|
Post by berkley on Nov 30, 2023 21:20:53 GMT -5
Brief comment on Colan, his work on the 1970 Dr. Strange series only starts to really work after Tom Palmer comes on board, I think around issue #10. His earlier issues really weren't that great, and all because of the incompatible inkers assigned, always a problem with Colan.
|
|
|
Post by Myke Gee on Dec 1, 2023 20:09:12 GMT -5
***ORIGINALLY POSTED ON FACEBOOK ON JUNE 5, 2021*** 1974: The Year in Review, Pt. III
Good morning, everyone. As I continue my break from monthly reviews, here is part three of 1974: The Year in Review. A review of the 1974 books overall as a series. Due to the Christmas/New Year’s schedule, some monthly books were released late, and the result was that some books only had 11 issues that year. Bi-monthly books were not affected. Here are my overall thoughts on....
AMAZING ADVENTURES #24-29: As I mentioned in the review for issue #28, Killraven has always been an acquired taste. Not really the superhero book that I prefer, but an intriguing sci-fi tale that’s more than an acceptable replacement. Honestly, if it didn’t have ties to the Marvel Universe, I probably would have never read it. My biggest gripe with this series has always been Don McGregor’s overly verbose narration. Characters didn’t speak much because the narration was always there to explain what was happening. I mean, always there. Yet, I look back on the grades that I awarded and it, obviously, didn’t bother me as much as I thought. The year started with Killraven and his Free Men battling the Martian High Overlord, Sabre, and *sigh* Rattack. Next up was Skar and his super-fast tripod called the Devil’s Marauder. This was followed by a strange but entertaining story set in Battle Creek, Michigan where the group faces off against Pstun-Rage who thought that they were there to steal a great “treasure”. What that “treasure” was turned out to be really interesting. The next three issues took the group to Chicago where they were joined by Volcana Ash who added some much-needed personality to the group. There, they took down a cell of slave breeders called Death Breeders, led by the Sacrificer and Atalon the Fear Master. This story also brought in P. Craig Russell who raised the overall grades with his beautiful artwork. Prior to his arrival, Herb Trimpe, Gene Colan and Rich Buckler inked by Klaus Janson handled the artwork. The Buckler/Janson team was really good, as well. So again, despite my gripes about the narration, this book continuously graded well. Average Grade: 7.66
---------------------------------------------------------------------------- ASTONISHING TALES #23-28: As a kid, I somehow managed to acquire a copy of A.T. #21 which featured It the Living Colossus. Don’t know what ever happened to it, but I remember that I read it quite a few times. I purchased another copy about 15 years ago and let’s just say that I wasn’t 8 years old anymore, lol!!! ’74 started with the final two issues of that brief run with mixed results grading-wise. Issue #25 is the debut of Deathlok the Demolisher. When I purchased those A.T. issues 15 years ago, I bought the Deathlok issues, as well. I wasn’t impressed at all back then, but, during this project, I came to love the Gerber DAREDEVIL books that wasn’t impressed with back then either. So, maybe I’ll have a change of heart about this series, as well, right? WRONG! This book feels like a really cool-looking character that Rich Buckler designed, but the story wasn’t fleshed out too well. Most of the time, I’m asking “What is going on in this book?” In one of the reviews, I mentioned that this book reminds me of GHOST RIDER—cool-looking characters in poorly executed books. ‘Lok has an arch-villain, but too bad that Harlan Ryker is so boring and that’s the best word to describe this series, so far: Boring. I hate when I have to negatively criticize a book that I wanted so much to love. But I’m just being honest. So much wasted potential here, in my opinion. Average Grade: 6.41
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
CAPTAIN MARVEL #32-37: The year begins with the final two issues of one of the greatest storylines in Marvel history, in my opinion. The Thanos War was simply a classic!!! So much so that the final two issues received back-to-back 10.0 grades! I really wish that I had this grading system in place when I first started this project. Then, I could definitively say whether this is a first or not. Issue #34 is when Steve Englehart steps in as the writer. Starlin plotted and penciled this issue. It’s mostly known for the introduction of Nitro and the events that led to the Death of Captain Marvel. #35 was the very first issue of CAPTAIN MARVEL that I ever bought. Lost or traded that one away as a kid but bought another copy around 15 years ago when I decided to expand my back catalog. I wasn’t overly impressed with this issue and the next two, for that matter. #36 was a reprint of MARVEL SUPER-HEROES #12. Trying to put the Starlin days and my biases aside, I enjoyed issue #37 a bit more than I did 15 years ago. As I read the post-Starlin book, I realized that I wasn’t just missing Starlin the writer, but Starlin the artist, as well. While I understand that Allen Milgrom is a much better artist than some give him credit for, he’s not Starlin. Needless to say, the first two issues were graded as high as possible. The others, not so much. Average Grade: 7.75
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
DEADLY HANDS OF KUNG FU #1-8/DHOKF SPECIAL #1: It’s 1974 and the kung fu craze is at its peak!!! Don’t believe me? Consider this: Shang Chi stars in THREE books this year: MASTER OF KUNG FU, GIANT-SIZE MASTER OF KUNG FU, and DEADLY HANDS OF KUNG FU. Only Spider-Man Is featured in three books, up to this point. (So, maybe the Shang Chi craze is at its peak, lol!!! Who knows? ) Anyway, I still maintain my point because it’s the only B&W magazine to go monthly up to this point. What was special to me was that, as an avid reader of MoKF, it was good to read Shang Chi stories that I’ve never read. Before LCS’s, I had no idea where to get B&W magazines. Also special, for me, was finally getting to read the Sons of the Tiger. My only exposure to them was from their guest appearance in MARVEL TEAM-UP #40. They started out smokin’, but the current storyline is starting to get a little stale. However, while I find their Green Lantern-like oath a little corny, I’m still enjoying reading them. Conspicuously absent, for the most part, is Iron Fist. He’s only shown up in the DHOKF SPECIAL and special features. I’ve graded Shang Chi and the Sons story individually. Shang Chi averaged 7.5, while the Sons averaged 7.66. Collectively, for the book (including the SPECIAL)… Average Grade: 7.88
---------------------------------------------------------------------------- THE DEFENDERS #13-21: Another book that was bi-monthly at the beginning of 1974. In July, it returned to a monthly schedule. This book was absolutely smokin’ in 1974! To start the year, we got the return of the Squadron Sinister, the defection of Nighthawk to the Defenders, and the first appearance of Nebulon. All over the course of just two great issues. Following up that tale was the Defenders and Prof. X facing Magneto and his Brotherhood of Evil Mutants. Magneto was still in his full megalomaniacal, world-conquering mode before Chris Claremont added layers to his character. This time, his attempt led to the creation of Alpha, the Ultimate Mutant. This plan turned out really bad for Maggy and Crew, lol!!! The next three issues featured the return of the Wrecker and the debut of the Wrecking Crew. It, also, began Power Man’s affiliation with the team. Of course, it was preceded by a hero vs hero battle as Cage took on the team by himself. (No, the Hulk was not there, lol) This storyline, also, was the end of Len Wein’s tenure on the book. The final two issues were Steve Gerber’s first issues on the book. Those two issues were good, but nothing special as he finished up the story he started in MARVEL TWO-IN-ONE #6 & 7 in DEFENDERS #20 and started laying down plots for future stories as he introduced the Headman. Throughout the year, Sal Buscema handled the pencils on this book with various inkers such as Klaus Janson, Dan Green, Frank Giacoia, Vince Colletta, and Sal Trapani. The book always scored high this year until Gerber took over. Those issues didn’t score below 7.0, but they weren’t as high as the previous issue. This book was probably my second favorite behind CAPTAIN AMERICA AND THE FALCON in 1974. Average Grade: 8.27
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
GHOST RIDER VOL. 2, #5-10: 1974 is when Tony Isabella took over this book and, for a couple of issues, at least, had it on a good path. The year starts with Wolman and Moench finishing up the latest G.R. vs Satan story *YYAAAAWWWNNNN!!!!* Sorry. That story had a couple of good moments, but the end result was “meh”. In comes Isabella and the Zodiac. This was when I realized that the problem with this book, for me, was G.R.’s opponents. I’ve said repeatedly that the hero vs the same villain over and over again gets dull pretty quickly. It’s fun to watch Johnny Blaze go into his spook routine against super-villains because it’s effective. It just falls flat against other demons. So, for two issues with the Zodiac, I was having fun. The next two were back to the doldrums of demons. Hopefully, next year is when we can get more villains and be done with the demons every issue. The year ended with a reprint of G.R.’s first appearance despite having the Hulk on the cover. Feast or famine this year as far as grading. Since issue #10 was a reprint, I didn’t bother to grade it. The average is for the other five issues. Average Grade: 7.00
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
POWER MAN #18-23: As a kid, I loved POWER MAN. As I got older, the stereotypes really started to bother me, and I grew to dislike the character. So, when I started this project, I was not looking forward to reading this series. Fortunately, the stories have been so good that I’ve been able to look past that…somewhat. Some of Cage’s dialog is quite cringe-worthy, lol!! Moving on, this was a great year for this book. The first issue was good as Luke kicked Steeplejack’s butt up and down an unfinished building. The next two issues made me realize that Luke is best in his element: namely the streets. He takes on Cottonmouth and his drug empire and the result is a fantastic POWER MAN story. The second part was written by Tony Isabella who took over the book from Len Wein. Next, the original Power Man comes gunning for Luke over the right to the name. Cage beat the crap out of him. A betting that we learn later in THE AVENGERS left him quite embittered. This is followed up by the return of Stiletto and the debut of his brother Discus. For two rather unspectacular villains, they always seem to be fun when they show up. The final issue of ’74 featured the return of Gideon Mace; a book that I read several times as a kid. For the most part, this series received high marks in 1974. Another strong year for POWER MAN. Average Grade: 8.16
---------------------------------------------------------------------------- SUPERNATURAL THRILLERS #7-11: I think that I’ve already admitted that my interest in the Horror genre has started to wane much like my interest in the Westerns. SUPERNATURAL THRILLERS may be a classic example of this. When N’Kantu the Living Mummy debuted in issue #5, I couldn’t wait for him to take over as the star of this series. That issue and issue #7 was written by Steve Gerber. Great story to start this year with my only gripe being that it was set in New York City. That didn’t sit well with me, for some reason. So, with issue #8 N’Kantu was gone from NYC and Gerber was gone from the book. Tony Isabella takes over and keeps the ball rolling with the introduction of the Elementals. A really cool “super-villain” group that I never heard of. With the Mummy in Egypt, I was pleasantly surprised to see the Living Pharoah make an appearance. The story was good, but it could have been better. Maybe if the Living Monolith had shown up, but that would be the end of the Living Mummy, I guess. The next two issues were a steady decline in the quality of the story, but one thing that never declined was the artwork of Val Mayerik. Every issue was beautiful. He mostly inked his own work and Dan Adkins stepped in for a couple of issues which just made the artwork even better. The series started with high marks but declined steadily with each issue. Fortunately, with only 5 issues this year, the grades didn’t decline that far. Average Grade: 7.50
---------------------------------------------------------------------------- TALES OF THE ZOMBIE #5-9: Only five issues of TotZ this year. This series came to an end this year and every issue leading up to it was great. As I mentioned in one of the issue reviews, for whatever reason, I dreaded reading the next issue despite how good the previous one was. I think that it has something to do with the B&W format. As good as many of these magazines are, I still wish that they were in color. B&W is still new to me. Never read one of these magazines until I started this project. Moving forward, Gerber continues to make you feel for the Zombie even if you didn’t like Simon Garth, which I didn’t. Constantly the pawn, it was hard not to feel sympathetic to the creature. I still feel like there were a few similarities to the Man-Thing, but that’s not a bad thing. Issue #9 was the last issue with the Zombie despite there being a 10th issue. Issue #9 also made it seem like we wouldn’t be seeing the Zombie any time soon, also. This was a fabulous series and one that I’m so happy that I put my biases aside to read. Also, issue #6 brought back Brother Voodoo with unspectacular results after his stint in STRANGE TALES ended. Issue #10 will feature Brother Voodoo again and then it’s done. Overall, this book graded very well every month. An extremely underrated series, in my opinion. Average Grade: 8.10
That’s all for this week. As always, I hope that you all enjoyed my thoughts on these comics. See you guys next week for Part IV. Until then, take care.
