|
Post by thwhtguardian on Nov 30, 2021 12:28:24 GMT -5
OFF THE RACKS!If you read it, let the world know!
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Nov 30, 2021 15:03:59 GMT -5
Nightwing Annual: 2021Written by Tom Taylor Art by Cian Tormey Summary: When a mobster is caught on camera apparently being gunned down by the Red Hood, Dick springs in to action to defend his brother. Plot: This was a really fantastic example of how to do a team up and make it work. As Dick and Jason race through Gotham trying to find out who framed the Red Hood for murder Taylor really found ways to showcase this dynamic duo's distinct personalities in fun and meaningful ways and the way he highlighted the brotherly relationship between Dick and Jason was just amazing. I could easily read pages and pages of flash backs to Dick mentoring Jason behind Bruce's back, the glimpse we got here was just that good. I was a little confused why they used Preston Payne as the Clay Face here...it's not as if he has a connection to Jason or Dick so I don't get why he was used over Basil Carlo...and further why they didn't use Payne's unique look and instead just gave him the regular Basil Clayface look. Other than that tiny continuity blip it was a fun read and I'm excited for Taylor to get back to his planned story for Dick. Art: My favorite part of this issue was the flashback to Dick and Jason teaming up in the past and I just can't get over how great the disco Nightwing suit and the pixie boot robin look even in a modern book! Who needs an update? Grade:8/10
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Nov 30, 2021 15:49:52 GMT -5
Detective Comics Annual #2021Written by Mariko Tamaki Art by David Lapham Summary: Batman and Nightwing track down a serial killer obsessed with blood while debating the merits of Gotham's mental health structure. Plot: Despite loving Tamaki's take on Batman I wasn't really looking forward to this book as its billed as the prelude to a 12 part weekly event story starting in January...which just sounds terrible to me as most stories just don't need to go on for that long. The fact that its weekly is slightly better as it at-least means it's three months rather than a whole year...but still that's a big commitment and a whole lot of pages needed to tell a story. All that said, this issue focusing on Dick and Bruce's differing views on crime fighting was really well done and the fact that Bruce actually listened to Dick and learned from his was fantastic. I don't know if I think an event focusing around those people lost to the deficiencies of the mental health system in Gotham and the building of a new and improved Arkham will lead to any real change...it'll probably actually be a disaster in the end and be no different than it was before but Tamaki has shown again and again that she can not only keep track of the personal moments amid the chaos of action but also make them feel important so I'll give her event a try. Art: We are seriously blessed with an embarrassment of riches here with Lapham on art! Literally every single image is perfect. I think my favorite element to Lapham's style is the softness of his edges, a lot of artists make Batman and his world all hard lines and sharp angles giving everything an extremely rigid look but Lapham's rounded, organic corners and softer edges give it all a much more warmer look that I just love. On top of that, I love his use of texture which really makes it clear that the heroes have cloth like costumes and not weird armor, it's just so fresh and unique and I can't get enough of it. I know he only does these big two projects to finance his own stories but man does he do super hero stories so damned well! Grade:9/10
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Dec 1, 2021 9:43:45 GMT -5
Batman: The Detective #6Written by Tom Taylor Art by Andy Kubert Summary: Equilibrium has her sights on punishing London and to stop her Batman has to learn to let go and let others in. Plot: I'm still not a fan of the premise of Batman pushing everyone out of his life so the message that in order to win he has to let others in comes across as weak to me as I never thought Batman worked best solo to begin with. On top of that the message of needing family itself felt rushed , unconnected to the plot and ultimately unearned so it's unlikely that it would convince anyone in the "I hate the Batfamily" camp that their stance is wrong...so in the end despite liking the globe trotting fun and action of the story felt pretty empty. Still, independent of that there was a lot to enjoy, I really liked Ducard having a role here and his characterization was a lot of fun and the army of anti-Batman was cool even and their motivation of seeing the ripple effects of Batman's actions outweighing the good he does was interesting so the book wasn't a total loss even if it didn't live up to the promise of its opening. Art: Although I was disappointed by the ending Kubert's art continued to be fun. While he doesn't have the same "wow" factor his father was always able to capture with me, Andy's line work is really dramtic and it definitely catches your eye so you'll never hear me say no to more of his work! Grade:7/10
|
|
|
Post by The Captain on Dec 1, 2021 10:14:29 GMT -5
Batman: The Detective #6Written by Tom Taylor Art by Andy Kubert Summary: Equilibrium has her sights on punishing London and to stop her Batman has to learn to let go and let others in. Plot: I'm still not a fan of the premise of Batman pushing everyone out of his life so the message that in order to win he has to let others in... This is LITERALLY the entire message of The Lego Batman Movie.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Dec 2, 2021 15:33:56 GMT -5
