|
Post by rberman on Aug 11, 2018 7:24:58 GMT -5
James Hudnall's Strikeforce: MorituriThis thread continues the issue-by-issue review of the late 80s Marvel comic book series Strikeforce: Morituri. The thread covering the first twenty issues can be found here. Strikeforce:Morituri's original creative team of Peter B. Gillis (writer) and Brent Anderson (artist) departed after twenty issues, replaced by James Hudnall on scripts and an initially unstable cadre of artists until Mark Bagley settled in eventually. The story began as a futuristic science fiction tale concerning an alien invasion of Earth combatted by human super-soldiers whose abilities came at the cost of an unpredictably shortened lifespan, such that they were prone to burst into flame. Gillis' writing had been characterized by ruthlessness toward his characters as well as a bent toward literary allusions and media satire, with aliens who proved to be total fanboys for Western pop culture. We'll see what Hudnall did with all of these elements across two connected series:
|
|
|
Post by rberman on Aug 11, 2018 7:36:49 GMT -5
#21 (August 1988) “The Earth Is Red”
Cover Corner Box features: Paideia insignia. This will be true for quite a few issues in a row, so I will stop mentioning it until that changes. The Story: We open on a frame story in which Jason Edwards, a human soldier (non-Morituri) tells his tale in an interrogation room. After his army squad was slaughtered, he disguised himself in civilian clothes (a serious violation of the Geneva Convention, but the aliens probably don't subscribe to that anyway) and was captured along with some other humans. A captive boy is executed in retaliation for the Morituri’s recent destruction of the Stark Fist’s spaceship (which occurred in issue #7). The humans are put to work doing janitorial work on the Horde spaceship. One day, a captured transport docks with the Horde spaceship, carrying a cocky shipful of Morituri. Toxyn meets Edwards, who comandeers a Horde tank which he drives around the spaceship, picking up the other Morituri and causing general havoc before detonating the Horde ship and returning to Earth. Toxyn and Edwards fall for each other romantically, but it’s all for naught, as she has her Morituri moment and explodes. Back at the conclusion of the frame story, Edwards agrees to undergo the Morituri treatment himself rather than be executed as a deserter. Because what else would you do with a desertion-prone soldier, except offer him super powers? Perhaps this shows how desperate Earth is getting. My Two Cents: A new day begins for this series under writer James Hudnall, penciler Huw Thomas, and inker Tony DeZuniga. I’m not familiar with any of these gentlemen. Hudnall went on to create a series called Harsh Realms that was made into a TV show by Chris “X-Files” Carter, but he’s fallen on hard times more recently, losing a leg and having no recent income beyond disability. If you like his work on this series (which I confess I did not at first, but appreciated more by the end), consider donating to help his expenses here. The tone is very different from Peter Gillis’ work. We get lots of exposition about the Horde. They are divided into a thuglike Yurkaa class and a ruling Volsenn class and speak the Va-Shakk language. They now have foreign names like Wek-Kuu and Gurto instead of British names like Gentle Inquirer and Hammersmith. Also, the distinctive font used for alien speech disappears on page 14 but returns in future issues. Both the art and the dialogue have taken a distinct turn for Silver Age, and I wonder whether the new creative team was under instructions to do the old “everybody talks about their superpowers all the time” exposition. That said, the “interrogation frame story” while hackneyed worked fine. The Morituri failed in their objective of capturing a high ranking Horde officer, but they did get to blow up an enemy capital ship. It would be nice to have some notion have how many ships like that the Horde have; they just keep coming, as dictated by the immediate needs of the story rather than an over-arching plan. Hudnall immediately begins introudicng his own new charaters and killing off Peter Gillis' characters. The beginning of the issue had a nice moment of foreshadowing in which a security guard watches a Strikeforce Morituri “video comic” in which Toxyn says that it is “my turn.” It is indeed her turn to die this issue. It’s also reasonably prescient of Hudnall to recognize that in the future, people would read comic books on electronic tablets. In issue #27, we’ll see another of these tablets, manufactured by Sony, but this one is a Panasonic.
