the Earth beginning with a single high school, this thing is paced incredibly well and continues to throw fun surprises at us, beginning like any other Titans adventure in which they are there to help a troubled teen, shifting gears to transport the Titans into a terrifying alternate dimension, further complicating things when the two dimensions begin blurring and the threat is thus brought to the high school, and culminating in Kid Flash attempting to run fast enough to cross the dimensional threshold and rescue the endangered teen. The ludicrous basic concept aside, the plotting itself is masterful. Yet another early Teen Titans almost-masterpiece. Department of Aquatic Desperation:I was ready to retire this department, but I guess Haney had to throw Aqualad a bone after three issues of inactivity. Oh, he tries to make it up to us. I loved this early scene in which he has Aqualad utilize water against the villains WITHOUT using it as an excuse for Aqualad to exercise his powers: It's a cute tease and nod to the readers who had frequently written in, complaining of the convenient bodies of water Aqualad would always run into. Of course, Haney does give Aqualad a convenient pool from which to beat the bad guys to a pulp later on: I guess Aqualad has to be allowed to get in the water sometimes. At least he's not conveniently finding adjacent lakes and coastlines in landlocked towns anymore. Department of Worrying About Wondy:Haney is similarly good about not giving Wonder Girl those disturbingly vapid boy-crazy traits anymore, but Cardy is back to sexualizing this minor with awkward good-girl poses once again: I mean, couldn't we have at least included her head in that last frame, Nick? Minor Details:- Legendary letterer Gaspar Saladino is having fun playing with new title logos for this and the next three issues after Captain Rumble literally shattered the old one last issue. - Cei-U! notes that the Titans have a new Titancopter in this issue. Plot synopsis: The Titans are summoned to help a boy who an entire town believes is losing his mind after he became convinced he visited an alternate dimension in which aliens were plotting to take over this world. The Titans investigate and discover the aliens residing in an alternate version of the boy's high school, led by their principal (who is actually a plant from the invasion fleet). Right now, only the principal is able to cross the dimensional barrier because he is a mutant, but they are developing a machine to enable them all to cross and conquer Earth. Kid Flash speeds through the machine in order to destroy it, but that only causes the realities to blur together, as the Titans race down populated high school hallways fighting aliens. The Titans are sent back and the gateway is destroyed, forcing Kid Flash to run fast enough to cross the barrier on his own and rescue the troubled youth they were sent to help. The alternate high school is destroyed and the threat is ended.
|
|