|
Post by thwhtguardian on Nov 27, 2019 19:54:05 GMT -5
Welcome to another thrilling edition of.... OFF THE RACKSReal reviews from real readers.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Nov 28, 2019 10:06:52 GMT -5
Picard: Countdown #1Written by Kirsten Beyer Art by Angel Hernandez Summary: When the Federation learns that the Hobus star is going supernova Admiral Picard leads the relief effort. Plot: I'm a big Star Trek fan but aside from the original Gold Key series I've found the comics to be a little more miss than hit but one of my favorites was Countdown which came out just before the 2009 reboot so I was excited to see a similar book being put out for the new Picard series; and it doesn't disappoint. Set after the 1998 film Insurrection and just before the events of the original Countdown series(which if you can believe it came out ten years ago!) the book sets out to tell the story of how the Federation first learned about the Hobus star going supernova and their trouble the had getting the Romulan Empire to accept aid from the Federation. I really liked seeing where the characters were, especially Geordie as the head of the Utopia Planitia ship yards and of course Picard as Admiral, and the way the Romulans interacted with Picard was fantastic. Art: I really enjoyed that Hernandez definitely went of his way to capture the different actor's likenesses but stayed away from tracing them, making them instantly recognizable but without looking lifeless. I was initially a little thrown off by the new Star Fleet uniforms as I felt the look from the latter films and DS9 was perfect, but once that wore off I actually got to like it. Sure, it's a little busy but if you're going to update the look this wasn't a bad design: Grade:8/10
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Nov 28, 2019 12:30:39 GMT -5
Hellblazer #1Written by Simon Spurrier Art by Aaron Campbell Summary: When a gang of young drug dealers start getting picked off by what appears to be a choir of angels, who do they call? John Constantine of course. Plot: While Vertigo may be shuttered, the spirit of one of its favorite sons is alive and well in the pages of Spurrier's John Constantine: Hellblazer. With its dark humor and engaging cast of characters it makes me feel like I'm reading a lost story from the Ellis and Ennis years of Hellblazer which is definitely high praise from me. It's not all top marks across the board from me though, while I love the rich characterization, tone and pacing of the book it occasionally gets bogged down with what I feel is excessively British slang which occasionally makes the dialogue difficult to read and the narration occasionally feels muddled as though it appears to belong to the gang leader it occasionally sounds like Constantine which was weird. That said this was hands down one of the best books I've read in a while. Art: John might be an old hat but Campbell gives him a tremendously beautiful new coat of paint here. His art is full of grit and grime but it's also exceedingly clear and clean where it's needed like the scenes where the angels skin their victims alive. Grade:10/10
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Nov 28, 2019 13:43:16 GMT -5
Batman: Creature of the Night #4Written by Kurt Busiek Art by John Paul Leon Summary: Bruce Wainwright comes to the end of his rope and finds a new way to move forward. Plot: It's been a long time coming but the wait was well worth it to get the ending to this story as we got to see Busiek's meditation on what makes Batman tick come full circle. This book could have been an easy cash in, just giving us a slightly realistic Batman and aping the beats of Superman: Secret Identity but instead Busiek really went all in to give us a story that was a truly unique look at the mythology of Batman. I loved that at it's core here is a story about a boy trying to impose fairness on the world and how that drive would destroy you; it seems like a gross over simplification to say that's what Batman is really about...but a child's impotent rage writ large really does describe Batman well when you think about it and that emotionally focused narrative is really what made this book so great. Art: I loved the mix of real life, grounded art and the deep horror elements that Leon brought to the page. That duality, the ability to make it look believable while at the same time pack in the horror really goes to the root of Batman; he's a normal guy who does impossible things. I think my only complaint goes again to a poor depiction of a local landmark: the Franklin Park Zoo. Previously I knocked the narrative for including a Bat exhibit where none existed but here the zoo is once again important and they got the entrance wrong which just baffles me as both zoo entrances as so beautifully Gothic as to make their absence seem almost criminal: Grade:9/10
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 30, 2019 10:09:16 GMT -5
