|
Post by Deleted on May 19, 2017 9:55:22 GMT -5
My thoughts on Superman #23: Lots happening in this issue which for me was a page turner! The Kents' neighbor's true nature revealed (he's up to no good), monsters invade Hamiltion, Superboy kidnapped, lots of fights. The scene where Superman is investigating the place where Robin and the others are held and then hears Lois in trouble--the way it is drawn where Superman realizes the danger and takes off was very well done. The art and panel layout change midway through the book when the monsters attack--the art becomes darker and murky, I guess to complement the sense of dread brought on by the monsters. Wasn't expecting the reveal of this arc's big bad and am looking forward to the wrap up--and hope Lois will be ok. For me, the book of the week. 10/10 Tomasi & Abnett are writing 4 of my favorite titles of DC Rebirth (of which I am down to 7 titles from my initial 12).
|
|
|
Post by Hoosier X on May 19, 2017 11:55:09 GMT -5
This is actually the cover to #9 because I couldn't find the cover for #11 on the Internet anywhere. I like this cover better anyway. Kong of Skull Island #11This title is really starting to grow on me. It started as a six-issue mini-series, but they continued it as a regular series and I've not always been overly fond of it. I like the idea, but the execution hasn't always worked for me. But it's really started to click for me the last few months. I think I'm finally getting into the flow of what they are doing here. I pick up every issue when I have time to really take it all in, to look at it and read it carefully. I treat each issue like a movie. I stare at the opening panels until I really feel like I'm on a tropical jungle island, enduring the humidity, smelling the ocean air, hearing the mysterious sounds of the rainforest. The little girl in the palm of the giant ape on the cover of #9 is K'vanni, the daughter of Ewata, the queen of the islanders. But there is a faction that opposes Ewata's leadership and they have kidnapped Kvanni, who has had some very interesting adventures over the last few issues. The opposition to Ewata had gotten a little stale, with too much sitting around and talking, but the abduction of K'vanni and Ewata's frantic and vengeful search for her lost child on an island full of conspirators, dinosaurs and Kongs has really livened things up!
|
|
|
Post by Hoosier X on May 21, 2017 10:36:16 GMT -5
It was a pretty good week for me. I enjoyed everything I read. I bought four new comics - Astro City #44, Kong of Skull Island #11, Cerebus in Hell #4 and Cave Carson has an Electric Eye #9 - and when I read them, I really had time to focus and read every word and take the time to get into them and enjoy them. My ritual when I read the new comics is to save what I think most likely to be best for last. (This week, that was Astro City #44.) Then I try to pick something else that looks really good for the first comic because I don't want to start off with a dud. (It's been a while since I read the latest Detective Comics first or last.) In between, I then go to what looks likely to be the worst comics and read them in increasing level of quality. After I decided to read Astro City last, I looked at the remaining three comics and decided to go with Cerebus in Hell. I haven't read this title before, though I have heard of it. Kong and Cave Carson are both titles I'm disappointed with a lot of the time, making Cerebus in Hell the obvious choice. Cerebus in Hell #4Using Gustave Dore art for Dante's Inferno as a backdrop, Cerebus has been inserted into the adventure. Virgil and Dante are regular character. Every page is an independent gag. It's not for everyone. Some of the humor is childish, but there's an unmistakable charm to all of it. Some of it is pretty damn funny. And you have to have more than a passing interest in Western literature and mythology to get all the jokes. The Tetragrammaton gag - it made me laugh out loud. It's been YEARS since I thought of the Tetragrammaton. Any comic book gets a lot of points for a Tetragrammaton joke.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on May 21, 2017 12:39:04 GMT -5
Star Wars #31Written by Jason Aaron Art by Salvador Larroca Summary: Luke and Aphra find that the Queen of the Screaming Citadel's hospitality is not what they expected. Plot: Upon reading this I thought I had missed an issue, but after looking it up I realized I hadn't...Aaron seems to have been asked to postpone his story in favor of tieing into the Screaming Citadel story leaving 3P0 stuck with Vader. As a second part of the Citadel story I felt the pacing was a little off, when Kieron left off at the end of part one there was a feeling of a slow burn mystery with great horror elements but here it was more of an action set piece adventure which was very jarring. Art: Larroca has always given these books a truly cinematic feel but that was really amped up here, so much so that the characters look almost like they were taken from stills from the films. I wonder if Harrison Ford, Mark Hammil and Carrie Fisher's estate received royalties for the use of their likenesses here? Grade:6/10
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on May 21, 2017 13:22:51 GMT -5
Written by Peter J. Tomasi and Patrick Gleason. Art by Doug Mahnke and Jaime Mendoza. Cover by Ryan Sook. As all kinds of weird stuff happens all over Hamilton, Jon is forced to watch his parents in the middle of it on a TV screen. The big bad guy is revealed (it was leaked a week ago). He wants to brainwash Jon to turn against his parents to get revenge on Superman. This arc feels a little too drawn out & a bit darker than usual. However I am confident in a big payoff that will be coming. It's ironic that Mahnke is drawing this as he drew the villain's first appearance back in Action Comics #775. 8/10.Yeah, I love the symmetry of using Manchester Black here when Mahnke did the art for "What's so funny about truth, justice and the American way?". I almost thought Batman was going to be the villain at the end but Black's involvement is fun.