|
|
|
Post by Myke Gee on Dec 15, 2023 20:06:39 GMT -5
***ORIGINALLY POSTED ON FACEBOOK ON JUNE 12, 2021***
1974: The Year in Review, Pt. IV Good morning, everyone. As I continue my break from monthly reviews, here is part four of 1974: The Year in Review. A review of the 1974 books overall as a series. Due to the Christmas/New Year’s schedule, some monthly books were released late, and the result was that some books only had 11 issues that year. Bi-monthly books were not affected. Here are my overall thoughts on....FANTASTIC FOUR #145-156: Just because the names in the credits are no longer Lee and Kirby, don’t think that this book is no longer capable of creating great stories. True, they don’t come as frequently as the Lee/Kirby heyday, but this series still has a lot of steam. Gerry Conway wrote this series for a little more than half of the year. In that time, he gave us a very good story in the Himalayas as the Torch and Medusa faced off against Ternak. A story that didn’t get better as the rest of the team showed up, but it was still pleasing. In the next three issues, Namor the Sub-Mariner invades the surface world….again. Conway penned a real page-turner with this one. You’d think that Namor invading the surface world would be a “ho-hum” affair, but the twist was he did with the Invisible Girl at his side. However, things weren't quite what they seemed, and I loved that about the story. Conway did not disappoint with this ending to a story that was reminiscent of the Lee/Kirby days. Up next was the 150th issue of the series which started in AVENGERS #127, guest-starring the Avengers and the Inhumans. Too bad such a star-studded cast yielded only a decent story. This one really felt like there should have been a two-issue lead-in so they wouldn't have to stoop to a rushed, deus ex machina conclusion. The second half of the issue was the wedding of Crystal and Quicksilver. The next three issues featured Thundra and the team's battle against Mahkizmo. I was SO prepared to dislike this character because of the corny name, but both he and the story were great. Conway scripted the first two issues of that story and Tony Isabella stepped in to deliver a damn good ending. Issue #154 was, essentially, a reprint with new material framing it. That was disappointing after the last storyline. The year ended on an exceedingly high note as the Silver Surfer battled the FF to free Shalla-Bal from Dr. Doom. The story wasn’t finished by the end of ’74, but that just means an exciting beginning to 1975….I hope, lol!! Rich Buckler and Joe Sinnott handled the art chores most of the year with Ross Andru penciling the first two issues of the year. Such an exceptional year for the First Family of superheroes. Average Grade: 8.25
----------------------------------------------------------------------------- JUNGLE ACTION #9-14: Panther’s Rage is another iconic, critically acclaimed story along the lines of The Kree-Skrull War, The Coming of Galactus, The Thanos War, etc. Like The Celestial Madonna, at times, I wonder how well deserved that status was. Unlike The Celestial Madonna, there have been moments in this story that I’ve genuinely loved. My only issue with is its length and like with Killraven, Don McGregor’s propensity to be overly verbose in his narration. As a bi-monthly book, it feels like enough narration to fill up a monthly title and then some. The first three issues of the year were great despite this. For the most part, McGregor keeps the story engaging, but it’s not without its flaws. One: for a character that fought alongside his fellow Avengers, the Panther doesn’t seem very superheroic in this series. He gets his butt kicked more than the Werewolf by Night. Two: Killmonger shows up and, you guessed it, kicks the Panther’s rear end and he’s rarely seen again in a story that’s as much about him as it is T’Challa. Finally: at times, some of the storyline feels like filler. Not an entire issue, but moments inside an issue where I wondered what the purpose of that scene was. Issue #14 was a classic example of this as there was (what seemed like) a long, drawn-out conversation between Monica Lynn and one of T’Challa’s aids, Taku. The action was flowing nicely, then everything just slowed down with the inclusion of the conversation. As I’ve said in almost every review of the book this year, despite my gripes, I’m still enjoying it. Artistically, Billy Graham handled the pencils all year and did a bang-up job. Much better than his work on POWER MAN. Inking him most of the year was Klaus Janson who always does a spectacular job. The final two issues were inked by P. Craig Russell and Pablo Marcos, respectively. Aside from the final issue, this book continued to grade respectfully. Average Grade: 7.58----------------------------------------------------------------------------- KA-ZAR #3-8: There are some characters that I feel like they work best as guest stars. Characters that have their own books like Morbius, Man-Thing, (to some extent) the Black Panther, and…Ka-Zar. Honestly, Ka-Zar is the first character that comes to mind when this subject is broached. Like Englehart and Mantis, I feel like Ka-Zar is a character that is constantly being forced on the audience. In the many LCSs I’ve visited and the gazillion conversations and/or debates in them, I can’t ever recall anyone ever saying that Ka-Zar was their favorite character. This does not mean that he’s no one’s favorite character. I just never understood his appeal as a featured character. The first half of this year continued the Man-Ape/Man-God story that bored me more as the story went on. Mike Friedrich, Don Heck, and Mike Royer were responsible for the continuous tedium of this story. Beginning in issue #1, I saw no reason to drag that story over five issues. The second half was better as a new creative team stepped in. Gerry Conway (oh, boy…here we go 🙄) was now the writer with John Buscema and Alfredo Alcala beautifully handling the art on issue #6. Bob McLeod inked #7 and Alcala returned for #8. This three-parter featured Ka-Zar and a young boy named Kem Horkus and their struggles in the city of Gondora. A good story with some thinly veiled Biblical allegory. The book graded better in the second half, but the damage to the GPA was already done by the first. Average Grade: 6.75----------------------------------------------------------------------------- MARVEL TEAM-UP #20-31: MTU was one of my mainstay series when I started really collecting it in 1975. At this point, it’s not at the consistent level of quality that those books had. In fact, only one issue earned an 8.0 grade this year. While it was nowhere near horrible (well, issue #28 with Hercules came close, lol), it always seems to hover between mediocre and very good. The year starts with a fairly good conclusion to the Stegron story that began at the end of ’73. The Spider-Man/Dr. Strange team-up the next issue was the only 8.0 awarded to an issue this year. Those two always seem to make for a great team-up. The next couple of issues were good and that’s about the highest praise that I can give them. #22 featured Spidey and Hawkeye vs Quasimodo. You’d think that two wise-mouths would make for a more entertaining story, but the two really didn’t have that much chemistry. Another disappointing tale was the Human Torch and Iceman vs Equinox the Thermodynamic Man. I loved Equinox’ appearance in MTU #59 & 60. I was expecting much more from this story. As I always say: I liked it, but I didn’t love it. The next two issues were slightly better. Surprising that Spidey and Brother Voodoo meshed a little better than him and Hawkeye, but they made a rather good team. #25 was one of my favorite childhood issues and it was the very first time that I ever saw Daredevil. While I still enjoyed the book, I’m not 9 years old anymore and what was “classic” to me then is just “very good” now. The second half of the year was pretty mediocre as the Torch and Thor faced those boring old Lava Men. Spidey and the Hulk was next, and it was a good story although it’s hard to say “Spider-Man and the Hulk vs the Chameleon” without laughing, lol!!! Issue #28 was the low point of the year (and, maybe, the series) as the infamous Hercules scene is one of the most ridiculous in comics history. The final three issues feature another childhood favorite as the Torch and Iron Man team up against a poor man’s version of the Melter called Infinitus and the year rounds out with so-so stories featuring Spider-Man and the Falcon and Iron Fist. Thankfully, I know that 1975 has greater stories coming. Average Grade: 6.83
----------------------------------------------------------------------------- MARVEL TWO-IN-ONE #3-8: The first full year for MTIO was fairly good, even if it was only six issues. Like most fledgling series, it spent the first year finding its footing and differentiating itself from its sister title MARVEL TEAM-UP. MTIO doesn’t follow the MTU formula of heroes meet, heroes fight, heroes realize that it’s a big misunderstanding, and then team up to bash the bad guys. Everyone knows that Ben Grimm is a hero, unlike Spider-Man whose status always seems to be in question. Gerber was there for all six issues, and he started this year by crossing MTIO into DAREDEVIL as a part of the Mandrill/Nekra/ Black Specter storyline. Next was the best story of the year for this book as Ben and Captain America go to the future to meet the Guardians of the Galaxy (in only their second appearance). While it was the best story, the conclusion felt a little rushed, making for a Gerry Conway-esque type ending. The next two issues featured Ben meeting Dr. Strange and the Valkyrie. Gerber continues to cross storylines from books that he writes over into this one. This time, MTIO crosses over into THE DEFENDERS, but the results aren’t as good as the DAREDEVIL crossover. The year ended with a strange Christmas story starring the Ghost Rider as he and Ben take on the Miracle Man. It’s a little off-beat, but I dug it. Along with Gerber for the entire year was Sal Buscema as the penciler. Mike Esposito handled the majority of the inking with Joe Sinnott and Frank Giacoia handling the inks on the first two issues, respectively. The book graded well, but aside from issue #4, nothing Earth-shaking. Average Grade: 7.58----------------------------------------------------------------------------- MASTER OF KUNG FU #17-26: It’s no secret that MASTER OF KUNG FU is my all-time favorite series. Yet, in the beginning, that wasn’t always the case. With the character's debut, Steve Englehart wrote two great stories in SPECIAL MARVEL EDITION #15 & 16 and Shang Chi graduated to his own book, keeping the same numeration of S.M.E. In ’74, Englehart started the series off with enjoyable tales, but it wasn’t on the level of his CAPTAIN AMERICA or his AVENGERS work. Issues #17-19 were written by him and neither rated higher than 7.5 which is still very good. All of the stories, like most this year, featured Shang Chi foiling a plot of world domination by his father Fu Manchu. These early issues are still important to the series because they introduced Black Jack Tarr, who is an essential character to the series, and issue #18 introduced artist Paul Gulacy to the series. Gulacy will go on to be even more essential. Doug Moench steps in with issue #20 and will remain the writer up to issue #120. As much as I love Moench and where he took this series, he wasn’t there yet in ’74. He continued to follow the pattern established in very early Marvel books, i.e., have the hero fight his arch-nemesis repeatedly. So, that means that it was Shang Chi vs. his father’s assassins issue after issue. Some of those were really good, but nothing was exceptional. What I find odd was that none of the stories from DEADLY HANDS OF KUNG FU magazine (now that I’ve started reading the series) were ever referenced in the comic and vice versa. Also, not in top form yet was Gulacy. One of the joys of reading this series is watching the progression of both Moench and Gulacy. Even by issue #50 (his last), Gulacy still wasn’t at his peak and those stories leading up contained some amazing artwork. This series has often graded in the 7.0/7.5 range with only one earning an 8.0 and one below 7.0. 1975 will bring a new direction and it will begin the classic era of this series. Average Grade: 7.30----------------------------------------------------------------------------- STRANGE TALES #173-178: STRANGE TALES returned in 1973 with the introduction of Brother Voodoo in issue #169. To start the year, Brother Voodoo’s tenure comes to an end in issue #173. #174 introduced the Golem; a character that is similar to It the Living Colossus, but a bit more interesting even though he doesn’t speak. As I type this, I’ve noticed a pattern that has been repeated at Marvel during this era. There seems to be an influx of characters that start out great, then very quickly fade; as if only the first story was thought out, but the creators struggle to take the characters forward. Brother Voodoo, Deathlok, The Cat, Shanna, Morbius, (to some extent, Shang Chi), and now the Golem. I enjoyed his debut and liked his second issues a little more than the first. Yet, with his third issue, the story stopped being intriguing and, I guess the powers-that-be agreed because that was his last appearance in the book. STRANGE TALES #178 is legendary because it began Jim Starlin’s tenure on the book and the return of Adam Warlock. Easily the highest-graded issue for the year for this series. Speaking of grades, S.T. was very up and down with only the Golem’s final issue scoring below 7.0. Issue #175 was a reprint of some musty old 1950s horror/sci-fi story, so I didn’t even bother to read it. So, the final average is from 5 issues. Average Grade: 7.40----------------------------------------------------------------------------- SUB-MARINER #70-72: In the end, it seemed like no one cared about this book anymore and that no one wanted to write it. Most of the stories felt mailed in. So, after 72 inconsistent issues, the book is canceled. Some really great runs on this series were always followed by periods of lackluster stories and bland new ideas. The Llyra story arc was the highlight of this series for me and a truly underrated storyline. As for the last three issues, the year started with a snoozer as Namor took on Piranha and the Men-Fish, whom I think were the same mutated characters that he and Spider-Man faced in MARVEL TEAM-UP #14. The first part was pretty dry, but the second part was actually great, in my opinion. Too little, too late, I suppose. The final issue of the series screamed of a fill-in issue, and it was truly the last nail in the coffin for this series. Average Grade: 6.00So, that’s it for this week. Next week, the final part of my review and the final ranking for all of the 1974 books that I reviewed. Until then, take care, everyone.