|
|
|
Post by beccabear67 on Aug 11, 2018 12:19:54 GMT -5
I really liked Hudnall's short-lived (at least so far as I knew) Espers comic from Eclipse so was curious about these after looking online and finding it and further Espers.
|
|
|
Post by Roquefort Raider on Aug 11, 2018 13:06:59 GMT -5
What, Hudnall doesn’t work for Breitbart anymore?
|
|
|
Post by rberman on Aug 11, 2018 14:37:57 GMT -5
What, Hudnall doesn’t work for Breitbart anymore? Dunno. Tell us the story!
|
|
|
Post by Roquefort Raider on Aug 11, 2018 17:34:59 GMT -5
What, Hudnall doesn’t work for Breitbart anymore? Dunno. Tell us the story! James Hudnall is a serious alt-right activist, who blogs profusely about how Obama ruined the United States and was the worst president ever, how the borders are wide open, how the democrats are clowns in the pocket of special interests, and who writes for Breitbart. He and Val Mayerik used to publish quote unquote political cartoons that merely mocked the Obamas, for example by picturing Michelle pigging out on sausages while advocating healthy habits. Real high brow stuff. I’m sorry to hear he might have fallen on hard times, but it’s hard to feel anything beyond the most basic empathy for a fellow who champions pretty much everything I loathe about the right.
|
|
|
Post by rberman on Aug 11, 2018 18:01:58 GMT -5
Dunno. Tell us the story! James Hudnall is a serious alt-right activist, who blogs profusely about how Obama ruined the United States and was the worst president ever, how the borders are wide open, how the democrats are clowns in the pocket of special interests, and who writes for Breitbart. He and Val Mayerik used to publish quote unquote political cartoons that merely mocked the Obamas, for example by picturing Michelle pigging out on sausages while advocating healthy habits. Real high brow stuff. I’m sorry to hear he might have fallen on hard times, but it’s hard to feel anything beyond the most basic empathy for a fellow who champions pretty much everything I loathe about the right. Huh. I don’t have much appreciation for either political party or for those who spend their time tearing down either party. Our disunity and inability to live with each other seems like a bigger threat. It seems to me that more comic book artists (and artists in general) lean left than right, so it will be interesting to see how Hudnall’s political philosophy plays itself out in Strikeforce Morituri.
|
|
shaxper
CCF Site Custodian
Posts: 22,874
|
Post by shaxper on Aug 11, 2018 18:25:37 GMT -5
James Hudnall is a serious alt-right activist, who blogs profusely about how Obama ruined the United States and was the worst president ever, how the borders are wide open, how the democrats are clowns in the pocket of special interests, and who writes for Breitbart. He and Val Mayerik used to publish quote unquote political cartoons that merely mocked the Obamas, for example by picturing Michelle pigging out on sausages while advocating healthy habits. Real high brow stuff. I’m sorry to hear he might have fallen on hard times, but it’s hard to feel anything beyond the most basic empathy for a fellow who champions pretty much everything I loathe about the right. Huh. I don’t have much appreciation for either political party or for those who spend their time tearing down either party. Our disunity and inability to live with each other seems like a bigger threat. It seems to me that more comic book artists (and artists in general) lean left than right, so it will be interesting to see how Hudnall’s political philosophy plays itself out in Strikeforce Morituri. For the most part, it doesn't. My biggest criticism of Hudnall on this run is he ends up with a Marty Stu protagonist and sort of misses the original rotating cast spirit of the series. Still, he does a solid job, and Electric Undertow (which should have been called "Strikeforce 2: Electric Boogaloo") proves worthwhile as well. Regarding Hudnall's politics, it is weird to consider how the guy who wrote Lex Luthor: The Unauthorized Biography could be a raging conservative. I wonder if his politics changed later on, or if maybe he does his political writing for a paycheck.
