|
Post by thwhtguardian on Sept 18, 2019 7:18:39 GMT -5
OFF THE RACKSFresh Comics, Real Reviews, Served Weekly
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Sept 18, 2019 8:39:43 GMT -5
Justice League #32Written by Scott Snyder Art by Howard Porter Summary: The Justice League acquires the shards of the Totality in the past and the present while the Monitors unite! Plot: I had initially skipped this book as I haven't cared for Snyder's writing in a while but I recently got DC Universe and they had the first few arcs of the story...and I actually liked it, so I played catch up on comixology so I could jump in. At 32 issues and counting without a conclusion it's definitely very decompressed, and the prior fill in issues by Tyrion are incredibly skippable but the story itself is still engaging. I think my favorite element so far is the way the story plays off of past events like Crisis on Earth Two, Crisis on Infinite Earths and Final Crisis in a way that is still fresh and exciting. Still, I find myself speed reading though it a bit do to how padded out the plot is. For my money I'm not sure this story needed to be more than say 12 issues or so but it's still interesting enough to keep me going. Art: Howard Porter does a great job of giving us both the Justice Society and Justice League: One Million and the scene during Pearl Harbor was absolutely fantastic. Grade: 7+/10
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Sept 18, 2019 20:24:58 GMT -5
Hellboy and the BPRD: Saturn Returns #2Written by Mike Mignola Art by Christopher Mitten Summary: As the team sorts through the corpses in an attempt to solve all the cold cases they find a clue when only one cold case can't be solved. Plot: I said it last time, but it sadly bears repeating; as much as I enjoy the character building with Liz as a young girl it doesn't add to the main story what so ever so every page spent on her is one less to develop the murder mystery Hellboy is working on and as that plot is much more interesting interesting than the former it's incredibly disappointing. The bones of Hellboy's investigation in New Hampshire are fantastic, it's great to actually see him as a legitimate paranormal detective rather than just punching monsters(not that there is anything wrong with that!) but with the limited page count spent fleshing that out it's starting to feel a little rushed and hollow and with only one more issue left I imagine that isn't likely to get better in the end. Mignola did this once before, cramming two disparate stories into one and it didn't work then and it's sadly not working now. Art: I Really love Mitten's work, although Hellboy looks a little cartoony on the cover but he looks great inside the book and I love the monster...I just wish there was more time spent on that. Grade:6+/10
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Sept 18, 2019 20:42:35 GMT -5
Not a full review but I think this might be my last issue of History of the Marvel Universe...it was just too rapid paced here, I mean previous entries were quick summaries but they were sweeping enough in their subjects to at least be interesting as they described different eras...but this was pretty much a list. First the FF came out, and then Peter Parker was bit by a spider then the Hulk happened. It's just all very bland at this point.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Sept 19, 2019 8:29:13 GMT -5
Strayed #2Written by Carlos Giffoni Art by Juan Doe Summary: As Lou continues his journeys through the universe his owner Kiara finds that these trips may have a terrible impact on her feline companion. Plot: Maybe it's because I'm the owner of a loving cat myself(his name is Bagheera if you must know!) but this sci-fi tale of a woman and her pet cat is just has me completely enthralled. As Kiara examines Lou and discovers the toll his astral projected journeys are having on him I can't help but remember sitting outside a vet's door wondering about the health of my own cat. The anxiety and pain that Kiara feels here is just so incredibly real, and the way Giffoni so effortlessly taps into that really elevates the story he's telling. We've all read sci-fi stories about humanity's manifest destiny like march across the universe in search of resources, such storis of colonialism are a dime a dozen but the level of simple human goodness that Giffoni infuses into his tale with the love between human and pet makes his story really stand out. I can't wait to see what the alien has to say to Lou in the next chapter! Art: In this second chapter Juan Doe continues to stun the audience with his ever trippier visions of alien worlds and their inhabitants. Each world and each species seen is unique and wondrous and the opposing color pallets used for each one create a feast for the eyes on each page. On top of that, I loved the lay outs for each of Lou's astral journeys; the way Juan splays out the scenes against a cosmic background brings to mind visions from a kaleidoscope which gives the journeys a very ethereal energy that's just fun to experience. Sound Track: Yeah, you read that right...this issue, as well as the previous one, features a sound track( which can be found here) While the previous issue's accompaniment was more classic sci-fi with it's up beat cosmic sounds this issues soundtrack is darker and more mechanical making them more unpleasant to hear but that dissonance certainly reflects the tone of the book it self but the final track that coincides with Lou's second journey and the discovery of the flower race has more of the uplifting tone that I enjoyed from the first issue leaving me really pleased with the sound track over all. Each issue having it's own unique sound is a really great concept, and it definitely augments the reading experience, I kind of wish more books had one. Grade:10/10
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Sept 20, 2019 17:54:33 GMT -5
Black Hammer: Age of Doom #12Written by Jeff Lemire Art by Dean Ormston Summary: It all comes down to this, the Anti-God has cracked opened up the sky and there is only one way to stop him. Plot: I hate to have to say this as I've loved the book as a whole...but this ending was pretty boring. I'm not an all-star, genius writer so I can't express how I would have ended this any better, but I still can't help feeling that this was an entirely unneeded story. I almost feel like the book should have just ended after they all woke up on the ship and then blipped out of existence. It would have been a downer, sure, but it would have had a much greater impact than the happily ever after we saw here...and somehow there will be more minis? I'm not sure I want more, which is something I couldn't imagine saying just six months ago. Art: Ormston looked as great as always but he had nothing fun to do here which is a shame. Grade:4/10
|
|
|