|
|
|
Post by berkley on Dec 15, 2023 23:46:04 GMT -5
I don' thnk I ever heard of "The Slime-Thing" before. I wonder why he didn't catch on like the Swamp Thing and the Man-Thing.
|
|
|
Post by Myke Gee on Dec 16, 2023 11:30:07 GMT -5
I don' thnk I ever heard of "The Slime-Thing" before. I wonder why he didn't catch on like the Swamp Thing and the Man-Thing. One of the great unsolved mysteries of the universe. There are some things (no pun intended, lol!!!) that just aren't meant for man to know.
|
|
|
Post by berkley on Dec 16, 2023 15:44:08 GMT -5
I don' thnk I ever heard of "The Slime-Thing" before. I wonder why he didn't catch on like the Swamp Thing and the Man-Thing. One of the great unsolved mysteries of the universe. There are some things (no pun intended, lol!!!) that just aren't meant for man to know.
Maybe he's like this huge star in the underwater world. "I'm the biggest Thing in Atlantis, I'll have you know!"
|
|
|
Post by Myke Gee on Dec 16, 2023 17:16:02 GMT -5
***ORIGINALLY POSTED ON FACEBOOK ON JUNE 19, 2021***
1974: The Year in Review, Pt. V
Good morning, everyone. As I continue my break from monthly reviews, here is the final installment of 1974: The Year in Review. A review of the 1974 books as an overall series. I’m closing this with a few odds and ends, plus Marvel’s Giant-Size books and a ranking of the final average grade for each book. So, here are my thoughts on… CREATURES ON THE LOOSE #29-34: CotL started off the year with the final issue of Thongorr’s run in the book. Since it’s the same old sword and sorcery stuff that I have no interest in, I skipped that run altogether. Issue #30 brought in the Man-Wolf and it, basically, starts where GS SUPERHEROES left off (see below). Also, it brought in Simon Stroud, who once was hunting Morbius in FEAR, but is now on the trail of the Man-Wolf. Of the horror books that Doug Moench writes, his Man-Wolf was very good. He hangs around for only one more issue to be replaced by (who else but…) Tony Isabella. He must have been the hot writer of 1974/75. Yet, he’s only there for that issue and to co-plot the next with the late David Anthony Kraft. Kraft finishes up the Isabella story that has the Man-Wolf squaring off against Kraven the Hunter. While I find the Man-Wolf more interesting and capable than the Werewolf by Night, the constant switch in writers made for an up-and-down year as far as grading was concerned. Nothing was crappy, but everything wasn’t great either. This was an inconsistent, but entertaining year. Average Grade: 7.40-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
GIANT-SIZE AVENGERS #1-3: Rascally Roy Thomas started this Giant-Size series by introducing Nuklo and elements of the series that made this one of my favorites. The Vision and Wanda are now officially in a relationship, the revelation that the Whizzer and Miss America are the parents of Wanda and Pietro and pairing the members to handle various threats. The only disappointing part was the art by Rich Buckler and Dan Adkins. I expected much more from those two. Issue two brings back Englehart and Kang the Conqueror. Honestly, the only thing that Kang conquers is my insomnia. Fortunately, we have Englehart who wrote a fantastic story as the team faced Kang who held his alternated selves, Rama Tut and Immortus, captive. A great story that ends with the death of the Swordsman. (I guess it’s up to Kang alone to cure my insomnia, now) Dave Cockrum handling the art was an extra treat. The year ended with Englehart’s obsession with pushing Mantis onto the audience. While it was fun to see individual members of the Legion of the Unliving, it was yet another less-than-stellar entry to the completely overrated Celestial Madonna story. The first two issues earned high marks with the last issue being the low point. Average Grade: 8.00
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
GIANT-SIZE CHILLERS/DRACULA #1-4: This book started as GS CHILLERS FEATURING DRACULA #1. A rather good story that sets up events for future TOMB OF DRACULA stories. As this was the only Marv Wolfman written issue, this makes sense. It’s the only issue drawn by Gene Colan, as well. The next two, now simply GIANT-SIZE DRACULA (although the splash page character intro says “CURSE OF DRACULA” each issue), were written by Chris Claremont with one being particularly good and the other excellent. If not for the Don Heck/Frank McLaughlin artwork, the latter may have earned a 9.5 or even a 10.0, it was that good. The final issue of the year was written by our beloved DAK. Unfortunately, it wasn’t one of his better stories; at least, not to me, anyway. Heck/Springer art didn’t help. Overall, this book graded well with the sole low mark being the last issue of the year. Average Grade: 7.12-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
GIANT-SIZE CREATURES #1/WEREWOLF #2-3: Like GS DRACULA, issue #1 of GS WEREWOLF featured the title character, but had another name. Only 3 issues of this series as all of the GS titles are published quarterly and this one didn’t start until April of ’74. While the Werewolf is in GS CREATURES #1, it’s mostly known for the Cat’s transformation into Tigra. A story that would have graded better if not for Don Perlin's artwork. GSW #2 & 3 were better despite Perlin. The Werewolf/Frankenstein Monster clash was really good! Yeah, the ol’ hairball got his butt kicked again, but come on!!! The Monster is no lightweight. Issue #3 was a tragic, but very engaging tale, as well. Two of the books graded in the 8s while issue #1 was a 7.0. Average Grade: 7.83
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
GIANT-SIZE DEFENDERS #1-3: GS DEFENDERS started kinda cheesy. Essentially, it’s a collection of reprints with a framing story done by Jim Starlin. The new Starlin stuff was great, of course, but the reprints felt like a cheap way to flesh out a story. The second issue was pretty good with a story that harkens back to the team’s supernatural beginnings. It was fun to have the Son of Satan join the team for this adventure. Issue #3 was the gem of them all as the Grandmaster (whom I’ve always liked) returns and Daredevil guest stars. Of course, with the GM, there’s always a game involved and this time it’s against the Prime Mover. While the story reminded me of the CONTEST OF CHAMPIONS, I loved it anyway. Also, this issue featured the first appearance of Korvac. The first two issues graded more than respectably, and the final issue of the year was a gem. Average Grade: 7.83
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
GIANT-SIZE MASTER OF KUNG FU #1-3: Like the regular comic, GS MoKF features more of Shang Chi vs. Fu Manchu. Fortunately, these were some of the better ones. While the first one was really good, the next two were excellent. The first issue featured three brand new stories unlike other Giant-Size books that give you one new tale, and the rest are reprints or special features. The problem was that only the first story was excellent and the other two reeked of inventory stories. Issue two was just a fabulous story that shows why he is the master of kung fu. The final issue wasn’t as great as the previous, but it was just a notch below as this introduced Clive Reston; hinted at being the son of James Bond and the great nephew of Sherlock Holmes. Reston is another character that will become integral to the series as well as the return of Dr. Petrie; thought to have been killed by Shang Chi in the latter’s debut. Gulacy is there for all three issues and was inked by Dan Adkins (whom I felt Gulacy best meshed with), Jack Abel, and Vince Colletta, respectively. The books all graded well, and the first issue would have gotten a higher mark if not for the two inventory-like stories. Average Grade: 8.00
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
GIANT-SIZE SPIDER-MAN #1-3: As I’ve mentioned before, GS ASM should have been called GIANT-SIZE MARVEL TEAM-UP since all of the stories here featured a guest star a la MTU. Although, the GS MTU title wouldn’t have worked with the first issue since Spidey and guest star, Dracula, never teamed up. In fact, they never even met in the story. The closest thing to a meeting was Peter Parker literally bumping into Count Dracula. It was a strange, but very enjoyable story. Next, Spidey meets my boy Shang Chi. The two did the obligatory MTU hero vs. hero thing and then went to stop yet another Fu Manchu plot. I thoroughly enjoyed this, but I was really hoping that Fu Manchu would not be the heavy. It would have been nice to see Shang Chi face someone else. The final issue of the year was something of a dud. Doc Savage did nothing for me in his short-lived series and even less in this tale which felt like another inventory story. The first two books graded well, but the clunker dropped the GPA. Average Grade: 7.66
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
GIANT-SIZE SUPERHEROES #1 (and only): This book, along with GIANT-SIZE SUPERSTARS, kicked off the Giant-Size books at Marvel. 68 pages of new material, a few reprints, and/or pin-ups for 50 cents. This issue features Spider-Man, Morbius, and the Man-Wolf. What I found most interesting about this issue was the use of science-spawned characters that mimicked supernatural ones, i.e., a vampire and a werewolf. While Morbius is not one of my favorite characters, his appearance here works as he makes a pawn of the Man-Wolf and it’s up to Spidey to stop them both. Really a great story. There was an announcement for GIANT-SIZE SUPERHEROES #2, but it never came. So, with only one issue, the average grade is what it was awarded that month. Average Grade: 8.5
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