|
|
|
Post by String on May 22, 2017 15:34:39 GMT -5
Thoughts on issues already mentioned:
Daredevil #20 - after waiting nearly two years or so for this reveal, I have to say it's satisfying. Matt's deductions, reactions, and guilt over this fix was handled very well. I do hate to see his relationship to Kirsten end in this regard though. My only caveat is that this doesn't fully explain the level of anger that Foggy now has towards Matt. (Also, in case I overlooked it somewhere, it doesn't explain the costume change either). In fact, my only real nitpick for Soule's run so far is the conspicuous absence of Franklin 'Foggy' Nelson. 8/10
Superman #23 - an amazing issue. The level of raw emotions that are raging between Clark and Lois over finding Jon, Superman's attitude and action against Cobb was wonderful, the truth (somewhat) behind some of the townspeople, and the return of Black intent on manipulating Jon. Dark and dramatic, this arc continues to impress and entertain. 9/10
Super-Sons #4 - a very fun and satisfying end to their first adventure. Damian's smack talk to Luthor was priceless. The banter, the action, the art, all of it is nigh excellent. 8/10
Flash #22 - Flash is one of the few physical books that I still get from my LCS but I have to wait for it to come in my next shipment from them. Still, the return/appearance of Jay Garrick can only be a great thing.
|
|
|
Post by String on May 22, 2017 15:46:59 GMT -5
Teen Titans #8 - Part 2 of the Lazarus Contract.
NuWally is still upset over learning that Barry knew his father's true identity and didn't reveal it to him till after his father's death. Through flashbacks up till the present, we see how Slade manipulates NuWally's grief and wanting to reunite with his father (in a similar way that he wants his son Grant back) into getting NuWally to help him, which NuWally reluctantly agrees to.
Meanwhile, the Teen Titans, realizing that something is up with NuWally, met up with the Titans who still can't find their Wally. Friction between the teams rise more when Nightwing finally admits to striking some bargain or contract with Slade years ago in connection somehow to protecting the team. Putting that aside, using a nifty bit of logic, the teams track down Slade's hideout and find Wally, only to see that Slade has already taken advantage of NuWally's help in literally the fastest way possible.
The highlight here is the teams meeting up. The initial friction between them was nicely handled as well the acknowledgement of previous relationships (such as Roy and Starfire). Later on, as the teams split up to search Slade's hideout for the Wallys, we get glimpses of how these two distinct groups could function together and even help each other out. Overall, Benjamin Percy, lead writer of TT, does a good job with their characterizations, prompting me to think about following this title after this crossover. Art by Jonboy Meyers and Khoi Pham was clean and decent.
8/10
|
|
|
Post by String on May 22, 2017 15:58:19 GMT -5
X-Men Gold #4 - Gambit, the mutant thief we all know and love, returns for a hi-tech heist, stealing a sample of an experimental cluster of nano-bot machines. However, upon learning the heist was for the granddaughter of Bolivar Trask, Sentinel creator, Remy decides to steal the 'bots back. Things ends poorly when the 'bots accidentally break free, infecting nearby computer systems (which has Sentinel programming within it) and mutating on their own, forcing Remy to call in the cavalry of Kitty and her X-Men before it's too late.
Another straight-forward story but Guggenheim uses some good character moments to enlighten it. Early on, Kitty and the team face off against some members of the Serpent Society and the ease and maturity they exhibit in handling them was very nice to see. They're actually starting to feel like a family again. And Gambit is as charming and devious as ever. New artist RB Silva delivers some very good work.
8/10
|
|
|
Post by String on May 22, 2017 16:14:45 GMT -5
Generation X #1 - Jubliee, with son Shogo in tow, meets with Kitty about helping mentor/teach the next generation of mutant students at the school. Menawhile, new student Nate Carver meets fellow student Morph as they stumble across Quentin Qire picking a fight with Bling over a perceived slight, causing Eye-Boy and Nature Girl to try and separate them. Kitty does so, which causes Nate to rethink joining the school. As he leaves, Jubilee tries to persuade him to stay when the group comes under attack from another classic X-foe group.
Okay, not exactly an A-list group of mutants here, but that's kinda the point. New writer Christina Strain wanted to fill this new title with the downtrodden and rejected members of the X-franchise. While there's not a lot of action here, there is plenty of drama and soap opera elements, qualities that have been missing from the X-books for some time. How are this group of misfits going to fit together? I'm unfamiliar with artist Amilcar Pinna. The art is okay yet shaky in some spots with some distorted angles present, as if you're seeing characters through a warped lens. Still, an interesting start.
