|
Post by thwhtguardian on Jan 13, 2021 8:43:17 GMT -5
Do you want honest reviews? Then equation is simple: New Comics+Real Readers= OFF THE RACKS!
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Jan 13, 2021 9:57:27 GMT -5
Future State: Dark Detective #1Written by Mariko Tamaki Art by Dan Mora Summary Bruce Wayne is a rumored suicide and it's reported that Batman is dead...but you can't always believe what you read. Plot: This was probably the only Future State book I was actually excited to get my hands on and read because this book is essentially a sneak peak into DC's spring line up as Tamaki and Mora will be taking the reins of Detective Comics in March starting with 'tec #1034. While it's true that many of the other Future State creative teams are also going to be around when things go back to normal Batman holds a spot near and dear to my heart so his fate concerned me the most...and I'm glad to say that it looks like Detective Comics will be in good hands when it returns.I said it before, and likely will again, but I like a Batman who smiles and while that is generally true I'm not opposed to a story that features Batman at the end of his rope with his back against a wall and no where left to turn either. I don't want grim and gritty all the time but when done well it does work and that's what Tamaki gave us here. Right from the get go Tamaki proved that she knew how to steal the scene and instantly command an audience's attention. she began with a single word and then a comma “Gotham,” before starting again after several silent panels with “...Gotham is a funeral no one’s attending." It's a purposeful false start, and one that not only sets the tone for the book and outlines its central theme but it also immediately conveys a sense of weariness in the speaker. It's a line that he literally doesn't have the energy to complete on his first try which is a beautiful way to give the reader a deep insight into a character with the use of only a handful of words. And that's a technique that Tamaki continues to employ through out the issue; unlike a lot of the other Future State books that burdened the reader with caption after caption of spoon fed exposition Tamaki dispenses her world building quickly through the use of subtext. As Bruce stumbles through the streets of Gotham seeking medical attention we see a news story on a billboard behind him with the headline, "Bruce Wayne: loses fortune, commits suicide?" and then nothing more other than a sentence saying the fistful of dollars he hands over at a no tell medical clinic is the last of the Wayne fortune. It's terse and it certainly leaves you with more questions than answers but it's more than enough to give you the lay of the land in the Gotham that Tamaki wants to show you. It's a dark and mysterious world she's given us and it fits well in the oeuvre of Batman.
While I'll be sad to see Tomasi go as his run was really solid, Tamaki illustrated here that she's able to deliver a really personal and gritty adventure so I'm hopeful that I'll be enjoying a lot more Batman in 2021 thanks to her.
Art: Mora has always been a fantastic artist but here he really pushed himself to new heights with the heavy lifting he accomplished in his panels. So much of the sense of mystery that Tamaki wished to build is left to Mora to create, her back ground through subtext style just couldn't work if she didn't trust Mora to deliver the goods...and he does in spectacular fashion. With his gritty images of Bruce running through the shadows juxtaposed against his bright, cleaner panels of billboards and restaurants we're introduced to so many of the concepts needed for the plot to work. Comics are a visual medium but too often writer seem to forget that and they walk all over the art with dialogue and captions that convey information to the reader in a much clumsier way than the art is able to, and I'm glad to see that isn't the case here as both parts of the comic, the words and the art, are given the space they need to shine.
If this book were only the work of Tamaki and Mora it would easily be a 10/10...but it had a back up and it was pretty bad. The art was muddy and the story just didn't engage me at all which really drags down my opinion of the book as a whole. Grade:8/10
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Jan 13, 2021 10:55:04 GMT -5
Immortal Hulk #42Written by Al Ewing Art by Joe Bennett, Adam Gorham, Rachael Stott and Alex Lins Summary: As the Leader tortures Bruce Banner in the world below things move quickly above them. Plot: Unless something goes terribly wrong and Ewing fails to stick the landing on the ending Immortal Hulk will easily go down as one of the greatest runs the character has ever had. However, that doesn't mean its a perfect run, although I've generally loved the story there have been their fair share of valleys for every peak of excellence...and sadly this issue was another one of those valleys. We left off last issue with the Thing and the Hulk coming to an understanding about the current state of the Hulk's powers and the trouble he was in and it seemed like Bruce had his head on straight at last and was going to take it to the Leader...but instead of that we get treated to Gamma Flight getting canned by their new government leader, we see McGee get fired from her job as a reporter and learn she has weird gamma powers and then we see the Leader get eaten for some reason by the One Below. All in all it's