GIANT-SIZE SUPERSTARS/FANTASTIC FOUR #1-4: Giant-size madness continues as the Fantastic Four, which is having its best year since the Lee/Kirby Dynasty, start the year in GS SUPERSTARS which becomes GS FANTASTIC FOUR with issue #2. This series starts with the Thing vs. the Hulk: Round….. Okay, so I’ve lost count. Whatever round it was, it was a great one with a twist: Ben Grimm was in the body of the Hulk and vice versa. Loads of fun in this issue! Next issue, it was GSFF #2 featuring a time travel story that has the members meeting famous people in history. A good, but not great story as the FF faced the Four Horseman of the Apocalypse. Nope, not the ones from future X-books, but a team that I knew nothing about and really don’t need to see again. Issue #4 was the debut of Madrox the Multiple Man and, boy, was that one a riot!! For the most part, GSFF was all that an oversized issue was supposed to be: an event! Three of the four issues graded extremely well and the fourth was still good, if not spectacular. Average Grade: 8.00
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
GIANT-SIZE SUPER-VILLAIN TEAM-UP #1: I was disappointed with this issue because it was, essentially, a reprint of SUB-MARINER #20 and MARVEL SUPER-HEROES #20. There was a framing sequence that was exciting as it set up the next issue of GSSVTU and the subsequent series. Since this debuted in December of 1974, this was the only issue reviewed. Average Grade: 7.00-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
MARVEL PREMIERE #15-21: With the success of martial arts films here in America at the time and the success of MASTER OF KUNG FU, MARVEL PREMIERE introduces its next martial arts superstar! …Or does it? Issue #15 is the debut of Iron Fist, the Living Weapon. (Marvel really loves “living” things, don’t they? The Living Weapon, the Living Mummy, the Living Pharaoh, the Living Monolith, the Living Laser, the Living Vampire….anywho…) Not that MASTER OF KUNG FU was perfect in these days, but it was much more interesting than Iron Fist. The biggest problem that I have with this book, so far, is that, like Shang Chi, he seems to be just wandering into fight after fight. Also, like Shang Chi, those fights are centered around his father. In Shang’s case, to end his father’s evil plans, and in Iron Fist’s case, to avenge the deaths of his mother and father. There have been moments that I’ve enjoyed in this series, but again, I’m not overly impressed with it. Iron Fist seems like yet another cool-looking character whose story hasn’t really been fleshed out. One parallel that I’ve noticed with such characters is the constant changing of writers. In this case, Roy Thomas writes the debut, co-plots his second appearance with Len Wein, and then both are gone. Doug Moench has his second kung fu book now, but he only hangs around for three issues before Tony Isabella, once again, takes over a book. Gil Kane, Larry Hama, and Arvell Jones were the artists on the book, but none of those guys could give this book the one thing that any of the writers failed to give it: Iron Fist woefully lacks a personality. If “Insipid” was a person, it would be Daniel Rand-Kai. This book continued to grade in the 6.5/7.0 range with only one issue earning a 7.5. I’m hoping that ’75 gets better. Average Grade: 6.85-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
MARVEL SPOTLIGHT #15-20: It’s hard to believe that some of my favorite series of this era are written by Steve Gerber. The writer that I once despised. Well…maybe “despised” is too strong of a word, but I really did not like the books that he wrote. Once again, 15 years ago, I started purchasing back issues starting from January 1973. This series was one that I read, and it did nothing to change my opinion of him. Now…I look forward to his books. The Son of Satan was another cool-looking character that I really wanted to love, and I’ve truly enjoyed his stint in SPOTLIGHT. This book, pretty much, always graded well with four of the six issues grading at 8.0/8.5. This says a lot about my complete 180 on Gerber because none of my favorite artists worked on the book. The first half was Jim Mooney whose work I’ve always been indifferent towards. Gene Colan takes over for two issues and, although I like him on a dark series, he didn’t blow me away like he does on TOMB OF DRACULA. The last issue was drawn by Sal Buscema who could do any type of series, in my opinion, but his contributions weren’t the reason why issue #20 graded an 8.5. It was Gerber who had been delivering all year. Great year for this book. Average Grade: 7.91-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
WEREWOLF BY NIGHT #16-27: The year started off very promising for this title. There was a great Hunchback of Notre Dame story to start, although it was more analogous than an actual telling of the story. That issue was also the last for Mike Ploog. Next issue begins….*sigh*…the Don Perlin era. I’ve resolved to not bash creators who have accomplished more than I ever will in the medium that I love. So, I’ll just say that his style is not for me and leave it at that. Anyway, from here on, the book is good enough to stay in the 7.0/7.5 range, but honestly, I feel like I may have been a little generous with a couple of those grades. The series is getting a little bland mainly because the Werewolf continuously gets his butt kicked. Plus, the Perlin artwork doesn’t help. For a series that started as one of the big surprises of this project, it’s starting to feel like it has overstayed its welcome. Or maybe it’s because my interest in the horror genre is starting to wane, as I’ve mentioned before. Average Grade: 7.25Final Ranking:
1. GIANT-SIZE SUPERHEROES – 8.50 (1 ISSUE) 2. CAPTAIN AMERICA & THE FALCON – 8.41 (12 ISSUES) 3. TOMB OF DRACULA – 8.36 (11 ISSUES) 4. THE DEFENDERS – 8.27 (9 ISSUES) 5. THE FANTASTIC FOUR – 8.25 (12 ISSUES) 6. POWER MAN – 8.16 (6 ISSUES) 7. TALES OF THE ZOMBIE – 8.10 (5 ISSUES) 8. DR. STRANGE – 8.08 (6 ISSUES) 9. GIANT-SIZE SUPERSTARS/FANTASTIC FOUR – 8.00 (4 ISSUES) 10. GIANT-SIZE AVENGERS – 8.00 (3 ISSUES) 11. GIANT-SIZE MASTER OF KUNG FU – 9.00 (3 ISSUES) 12. IRON MAN – 8.00 (6 ISSUES) 13. MARVEL SPOTLIGHT – 7.91 (6 ISSUES) 14. DAREDEVIL – 7.90 (11 ISSUES) 15. DEADLY HANDS OF KUNG FU/DHOKF SPECIAL – 7.88 (9 ISSUES) 16. GIANT-SIZE DEFENDERS – 7.83 (3 ISSUES) 17. GIANT-SIZE CREATURES/WEREWOLF – 7.83 (3 ISSUES) 18. AMAZING SPIDER-MAN – 7.75 (12 ISSUES) 19. CAPTAIN MARVEL – 7.75 (6 ISSUES) 20. AMAZING ADVENTURES – 7.66 (6 ISSUES) 21. GIANT-SIZE SPIDER-MAN – 7.66 (3 ISSUES) 22. THOR – 7.62 (12 ISSUES) 23. THE FRANKENSTEIN MONSTER – 7.58 (6 ISSUES) 24. MARVEL TWO-IN-ONE – 7.58 (6 ISSUES) 25. JUNGLE ACTION - 7.58 (6 ISSUES) 26. INCREDIBLE HULK – 7.54 (11 ISSUES) 27. MAN-THING – 7.54 (12 ISSUES) 28. THE AVENGERS – 7.50 (12 ISSUES) 29. SUPERNATURAL THRILLERS – 7.50 (5 ISSUES) 30. CREATURES ON THE LOOSE – 7.40 (5 ISSUES. #29 did not interest me) 31. STRANGE TALES – 7.40 (5 ISSUES. #175 is a reprint) 32. MASTER OF KUNG FU – 7.30 (10 ISSUES) 33. WEREWOLF BY NIGHT – 7.25 (12 ISSUES) 34. GIANT-SIZE CHILLERS/DRACULA – 7.12 (4 ISSUES) 35. GHOST RIDER – 7.00 (6 ISSUES) 36. GIANT-SIZE SUPER-VILLAIN TEAM-UP – 7.00 (1 ISSUE) 37. MARVEL PREMIERE – 6.85 (7 ISSUES) 38. MARVEL TEAM-UP – 6.83 (12 ISSUES) 39. ASTONISHING TALES – 6.41 (6 ISSUES) 40. SUB-MARINER – 6.00 (3 ISSUES) 41. FEAR – 5.66 (6 ISSUES) Okay, so don’t think for a second that I believe that GIANT-SIZE SUPERHEROES was the #1 book of the year after only one issue, lol!! I just ranked them according to the grade point averages. The clear-cut winner was CAPTAIN AMERICA AND THE FALCON. That’s the problem with getting averages for books that don’t have the same number of issues. The rankings get skewed. Anyway, 1974 was a blast and some series continued to surprise me. My love for the horror genre is waning and I guess sales reflected that as a lot of those books were canceled in 1975. But worry not. As long as TOMB OF DRACULA maintains the quality, I’ll keep reading. I hope that everyone enjoyed this five-part review. I’ll see you all in July with my thoughts on the January 1975 issues. Take care, everyone!
|
|
|
Post by Myke Gee on Dec 19, 2023 22:50:32 GMT -5
***ORIGINALLY POSTED ON FACEBOOK ON AUGUST 7, 2021***
JANUARY 1975 (Cover Dated: April 1975) Good morning, everyone. I’m back with a new year of reviews and it’s one that I’ve been eagerly awaiting. 1975 was when I really started getting into comics. I bought or traded for whatever I could get my hands on. It’s also the year that I started gravitating more toward MARVEL over all the other companies. MARVEL had the superhero teams, and this year introduced a bunch of them. The horror books were getting canceled, for the most part, and quite a few new titles were introduced. The Giant-Size line was also dying out, but a lot of the new series were among my childhood favorites. None of them debuted this month, but stay with me, folks. I’ll definitely get to them. So, without further ado, here are my thoughts on the January 1975 MARVEL titles.
On sale January 7, 1975
DAREDEVIL #120 “And a HYDRA New Year!”
Written by Tony Isabella, pencils by Bob Brown, inks by Vince Colletta. Cover by Gil Kane and Tom Palmer DD and the Black Widow return to New York; With the Widow still mad at Foggy for putting her on trial, Matt tricks her into going to a New Year’s party thrown by his old partner. Hydra crashes the party and DD finds himself battling El Jaguar. Plus, Nick Fury shows up and asks Foggy to join SHIELD! Text feature: Part 1 of the origin of HYDRA, by Tony Isabella.
First appearance of El Jaguar.For some reason, I didn’t think I would enjoy this issue. Mainly because, since Steve Gerber left, we received two less-than-remarkable issues; one of them written by Tony Isabella. Yet, Isabella bounces back this month with an action-packed story. El Jaguar was kinda cool in his own way. Sure, he’s a poor man’s White Tiger, but I liked him anyway. Really good start to this storyline. Grade: 8.5
DEADLY HANDS OF KUNG FU #9 Cover by Earl Norem
Includes: "Enter the Letters!" A letters page with readers' thoughts on previous issues.
Shang Chi, the Master of Kung Fu, stars in "A Contest of Truth!" Written by Doug Moench. Art by Mike Vosburg and Jack Abel.
"Kihon Kumite!" Basic shotokan-style sparring by Frank McLaughlin.
"The Hidden Fist of David Brownridge!" An interview with the Midwest martial arts master by Dan Hagen.
"Oriental World of Self-Defense!" A special photo feature on a martial arts tournament by Michele Wolfman.
