|
Post by thwhtguardian on Dec 6, 2016 21:10:02 GMT -5
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Dec 7, 2016 14:53:54 GMT -5
Deadman: Dark Mansion of Forbidden Love #2Written by Sarah Vaughn Art by Lan Medina Colored by Jose Villarrubia Break downs (chapter 4) by Phil Hester Summary: Drawn to an old house by a disturbance in Spectral plain Deadman now finds himself trapped inside and the mystery runs deeper than he thought.
Plot: Man, Sarah Vaughn's moody Deadman story continues to impress. Too often Deadman stories come out feeling like an action or detective story and while those types of stories can be fun they often miss the fundamental nature of the character...he's a ghost and as such lends himself perfectly to ghost stories. Most people think bumps in the night and dusty mansions when they think ghost stories but Vaughn understands that at their best they are more than that, that ghosts aren't simply screams in the night but metaphors for doubt, regret and emotions that are repressed by the boundaries of society. In this issue Vaughn looks into exploring regrets and doubts and gender identity all in one fell swoop. The characterizations are rich and emotional turmoil is beautiful. The pacing may be slow and the only action appears in the final scene but that is intentional as it gives it a great Gothic feel.
Art: The complex range of emotions that Medina manages to express through the characters faces and body language continues to amaze and the inky blacks and muted oil based looking color scheme that Villarrubia uses is a perfect pairing for the feel of the book. The credits list Phil Hester as being behind break downs in the second half of the book and I anticipated there being some kind of subtle tonal change in the art that Hester's style would signal but if his name wasn't listed I wouldn't have known as there was no difference in the art. I'm not sure why Hester was brought in but it's a shame he wasn't used better.
Conclusion: This tale of Gothic romance continues to be thrilling, it's so utterly unlike any other book out there that you need to read it to believe it.
Grade: 10/10
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Dec 7, 2016 16:21:55 GMT -5
Jim Henson's the Storyteller: Giants #1Written and Illustrated by Conor Nolan Summary: A kindly old couple prays to the gods for a child and their prayers are answered by...a giant peach and an equally giant baby. Though kindly he shunned by the villagers until he defeats a horde of ogres. Plot: For fans of Stan Sakai's Usago Yojimbo (specifically V.3 #25 shaxper)Conor Nolan's fairy tale about a boy born from a peach should sound very familiar indeed as both are based on the same Japanese folk tale Momotaro. It's a fairly straightforward story and there are dozens from other cultures with similar themes and devices, which Carl Yung would say supported his collective unconscious though I think just points to the fact that ancient people probably just moved about more often than we think and they brought their stories with them. One thing that is unique to this version though is the fact that the son was giant, an interesting inversion of the Thumbelina and Tom Thumb stories, and instead of teaching simple moral lessons like the traditional Japanese version Nolan instead focuses on the journey of finding a home and sense of self which is a great modern update. That said I'm a little disappointed that Conor never attributed this story to the original folktales he based it on, perhaps he felt that the works he was using for inspiration were so well known that it would be understood that he was just retelling them like the storyteller himself in the story, but still I think a reference would have been nice as it was from Stan Sakai's reference that I found out about the story and I imagine that for many western readers this could be their first exposure to the story as well. Art: The failing of attribution aside Nolan's work is impressive in that he not only tells the story but illustrates it and colors it as well. And while there is nothing flashy about his composition or lay out in his visual story telling that fits the nostalgic feel of a fairytale being told by a fire perfectly. Conclusion: Although straightforward and lacking some of the nuances of other versions of the story Nolan tells a heart warming tale none the less that truly feels like a fairytale. Grade: 7/10
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Dec 7, 2016 19:28:41 GMT -5
Unworthy Thor #2Written by Jason Aaron Art by Oliver Coipel Colored by Matt Wilson Summary: Crushed by the loss of his home Thor teams up with Beta Ray Bill to uncover the mystery of Asgard's disappearance and the location of the Ultimate Thor's hammer.