just a lot of plots that don't fit well together which makes for a very disjointed reading experience. I have faith that things will get better, Ewing has recovered from missteps before, but that hope doesn't make this particular issue read well in and of itself. Art: Usually an excellent bit of art from Bennett could save a slightly weak script but sadly the art is just as disjointed as the plot here with different artists with very different styles taking on the individual plots. And while each artist certainly does a good job with their individual piece the fact that they don't flow together really highlights and compounds the flaw in the story rather than smoothing it over. It's just a really weird choice, I can see having a fill in artist if you want to keep to the deadline...but a different artist for each scene? That's beyond jarring. Grade:6/10
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Jan 14, 2021 9:04:44 GMT -5
The Cimmerian: The Frost Giant's Daughter #2Plotting and Art by Robin Recht Summary: As Conan defeats Heimdul he mistakes the Frost Giant's daughter for a Vanir and follows her into the snowy wastes. Plot/Art: Recht's retelling of Robert E. Howard's "The Frost Giant's Daughter" continues here, giving us brutal action and a pursuit of beauty across the frozen wastes. As Recht did in the first chapter he continues to build on the mythology around the Frost Giant and his daughter Atali but rather than mindless exposition just dumped at your feet it's information that's doled out sparingly and with great subtly building a sense of mystery around Atali and her motivations which goes a great way to making it feel like a true myth. However the book isn't with out its flaws...though I may be from Massachusetts I like to think I'm far from Puritanical but I'm not going to lie the depiction of Atali, especially in the scenes where she had close contact with Conan were slightly troubling to my eye. I'm not against nudity, and I know the misogyny of warriors thinking of women as chattel is correct for the period the story is going for and although she's a timeless goddess with obvious womanly needs...when portrayed against Conan's hulking, brutal form she looks like an adolescent girl which makes not only Conan's pursuit of her slightly difficult to watch but her ::ahem:: actions :ahem:: at the climax ( hey, you try voiding that pun) of the issue seem like I have need of the confessional (and I'm not Catholic) or a spot on the next episode of To Catch a Predator. And although the book is so amazing that I'm in dire need of the conclusion I can say it is with a slightly guilty conscious. I knew it was slightly problematic from your amazing review (and it is amazing! Click the link to see for yourself) Roquefort Raider but perhaps I am more Puritanical than I thought because I was not ready for this. Grade:7/10
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 14, 2021 11:26:20 GMT -5
The Cimmerian: The Frost Giant's Daughter #2Plotting and Art by Robin Recht Summary: As Conan defeats Heimdul he mistakes the Frost Giant's daughter for a Vanir and follows her into the snowy wastes. Plot/Art: Recht's retelling of Robert E. Howard's "The Frost Giant's Daughter" continues here, giving us brutal action and a pursuit of beauty across the frozen wastes. As Recht did in the first chapter he continues to build on the mythology around the Frost Giant and his daughter Atali but rather than mindless exposition just dumped at your feet it's information that's doled out sparingly and with great subtly building a sense of mystery around Atali and her motivations which goes a great way to making it feel like a true myth. However the book isn't with out its flaws...though I may be from Massachusetts I like to think I'm far from Puritanical but I'm not going to lie the depiction of Atali, especially in the scenes where she had close contact with Conan were slightly troubling to my eye. I'm not against nudity, and I know the misogyny of warriors thinking of women as chattel is correct for the period the story is going for and although she's a timeless goddess with obvious womanly needs...when portrayed against Conan's hulking, brutal form she looks like an adolescent girl which makes not only Conan's pursuit of her slightly difficult to watch but her ::ahem:: actions :ahem:: at the climax ( hey, you try voiding that pun) of the issue seem like I have need of the confessional (and I'm not Catholic) or a spot on the next episode of To Catch a Predator. And although the book is so amazing that I'm in dire need of the conclusion I can say it is with a slightly guilty conscious. I knew it was slightly problematic from your amazing review (and it is amazing! Click the link to see for yourself) Roquefort Raider but perhaps I am more Puritanical than I thought because I was not ready for this. Grade:7/10 I don't think I'm exceptionally prudish either (but who really is capable of forming objective opinions of their own personality?), but I had similar concerns. I think mostly it's because it seems like the creators are just putting their masturbatory fantasies on the page. Even if that's not fair, that idea's hard to avoid, and it takes me right out of the story. Just because you can do something ("look - Marvel and Dark Horse would not have dared do this in their adaptations!") doesn't mean you should. I was really looking forward to this series, but I don't think I'll be picking up the next issue.