Plus, the Sons of the Dragon star in "Slaughter in Central Park!" Story by Bill Mantlo. Art by George Perez and Mike Esposito. Black and White. Shang Chi: Wow! I loved this story, mainly, for one reason: no Fu Manchu. This was a good ol’ Kung Fu battle between two masters with a lesson on what makes a hero to a young observer. Great story! Grade: 8.5
Sons of the Tiger: This issue introduces Lotus. From what I know about this team (which is little), she becomes the fourth member and the cause of the breakup of the Sons. This issue, she’s the Trojan Horse for the Silent Ones. Great Kung Fu action as George Peréz is starting to exhibit some of his signature style. While I’m still hoping that they hurry up and wrap this Silent Ones story up, I enjoyed this chapter. Grade: 8.0INCREDIBLE HULK #186 "The Day of the Devastator!”
Written by Len Wein, art by Herb Trimpe. Cover art by Herb Trimpe. Following the deaths of Colonel Armbruster and Glenn Talbot, General Ross succeeds in capturing the Hulk and has the beast placed in sedation in a deprivation tank. In overseeing the operation with Captain Kirkman, Ross is convinced that the Hulk will remain incapacitated so long as the fluid in the tank maintains a temperature of 250 degrees below zero. The base is attacked by the Devastator, who powered by a Russian satellite, begins to lay waste to the Hulkbuster Base. Spotting the Hulk, the Devastator attacks him, and the confused brute fights back. Confession: I read this book only because I need to in order to review it. Not because I want to. This doesn’t mean that I don’t enjoy the stories. Just that this series isn’t high up on my list to read first. I guess it’s because you just know that the Hulk is going to beat the crap out of whoever he faces. That’s why I get so excited when the Abomination shows up. He makes the outcome questionable sometimes. Devastator was a cool enough villain, but the outcome was not a mystery. The Hulk, Thor, and Namor need opponents that are nearly their equal or more to make them interesting, in my opinion. This issue was good, but I’m hoping to see more formidable opponents in the future. Grade: 7.5
TOMB OF DRACULA #31 "Ten Lords a Dying!"
Written by Marv Wolfman. Art by Gene Colan and Tom Palmer. Cover by Gil Kane and Tom Palmer.
A major turning point for our cast, as Taj must make the hardest decision of his life. Rachel Van Helsing lets her guard down and makes a fateful mistake. Quincy Harker is drawn into a murder mystery. And Inspector Chelm faces off with the Lord of Vampires himself! We are at the midway point, boys, and girls. Don't miss the issue that will change everything. So, the summary is a bit hyperbolic, but that doesn’t mean that the issue wasn’t good. In fact, it was another great issue in this series. Grade: 8.0
ALSO ON SALE THIS WEEK
On sale January 14, 1975
AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #143 "...And the Wind Cries: Cyclone!"
Written by Gerry Conway. Pencils by Ross Andru. Inks by Frank Giacoia and Dave Hunt (backgrounds). Cover by Gil Kane and John Romita. Spider-Man continues to hallucinate thanks to Mysterio’s mind-warping abilities. After Jameson is kidnapped, Joe Robertson and Peter travel to France with nearly a million dollars for his ransom. Plus, Peter and MJ share their first kiss!
First appearance of the Cyclone.AMAZING SPIDER-MAN was a little lackluster last year. This year, things got off to a good start as the introduction of the Cyclone was quite enjoyable. Of course, this is just part one of a Gerry Conway story. So, who knows how good the ending will be? Right now, I’ll settle for a very solid start. Grade: 7.5
CAPTAIN AMERICA AND THE FALCON #184 "Cap's Back!"
Written by Steve Englehart, pencils by Herb Trimpe, inks by Frank Giacoia and Mike Esposito. Cover by Gil Kane/John Romita Sr. The Red Skull is back to exact revenge on Captain America once again! But will there be an innocent lost in their never-ending war of good versus evil? Well, Frank Robbins is gone (at least, for this issue) to be replaced by Herb Trimpe. Not exactly my choice to replace him, but despite my dislike of Trimpe’s style, he is an upgrade from Robbins. This is a good story, but it kind of feels like Englehart has said all that he has to say with this character. A good start to this story, but it felt a little off; not the usual Englehart magic. Ah well. Maybe it will pick up the next issue. Grade: 7.5
DOCTOR STRANGE VOL. 2, #7 “The Demon Fever!”
Written by Steve Englehart, pencils by Gene Colan, inks by John Romita Sr. Cover art by John Romita. Strange travels to the Dark Dimension, where he is overcome by Umar & Orini. Plus, Strange is drained of magical knowledge by the G'uranthic Guardian. Appearance by Dormammu. Cameo by the Scarlet Witch. The story continues in GIANT-SIZE AVENGERS #4.The interesting thing about this issue is how it gets better towards the end. Clea goes into action and finally gets to wield some magic. I, honestly, thought that writers had forgotten that she has powers of her own. Most of the time, she’s depicted as being an extreme novice or the damsel that Strange must save. Good stuff! Grade: 7.5
GHOST RIDER VOL. 2, #11 "The Desolation Run!"
Written by Tony Isabella. Art by Sal Buscema and John Tartaglione. Cover by Gil Kane and Klaus Janson. Guest-starring the Hulk. Johnny Blaze enters the Desolation Run, a motorcycle race across the vast wilds of America. But when the Inferno-possessed Hulk crashes the scene, Blaze has no choice but to unleash hellfire! This issue sort of drives home a point that I made in my review of MARVEL TWO-IN-ONE #8. In that review, I mentioned that GR was transitioning into a fledgling superhero. In this issue, Johnny Blaze talks about how he used his powers, mostly, to save himself, and now, he’s using them to save others and he likes the feeling. “With great power...” heh-heh. Speaking of great power, this issue, GR takes on the Hulk. Okaaaayyy....if they say so. If he is becoming a superhero, surviving a battle with the Hulk seems to be the baptism of fire for every hero. Plenty of eye-rolling moments, but enjoyable. Grade: 7.5
GIANT-SIZE WEREWOLF #4 "A Meeting of Blood"
Written by Doug Moench, art by Virgil Redondo. Cover pencils by Gil Kane. The Werewolf finds himself yet again locked in a deadly battle - this time, against Morbius, the Living Vampire! Plus, classic tales of Marvel horror throughout the ages! Sometimes, it’s a struggle to read this book. After a really strong start to the regular series, it’s pretty much obvious that its heyday is over. Now, we have Giant-Size tedium. A monthly and quarterly book that features its star getting the crap beaten out of him in nearly every issue. This time it’s Morbius’ turn to smack the fur ball around. At least this issue gave us a break from Don Perlin, but Redondo wasn’t that much better. When I started this project, I gained a newfound respect for the Western and horror genres, but like the Westerns, my interest in the horror books (TOMB OF DRACULA aside) is starting to wane. Grade: 4.5
MASTER OF KUNG FU #27 "Confrontation!"
Written by Doug Moench, pencils by John Buscema, inks by Frank Springer. Gil Kane cover pencils (Klaus Janson cover inks?)
The Master of Kung Fu, Shang Chi, fights his way into the inner sanctum of Fu Manchu. However, can Chi survive an encounter with the deadly Council of Seven? Get ready for a confrontation between father and son unlike any that has come before. A really good issue not because of the action, but because of a very interesting and poignant conversation between Shang Chi and Fu Manchu. Fu Manchu was the real star of this story. As much as I love the arrogant dialogue of Dracula, Dr. Doom, and Thanos, Fu’s arrogance truly rivals each of theirs. I love how these characters rationalize their actions and how they are unyielding in admitting that they are truly evil. (Well, maybe not Dracula. He knows that he’s evil and revels in it, lol). While I’m tired of the nonstop confrontations with Fu Manchu, directly and indirectly, this was an enjoyable issue. My only gripe is letting Springer ink Big John. Just.....why? Grade: 7.5
TALES OF THE ZOMBIE #10 Cover by Earl Norem
“The Resurrection of Papa Jambo” Written by Doug Moench, art by Tony DeZuniga. Brother Voodoo must return to Haiti to save the life of a young girl from ritual sacrifice.
“Eye for an Eye, Tooth for a Tooth” Written by Gerry Conway, art by Vir Redondo and Rudy Nebres. Dead bodies, darksome mysteries, and...zombies!
“Malaka’s Curse” Written by Carl Wessler (Plot) and John Warner (Story), art by Vincente Alcazar. Voodoo madness on a grim night of terrifying vengeance!
Final issue of TALES OF THE ZOMBIE. Brother Voodoo: Brother Voodoo is another character that I really want to love, but he’s just okay, to me. At least, as he’s been written, so far. The story is pretty straightforward as BV faces a villainous houngan called...*sigh*...Dramabu. (There’s a goofy name if you’ve ever heard one.) A decent story is enhanced by Tony DeZuniga’s beautiful artwork. His black & white work completely dwarfs anything that I’ve seen from him in full-color comics. Grade: 7.5
THOR #234 “O, Bitter Victory!"
Written by Gerry Conway, pencils by John Buscema, and inks by Joe Sinnott. Cover pencils by Gil Kane, inks by Dick Giordano.
Loki and his army are winning the war and Thor and the US army might have to consider a final, desperate action. Guest appearances by Hercules, Firelord, and Sif. Jane Foster cameo. Thor vs. Loki, round 732! Color me unimpressed. Again, it’s not that these are bad stories. Not at all. It’s just that it’s been done to death. Even the inclusion of Firelord gave nothing more than a bit more spice. Just a bit. As I said in the last review of this book. It’s getting a little stale. Grade 7.0
ALSO ON SALE THIS WEEK
On sale January 21, 1975
THE AVENGERS #134 "The Times That Bind!"
Written by Steve Englehart. Art by Sal Buscema (layouts) and Joe Staton (finishes). Cover by Gil Kane and Joe Sinnott (with John Romita touch-ups). With half of the Avengers in Kree space, the team receives a lesson in the military history of the Kree-Cotati wars. In Limbo, the Vision re-lives his past as the original Human Torch. Meanwhile, Moondragon shows up at the abandoned Avengers Mansion, following the summons of Captain Marvel. *ZZZZZZZZZ* Oh...um, hello. Sorry about that. If you think that I opened my comments like that for comedic effect, then you’re wrong. I, actually, nodded off while reading this. The Celestial Madonna has been the biggest disappointment I’ve ever read from a story that receives so much praise; from one of the so-called “classic” Marvel sagas. The origin of the Vision continues to cover no new ground and Mantis’ is blended into a convoluted history of the Cotati and the Kree. None of this stuff is interesting. It comes off so much like filler that Englehart even threw in an obligatory two-panel fight scene between the Scarlet Witch and Moondragon. I cannot wait for this story to be over. Grade: 4.5
THE DEFENDERS #22 “Fangs of Fire and Blood!”
Written by Steve Gerber, pencils by Sal Buscema (layouts) and Mike Esposito (finished art), inks by Mike Esposito. Cover pencils by Gil Kane, inks by Joe Sinnott. Valkyrie learns about life among the poor, Nighthawk discovers he'd rather spend time with the Defenders than with his old crowd. Also, the Defenders battle bigotry in New York City as the Sons of the Serpent begin to terrorize the poor. It’s...interesting to me how writers who write multiple books can completely smoke on one title, be up and down on another, and be barely interesting on another. Gerber, Englehart, and Conway are classic examples of this. On MAN-THING, Gerber has really been hit or miss, lately. Yet, on THE DEFENDERS, his stories are, nearly, perfect. Case in point, this issue. A fantastic story built a little slowly, but quickly became a page-turner. The Sons of the Serpent have always made for an interesting story because their appearances broach an uncomfortable subject; especially nowadays. After seeing Englehart torture his AVENGERS audience with his self-indulgence, it’s good to see that Gerber is more interested in telling great stories. Looking forward to the next issue. Grade 9.0
FEAR #27 "Night of the Vampire-Stalker."