Shazam! #8. Written by Geoff Johns. Art by Scott Kolins. I had forgotten this book was still on my pull list. The delays have killed this title. This may all read decent in a collected edition but as individual issues it has been terrible with pacing issues, etc. I am one of those readers who liked the New 52 update even though I would still prefer the classic Marvel Family. Anyway Billy rescues some of his siblings this issue, fights Black Adam and saves his biological father in an unexpected way (which I have to admit surprised me!). Not sure where the story will go from here as we still have 4 issues to go in this overly bloated arc. The Good: Kolins art. The last page surprise. Billy being more heroic. The Bad: Terrible pacing from issue to issue. Delays. Awful decompression stretching a 6 issue story to 12 parts. 5/10.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Nov 30, 2019 16:46:22 GMT -5
Shazam! #8. Written by Geoff Johns. Art by Scott Kolins. I had forgotten this book was still on my pull list. The delays have killed this title. This may all read decent in a collected edition but as individual issues it has been terrible with pacing issues, etc. I am one of those readers who liked the New 52 update even though I would still prefer the classic Marvel Family. Anyway Billy rescues some of his siblings this issue, fights Black Adam and saves his biological father in an unexpected way (which I have to admit surprised me!). Not sure where the story will go from here as we still have 4 issues to go in this overly bloated arc. The Good: Kolins art. The last page surprise. Billy being more heroic. The Bad: Terrible pacing from issue to issue. Delays. Awful decompression stretching a 6 issue story to 12 parts. 5/10. I might pick this up when it's finally collected in its entirety.
|
|
Roquefort Raider
CCF Mod Squad
Modus omnibus in rebus
Posts: 17,413
Member is Online
|
Post by Roquefort Raider on Nov 30, 2019 19:48:02 GMT -5
Hellblazer #1Written by Simon Spurrier Art by Aaron Campbell Summary: When a gang of young drug dealers start getting picked off by what appears to be a choir of angels, who do they call? John Constantine of course. Plot: While Vertigo may be shuttered, the spirit of one of its favorite sons is alive and well in the pages of Spurrier's John Constantine: Hellblazer. With its dark humor and engaging cast of characters it makes me feel like I'm reading a lost story from the Ellis and Ennis years of Hellblazer which is definitely high praise from me. It's not all top marks across the board from me though, while I love the rich characterization, tone and pacing of the book it occasionally gets bogged down with what I feel is excessively British slang which occasionally makes the dialogue difficult to read and the narration occasionally feels muddled as though it appears to belong to the gang leader it occasionally sounds like Constantine which was weird. That said this was hands down one of the best books I've read in a while. Art: John might be an old hat but Campbell gives him a tremendously beautiful new coat of paint here. His art is full of grit and grime but it's also exceedingly clear and clean where it's needed like the scenes where the angels skin their victims alive. Grade:10/10
I read that this wasn’t the “super-heroic” Constantine that was a part of the Justice League Dark concept... but is it the original Hellblazer, or is it a soft reboot that sidesteps the very final last issue of the first run?
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Nov 30, 2019 20:24:52 GMT -5
Hellblazer #1Written by Simon Spurrier Art by Aaron Campbell Summary: When a gang of young drug dealers start getting picked off by what appears to be a choir of angels, who do they call? John Constantine of course. Plot: While Vertigo may be shuttered, the spirit of one of its favorite sons is alive and well in the pages of Spurrier's John Constantine: Hellblazer. With its dark humor and engaging cast of characters it makes me feel like I'm reading a lost story from the Ellis and Ennis years of Hellblazer which is definitely high praise from me. It's not all top marks across the board from me though, while I love the rich characterization, tone and pacing of the book it occasionally gets bogged down with what I feel is excessively British slang which occasionally makes the dialogue difficult to read and the narration occasionally feels muddled as though it appears to belong to the gang leader it occasionally sounds like Constantine which was weird. That said this was hands down one of the best books I've read in a while. Art: John might be an old hat but Campbell gives him a tremendously beautiful new coat of paint here. His art is full of grit and grime but it's also exceedingly clear and clean where it's needed like the scenes where the angels skin their victims alive. Grade:10/10
I read that this wasn’t the “super-heroic” Constantine that was a part of the Justice League Dark concept... but is it the original Hellblazer, or is it a soft reboot that sidesteps the very final last issue of the first run? It's a soft reboot that I think works very well, but rather than starting after the last arc of the original series it sort of starts after a dark ending to Books of Magic.
