|
Post by tartanphantom on Nov 30, 2021 1:20:35 GMT -5
I'm a little late to this thread, so I'll begin with my 1930 favorites.
While I love "All Quiet" and it certainly deserves the accolades that it received, it's not at the top of my list. Instead, I prefer its German contemporary, G.W. Pabst's Westfront 1918.
To me, it's a more powerful film (although perhaps not as emotionally moving), and the cinematography is brutally stark at times. I also like the fact that it was later banned by Germany's National Socialist party as being too "pacifistic" in nature, which speaks volumes to its message. Criterion released a restored version.
Close behind this would be my 2nd favorite film of 1930, Howard Hawks' Dawn Patrol starring Douglas Fairbanks Jr. (not to be confused with the 1938 re-make featuring Errol Flynn). The 1930 edition won the Oscar for best screenplay that year.
|
|
|
Post by tartanphantom on Nov 30, 2021 1:53:26 GMT -5
On to 1931... This was an absolute blockbuster year for cinema, and as others have previously demonstrated, picking just ONE film would be an injustice to the dozens of great movies released that year. However, these are a few of my perennial favorites:
Tod Browning's Dracula and James Whale's Frankenstein need no explanation, and consistently stand up to repeated viewings to this day. Both are so deeply ingrained in the American film psyche that it is impossible to exclude them from a list of "bests".
Aside from them, perhaps my favorite film of 1931 is another German production, Fritz Lang's "M", which in my view is one of the pinnacles of the thriller genre, and proved to be Peter Lorre's breakthrough role. The influence of this film on the movie business is still felt today as it established scene fluidity, as well as many serial killer tropes still used in modern cinema. On top of that, the camera work is flat-out gorgeous.
Other favorites from 1931 include Garbo as Mata Hari, The Public Enemy starring James Cagney, Little Caesar Starring Edward G. Robinson, and last but certainly not least--
a holdover from the silent era, Charlie Chaplin's "Tramp" persona in City Lights... I love this film.
|
|
|
Post by Slam_Bradley on Nov 30, 2021 8:29:17 GMT -5
I'm a little late to this thread, so I'll begin with my 1930 favorites.
While I love "All Quiet" and it certainly deserves the accolades that it received, it's not at the top of my list. Instead, I prefer its German contemporary, G.W. Pabst's Westfront 1918.
To me, it's a more powerful film (although perhaps not as emotionally moving), and the cinematography is brutally stark at times. I also like the fact that it was later banned by Germany's National Socialist party as being too "pacifistic" in nature, which speaks volumes to its message. Criterion released a restored version.
Close behind this would be my 2nd favorite film of 1930, Howard Hawks' Dawn Patrol starring Douglas Fairbanks Jr. (not to be confused with the 1938 re-make featuring Errol Flynn). The 1930 edition won the Oscar for best screenplay that year.
I’ll definitely have to seek out Westfront. I’ve seen Dawn Patrol but probably only once and it’s be eons.
|
|
|
Post by berkley on Nov 30, 2021 23:57:42 GMT -5
Since we're talking favourites rather than best, I think I'll have to settle on Dracula as my 1931 pick: of the five I narrowed my choices down to, there were better constructed films that year - M, Frankenstein; and better written scripts - The Front Page - but Dracula is the movie that's left the biggest impression on me from seeing it on tv at a young age through all the intervening years until today. A flawed adaptation of Stoker's book, but still great sets, effectively mysterious and ominous atmosphere, and of course an iconic performance by Lugosi. Also I think an inspired and perhaps not that obvious choice of theme music with Tchaikovsky's Swan Lake.