Written by Doug Moench, pencils by Frank Robbins, inks by D. Fraser. Gil Kane cover pencils. Simon Stroud effectively hunted Man-Wolf… and now he’s added a certain vampire to his list! Okay, so maybe it was the convoluted story that ran all of last year that I couldn’t get into. This may be the best Morbius story that I’ve ever read. No, it is the best Morbius story that I’ve ever read. One thing that I find interesting about this series is how people react to him as a pseudo-vampire. Stroud is a good character that faded into obscurity after this series, but his presence and relentless pursuit of Morbius has made this best....well...you all know the rest. Good story...drawn by Frank Robbins, unfortunately. Grade: 7.5
GIANT-SIZE SPIDER-MAN #4 "To Sow the Seeds of Death's Day!"
Written by Gerry Conway. Pencils by Ross Andru. Inks by Mike Esposito. Cover by Gil Kane and Mike Esposito. The Punisher has discovered that an evil mastermind is testing biological weapons on kidnapped Americans somewhere in South America. After recruiting the web-slinger to help him, the Punisher and Spider-Man break into the offices of the shadowy Deterrence Research Corporation in New York City. However, during the attack, the wall-crawler is captured and transported to the death camp of Moses Magnum! Can the Punisher rescue the Amazing Spider-Man and the captive civilians before they meet a horrible fate?
3rd appearance of the Punisher.
First appearance of Moses Magnum.
Backup story: "The Wondrous World of Doctor Strange!"
Written by Stan Lee. Art by Steve Ditko. Spider-Man and the Master of the Mystic Arts team up to battle Xandu! Reprinted from DOCTOR STRANGE #179. This was really a lot of fun to read because I’ve never read any of the early Punisher appearances prior to his Frank Miller makeover in DAREDEVIL. Equally fun was seeing the first appearance of Moses Magnum. He’s one of those villains that gets more interesting each time he appears. The story here was pretty straightforward and in typical MARVEL TEAM-UP fashion. Typical, but quite enjoyable. Grade: 8.0
MAN-THING #16 "Decay Meets the Mad Viking!"
Written by Steve Gerber. Art by John Buscema and Tom Palmer. Cover by Gil Kane and Klaus Janson. When two strange beings stalk the same swamp, only one can survive!!! What a really strange story. So, a hippie rock star quits in the middle of his tour to hang out with his groupies in the Man-Thing’s swamp. Also, there’s a crazy old man dressed as a Viking and is really strong who is, pretty much, a few sandwiches short of a picnic. This ax-wielding nut rants about how there a no real men left; only “sissies”! Oh Mr. Gerber, what were you smoking? I get that it’s satirical, but man is it bizarrely entertaining. Grade: 7.5
MARVEL SPOTLIGHT #21 “Mourning at Dawn!”
Written by Steve Gerber, pencils by Sal Buscema, inks by Joe Giella. Cover pencils by Gil Kane, inks by Tom Palmer. Continuation of the story "The Fool's Death", where Hellstrom still struggles with the strange forces that are trying to kill him, while Dr. Reynolds and a police detective discover the truth about Madam Swabada. When I purchased a bunch of comics around 2005 or so, SPOTLIGHT was one of them. I remember reading these same Son of Satan stories, but I don’t remember enjoying them as much as I’m enjoying them now. This Madam Swabada tale is really interesting. Again, I have to give Gerber his credit for crafting strange, but entertaining stories. Son of Satan only has a few more issues as the star of this book before he’s off to his own title. I hope that I have a newfound respect for those stories, as well. Grade: 7.5
POWER MAN #24 "Among Us Walks...Black Goliath!"
Written by Tony Isabella, pencils by George Tuska, inks by Vince Colletta. Cover by Gil Kane and Dan Adkins Luke Cage meets Claire's ex-husband, Dr. Bill Foster, former lab assistant to Hank Pym (Giant Man) and the superhero known as Goliath. And the big man isn't too happy when he finds the woman he still loves in the arms of another man. Everyone knows what follows next...super-hero tussle in the mighty Marvel fashion.
First appearance of Bill Foster as Black Goliath.When BLACK GOLIATH #1 hit the stands, the cover had an interesting, but familiar line. “Because YOU demanded it!!!” Really?!! Who demanded it and when?? Don’t get me wrong, Bill Foster is a likable enough character, but I never understood how his book would be any better than Hank Pym’s in his TALES TO ASTONISH days. The battle between Cage and B.G. was fun, but this was the most unspectacular audition for a solo series ever. I’m not saying that I didn’t enjoy the book. Just that there was nothing special here to warrant a solo series. Grade: 7.5
SUPERNATURAL THRILLERS #12 “The War That Shook the World!”
Written by Tony Isabella and Val Mayerik, pencils by Val Mayerik, inks by Klaus Janson. Cover pencils by Gil Kane, inks by Klaus Janson. While helping Dr. Skarab and the Asp, the Mummy learns that Miles Olddan and Zephyr have been captured by the Elementals. They have taken over Cairo and have encased the city in a magical force shield. What separates the Living Mummy from a few of his horror contemporaries is that, unlike the Werewolf, Man-Thing, the Zombie, and the Man-Wolf, he’s capable of intelligent thought. Yet, just like the others, he cannot communicate with the people that he encounters because he doesn’t speak their language. The other thing that I find interesting is that his heroic moments aren’t incidental to the circumstances of the story. He’s heroic because he’s a good man. All of this was on display here in this issue and that made this chapter of an otherwise unremarkable story enjoyable. Grade: 7.5
ALSO ON SALE THIS WEEK
On sale January 28, 1975
FANTASTIC FOUR #157 "And Now the Endgame Cometh!"
Written by Roy Thomas. Art by Rich Buckler (breakdowns) and Joe Sinnott (finishes). Cover by Rich Buckler and Joe Sinnott. Guest-starring the Silver Surfer. The Silver Surfer is trying to revive the memory of Shalla-Bal, while the FF battles Doomsman II- who wields the Power Cosmic! Will Doctor Doom’s plan to eliminate the Fantastic Four follow through? Or is there a larger plan in motion? Hoo-boy!!! This one was a doozy!!! Nearly perfect, if I must admit! That last sentence in the description: “Or is there a larger plan in motion?” The answer to that is what makes this entire storyline so damn good. This may be the best FF story of the post-Lee/Kirby era! It also sets up the fabulous 1982 SILVER SURFER one-shot. I was going to grade this as a 9.5, but.... Grade: 10.0
GIANT-SIZE DEFENDERS #4 "Too Cold a Night for Dying!"
Plot by Don McGregor and Roger Slifer. Script by Steve Gerber. Pencils by Don Heck. Inks by Vince Colletta. Cover by Gil Kane and Frank Giacoia. Guest-starring Yellowjacket. The main story of this Giant-Size mag features a car explosion in which Kyle Richmond and his girlfriend, Trish Star, are tragically injured. The problem is the Defenders are wrong about who was behind the attack. Yellowjacket, for reasons his own, wants in on the action and finds the real perpetrator. However, he also has to save the Defenders from their own mistakes. The only thing that brought this issue down a little was the Don Heck artwork. Believe it or not, Colletta actually helped make it more tolerable. Otherwise, it was a great story. I got the Squadron Sinister and I got my favorite version of Hank Pym as Yellow Jacket. Grade: 8.0
MARVEL TEAM-UP #32 "All the Fires in Hell!"
Written by Gerry Conway. Pencils by Sal Buscema. Inks by Vince Colletta. Cover by Gil Kane and Frank Giacoia. Johnny Storm and the Son of Satan battle a supernatural force that has possessed Wyatt Wingfoot! But once the inner demonic rage consumes Hellstrom, Johnny gets more than he bargained for! Will the Human Torch be able to save Wyatt...and survive the Son of Satan's fury? Cameo appearance by the Thing. Up to this point, MTU continues to hover around the mediocre to above average range with a few good to very good issues thrown in. The pairing of the Torch and Hellstrom was interesting enough, but what the story lacked was an interesting villain. Dryminextes could stop at the first three letters when taking a name. A faceless demon that we never really got to see makes for a less-than-memorable tale. Disappointing. Grade: 6.0
STRANGE TALES #179 "Death Ship!"
Written and drawn by Jim Starlin. Cover art by Jim Starlin. Warlock is captured by Autolycus of the Black Knights and brought aboard Magus' Flagship. He'll stick around for a little just to learn more about this strange race, but his breakout is imminent!
First appearance of Pip the Troll.Something that I’ve never noticed before is how Starlin becomes a better artist between the end of his CAPTAIN MARVEL run and his work on Warlock. And I loved his CAPTAIN MARVEL stuff. Warlock begins his battle against the Magus and his Universal Church of Truth. Again, this story still holds up. Grade: 8.0
WEREWOLF BY NIGHT #28 “The Darkness from Glitternight”
Written by Doug Moench, art by Don Perlin. Cover pencils by Gil Kane, inks by Dan Adkins.
The Werewolf battles Dr. Glitternight. Plus, approaching Lissa's 18th birthday, the gang fears she will succumb to the Russoff curse…! Man, Moench is really dragging this Dr. Glitternight story out. This chapter was a little more interesting than the previous one, but literary tour-de-force it was not. Glitternight, also, resurrects Taboo and talks about how the “...battled as only two supreme sorcerers can.” Makes me wish that Dr. Strange would show up and just put a magical smackdown on both of these wannabes. What makes this chapter better is what happens at the end and, I admit, I’m anxiously awaiting the next issue. The last issue was graded at 5.5. Again, this one was a little better, but not by much. Grade: 6.5ALSO ON SALE THIS WEEK
YES!!! I gave FF #157 a 10.0!!! Wanna make something of it?!?!! Anyway, less than half the books graded an 8.0 or above. That makes this month slightly disappointing. Yet, there were a lot of 7.5s this month. That grade is still more than acceptable in my book. So, I’ll take them. Not much to say about this year’s start. Only 4 out of 25 books rated less than a 7.0. Despite a slight bit of disappointment, this was a good month. From here on, I’ll be ranking all of the books that I’ve read for the month, but the Top 5 Covers will remain. Next week: the conclusion of the Celestial Madonna Saga and the beginning of the Gwen Stacy clone storyline. Until then, take care, everyone! This Month’s Rankings: 1. FANTASTIC FOUR #157 – 10.02. THE DEFENDERS #22 – 9.03. DAREDEVIL #120 – 8.54. DEADLY HANDS OF KUNG FU #9 - 8.25 (2 story average)5. STRANGE TALES #179 – 8.06. TOMB OF DRACULA #31 – 8.07. GIANT-SIZE DEFENDERS #4 – 8.08. GIANT-SIZE SPIDER-MAN #4 – 8.09. DOCTOR STRANGE VOL. 2, #7 – 7.510. MAN-THING #16 – 7.511. AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #143 – 7.512. MARVEL SPOTLIGHT #21 – 7.513. MASTER OF KUNG FU #27 – 7.514. SUPERNATURAL THRILLERS #12 – 7.515. FEAR #27 - 7.516. GHOST RIDER VOL. 2, #11 – 7.517. POWER MAN #24 – 7.518. TALES OF THE ZOMBIE #10 – 7.519. INCREDIBLE HULK #186 – 7.520. CAPTAIN AMERICA AND THE FALCON #184 – 7.521. THOR #234 – 7.022. WEREWOLF BY NIGHT #28 – 6.523. MARVEL TEAM-UP #32 – 6.024. THE AVENGERS #134 – 4.525. GIANT-SIZE WEREWOLF #4 – 4.5 Top 5 Covers of the Month: 1. GIANT-SIZE DEFENDERS #4 2. GHOST RIDER #113. AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #1434. GIANT-SIZE WEREWOLF #4 5. OUTLAW KID #27
|
|
|
Post by chaykinstevens on Dec 24, 2023 18:34:27 GMT -5
VAMPIRE TALES #9 Blade the Vampire Slayer in "Blood Moon" Written by Chris Claremont, plotted by Marv Wolfman, art by Tony DeZuniga. Blade, Vampire Hunter, continues his quest to take down endless legions of the UNLIVING DEAD! JAD (Jose Antonio Domingo) painted cover. Black and white. Claremont can craft a great vampire story as well as a mutant story, I see. Of course, at this point, he hasn’t written any mutant stories yet. Yet, the pacing of this story has his name written all over it.If Marv Wolfman plotted the story, it may have been drawn before it came to Claremont, so I don't know how much influence Claremont would have had over the pacing, unless he slowed everything down with too many angst-ridden thought balloons. MARVEL TWO-IN-ONE #8 This issue, the Ghost Rider is “formally” brought into the Marvel Universe. His adventures in his own book never crossed over to a part of the MU that I can recall. Yes, he’s met the Son of Satan, but he hasn’t interacted in the MU either. Someone correct me if I’m wrong.Ghost Rider had previously teamed up with Spider-Man in Marvel Team-Up #15 and with Stunt-Master in GR #7, and had appeared in one panel in Avengers #118.
