cee
Full Member
Posts: 105
|
Post by cee on Jul 21, 2018 20:22:50 GMT -5
I've seen some of the line work as well, and didn't find it detail heavy. I quite enjoy that in the final product, the blurry effects. Its just highly stylized, the artist obviously is in command of what he is doing, the aesthetic is consistant, and the storytelling is good. I can understant it not to be to one's liking, but terrible?... I find you extremely harsh with that statement, and I don't really understand why, after being so generous with the Hulk book. But hey, it's only a matter of opinions Thor is IMHO a visual feast, bold and dynamic, unlike anything else right now. Del Mundo is a treasure.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Jul 21, 2018 20:47:07 GMT -5
Avengers #5Written by Jason Aaron Art by Ed McGuinness Summary: Loki unveils the history of life as we know it and the Ghost Rider learns that he can do more than be a hotroder from Hell. Plot: I may have dropped Aaron's Thor due to it's meandering plot but I'm still going strong with his run on the Avengers. It's not as if it's the most meaningful story ever told, and it isn't exploring deep emotional underpinnings in the characters assembled but it isn't trying to do that either. Deeply metaphorical, layered, moving comics are fantastic; don't get me wrong but you don't always need a book to be reaching for the stars to enjoy it...sometimes you just wanna see some people in brightly colored unitards wale on each other and yell fun bits of dialogue. I may not necessarily remember this story ten years down the road, but I'll be damned if I'm not enjoying it right now while I'm reading it, it's light, colorful and fast paced and best of all it isn't going to drag on forever as the next issue is the end of the Host. I don't know where Aaron will go next after he finishes up this story but I hope he keeps up the energy. Art: Mcguinness really marries perfectly with the light zippy energy of Aaron's plot; you just look at his designs and you feel transported to the golden days of your youth where you'd spend your whole Saturday in your pajamas just glued to your television, a time when you loved the commercials almost as much as the cartoons as you imagined having them all in your bedroom. I'm not an action figure guy but as McGuinness unveiled the Giant Sized Avengers I couldn't help but smile and think, "Damn, I'd love that action figure set!" It was just such a fun look and I can't wait to see them punch the Celestials in the next issue. Grade:8/10
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Jul 21, 2018 20:52:41 GMT -5
I've seen some of the line work as well, and didn't find it detail heavy. I quite enjoy that in the final product, the blurry effects. Its just highly stylized, the artist obviously is in command of what he is doing, the aesthetic is consistant, and the storytelling is good. I can understant it not to be to one's liking, but terrible?... I find you extremely harsh with that statement, and I don't really understand why, after being so generous with the Hulk book. But hey, it's only a matter of opinions Thor is IMHO a visual feast, bold and dynamic, unlike anything else right now. Del Mundo is a treasure. Eh, from a story telling perspective that consistent look is part of why I find it doesn't work. That even wash, though beautiful in individual panels, robs the art of the illusion of depth giving the book a very static feel that is at odds at the action it's conveying. I think it'd be beautiful to look at in say a story book where motion isn't that important and the pictures aren't the whole draw but when you see the same, limited, washed out pallet on every page it just feels monotonous after a while.
|
|
cee
Full Member
Posts: 105
|
Post by cee on Jul 22, 2018 3:49:04 GMT -5
Well, agree to disagree : I really enjoy the concept of what you see as an even wash. I feel I'm seing some kind of rebooted tapestry, the earliest comics, which suits very well a title such as Thor. But I really don't find it static either. The fact that the pallet is washed out and limited is an artistic choice, and I find it quite refreshing in this context, where so many Thor books barely had a personnal color style. So yeah, just a matter of opinions
|
|
|
Post by wildfire2099 on Jul 23, 2018 22:54:06 GMT -5
I think it depends on what you were expecting of it, if you wanted serious revelations about what happened between Return of the Jedi you'd be understandably disapointed but if you were just looking for a little Star Wars to take to you with the beach it was a good read. I was looking for something new and interesting to assume me the 'new' EU was going to be good... revelations would have been nice, but I actually had seen reviews and had pretty low expectations. The book managed to fall short of even those.. terrible YA writing not at all suited to Star Wars and some pretty boring characters. Happily, Lost Stars and some of the others have made up for it
|
|