|
|
|
Post by Slam_Bradley on Dec 7, 2021 19:47:44 GMT -5
Moving on to 1932. Now I could make a pretense of going through potential favorites, but honestly what's the point? I already know my favorite film of 1932 and I kind of telegraphed it before. I will, however, provide a few that I do like a lot after the main event. Horse Feathers - This is my favorite Marx Brothers movie and it's one of my favorite movies. Groucho is absolutely brilliant as Professor Quincy Adams Wagstaff and Chico and Harpo are equally great as Baraveli and Pinky. The films climax was number one on ESPN's list Top 11 Scenes in Football Movie History. On a personal note, my youngest son dressed up as Groucho for his grade school gifted and talented program's "Night of the Notables" and sang "Whatever It Is, I'm Against It." This movie just always makes me laugh and fills me with joy. Not that there aren't some other great films from 1932 (though I don't think it's on par with 1931). The Mummy - This has always been kind of one of the lesser step-children of the Universal horror films, but I'm a pretty big fan. Jack Harris' make-up work is absolutely fabulous. We get a chance to see Karloff in both monster and in a more traditional role. While successful it didn't generate any direct sequels, but was more continually re-imagined. Scarface - This is the only version of Scarface I have any interest in watching. Based on the Armitage Trail novel, this is the third leg (along with The Public Enemy and Little Caesar) of the three movies that codified the gangster movie for at least a generation. This was the film that took Paul Muni off Broadway and made him a movie star. The film also catapulted George Raft to stardom and had a great turn by Boris Karloff. Freaks - Aww...the movie that essentially killed Tod Browning's career. This had originally been conceived as a vehicle for Lon Chaney, one has to wonder what might have happened had Chaney lived to lend his star-power and cachet to the film. It's also a film that was essentially destroyed when Irving Thalberg decided to take the scissors to the original version, which was, apparently, doing very good business at the Fox Theater in San Diego. The excised version completely changed Browning's social critique. After years of being largely unavailable it became a cult film and has garnered significant re-evaluation. The Music Box - How did I miss this one. I think this may be Laurel & Hardy's greatest short. Them trying to move a piano up a steep set of stairs is just pure joy. 1932 in film in case someone needs a look.
|
|
|
Post by Hoosier X on Dec 7, 2021 21:37:10 GMT -5
I’ve been watching Horse Feathers and The Mummy over and over since I was a kid! (The 1970s)
I’ve seen The Music Box a few times. It’s great! I’ve been to the steps! When I lived in Hollywood!
But the winner for me is ...
FREAKS!
|
|
|
Post by Hoosier X on Dec 7, 2021 22:23:31 GMT -5
I like Scarface as well but I’ve only seen it once.
I started to write down my recommendations from the 1932 list but I’m rather fatigued from my booster shot, so I’ll do it later.
|
|
|
Post by Hoosier X on Dec 7, 2021 23:41:15 GMT -5
Highlights of 1932:
Union Depot - Joan Blondell. This is the kind of movie that makes me think every movie should be set in the 1930s.
Murders in the Rue Morgue - Lugosi!
Grand Hotel - Have you seen it? It’s marvelous!
The Dark Horse - One of the best of Betty Davis’s early films.
Red-Headed Woman - Probably my favorite Jean Harlow movie.
Million Dollar Legs - WC Fields. I don’t even know where to begin ...
White Zombie - Lugosi!
Big City Blues - So early in Bogart’s career that he isn’t credited. But he makes the most of his few lines.
Blonde Venus - This movie ... It’s got Marlene Dietrich and Cary Grant. And it’s only got one good scene ... but what a scene!
The Most Dangerous Game
Thirteen Women - Irene Dunne and Myrna Loy. And Myrna is an evil Eurasian woman who is killing a bunch of women who were mean to her!
The Old Dark House
Trouble in Paradise
Three on a Match - The first time Bogart played a gangster. But even without that, I love this movie so much.
I Am a Fugitive from a Chain Gang
The Sign of the Cross - Charles Laughton as Nero
Rasputin and the Empress - LIONEL BARRYMORE IS RASPUTIN!! I sometimes wonder if this movie was the inspiration for that SNL skit where John Belushi was Rasputin.
Island of Lost Souls - Lugosi!