|
|
|
Post by james on Jan 14, 2021 15:14:04 GMT -5
Immortal Hulk #42Written by Al Ewing Art by Joe Bennett, Adam Gorham, Rachael Stott and Alex Lins Summary: As the Leader tortures Bruce Banner in the world below things move quickly above them. Plot: Unless something goes terribly wrong and Ewing fails to stick the landing on the ending Immortal Hulk will easily go down as one of the greatest runs the character has ever had. However, that doesn't mean its a perfect run, although I've generally loved the story there have been their fair share of valleys for every peak of excellence...and sadly this issue was another one of those valleys. We left off last issue with the Thing and the Hulk coming to an understanding about the current state of the Hulk's powers and the trouble he was in and it seemed like Bruce had his head on straight at last and was going to take it to the Leader...but instead of that we get treated to Gamma Flight getting canned by their new government leader, we see McGee get fired from her job as a reporter and learn she has weird gamma powers and then we see the Leader get eaten for some reason by the One Below. All in all it's just a lot of plots that don't fit well together which makes for a very disjointed reading experience. I have faith that things will get better, Ewing has recovered from missteps before, but that hope doesn't make this particular issue read well in and of itself. Art: Usually an excellent bit of art from Bennett could save a slightly weak script but sadly the art is just as disjointed as the plot here with different artists with very different styles taking on the individual plots. And while each artist certainly does a good job with their individual piece the fact that they don't flow together really highlights and compounds the flaw in the story rather than smoothing it over. It's just a really weird choice, I can see having a fill in artist if you want to keep to the deadline...but a different artist for each scene? That's beyond jarring. Grade:6/10 I have been reading this title since it started and I'm staying with it to the end. I do have concerns that at issue 50 (last issue of the run?) I'm going to be let down. I'm finding the valleys are becoming more and more frequent and lately the best art is the Alex Ross covers.
|
|
|
Post by Roquefort Raider on Jan 14, 2021 16:21:47 GMT -5
Re: The Frost Giant's Daughter...
I must defend my man Recht!
The sexual elements of the story are absolutely vital to what Recht is attempting as a storyteller, and the book would have been much poorer if the artist had demurred. The gods depicted in the book are clearly using us mortals for their selfish pleasure, something Atali's behaviour makes quite clear. She doesn't care about Conan's prowess because she roots for him; she cares about it because it brings her pleasure. It's all about her and the gods and what pleases them; never about us. Plus, the primordial motivations of sex and death are completely intertwined in this story; it would have been as inappropriate to tone down Atali's raw sexuality as it would have been to hide the brutality of the opening scene. The story would have worked anyway, but it would have been weaker.
Masturbatory fantasies, to me, are the stuff of overly-endowed superheroines dressed in a coat of paint or in dental floss; not that of normal-looking women who actually engage in such activities because the plot demands it. The graphic sex scene between Conan and Bêlit in Queen of the Black Coast was far more gratuitous that what we have here, as far as I'm concerned, even if the artist took care of never showing a nipple.
I don't much care for sex as a titillating plot device, but when it's a crucial element of a particular story, I don't mind it at all!
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 14, 2021 17:06:50 GMT -5
I read Immortal Hulk this week and was also let down. However I also picked up Bloodshot Book 3 which was OK. But I really loved Thor: The Devourer King. I posted my thoughts here: Thor 2020 Trade
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 14, 2021 20:08:27 GMT -5
Re: The Frost Giant's Daughter...
Masturbatory fantasies, to me, are the stuff of overly-endowed superheroines dressed in a coat of paint or in dental floss; not that of normal-looking women who actually engage in such activities because the plot demands it. I hear that the amateur categories of certain internet sites are fairly popular. I also hear that there's sometimes stories involved. Maybe somebody else can confirm. I hear what you're saying, and I, for one, might even give the story another chance down the road, but not today. It's very possible that the reasoning behind the story choices can be a little from column A and a lot from column B. It's just a matter of your perceptions of column A and column B.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Jan 15, 2021 14:47:59 GMT -5
Re: The Frost Giant's Daughter...
I must defend my man Recht! The sexual elements of the story are absolutely vital to what Recht is attempting as a storyteller, and the book would have been much poorer if the artist had demurred. The gods depicted in the book are clearly using us mortals for their selfish pleasure, something Atali's behaviour makes quite clear. She doesn't care about Conan's prowess because she roots for him; she cares about it because it brings her pleasure. It's all about her and the gods and what pleases them; never about us. Plus, the primordial motivations of sex and death are completely intertwined in this story; it would have been as inappropriate to tone down Atali's raw sexuality as it would have been to hide the brutality of the opening scene. The story would have worked anyway, but it would have been weaker. Masturbatory fantasies, to me, are the stuff of overly-endowed superheroines dressed in a coat of paint or in dental floss; not that of normal-looking women who actually engage in such activities because the plot demands it. The graphic sex scene between Conan and Bêlit in Queen of the Black Coast was far more gratuitous that what we have here, as far as I'm concerned, even if the artist took care of never showing a nipple. I don't much care for sex as a titillating plot device, but when it's a crucial element of a particular story, I don't mind it at all! It's definitely an important part of the story, the Frost Giant's Daughter is one of my favorite Conan stories of all time and the pursuit has never really bothered me before...but I've never thought of her as looking like a child and that was my sticking point. It was more about the optics of it rather than the content itself. And I know she's not really a child, she's an ageless Goddess who's been seducing warriors to their graves since time immemorial and in the grand scheme of things the power in this pursuit definitely rests in her corner rather than Conan's but appearance wise that's not the case. And in some respects that play on appearance versus reality is in fact an important theme at play...but the age difference plays into that just a little too much for my tastes.
|
|
|
Post by Roquefort Raider on Jan 15, 2021 15:30:31 GMT -5
Re: The Frost Giant's Daughter...