Batman: The Detective #6Written by Tom Taylor Art by Andy Kubert Summary: Equilibrium has her sights on punishing London and to stop her Batman has to learn to let go and let others in. Plot: I'm still not a fan of the premise of Batman pushing everyone out of his life so the message that in order to win he has to let others in... This is LITERALLY the entire message of The Lego Batman Movie. And it was certainly better done there. It just felt rushed here, if Taylor had introduced Bruce regretting being alone earlier or even really mentioning it at all before the final issue the message could have had some emotional resonance...but tacked on at the end it felt like it was completely out of the blue.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Dec 2, 2021 17:38:08 GMT -5
Sir Edward Gray: Acheron Written and Illustrated by Mike Mignola Summary: Hellboy is dead and gone and Hell and Earth are both changed forever, but there is more change in store for Edward Gray. Plot: Usually I'm all for the idea that comics should have an in for everyone as any issue could be someones first...but for every rule there is often an exception and this book is definitely one of those. To put it mildly Acheron is an indulgence aimed squarely at those fans who have poured over every panel of every page of Hellboy's journey for the last three decades; it's a story that is more exclusive to new readers than any comic I've ever read in my life. Literally every line and plot element of Gray's journey here is a call back to something that occurred before and nary a one of them has an accompanying flash back to explain it, it's a book where if you know then you know and if you don't then you'll have no idea what is even occurring, which yeah would be frustrating for those who came in late and only bought it for its glorious cover...but for those of us who have forever been faithful its the coda we never thought we'd get. When BPRD: Ragnarok ended back in April of 2019 with Earth shattered and inherited by a new breed of benevolent monsters living beside the last remnants of man and forests sprouting from the blood of Hellboy in the depths of Hell I never thought we'd see past that; it was the end and it was glorious...but here comes a look into how the denizens of Hell reacted to that change and what it means that I never thought we'd ever get and I'm blown away. It's a reward for long time readers and I definitely feel I deserve it and I can't wait for the second part. Art: As rewarding as the story of Edward Gray's transformation was the visuals(as is often the case with Mignola) really stole the show. I loved the way how malleable Mignola makes reality appear to be in Hell; and the conflict between Gray and Eligos plays out in subtle visual changes as much as it does in actual battle. As Eligos evokes his new master Pluto his shape and size and color grow with the repetition, but as Gray tells him his master's words are lies his hammer becomes a chain, and the horns growing from his eye sockets lengthen and twist blinding him to the world around him. It's a battle that requires an incredibly nonliteral readings of the scenes and that is just so beautiful. Mignola is a master and this is one of his greatest works by far. Grade:10/10
|
|
|
Post by majestic on Dec 2, 2021 23:39:17 GMT -5
DC 2021 Annuals:Nightwing: My favorite of the 3 I got this week. Great stand alone story by Taylor with a team up between Dick & Jason. Taylor is probably my favorite Nightwing writer so far (although Tomasi had a great run). Robin: This story fits into the current arc around #5-6. It expands on some of the other players in the Robin series plus gives us some more insight into Damian. Great story by Williamson. Detective Comics: as thwhtguardian stated this is the prelude issue to the upcoming 12 part arc in 'Tec. Tamaki has been interesting enough as a writer to keep me engaged in Detective.
|
|
|
Post by majestic on Dec 2, 2021 23:59:07 GMT -5
Marvel:
Daredevil #36. Mayor Wilson Fisk & Typhoid Mary get married. Daredevil is released from jail. And Zdarsky revisits Mark Waid's DD run from 2015 when Matt's secret ID was returned to him by the Purple Man's children. This last issue concludes DD for now as next month starts the Devil's Reign mini series.
Fantastic Four #38. Dan Slott channels James Robinson's 2014 story with the Wizard trying to destroy the FF by getting Reed & Sue and Ben & Alicia declared unfit parents. She-Hulk guest stars as the family's lawyer. Slott's run on FF has touched on past classic runs and he really shows what makes this title unique: they are a family first. Heroes second.
|
|
|
Post by DubipR on Dec 3, 2021 11:06:13 GMT -5
Reading pile this week:
- Daredevil #36 - Fantastic Four #38 - Human Target #2 - Wonder Woman Historia- The Amazons #1 - Animal Castle #1
I'll figure out a Read of the Week.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Dec 3, 2021 13:41:44 GMT -5
DC 2021 Annuals:Nightwing: My favorite of the 3 I got this week. Great stand alone story by Taylor with a team up between Dick & Jason. Taylor is probably my favorite Nightwing writer so far (although Tomasi had a great run). Robin: This story fits into the current arc around #5-6. It expands on some of the other players in the Robin series plus gives us some more insight into Damian. Great story by Williamson. Detective Comics: as thwhtguardian stated this is the prelude issue to the upcoming 12 part arc in 'Tec. Tamaki has been interesting enough as a writer to keep me engaged in Detective. I didn't care for the Robin annual, it felt more like a fact file kind of thing than a proper story.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 3, 2021 16:49:43 GMT -5
DC Super Villain Special (or whatever it's called). . being sold as a story written by Danny DeVito
which shows a SPECTACULAR misunderstanding of the characters of both Penguin & Catwoman. and tosses in some stuff that means well, but is shoehorned in.
just absolutely awful storytelling. . and it kicks off the book!
if everything else was this caliber? and F book. . especially for $10.