Post by Slam_Bradley on Sept 20, 2019 18:19:07 GMT -5
Black Hammer: Age of Doom #12Written by Jeff Lemire Art by Dean Ormston Summary: It all comes down to this, the Anti-God has cracked opened up the sky and there is only one way to stop him. Plot: I hate to have to say this as I've loved the book as a whole...but this ending was pretty boring. I'm not an all-star, genius writer so I can't express how I would have ended this any better, but I still can't help feeling that this was an entirely unneeded story. I almost feel like the book should have just ended after they all woke up on the ship and then blipped out of existence. It would have been a downer, sure, but it would have had a much greater impact than the happily ever after we saw here...and somehow there will be more minis? I'm not sure I want more, which is something I couldn't imagine saying just six months ago. Art: Ormston looked as great as always but he had nothing fun to do here which is a shame. Grade:4/10 Yeah...a horrible ending to what started out as a great story and book. Just totally fell flat. I can understand that they're sacrificing themselves again. Maybe when I sit and think about it some more I'll feel better about it. But at first blush it did not work at all.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Sept 20, 2019 18:26:02 GMT -5
Black Hammer: Age of Doom #12Written by Jeff Lemire Art by Dean Ormston Summary: It all comes down to this, the Anti-God has cracked opened up the sky and there is only one way to stop him. Plot: I hate to have to say this as I've loved the book as a whole...but this ending was pretty boring. I'm not an all-star, genius writer so I can't express how I would have ended this any better, but I still can't help feeling that this was an entirely unneeded story. I almost feel like the book should have just ended after they all woke up on the ship and then blipped out of existence. It would have been a downer, sure, but it would have had a much greater impact than the happily ever after we saw here...and somehow there will be more minis? I'm not sure I want more, which is something I couldn't imagine saying just six months ago. Art: Ormston looked as great as always but he had nothing fun to do here which is a shame. Grade:4/10 Yeah...a horrible ending to what started out as a great story and book. Just totally fell flat. I can understand that they're sacrificing themselves again. Maybe when I sit and think about it some more I'll feel better about it. But at first blush it did not work at all. This was the first book I read on Wednesday and I've read it and the preceding 11 issues since then while tossing the end around in my head and it hasn't gotten any better for me yet.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 21, 2019 12:04:18 GMT -5
Not a full review but I think this might be my last issue of History of the Marvel Universe...it was just too rapid paced here, I mean previous entries were quick summaries but they were sweeping enough in their subjects to at least be interesting as they described different eras...but this was pretty much a list. First the FF came out, and then Peter Parker was bit by a spider then the Hulk happened. It's just all very bland at this point. Same here
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 21, 2019 14:29:17 GMT -5
Superman #15. Written by Brian Michael Bendis. Art by Ivan Reis. As usual Reis' art is stellar. As usual Bendis has some great ideas that take forever to develop. Finally we meet the Rebirth version of the Legion of Super Heroes. We also see the fates of Jor-El, Zod, Zaar and the set up of a United Planets. And despite the slow pace to get to this point the ending of this story manages to feel rushed. I think Bendis is a decent writer however I feel he would be better with a co-writer that could balance out some of his quirks. 6/10. Mostly for the concepts and art.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 21, 2019 14:36:09 GMT -5
Aquaman #52. Written by Kelly Sue DeConnick. Art by Robson Rocha. First of all Rocha's art has been awesome. He has shown growth on this title over the last year and I look forward to any issue he draws. DeConnick's first arc was a bit uneven but she has settled nicely into making her mark on Aquaman. I like the focus on Amnesty Bay. I like Jackson Hyde Aqualad being a part of the book. I like the slow build to the eventual confrontation with Black Manta. I like this "new" mystery on the last page. 8/10.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 21, 2019 14:41:26 GMT -5
Superman's Pal Jimmy Olsen #3. Written by Matt Fraction. Art by Steve Lieber. This is a weird book. But weird in a good way. Take Jimmy's old Silver Age stories and view them/update them for modern times and you get this title. It is structured different from any other books on the stands. It is silly. It is entertaining. It is quirky. Finally we find out why Jimmy decided he had to "hide" in Gotham City. Great appearances by the Superman supporting cast and Metamorpho too! 8/10.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Sept 21, 2019 19:44:12 GMT -5
Superman's Pal Jimmy Olsen #3. Written by Matt Fraction. Art by Steve Lieber. This is a weird book. But weird in a good way. Take Jimmy's old Silver Age stories and view them/update them for modern times and you get this title. It is structured different from any other books on the stands. It is silly. It is entertaining. It is quirky. Finally we find out why Jimmy decided he had to "hide" in Gotham City. Great appearances by the Superman supporting cast and Metamorpho too! 8/10. Along with Lois Lane this is one of my favorite books out right now.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 22, 2019 7:31:58 GMT -5
Superman's Pal Jimmy Olsen #3. Written by Matt Fraction. Art by Steve Lieber. This is a weird book. But weird in a good way. Take Jimmy's old Silver Age stories and view them/update them for modern times and you get this title. It is structured different from any other books on the stands. It is silly. It is entertaining. It is quirky. Finally we find out why Jimmy decided he had to "hide" in Gotham City. Great appearances by the Superman supporting cast and Metamorpho too! 8/10. Along with Lois Lane this is one of my favorite books out right now. More proof that with the right creative team any character can be made interesting.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Sept 22, 2019 7:56:37 GMT -5
Along with Lois Lane this is one of my favorite books out right now. More proof that with the right creative team any character can be made interesting. Very true, though I've enjoyed previous stories focused on both Lois and Jimmy in the past. Both Curt Swan and Jack Kirby had great runs on Jimmy Olsen, though if I think the closest thing in the past to this run was Nick Spencer's back up from Action Comics a few years back.
|
|