7/10
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on May 22, 2017 21:51:42 GMT -5
Thoughts on issues already mentioned: Daredevil #20 - after waiting nearly two years or so for this reveal, I have to say it's satisfying. Matt's deductions, reactions, and guilt over this fix was handled very well. I do hate to see his relationship to Kirsten end in this regard though. My only caveat is that this doesn't fully explain the level of anger that Foggy now has towards Matt. (Also, in case I overlooked it somewhere, it doesn't explain the costume change either). In fact, my only real nitpick for Soule's run so far is the conspicuous absence of Franklin 'Foggy' Nelson. 8/10
Super-Sons #4 - a very fun and satisfying end to their first adventure. Damian's smack talk to Luthor was priceless. The banter, the action, the art, all of it is nigh excellent. 8/10
You are right about DD. I miss Matt's supporting cast. And there has been no reason given for the change in costumes.
Super Sons has been another fun title along with Superman & ASM:RYV.
|
|
|
Post by Hoosier X on May 23, 2017 1:33:17 GMT -5
Cave Carson Has a Cybernetic Eye #8O don't even know why I started getting the new Cave Carson series from DC. I sort of like all those not-quite-super-hero series from DC from the 1960s, like the Challengers of the Unknown, the Sea Devils, Rip Hunter Time Master and Tommy Tomorrow. I've read one or two (or maybe three) stories for each of these, mostly in 1970s reprints, like those World's Finest Super-Spectaculars. But I have never read a Cave Carson story before Cave Carson Has a Cybernetic Eye #1 came out. I generally have mixed feeling about the series, and I sometimes have a little trouble getting into it. But it has really started clicking for me. Cave has gone rogue because he doesn't trust the people works for and he's taken a small crew - including his daughter and Wild Dog, of all people (it's so strange) - and they've gone underground where they encounter all kinds of random underground menaces and things. I don't even know who to recommend this to. It's so strange. Paging all Cave Carson fans!
|
|
|
Post by wildfire2099 on May 26, 2017 13:36:57 GMT -5
It's been a while since I read Astro City regularly but I started buying it again last year and I have most of the last ten issues. I especially love the Jazzbaby issues. It has maintained the high quality I got used to back when I read Astro City in the 1990s. But, man, I loved #44! I really didn't expect THAT! I'm not going to say anything about it. I want you to be surprised too. OK, I won't say more then, except when I finished, it, I came on here specifically to post and make sure you didn't miss this one, Hoosier. I will say it's set in the 80s, and the bad guy is an awesome visual. Also, more purple dude next month *sigh*
|
|
|
Post by wildfire2099 on May 26, 2017 14:40:38 GMT -5
Written by Peter J. Tomasi and Patrick Gleason. Art by Doug Mahnke and Jaime Mendoza. Cover by Ryan Sook. As all kinds of weird stuff happens all over Hamilton, Jon is forced to watch his parents in the middle of it on a TV screen. The big bad guy is revealed (it was leaked a week ago). He wants to brainwash Jon to turn against his parents to get revenge on Superman This arc feels a little too drawn out & a bit darker than usual. However I am confident in a big payoff that will be coming. It's ironic that Mahnke is drawing this as he drew the villain's first appearance back in Action Comics #775. 8/10.Yeah, I agree.. it feels alot like re-doing the Mr. Mxyzptlk arc with a different bad guy. The character bits are still totally worth it, and it was fun seeing the entire city turn out to be bad guys, but still a bit like spinning ones wheels. Also, I kinda hate the bad guy, so there's that, too. On the plus side, last issue (with Lois kicking butt) was pretty amazing... hope we get more of that.
|
|
|
Post by Hoosier X on May 27, 2017 2:33:43 GMT -5
It's been a while since I read Astro City regularly but I started buying it again last year and I have most of the last ten issues. I especially love the Jazzbaby issues. It has maintained the high quality I got used to back when I read Astro City in the 1990s. But, man, I loved #44! I really didn't expect THAT! I'm not going to say anything about it. I want you to be surprised too. OK, I won't say more then, except when I finished, it, I came on here specifically to post and make sure you didn't miss this one, Hoosier. I will say it's set in the 80s, and the bad guy is an awesome visual. Also, more purple dude next month *sigh* So how long have they been teasing us with purple meta-dude? I hadn't read Astro City for quite a while when I picked up the recent Jack in the Box storyline, and I don't think I've ever seen purple meta-dude before this bunch of issues. He was in the Jazzbaby issues, wasn't he? (I love the Jazzbaby issues, by the way.) I'm fairly indifferent to purple meta-dude at this point.
|
|
|
Post by The Cheat on May 27, 2017 14:47:00 GMT -5
So how long have they been teasing us with purple meta-dude? I hadn't read Astro City for quite a while when I picked up the recent Jack in the Box storyline, and I don't think I've ever seen purple meta-dude before this bunch of issues. He was in the Jazzbaby issues, wasn't he? (I love the Jazzbaby issues, by the way.) I'm fairly indifferent to purple meta-dude at this point. He first appeared at the beginning of this series, so a few years. He's not in very often though, so it's not a particularly obtrusive subplot.
|
|