The Mask of Fu Manchu - Karloff is Fu Manchu. Myrna Loy is Fah Lo Suee. This movie ... it has to be seen to be believed.
|
|
|
Post by chadwilliam on Dec 7, 2021 23:49:20 GMT -5
My favorite has to be Chandu the Magician. Not crazy about Edmond Lowe in this, but everything else is fantastic about this picture. It feels too polished and perfect in so many respects that despite my love for this film, I'm not certain I give it the credit it deserves. It runs only about an hour, but I learned so much from this where later creators got their ideas. Bela Lugosi is fantastic (hardly surprising) and plays the type of villain for whom the death ray was invented. It plays around with a medium and tropes even as they're still being invented. Love this picture.
Runner-ups:
The Old Dark House. All of the acclaim it gets might have made it impossible for it to have lived up to its reputation when I finally saw it, but perhaps it's because its not what I expected that I loved this one so much. Charles Laughton is terrific convincing you that he's a one-dimensional oaf before peeling back layer after layer of a much deeper character; Brember Wills as Saul is perfect as a crazy man capable of passing off himself of as perfectly sane; you can practically hear Whale's mind spinning with future plans whenever Karloff and Ernest Thesiger are on screen - deservedly a classic, but I'd be hard pressed to describe it to anyone since there's really nothing else to compare it with.
White Zombie. I've never seen such a wrath brought down upon a man's enemies for the slight of refusing to shake a man's hands like I've seen it here. God help the poor soul who has the misfortune of making eye contact with Lugosi in 1932 on a bad day. No one can see a grudge through to the bitter end like Murder Legendre as captured by Lugosi.
Island of Lost Souls. Charles Laughton, Bela Lugosi, H.G. Wells. I don't think I have to add more.
I'll also second Freaks, Scarface, and The Mummy (though to be honest, it's always the sequels I head for when I grab my set rather than the original. What can I say - I want a guy in bandages if I'm watching a movie with a mummy in it). To my shame, I don't think I've seen The Music Box in full, but when I do, I'm sure I'll be regretting not singing its praises when I had the chance now.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 8, 2021 0:38:46 GMT -5
Highlights of 1932: The Mask of Fu Manchu - Karloff is Fu Manchu. Myrna Loy is Fah Lo Suee. This movie ... it has to be seen to be believed. I'm actually got about a half hour into it this afternoon (I DVRed it from TCM over a year ago and never got to it) and plan on watching the rest tomorrow (I rarely get to see films in one sitting these days). Of the movies form 1932 I am familiar with though, Tarzan the Ape Man and the Mummy are the only ones that stand out for me from multiple viewings, and since the Mummy is one of my favorite of the universal monster films, I will have to go with that. -M
|
|
|
Post by Hoosier X on Dec 8, 2021 4:38:58 GMT -5
I should have included Tarzan the Ape Man. But I like Tarzan and His Mate a lot more. And Tarzan Escapes too. The first one kind of pales in comparison, but it’s still pretty good. I haven’t seen it in a very long time.
|
|
shaxper
CCF Site Custodian
Posts: 22,860
|
Post by shaxper on Dec 8, 2021 11:28:21 GMT -5
1932
First off, as a huge Marx Brothers fan myself, I have to say I've never heard someone claim Horsefeathers as their favorite before. It's not that I can't see it being a favorite; it just usually comes down to Duck Soup or (my favorite) A Night at the Opera.
Now, as for my favorite films of 1932:
GRAND HOTEL -- I'm generally not a fan of films that just throw famous celebrities together, but man is this good (and surprisingly dark/meaningful).
MURDERS IN THE RUE MORGUE -- Such an underrated Universal classic, and absolutely one of Bela Lugosi's finest roles!
SCARFACE -- you covered that one
VAMPYR -- Holy crap does this one mess with you. I always explain it to others as feeling like you're walking through a dream, where feelings/impressions guide the narrative more than logic.
WHITE ZOMBIE -- Probably my favorite comfort film of all time. I probably watch it 20 times a year. Also absolutely Bela Lugosi's finest role.