|
|
|
Post by chaykinstevens on Dec 24, 2023 18:52:24 GMT -5
Written by Doug Moench, pencils by Frank Robbins, inks by D. Fraser. GCD says D. Fraser was a pseudonym for Leonard Starr, who was probably best known for his work on Annie.
|
|
|
Post by Myke Gee on Dec 25, 2023 12:26:22 GMT -5
VAMPIRE TALES #9 Blade the Vampire Slayer in "Blood Moon" Written by Chris Claremont, plotted by Marv Wolfman, art by Tony DeZuniga. Blade, Vampire Hunter, continues his quest to take down endless legions of the UNLIVING DEAD! JAD (Jose Antonio Domingo) painted cover. Black and white. Claremont can craft a great vampire story as well as a mutant story, I see. Of course, at this point, he hasn’t written any mutant stories yet. Yet, the pacing of this story has his name written all over it.If Marv Wolfman plotted the story, it may have been drawn before it came to Claremont, so I don't know how much influence Claremont would have had over the pacing, unless he slowed everything down with too many angst-ridden thought balloons. MARVEL TWO-IN-ONE #8 This issue, the Ghost Rider is “formally” brought into the Marvel Universe. His adventures in his own book never crossed over to a part of the MU that I can recall. Yes, he’s met the Son of Satan, but he hasn’t interacted in the MU either. Someone correct me if I’m wrong.Ghost Rider had previously teamed up with Spider-Man in Marvel Team-Up #15 and with Stunt-Master in GR #7, and had appeared in one panel in Avengers #118. About your Ghost Rider comments, all of that I completely forgot about, and in the case of MTU #15, that’s embarrassing because I love that issue.
|
|
|
Post by MDG on Dec 25, 2023 19:35:00 GMT -5
Written by Doug Moench, pencils by Frank Robbins, inks by D. Fraser. GCD says D. Fraser was a pseudonym for Leonard Starr, who was probably best known for his work on Annie. I'd say, even after he took over Annie, Starr was best known for On Stage. What's more interesting is that his style is diametrically opposite of Robbins.
|
|
|
Post by Myke Gee on Jun 20, 2024 12:28:33 GMT -5
Greetings, everyone. It's been nearly six months since I posted the January 1975 review. So much has been going on in my life that I just haven't had the time to post in this group, and frankly, I didn't anyone was reading these anymore, lol!!!
***ORIGINALLY POSTED ON FACEBOOK ON AUGUST 18, 2019*** FEBRUARY 1975 (Cover Dated: May 1975)
Good morning, everyone. Here is the second installment of my review of Marvel Comics published in 1975; one of my favorite years in comics. None of the great debuts happened this month, but they’re coming. So now, here are my thoughts on the Marvel Comics of February 1975.
On sale February 4, 1975
DAREDEVIL #121 “Foggy Nelson, Agent of SHIELD”
Written by Bob Brown (co-plot) and Tony Isabella, pencils by Bob Brown, inks by Vince Colletta. Cover pencils by Gil Kane, inks by Joe Sinnott. As Foggy tries to decide if he should join SHIELD, Hydra attacks, and DD and the Widow fail to prevent the Dreadnaught from capturing D.A. Nelson. Appearances by Nick Fury, SHIELD, El Jaguar, Mentallo, and Silvermane. Okay, Mr. Isabella. You’re changing my mind about your ability to restore this book to its very brief moment of glory, thus far, that Steve Gerber established. This DD/BW vs Hydra story is a heck of a lot of fun. Although, I have no idea how these two stood up to a Dreadnaught, but....whatever. Like I said, it was a fun read. Grade: 8.0THE FRANKENSTEIN MONSTER #16 “Code-Name: Berserker!”
Written by Doug Moench, pencils by Val Mayerik, inks by Bob McLeod. Cover by Ron Wilson. Eric Prawn takes Ralph and the Frankenstein Monster to Europe to Veronica Frankenstein's home. Criminal organization I.C.O.N. is dead set on perfecting their super soldier program. Unfortunately, Frankenstein’s Monster may pay the price! I.C.O.N. kidnaps the Monster, all in the name of ethically unsound science. Will the monster’s genetics hold the key to I.C.O.N.'s success? This book feels more like FRANKENSTEIN, THE ANTI-HERO than the “horror” comic it once was. Now, he’s in the Swiss Alps with robots on skis trying to kidnap him for a world-conquering organization called SMERSH...🙄 I’m sorry, I meant I.C.O.N. 😊 I swear, as the skiing robots were approaching, all I could hear was the James Bond theme song in my head. Maybe this is where Moench got the idea to have Shang Chi become a spy. If the Frankenstein Monster can fight criminal organizations, why not a master of kung fu? Grade 7.0GIANT-SIZE MAN-THING #4 "The Kid's Night Out!"
Written by Steve Gerber, pencils by Ed Hannigan and Ron Wilson, inks by Frank Springer. Cover art by Frank Brunner. Panic in the sky as the most startling slime creature of all stalks the hallowed halls of a terrified high school. Prejudice and hypocrisy play a big part in a kid’s death. "Frog Death!" Written by Steve Gerber, art by Frank Brunner. Howard the Duck falls through the dimensions back to Earth and must face Garko the Man-frog. Man-Thing: This was a quirky, but tragic tale. It’s a cautionary tale of how bullying can lead to tragic results. In the beginning, it was quite engaging, but then it bogged down a bit with the reading of the dead kid’s diary. As usual, the Man-Thing’s involvement was pivotal and ancillary at the same time. An interesting, thought-provoking story about the effects of bullying. Grade: 7.5
Howard the Duck: HtD was another character that I never quite “got”. I understand that his stories are satirical and all, but the character just never appealed to me. Now that I’ve read his first appearance in FEAR, I’m hoping that my newfound love for Steve Gerber trickles down to Howard. This short story was a great start to winning me over. Garko was an interesting and bizarre character. Too bad how he ended up, lol!! Frank Brunner’s art was as fabulous as it’s ever been. This was quite an enjoyable story. Grade 8.0INCREDIBLE HULK #187 “There's a Gremlin in the Works!”
Written by Len Wein, pencils by Herb Trimpe, inks by Joe Staton. Cover art by Herb Trimpe.
It is revealed that Glenn Talbot is being held captive at a Soviet base in Siberia! Can General Ross, S.H.I.E.L.D.’s Nick Fury, and Clay Quartermain save Talbot…without Bruce Banner’s help? Banner stows away on a mission to rescue the captured Talbot, which brings the Hulk into conflict with the Gremlin, who has brainwashed Talbot. So, ol’ Clay Quartermain and his Roger Ramjet grin are back, huh? This was the first series that I ever saw him in, back when I would sporadically read the HULK. It was a great issue with a twist ending. At the same time, I feel stupid for not seeing it coming, lol!! Grade: 8.0TOMB OF DRACULA #32 "And Some Call Him Madness!"
Written by Marv Wolfman, pencils by Gene Colan, inks by Tom Palmer. Gil Kane/Palmer cover.
Quincy Harker believes he has the necessary deathtraps and accoutrement to kill Dracula. The Lord of Vampires is led through a fatal maze in Harker's estate! Man, this series is SO good at times. Yes, there are times when it feels a bit slow, but Wolfman always seems to make those slow moments pay off in the end. Dracula is at his arrogant best even as he faces death from the defiant Harker’s home of vampire death traps. This fabulous story continues in the next issue. I can’t wait!!! Grade: 9.0ALSO AVAILABLE THIS MONTH
************************************************************************** On sale February 11, 1975 AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #144 "The Delusion Conspiracy!"
Written by Gerry Conway. Art by Ross Andru (breakdowns), Frank Giacoia (finishes), and Dave Hunt (backgrounds). Cover by Gil Kane and John Romita.
On the banks of the Seine River inside the Cathedral de Notre Dame, the wondrous wall-crawler battles the Cyclone to save J. Jonah Jameson and Joe Robertson! Stateside, Aunt May sees a young woman who is the spitting image of the deceased Gwen Stacy! Is this a strange apparition? Or has Gwen Stacy returned from the dead? The web-slinger's nightmare is only just beginning. The first (full) appearance of the Gwen Stacy clone. Cameo appearances by Aunt May and Anna Watson. Origin of the Cyclone. So, once again, I’ve come to a story (or the beginning of one, actually) that is lauded and/or panned, depending on whom from this group that you’re talking to. But I’m getting ahead of myself. First, there is the kidnapping of James and Robbie that Spidey deals with without making both suspicious of why Spider-Man was in France. The solution was a little cheesy, but fun at the same time. Next month, the first chapter of the Gwen Stacy clone story. Grade: 7.5CAPTAIN AMERICA AND THE FALCON #185 "Scream the Scarlet Skull!"
Written by Steve Englehart, pencils by Sal Buscema (pages 1 and 2) and Frank Robbins (pages 3-18), inks by Frank Giacoia. Gil Kane/Giacoia cover.
The Red Skull returns to cause more trouble. With Captain America hopelessly outnumbered, will the Red Skull finally triumph? Prepare for an unbelievable ending! Englehart is still bringing it on this title. Unfortunately, it has Robbins to interpret this wonderful story. Yet, fortunately, the story is good enough to tolerate Robbins’ awkward style. The Skull is more menacing than he’s ever been in this story and, for once, I’m finding him interesting. Grade: 8.0MARVEL TWO-IN-ONE #9 "When a God goes Mad!"
Plot by Steve Gerber, script by Chris Claremont, pencils by Herb Trimpe, inks by Joe Giella. Gil Kane cover pencils. Thor and the Fantastic Four guest star. The sinister Puppet Master wants to destroy the Fantastic Four and he plans to use the power of Thor to do it. Under the thrall of the villain, the Thunder God attacks his friends, and only the Thing is left standing to stop him. Wundarr cameo. This one was about as formulaic as it gets. That doesn’t mean that it wasn’t entertaining, but it had all the obligatory tropes of a superhero team-up story. Grade: 7.0MASTER OF KUNG FU #28 "A Small Spirit Slowly Shaped..."