Plot: In Aaron's second chapter in the redemption of the Odinson we get a fun reunification with Beta Ray Bill, some good action and a mysterious villain freeing Thanos from the Ultimate Universe. As I said previously, my knowelge of the Ultimate Universe and its fate ends with Galactus: the Hunger and in that the Ultimate Thor got sucked into the negative universe with Galactus in order to save his world. I gather that he came back during a recent even and as seen in this issue he then died. The details are not clear here but there's enough to keep you going in the story with out it feeling like an info dump. Seeing Beta Ray Bill again was neat and the collector as the thief of Asguard was a great modern element that makes this story feel like it could fit right into the Marvel cinematic universe which is a nice touch. That said, I'm not sure what the status of the Ultimate Universe is so the scene at the end there threw me for a loop, is that the present? If so how? I thought the Ultmate Universe died? Is it the past? If so when as I don't recall Thanos ever showing up there and I just reread the whole Ultimate Universe from start to finish over the summer. It's not a terrible flaw and I'm willing to let it play out on its own time but its not very new reader friendly.
Art: I love Coipel's art but I think the real star here is Matt Wilson, the color pallets he uses here are just fantastic. He has one color scheme for Thor, Beta Ray Bill and Asgard that's these muted primary colors out of an old fairy tale book and another for the space ships and the Collector's world that's all neon colors and stark blacks and whites and when the two exist on the same page the juxtaposition is somehow beautiful instead of jarring.
Conclusion: Although not very new reader friendly Aaron's yarn is compelling enough to keep you interested and the art is top notch.
Grade: 7/10
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Dec 7, 2016 22:09:19 GMT -5
Death of Hawkman #3Written by Mark Andreyko Art by Aaron Lopresti Summary: As Rann and Thannagar march closer to war Adam Strange and Hawkman investigate just what is causing the tensions.
Plot: Andreyko is still having a hard time managing the timeline in his narrative, after three issues I can sort of piece it together but it should be much easier. Also, while the last few issues were pretty new reader friendly in introducing Adam Strange and Hawkman this issue is a definite step back as it seems the instigator is Desparo and although I'm aware of who he is I'm not an expert and I have no idea how he been used recently which is an issue as this story seems to spin directly out of that. However, the mystery is still interesting and the relationship between Strange and Hawkman is still really fun to see.
Art: I think I said it the last two times but it remains true here as well...while there's nothing terrible about Lopresti's art there's nothing all that great about it either. He's competent at telling the story but there's nothing that really sings so it makes for a quick issue because there is nothing to linger over.
Conclusion: While the pacing and the great dialog between Strange and Hawkman make it easy to get into the story remains fairly pedestrian.
Grade:6/10
|
|
shaxper
CCF Site Custodian
Posts: 22,871
|
Post by shaxper on Dec 7, 2016 22:15:02 GMT -5
Mickey Mouse #15 (#324, old numbering)written and drawn by Romano Scarpa Overview: When I reviewed the last issue, I told you all how amazing Andrea Castallan was and how much you needed to be reading this comic. Well, I hope you didn't listen too well because this is not a "Casty" issue. Every few issues, IDW rotates the Casty stories with stories by Romano Scarpa, the second most well-known Mickey creator of all time (Floyd Gottfredson being the first, at least in the U.S.). But I absolutely do not understand the appeal. It's easier to keep a consistent pull for this title than try to cherry pick which issues will have Casty and which will not, and, at $4 an issue for double-length issues, it's a good enough value that I don't feel cheated, so every time there's a Scarpa story, I give it another shot. But, as of this issue, I still don't get it. Plot: So...ummm...Goofy is a werewolf. No, wait. It's more ridiculous than that. A mad scientist has turned Goofy into a werewolf in order to steal cats for him. No, wait. It's more ridiculous than that. A mad scientist has turned Goofy into a werewolf in order to steal cats for him which he will use to create a potion that turns ordinary cats into valuable exotic pets for 120 hours so that he can scam people out of their money. Because that's a logical use of science so advanced that it can chemically ascertain rare breeds of pets and instantly morph a cat into one of them at random. Best of all, by the end, nobody ever stops to reflect on the first 20 cats that gave their lives to make the formula. Both morbid AND stupid. There isn't any good action, the humor is terrible, and forget characterization unless you enjoy one-dimensional stereotypes. Art: Scarpa really enjoys giving Mickey an expressive face, but he overdoes it. Mickey is practically exploding in sweat drops several times a page for no good reason. Conclusion: There must be someone out there who can explain to you why Romano Scarpa is a legend in the field, but it sure as heck isn't me. You NEED to read the Mickey issues that have Casty stories in them. You can absolutely skip this one though. Grade: 4/10