|
|
|
Post by rberman on Aug 12, 2018 6:57:20 GMT -5
#22 (September 1988) “The Long Suicide”
The Story: Dr. Tuolema checks out Jason Edwards, the new Morituri recruit whom we met in the last issue. It seems Jason has contracted some “benign virus” while in alien custody. Could it be the secret to extending Morituri lifespans? Dr. Tuolema turns his attention to another new recruit, Dan Baker, who lost his family when the Horde send rocket-powered asteroids to pulverize three cities, including his home of Salt Lake City. Much of the issue is given over to flashbacks of the life and love that he has lost due to the war. A trio of shadowy officials discuss how to keep the Morituri from ending the war too quickly. I didn’t realize that the humans were doing well enough to make such a discussion worth having. Even when Peter Gillis was writing the series, it was never clear how close either side was to losing either its resources or its resolve. If the Horde withdraw, do they even have anywhere to go? However, I will give Hudnall credit for providing the answer that Gillis never did: Why do the Morituri almost never get sent on missions? If Gillis had an answer for this, we never saw it in the first 20 issues. During a TV interview, Shear admits that his costume was based on that of an old comic book called The Punisher. A Horde crew attacks the studio to embarrass the Morituri on national TV and demoralize the human race. Its troops are divided into groups who have trained specially to counter the powers of one particular Morituri, so the obvious way to defeat them is for the Morituri to force them to switch to other targets. Backhand dies in the attack but takes several Super-Hordians with him. My Two Cents: John Calimee replaces Huw Thomas on pencils. The musical chair of artists makes Strikeforce:Morituri feel distinctly like a red-headed stepchild of Marvel Comics. The innovative forward momentum with which Gillis started out has sputtered in favor of a more traditional "monster of the week" feeling: Human heads driving killer robots. Killer plants. Killer asteroids. Bombs inside humans. The exception is Jason Edwards, who appears to be the new protagonist-in-the-making. Hudnall has retconned three key elements of the latter Gillis run: (1) Dr. Tuolema went rogue from the Paideia several issues ago, but now he’s back at work; (2) The Paideia didn’t trust him anyway, but now they do; (3) Tuolema had erased all information about the Morituri process in retaliation for the creation of the monster Morituri, but now it seems the project is proceeding. All of this makes me wonder whether (1) Gillis had an actual ending in mind for the series when he started it; (2) That ending was communicated to Hudnall; (3) That ending was rejected in favor of retooling the series into an open-ended anthology rather than a story arc with a predetermined conclusion. Perhaps Gillis had intended to wind down Strikefore:Morituri relatively quickly, but Hudnall had editorial instructions to keep it going. In that case, the shadowy trio of human conspirators represents Marvel Editorial, prolonging the war beyond its natural conclusion. This issue is unusually bloody for an 80s Comics Coded book. Brava pounds one Hordian head into a pulp. Dan Baker passes another person lying in a pool of blood. Blood pours from Silencer’s side when she is stabbed. But all the blood is mainly black, which I guess is how they avoided the wrath of the Comics Code, kind of like when Tarantino shot that scene in Kill Bill in black and white.