However, everything else is loads better, including some excellent work on Poison Ivy, and a truly wonderful Killer Moth story.
it loses more points from me for the fact that more than 3/4ths of the stories aren't really all that self contained - but are just pushes to pick up other books (ie: see what happens next by following xxxxxx book).
but overall a very average C+ book, with some beautiful art in places, and one or two shining moments in stories that can't make up for the less than stellar ones.
|
|
|
Post by wildfire2099 on Dec 3, 2021 21:43:30 GMT -5
DC 2021 Annuals:Nightwing: My favorite of the 3 I got this week. Great stand alone story by Taylor with a team up between Dick & Jason. Taylor is probably my favorite Nightwing writer so far (although Tomasi had a great run). Robin: This story fits into the current arc around #5-6. It expands on some of the other players in the Robin series plus gives us some more insight into Damian. Great story by Williamson. Detective Comics: as thwhtguardian stated this is the prelude issue to the upcoming 12 part arc in 'Tec. Tamaki has been interesting enough as a writer to keep me engaged in Detective. I read all 3 of these as well... totally agree Nightwing was a great stand alone story... and I really dislike Jason Todd. He also was likeable here. It was a nice use of Alfred too, without having to bring him back as a zombie clone or having it be ridiculous... just a good flashback. I grabbed the 'Tec one back on thwhtguardian's review, but I don't think I liked it as much. Dick was really just there as a conscious, not as himself, and it really doesn't make any sense he'd be randomly hanging around Gotham when it's got so much of his own stuff going on. The end , with Bruce chatting with Nighwing at the end of the story was pretty ridiculous too... we're supposed to believe Batman would be that dumb, and that no one can figure out who hie is? That's silver age levels of straining credibility right there. I liked Flatline's origin.. kinda fun bringing the Batmanga into the main DCU too... I don't mind profiles and such like that in an annual..it's kinda fun as long as it's not overused.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Dec 6, 2021 18:04:57 GMT -5
DC 2021 Annuals:Nightwing: My favorite of the 3 I got this week. Great stand alone story by Taylor with a team up between Dick & Jason. Taylor is probably my favorite Nightwing writer so far (although Tomasi had a great run). Robin: This story fits into the current arc around #5-6. It expands on some of the other players in the Robin series plus gives us some more insight into Damian. Great story by Williamson. Detective Comics: as thwhtguardian stated this is the prelude issue to the upcoming 12 part arc in 'Tec. Tamaki has been interesting enough as a writer to keep me engaged in Detective. I read all 3 of these as well... totally agree Nightwing was a great stand alone story... and I really dislike Jason Todd. He also was likeable here. It was a nice use of Alfred too, without having to bring him back as a zombie clone or having it be ridiculous... just a good flashback. I grabbed the 'Tec one back on thwhtguardian's review, but I don't think I liked it as much. Dick was really just there as a conscious, not as himself, and it really doesn't make any sense he'd be randomly hanging around Gotham when it's got so much of his own stuff going on. The end , with Bruce chatting with Nighwing at the end of the story was pretty ridiculous too... we're supposed to believe Batman would be that dumb, and that no one can figure out who hie is? That's silver age levels of straining credibility right there. I liked Flatline's origin.. kinda fun bringing the Batmanga into the main DCU too... I don't mind profiles and such like that in an annual..it's kinda fun as long as it's not overused. As a regular thing I wouldn't be for Dick as Jimmie Cricket but in an annual that acts as a kind of holiday special I think it worked and I try not to think too hard about where these characters are all the time when they're in multiple books so I didn't mind that Dick was here in Gotham instead back home.
|
|
|
Post by EdoBosnar on Dec 26, 2021 12:16:41 GMT -5
Wow, I can actually participate in one of these posts, albeit with a delay... Hotell (v2) #1, by John Lees (writer) and Dalibor Talajić (artist), AWA/Upshot Got this from Talajić himself when we met last week (he told me AWA sends him a whole stack of them as soon as they're released). The horrific goings-on at the small motel on Route 66 continue. In this first issue of the second series, a down-and-out family stops to spend a few days there while the father drives off every day to look for work. Their two bored children, a son and daughter, wander off into a small grove of woods near the hotel, and one day the daughter doesn't return as night falls. Their dad eventually finds her, but somethings seems a bit off. And it just spirals downhill from there. Like in the first series, each one of these issues tells a more or less complete story, but all of the separate issues kind of touch on each other (which is why I prefer reading stuff like this in the trade - like I did the first volume - rather than in monthly installments). Still, looking forward to reading more.
|
|