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 7, 2016 22:21:37 GMT -5
Written by Tom DeFalco. Art and Cover by Sandy Jarrell. The New Riverdale has another hit. Like Betty & Veronica is narrated by Jughead's dog Hot Dog this title is told thru the eyes of Reggie's dog Vader. DeFalco uses this technique well as Vader's view of Reggie soften Reggie's unlikeable qualities. Reggie is still a bit of a jerk but we see part of it is because he is insecure. Most of Riverdale High is at a party at Reggie's house but they ditch the party for another one at Veronica's home. The art is perfect for this title. I can't believe how well Archie Comics has handled this relaunch. Score: 8/10.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Dec 7, 2016 22:36:03 GMT -5
I love comics told through unique perspectives so I may need to track down Reggie and Me.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Dec 7, 2016 22:38:11 GMT -5
Mickey Mouse #15 (#324, old numbering)written and drawn by Romano Scarpa Overview: When I reviewed the last issue, I told you all how amazing Andrea Castallan was and how much you needed to be reading this comic. Well, I hope you didn't listen too well because this is not a "Casty" issue. Every few issues, IDW rotates the Casty stories with stories by Romano Scarpa, the second most well-known Mickey creator of all time (Floyd Gottfredson being the first, at least in the U.S.). But I absolutely do not understand the appeal. It's easier to keep a consistent pull for this title than try to cherry pick which issues will have Casty and which will not, and, at $4 an issue for double-length issues, it's a good enough value that I don't feel cheated, so every time there's a Scarpa story, I give it another shot. But, as of this issue, I still don't get it. Plot: So...ummm...Goofy is a werewolf. No, wait. It's more ridiculous than that. A mad scientist has turned Goofy into a werewolf in order to steal cats for him. No, wait. It's more ridiculous than that. A mad scientist has turned Goofy into a werewolf in order to steal cats for him which he will use to create a potion that turns ordinary cats into valuable exotic pets for 120 hours so that he can scam people out of their money. Because that's a logical use of science so advanced that it can chemically ascertain rare breeds of pets and instantly morph a cat into one of them at random. Best of all, by the end, nobody ever stops to reflect on the first 20 cats that gave their lives to make the formula. Both morbid AND stupid. There isn't any good action, the humor is terrible, and forget characterization unless you enjoy one-dimensional stereotypes. Art: Scarpa really enjoys giving Mickey an expressive face, but he overdoes it. Mickey is practically exploding in sweat drops several times a page for no good reason. Conclusion: There must be someone out there who can explain to you why Romano Scarpa is a legend in the field, but it sure as heck isn't me. You NEED to read the Mickey issues that have Casty stories in them. You can absolutely skip this one though. Grade: 4/10 I think I must have terrible luck, as I've tried getting into the Disney comics a few times only to be disappointed. I thought I couldn't go wrong this time time with Goofy as a werewolf but as you pointed out, boy was I wrong.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 7, 2016 22:45:46 GMT -5
Conclusion: Although not very new reader friendly Aaron's yarn is compelling enough to keep you interested and the art is top notch. Grade: 7/10 I haven't read Thor for years & I never read the Ultimate titles (except Millar/Hitch Ultimates). However I am following this story well enough.
|
|
shaxper
CCF Site Custodian
Posts: 22,871
|
Post by shaxper on Dec 8, 2016 5:30:07 GMT -5
I think I must have terrible luck, as I've tried getting into the Disney comics a few times only to be disappointed. I thought I couldn't go wrong this time time with Goofy as a werewolf but as you pointed out, boy was I wrong. Casty is back for a three parter as of next issue. Don't give up!