|
|
|
Post by beccabear67 on Aug 12, 2018 14:25:28 GMT -5
That's too bad about the politics/conspiracies. It is kind of amazing there are people who do believe in any politicians actually, I sometimes wonder about some who seem to if they really do. You find out sometimes the people with signs and balloons and all that are actually paid, Trump had some to start at least, and Doug Ford in Ontario, Canada (now Premier of that province) too. And yet it seems to be a thing to call children and their parents from school shooting incidents paid actors? So messy out there. I still liked the original Espers, but yeah, making fun of Michelle Obama for supposedly being fat (seen altered photos) really speaks for itself. Dumb. I don't even want to bother commenting on Trump's skin color or hair; why? If I don't respect or like someone who would do that why would I become the same? 'Obummer' and 'Frump' and all that, if you have something serious to say you don't need to make fun of the names even. So I guess I would think less of Hudnall more for the very low level of commentary if you can call it that regardless of the subject. Another artist I used to know spends part of every day seemingly ranting on twitter in the opposite direction even replying to Trump's own tweets. he crosses the line with the insults now to the point I'd worry the FBI might just visit him, but the further back you go on his account the calmer he used to be! I probably agree with him politically a lot, but he used to be someone that never seemed to have any interest in politics that I knew of, and yet what I read was genuinely shocking. He has work, he could focus on that as something positive... it's like they get seriously derailed. Do they ever come back? Another artist friend before he died was alienating everyone as a real extreme gun rights and Christianity person. You could swear the old person who was Jewish and leaning toward the radical left/Nader/Green completely disappeared. He was very strong in character back then, and then became even more pungent let's say later but without the humor and a lot of real military style guns), became all absolutes and survivalist; it may even be his tumor effected things? Sorry to go off topic so long here. Just thinking about some comics people who got sort of 'radicalized'. I can't imagine ever using comic or cartoon stories for any specific political or even dogma purposes, politics seeming so changeable and temporal for most for one thing, it'd end up pretty dated you might think. You live long enough you'll see what is left or right do complete place trades. I don't mind so much that a comic would have realistic violence, deaths, whatever as it looks out of place in four colors with typical superhero comic art. It seems like maybe a more realistic art style should go with it, what I'm seeing here looks fairly basic cartoony and it hits me like funny animals with the boobs and having human sex interactions... 'retarded' kind of in the dictionary sense of the word being useful to describe something. If these were the old super people established as something created mainly for kids in the '30s to '60s it also can seem very wrong to me. I even felt that about Denny O'Neil's Green Lantern/Green Arrow, and Gerry Conway's Spider-Man. I know O'Neil genuinely meant well, but Speedy shooting up on a cover... at least the Neal Adams art fit that kind of story, can you imagine if say Sal Buscema had been the artist? That's kind of what some of these Morituri pages look like. But as I said, at least it isn't with older established characters, it was created to be this. Still, form follows function for me, why is this form necessary for this function? If I want to tell a story of adult nature for adults I'm going to do it with colorful costumed super powered people? I'd stick with the naughty undergrounds fro that, at least they knew they were breaking rules and provoking simply to provoke. You've definitely saved me from buying these. Too much graphic violence in a simple style desensitizes, becomes a joke; just some kind of weird mistake from a time of a lot of weird mistakes. As an adult this kind of adult super comic doesn't seem to have been very well done here nor had the time put in it would've needed. Maybe the earlier issues were better by the books creators though.
|
|
|
Post by rberman on Aug 12, 2018 14:39:03 GMT -5
I don't mind so much that a comic would have realistic violence, deaths, whatever as it looks out of place in four colors with typical superhero comic art. It seems like maybe a more realistic art style should go with it, what I'm seeing here looks fairly basic cartoony and it hits me like funny animals with the boobs and having human sex interactions... 'retarded' kind of in the dictionary sense of the word being useful to describe something. If these were the old super people established as something created mainly for kids in the '30s to '60s it also can seem very wrong to me. I even felt that about Denny O'Neil's Green Lantern/Green Arrow, and Gerry Conway's Spider-Man. I know O'Neil genuinely meant well, but Speedy shooting up on a cover... at least the Neal Adams art fit that kind of story, can you imagine if say Sal Buscema had been the artist? That's kind of what some of these Morituri pages look like. But as I said, at least it isn't with older established characters, it was created to be this. Still, form follows function for me, why is this form necessary for this function? If I want to tell a story of adult nature for adults I'm going to do it with colorful costumed super powered people? I'd stick with the naughty undergrounds fro that, at least they knew they were breaking rules and provoking simply to provoke. You've definitely saved me from buying these. Too much graphic violence in a simple style desensitizes, becomes a joke; just some kind of weird mistake from a time of a lot of weird mistakes. As an adult this kind of adult super comic doesn't seem to have been very well done here nor had the time put in it would've needed. Maybe the earlier issues were better by the books creators though. The graphic violence I showed above does seem out of place for a super hero comic book. Sadly, this was 1989, when everybody and their brother was chasing some of that Dark Knight mojo and revenue. Later issues of this comic book and its sequel downplayed the graphic violence and bloodshed, perhaps in response to complaints.