HORSE FEATHERS -- Oddly enough, though I've watched this one at least four times (and I enjoyed it each time), all I really remember is the beginning and "swordfish"
THE OLD DARK HOUSE -- Not exactly a favorite of mine, but I applaud how creepy and nontraditional it is; the acting is so fantastically "odd". It was also likely the basis for The Rocky Horror Picture Show.
THE MUMMY -- I honestly think this one is overrated as a Universal horror classic, likely because Karl Freund didn't know a damn thing about directing when he made it and was routinely bullied by his own cast. Thus, Freund's cinematic genius is all over the film, but so many changes were made to accommodate the cast that the film really suffers as a result. I much prefer The Mummy's Hand as a sort of reboot of the franchise, as well as the sequels that followed.
|
|
|
Post by Slam_Bradley on Dec 8, 2021 11:50:17 GMT -5
Highlights of 1932: I Am a Fugitive from a Chain Gang This is one I kind of wanted to give a shout-out to but it's been at least three decades since I've seen it. This was honestly a very important film at the time and probably couldn't have been made post-code. As I recall, the film did a good job of portraying the abysmal treatment of Robert Elliot Burns for a pretty minor crime (I believe in the film he was innocent, in real life he was a dupe). I also can't remember if the film delves in to Burns' significant "shell-shock" which was a major part of the book.
|
|
|
Post by Mormel on Dec 8, 2021 11:58:19 GMT -5
Just wanted to say I've only recently been introducing myself to Classic Hollywood, and its been a fun introduction so far. I've not seen a great many films, but All Quiet On The Western Front was among the 1930s movies I've seen and it made a deep impression. Not just for the story, but also for how they filmed the trench warfare action scenes. Very dynamic and shows how terrifying WW1 battles were with the soldiers just running in waves into machine gun fire. That was a fresh war at the time too, and the movie preceded Hitler's seizure of power, so Americans portraying German soldiers you could root for didn't yet have the connotations that would come with WW2.
|
|
|
Post by Slam_Bradley on Dec 8, 2021 12:31:20 GMT -5
1932 First off, as a huge Marx Brothers fan myself, I have to say I've never heard someone claim Horsefeathers as their favorite before. It's not that I can't see it being a favorite; it just usually comes down to Duck Soup or (my favorite) A Night at the Opera. Now, as for my favorite films of 1932: GRAND HOTEL -- I'm generally not a fan of films that just throw famous celebrities together, but man is this good (and surprisingly dark/meaningful). MURDERS IN THE RUE MORGUE -- Such an underrated Universal classic, and absolutely one of Bela Lugosi's finest roles! SCARFACE -- you covered that one VAMPYR -- Holy crap does this one mess with you. I always explain it to others as feeling like you're walking through a dream, where feelings/impressions guide the narrative more than logic. WHITE ZOMBIE -- Probably my favorite comfort film of all time. I probably watch it 20 times a year. Also absolutely Bela Lugosi's finest role. HORSE FEATHERS -- Oddly enough, though I've watched this one at least four times (and I enjoyed it each time), all I really remember is the beginning and "swordfish" THE OLD DARK HOUSE -- Not exactly a favorite of mine, but I applaud how creepy and nontraditional it is; the acting is so fantastically "odd". It was also likely the basis for The Rocky Horror Picture Show. THE MUMMY -- I honestly think this one is overrated as a Universal horror classic, likely because Karl Freund didn't know a damn thing about directing when he made it and was routinely bullied by his own cast. Thus, Freund's cinematic genius is all over the film, but so many changes were made to accommodate the cast that the film really suffers as a result. I much prefer The Mummy's Hand as a sort of reboot of the franchise, as well as the sequels that followed. I'm not sure why Horse Feathers particularly hits me, but it does. Part of it is probably that I'm a big college football fan. And I just think Groucho is at 100% in the film. It's also probably Zeppo's best role. Grand Hotel is one of my blank spots. I don't think I've ever seen it. I've not seen White Zombie or Vampyr in eons, so they just don't stick in my mind.
|
|