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 8, 2016 9:14:13 GMT -5
Josie and Pussycats #3: Alexandra Cabot crashes the Pussycats' show in Cancun--complete with hoverboard (that doesn't catch on fire) and all kinds of Alexandra merchandise--even a menagerie of animals! We learn why Alexandra and Josie are enemies--from both girls' perspectives. The dialog is quick, lots of pop culture references and jokes. A crime is solved courtesy of Melody and Valerie. This series has so far been fun with nods to the former comic series as well as the cartoon. The art fits the story. Still no sign of Alexandra's brother, Alex. Alan M. is in this issue. Also a quick Josie story from 1971. 9/10
Reggie and Me #1: For some reason when I was a child I always liked Reggie better than Archie. Archie was nice and all, but for some reason I related more to Reggie and saw myself being his friend, rather than hanging with Archie and Jughead. Not that I was a jerk or anything, but Reggie just seemed more fun. Perhaps it was because Reggie acted on impulses that I did not. When wronged, his first instinct is to get even. Something most of us do not do. When I was in college, there was a guy in my fraternity that reminded me of Archie. Red-headed, lanky, goofy, but everyone loved him. I didn't quite get why and he often irritated me. In this first issue, we get a bit of background on Reggie and why he acts the way he does. The story is narrated by his dog and only true friend, Vader. We learn at some point he and Archie were good friends, but no more. The art is crisp and clean, nice colors, and a great story. Can't wait to read more and see just what Reggie has in store for the Riverdale gang. There is also a text page about Reggie as well as a classic story that looks like it is from the 40s or 50s. If you've ever read an Archie comic, check out these titles. You'll find familiar elements with a new twist. Wish I had gotten in on Archie and Jughead from their relaunches! 9/10
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Dec 8, 2016 11:30:31 GMT -5
I think I must have terrible luck, as I've tried getting into the Disney comics a few times only to be disappointed. I thought I couldn't go wrong this time time with Goofy as a werewolf but as you pointed out, boy was I wrong. Casty is back for a three parter as of next issue. Don't give up! Well, the cover certainly looks promising!
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Dec 8, 2016 12:41:35 GMT -5
Doctor Aphra #1Written by Kieron Gillen Art by Kev Walker Colored by Antonio Fabela Summary: Thought dead by Vader Doctor Aphra is free go back to her routs as a space Archaeologist looking for riches and glory. It all seems to be going so well, when she suddenly finds that her credentials have been revoked and she can no longer sell her wares.
Plot: After a fantastic run on Darth Vader Gillen returns to the land of a long time ago with this follow up to the adventures of Doctor Aphra. In Darth Vader Aphra was one of the best parts of the series, her wit and humor in the face of Vader's darkness was a fantastic contrast with out altering the tense mood. That said when it was announced she was getting her own title I was a bit mystified, sure Aphra was a fun character but her death at the hands of Vader was a perfect thematic ending that made seeing where she'd go next very cloudy. After an issue I'm still not sure where the series is going but the dialogue is fun so I'm on board for the time being.
Art: Although there wasn't a lot to go on plot wise Kev walker's art was a big bright spot. His action was smooth and clear and his visual pacing was perfect but I think my favorite element was his Moebius inspired designs for the gangster, the space ships and Aphra's father. That bright, clean look was very unique and it fits so well in the Star Wars universe that I wish Moebius himself had done a Star Wars comic.
Conclusion: While light on substance the humor, action and art were more than fun enough to keep me engaged.
Grade:7/10
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 8, 2016 13:16:43 GMT -5
Reggie and Me #1: In this first issue, we get a bit of background on Reggie and why he acts the way he does. The story is narrated by his dog and only true friend, Vader. We learn at some point he and Archie were good friends, but no more. The art is crisp and clean, nice colors, and a great story. Can't wait to read more and see just what Reggie has in store for the Riverdale gang. There is also a text page about Reggie as well as a classic story that looks like it is from the 40s or 50s. If you've ever read an Archie comic, check out these titles. You'll find familiar elements with a new twist. Wish I had gotten in on Archie and Jughead from their relaunches! 9/10 The reprint is from 1950. So far Jughead is my favorite. Archie is #2. Reggie is #3. And Betty & Veronica is #4 (only because of the BIG delays). I really never was interested in Josie.
|
|