|
|
|
Post by profholt82 on Dec 4, 2019 17:40:27 GMT -5
Batman: Creature of the Night #4Written by Kurt Busiek Art by John Paul Leon Summary: Bruce Wainwright comes to the end of his rope and finds a new way to move forward. Plot: It's been a long time coming but the wait was well worth it to get the ending to this story as we got to see Busiek's meditation on what makes Batman tick come full circle. This book could have been an easy cash in, just giving us a slightly realistic Batman and aping the beats of Superman: Secret Identity but instead Busiek really went all in to give us a story that was a truly unique look at the mythology of Batman. I loved that at it's core here is a story about a boy trying to impose fairness on the world and how that drive would destroy you; it seems like a gross over simplification to say that's what Batman is really about...but a child's impotent rage writ large really does describe Batman well when you think about it and that emotionally focused narrative is really what made this book so great. Art: I loved the mix of real life, grounded art and the deep horror elements that Leon brought to the page. That duality, the ability to make it look believable while at the same time pack in the horror really goes to the root of Batman; he's a normal guy who does impossible things. I think my only complaint goes again to a poor depiction of a local landmark: the Franklin Park Zoo. Previously I knocked the narrative for including a Bat exhibit where none existed but here the zoo is once again important and they got the entrance wrong which just baffles me as both zoo entrances as so beautifully Gothic as to make their absence seem almost criminal: Grade:9/10 This one definitely has me interested. This is the 3rd positive review I've seen now. I haven't read the previous 3 issues, and my local doesn't have them anymore sadly. How could they let the 4th issue take this long to come out?! So, I plan on picking up the new one at my local this week and searching Ebay for the original 3.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 4, 2019 17:50:57 GMT -5
Batman: Creature of the Night #4Written by Kurt Busiek Art by John Paul Leon Summary: Bruce Wainwright comes to the end of his rope and finds a new way to move forward. Plot: It's been a long time coming but the wait was well worth it to get the ending to this story as we got to see Busiek's meditation on what makes Batman tick come full circle. This book could have been an easy cash in, just giving us a slightly realistic Batman and aping the beats of Superman: Secret Identity but instead Busiek really went all in to give us a story that was a truly unique look at the mythology of Batman. I loved that at it's core here is a story about a boy trying to impose fairness on the world and how that drive would destroy you; it seems like a gross over simplification to say that's what Batman is really about...but a child's impotent rage writ large really does describe Batman well when you think about it and that emotionally focused narrative is really what made this book so great. Art: I loved the mix of real life, grounded art and the deep horror elements that Leon brought to the page. That duality, the ability to make it look believable while at the same time pack in the horror really goes to the root of Batman; he's a normal guy who does impossible things. I think my only complaint goes again to a poor depiction of a local landmark: the Franklin Park Zoo. Previously I knocked the narrative for including a Bat exhibit where none existed but here the zoo is once again important and they got the entrance wrong which just baffles me as both zoo entrances as so beautifully Gothic as to make their absence seem almost criminal: Grade:9/10 This one definitely has me interested. This is the 3rd positive review I've seen now. I haven't read the previous 3 issues, and my local doesn't have them anymore sadly. How could they let the 4th issue take this long to come out?! So, I plan on picking up the new one at my local this week and searching Ebay for the original 3. Both creators have battled health issues and the artist John Paul Leon has been fighting his third bout with cancer.
|
|
|
Post by profholt82 on Dec 4, 2019 17:55:28 GMT -5
Sheesh. Well, that sure sucks to hear. Good for them (and fortunate for us) for actually finishing it up in spite of their troubles.
|
|