|
|
|
Post by Roquefort Raider on Aug 12, 2018 14:49:38 GMT -5
Regarding Hudnall's politics, it is weird to consider how the guy who wrote Lex Luthor: The Unauthorized Biography could be a raging conservative. I wonder if his politics changed later on, or if maybe he does his political writing for a paycheck. I don’t know, but I certainly had no clue as to his political views just from his comica. Today, however, there is a comic he would be perfect to write: Space Force!
|
|
|
Post by rberman on Aug 13, 2018 7:45:41 GMT -5
#23 (October 1988) “Castles of Fire, Rivers of Blood”
The Story: The Morituri are once again sent to Africa, where they kill some Horde who have poached an elephant. We later learn that the good guys have also destroyed a series of Horde bases, inflicting heavy casualties. How come we don’t get to see the war scenes in this war comic? I guess it’s the same as how shows set in a high school are not mainly about kids sitting in English and Math class. I guess I can't complain about "Morituri never sent on missions" as much now, so Hudnall has fixed that, despite that scene last issue where the shadowy cabal declared their intention to limit Morituri effectiveness. Silencer finds out that Hardcase is a virgin and immediately sets about changing that situation. But on the way to somewhere private, the two of them are accosted by new Morituri recruit Dan “Scanner” Baker, who summons them to a briefing. Later they pick up where they left off. Jason Edwards (whom they rescued several months previously from a Horde spaceship) is Morituri too. Their boss’ boss appears in video conference to announce that the Morituri will only be used as a reactive defense force rather than being sent on proactive engagements that might end the war. This feels like a real step back in the plot progression (though consistent with the shadowy cabal's intent), and the Morituri are no happier to hear it than I am. But uncharacteristically, the team protests and then submit. “We can’t change our orders,” Silencer meekly says later. Why not? Disobedience was the most common Morituri response to orders under Gillis, but perhaps these new Morituri are more submissive. Up next: The Horde raid a chocolate factory. Again. But it’s not Hershey’s this time; its Ghirardelli’s, so at least the Horde have upgraded to the expensive stuff. The Horde, while numerous, are armed only with swords. Jason, a former Horde prisoner, realizes that these Horde bear the markings of convicts, not soldiers. They are cannon fodder, and a few seconds later, an orbital microwave cooks the area, killing Hardcase and Silencer in the process. Jason rigs the Horde transport ship to fly up and collide with the micro-wave emitter, destroying it. So once again, a threat that will only appear in a single issue. Dr. Tuolema suspects that the benign Horde virus inside of Jason may prevent the Morituri effect from killing the heroes. My Two Cents: The revolving door of art continues, with Mark Bagley and Val Mayerik doing the honors this time. But they are an improvement on the last two issues, so I won’t complain. Gore continues to characterize the series, with blood dripping from the hand of Hardcase after he manually disembowels an enemy soldier. Hudnall is rapidly killing off the old characters, making room for his own additions of Scanner (who is helpful) and Jason (who lacks a codename as of yet and is surly). Scatterbrain is still in a coma. Blackthorn’s baby has disappeared from the plot. I thought for sure he/she was going to become a big McGuffin, perhaps aging quickly into a super-powered teenager who can either save the world or destroy it. Maybe that’s still coming? Interesting to see the comic book specifically affirming that “a rose –colored paradise” awaits our deceased heroes. I doubt a modern comic would do so. A monument to the Black Watch contains only three figures, but in issue #13, we learn that the Black Watch started with five. Perhaps the other two died too early to become famous enough to enshrine as statues?
|
|
|
Post by wildfire2099 on Aug 13, 2018 21:45:01 GMT -5
The Horde seem alot less unique in the panels you've posted under Hudnall.. did they get rid of the nostalgia gathering stuff as well?
|
|
|
Post by rberman on Aug 13, 2018 21:56:39 GMT -5
The Horde seem alot less unique in the panels you've posted under Hudnall.. did they get rid of the nostalgia gathering stuff as well? Yes, their character changes in many respects, and in the future their appearance will change as well.
|
|