I must defend my man Recht! The sexual elements of the story are absolutely vital to what Recht is attempting as a storyteller, and the book would have been much poorer if the artist had demurred. The gods depicted in the book are clearly using us mortals for their selfish pleasure, something Atali's behaviour makes quite clear. She doesn't care about Conan's prowess because she roots for him; she cares about it because it brings her pleasure. It's all about her and the gods and what pleases them; never about us. Plus, the primordial motivations of sex and death are completely intertwined in this story; it would have been as inappropriate to tone down Atali's raw sexuality as it would have been to hide the brutality of the opening scene. The story would have worked anyway, but it would have been weaker. Masturbatory fantasies, to me, are the stuff of overly-endowed superheroines dressed in a coat of paint or in dental floss; not that of normal-looking women who actually engage in such activities because the plot demands it. The graphic sex scene between Conan and Bêlit in Queen of the Black Coast was far more gratuitous that what we have here, as far as I'm concerned, even if the artist took care of never showing a nipple. I don't much care for sex as a titillating plot device, but when it's a crucial element of a particular story, I don't mind it at all! It's definitely an important part of the story, the Frost Giant's Daughter is one of my favorite Conan stories of all time and the pursuit has never really bothered me before...but I've never thought of her as looking like a child and that was my sticking point. It was more about the optics of it rather than the content itself. And I know she's not really a child, she's an ageless Goddess who's been seducing warriors to their graves since time immemorial and in the grand scheme of things the power in this pursuit definitely rests in her corner rather than Conan's but appearance wise that's not the case. And in some respects that play on appearance versus reality is in fact an important theme at play...but the age difference plays into that just a little too much for my tastes. I see your point, and it is certainly be a good reason to feel uncomfortable! To me, she looked 20-ish; certainly not of my generation, but apparently of an age with Conan in that tale, so it didn't strike me as inappropriate.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Jan 15, 2021 15:55:41 GMT -5
It's definitely an important part of the story, the Frost Giant's Daughter is one of my favorite Conan stories of all time and the pursuit has never really bothered me before...but I've never thought of her as looking like a child and that was my sticking point. It was more about the optics of it rather than the content itself. And I know she's not really a child, she's an ageless Goddess who's been seducing warriors to their graves since time immemorial and in the grand scheme of things the power in this pursuit definitely rests in her corner rather than Conan's but appearance wise that's not the case. And in some respects that play on appearance versus reality is in fact an important theme at play...but the age difference plays into that just a little too much for my tastes. I see your point, and it is certainly be a good reason to feel uncomfortable! To me, she looked 20-ish; certainly not of my generation, but apparently of an age with Conan in that tale, so it didn't strike me as inappropriate. There are panels where she was drawn with harder, more angular features which make her look older but there are even more, especially in the scenes she shares directly with Conan where her features are much softer and her ::ahem:: curves are less pronounced which coupled with her much shorter stature in comparison to Conan give her an appearance of a much younger woman.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 16, 2021 0:55:52 GMT -5
the Claremont special was horrifically awful.
with some nice art.
|
|
|
Post by wildfire2099 on Jan 17, 2021 9:05:31 GMT -5
Space Bastards #1
Well, that was interesting. I'm not sure if it's just because it was Darick Robertson on art, but it definitely had a bit of a Transmet vibe. If the authors can rise about the slapstick Lobo-esque violence (which was fun for this first book) and deliver something interesting (which they seemed to be setting up a bit), this could be a keeper. Awesome art, of course, and an entertaining premise (package delivery is a mercenary job, with delivery guys being above the law, so lots of Mayhem ensues), made more so by the current issues our postal service is having... maybe this is the future?
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Jan 17, 2021 10:07:28 GMT -5
Space Bastards #1 Well, that was interesting. I'm not sure if it's just because it was Darick Robertson on art, but it definitely had a bit of a Transmet vibe. If the authors can rise about the slapstick Lobo-esque violence (which was fun for this first book) and deliver something interesting (which they seemed to be setting up a bit), this could be a keeper. Awesome art, of course, and an entertaining premise (package delivery is a mercenary job, with delivery guys being above the law, so lots of Mayhem ensues), made more so by the current issues our postal service is having... maybe this is the future? Certainly looks fun, I'll have to look out for this
|
|