Written by Doug Moench; pencils by Ron Wilson, Ed Hannigan, and Aubrey Bradford; inks by Sal Trapani. Gil Kane cover pencils. Sir Denis Nayland Smith has been kidnapped, and an esoteric message on a bamboo scroll is the only lead Shang-Chi has! Shang Chi comes face-to-face with the Shadow-Stalker (last seen in GIANT-SIZED MASTER OF KUNG FU # 3). But this time, is the man who can smash steel here to kill Chi, or help him? Finally!!! The last of the, seemingly, never-ending Fu Manchu stories. However, this issue centered more around his sister Fah Lo Suee. Again, enjoyable, but nothing special. Next issue, a bold new direction! Grade: 7.0THOR #235 "Who Lurks Beyond the Labyrinth!"
Written by Gerry Conway, pencils by John Buscema, inks by Joe Sinnott. Cover pencils by Gil Kane, inks by Frank Giacoia. The Absorbing Man is looking to take the fight to Thor and when he absorbs the power of Mjolnir, he might have enough might to do so. Plus, Hercules and Sif prepare for the threat that is Kamo Tharn. Like Hawkeye, Hercules has always been one of those characters that was popular enough to keep featuring him in a series, but not popular enough to get his own. He’s been a guest star in this book for quite some time, now, and this issue was as much about him as it was Thor. Maybe even more as he and the Lady Sif battled Kamo Tharn for the Runestaff. It almost felt like Marvel was giving him a “try-out” to see if the fans would petition for a solo series. The result was a great chapter in a story that has been a little lackluster, in my opinion. The return of the Absorbing Man was also quite a treat. This is really odd: A Gerry Conway story that’s getting better as it goes along, lol!!! Grade: 8.5 ALSO AVAILABLE THIS MONTH
************************************************************************** On sale February 18, 1975 THE AVENGERS #135 "The Torch is Passed!"
Written by Steve Englehart. Pencils by George Tuska. Inks by Frank Chiaramonte. Cover by Jim Starlin and John Romita Sr. (vignettes). The Vision discovers that Ultron played a significant role in his transformation from human to sentient A.I. Moondragon tells Mantis that she is the runner-up “Celestial Madonna”, should Mantis prove unworthy of the title. Meanwhile, in present-day Vietnam, Moondragon joins Mantis, Hawkeye, Iron Man, Thor, Libra, and the Cotati to uncover the secrets of the Celestial Madonna. Origin of the Vision. Origin of Moondragon. This was the most interesting part of the Vision’s origin mainly because what came before this chapter has already been explained. Interesting to know that, when the Vision first came to be, he still had the mind of the original Human Torch as well as the body. What does any of this have to do with the overrated Celestial Madonna story, I’m not sure anymore. The new info, while interesting, is a somewhat convoluted chapter to a convoluted story. The best part of this issue is its cover. Thank goodness, there’s only one more chapter. Grade: 6.5CAPTAIN MARVEL #38 "No Way Out!"
Written by Steve Englehart (co-plot, script) and Al Milgrom (co-plot), pencils by Al Milgrom, and inks by Klaus Janson. Cover pencils by Al Milgrom, inks by Klaus Janson.
The Lunatic Legion is a group of blue-skinned Kree opposed to their race's intermixing with other species that produced the pink-skinned offshoot and to the Supreme Intelligence that fostered Kree culture away from their conservative ideals and they want to execute Mar-Vell. Before that happens, Mar-Vell must recover from Rick's drug-induced trip and discover the mind-expanding effects that the drug has on his Cosmic Awareness. So, now Englehart writes elements of the boring Celestial Madonna story into these pages. A skewed retelling of the beginning of the Kree-Skrull enmity. Fortunately, it was only a small part of the story. The clash with the not-so-formidable Lunatic Legion was just a precursor to the Trial of the Watcher. Again, I’m enjoying this a bit more than I did years ago. Grade: 7.5 CREATURES ON THE LOOSE #35“Wolfquest”
Written by David Kraft. Art by George Perez and Frank McLaughlin. Cover by Gil Kane, Tom Palmer, and George Roussos. The Orbiting Space Station is nearly taken by Hate-Monger and Red Hate! Meanwhile, J. Jonah Jameson takes heat from the FBI as they probe into the disappearance of his son. DAK is building something here and we all know that it culminates in MARVEL PREMIERE. This is a series that’s getting better and it’s fun to see George Perez growing as an artist. I’ve never been a big fan of the Hate-Monger, but he had some appeal in this issue. A decent series that has only two issues left in this mag. Grade: 7.5THE DEFENDERS #23 "The Snakes Shall Inherit the Earth!"
Script by Steve Gerber, pencils by Sal Buscema, inks by Vince Colletta. Cover by Gil Kane and Klaus Janson. The Sons of the Serpent continue their attack. Are the Defenders prepared? Yellowjacket guest stars. A few of the best stories that I’ve read on this journey involved the Sons of the Serpent. Yes, they’re a little ham-fisted, at times, but I guess that I gravitate towards these stories because they are still relevant today. Gerber tells a great story without sensationalism. 60s, 70s, 80s, 90s, 2000s, it doesn’t matter. It’s a problem here in this country and even in comics, there will never be a clear-cut solution to it. At least, stories like this are not just entertaining but thought-provoking. Looking forward to the next chapter. Grade: 8.5 JUNGLE ACTION #15 “Panther's Rage, Pt 10: Thorns in the Flesh, Thorns in the Mind"
Written by Don McGregor, pencils by Billy Graham, inks by Dan Green. Cover art by Gil Kane. The Panther encounters another of Killmonger's assassins, Salamander K'Ruel, in the Forest of Thorns. He also has to fight a killer pterodactyl. I recently remarked in one of my reviews of this book that the Panther gets his butt kicked nearly as much as the Werewolf by Night. Kicked by Killmonger and whatever crazy aid he has with him. Kicked so much so that he hardly seems like a superhero at all. Yet, in the last two issues, he’s singlehandedly beaten a T-Rex and a pterodactyl. That is the frustration of reading this book, at times. Never mind that we are into part 10 and a half of that felt like well-written filler. Always slowing the pace of the story is the nonstop narration (which I’ve taken to hearing in the voice of the late Roscoe Lee Brown to make it more tolerable, lol), and the cutaway scenes with Monica Lynn and Taku. I am still, somewhat, enjoying this book. But it’s time to wrap this story up. Grade: 7.0 MAN-THING #17 "A Book Burns in Citrusville!"
Written by Steve Gerber. Art by Jim Mooney. Cover by Gil Kane and Tom Palmer. Richard finds himself swept up in a war of intolerance and the Man-Thing may be powerless to help. Not a lot happens in this issue; particularly from the Man-Thing. What does happen is that fear and narrow-mindedness make an entire town go crazy by the end of the issue. Again, not much happens, but I found it fascinating. Grade: 8.0ALSO AVAILABLE THIS MONTH ************************************************************************** On sale February 20, 1975
DEADLY HANDS OF KUNG FU #10 Cover by Harold Shull.
Special full-length Iron Fist extravaganza. Includes: "Enter the Letters!" A letters page with readers' thoughts on previous issues. Iron Fist stars in "Slay Now, Die Later!" Part 1. Story by Tony Isabella and David Kraft. Art by Frank McLaughlin and Rudy Nebres. Part 2: "The Origin of Iron Fist!" Story by Doug Moench. Art by Don Perlin. Part 3: "Iron and Steel!" Story by Tony Isabella and David Kraft. Art by Frank McLaughlin and Rudy Nebres. Plus, the Sons of the Tiger star in "They Who Dwell Within!" Story by Bill Mantlo. Art by George Perez and Mike Esposito.
Includes a B&W poster of Shang Chi, the Master of Kung Fu. Black and white. Iron Fist: So, apparently there was another Steel Serpent before the one that was introduced in MARVEL TEAM-UP. I didn't know that. This story was better than anything that’s been published in MARVEL PREMIERE, so far. All of the creators involved did a great job on this issue. Iron Fist still doesn’t have much in the way of personality, but at least the story was good. I’m awarding an extra half point for the fantastic artwork by McLaughlin and Nebres. Grade: 8.0Sons of the Tiger: A very trippy issue, complete with the Sons fighting spiritual versions of themselves. It’s a decent chapter in this, seemingly, never-ending war with the Silent Ones. I love multi-chapter stories, but like Panther’s Rage and the Celestial Madonna, it’s time to wrap this one up, as well. Grade: 7.5ALSO ON SALE THIS WEEK.
************************************************************************** On sale February 25, 1975
AMAZING ADVENTURES #30 "The Rebels of January and Beyond!"
Written by Don McGregor, pencils by Craig Russell (pages 1-5, 18), inks by Dan Adkins (pages 1-5, 18). Pages 6-17 reprint pages from AMAZING ADVENTURES #23-24 with pencils by Herb Trimpe and inks by Frank Chiaramonte and Jack Abel. Cover by Craig Russell.
April 2019: The High Overlord is called to his Martian superiors in Washington D.C. to provide a report on the battle between him and Killraven back in January. Another reprint with a framing sequence of new material. See the December 1973 review for issue #23 and February 1974 for issue #24. As for the framing sequence, it was nothing special. Grade: 6.0FANTASTIC FOUR #158 "Invasion from the 5th (Count It, 5th!) Dimension"
Script by Roy Thomas. Art by Rich Buckler (breakdowns) and Joe Sinnott (finishes). Cover by Rich Buckler and Al Milgrom.
Guest-starring the Inhumans. With the Inhuman royal palace under siege by Xemu of the 5th Dimension, Quicksilver is sent to retrieve Medusa by order of Black Bolt. The rest of the FF head to the Hidden Land to take the palace back. But are they headed straight into a trap? It occurred to me as I was reading this story that, after 158 issues, a few Annuals, and 3 Giant-Size books, the Invisible Girl MAY have been a part-time member more than she's been a full-time member. Crystal had a lengthy stint and Medusa has been a member since issue #132; just over two years. None of that is germane to the review of this issue. Just a thought that popped into my head. As for the issue, Roy Thomas continues to impress. In my opinion, since Gerry Conway left, the book has nearly returned to its original glory. Grade: 8.0GIANT-SIZE AVENGERS #4 "Let All Men Bring Together!"
Written by Steve Englehart. Pencils by Don Heck. Inks by John Tartaglione. Cover by Gil Kane, Al Milgrom, and John Romita (touch-ups). The story continues from AVENGERS #135. Wedding of the Vision and Scarlet Witch. The Scarlet Witch is imprisoned by the almighty Dormammu- but not if Vision can help it! The Avengers’ resident synthezoid travels to the Dark Dimension to save the woman he loves. But can the Vision, a creation of science, hold battle with Marvel’s mightiest mystic? The Vision and the Scarlet Witch vs. Umar and the hellish Dormammu! Meanwhile, in Vietnam, the Cotati explains the mystery of the Celestial Madonna to Mantis and Moondragon. An extraordinary ending for Earth's Mightiest Heroes! I really wish you all could have seen my face after reading this. There's not an emoji that can do it justice. Of all the long, overly drawn-out crap that I've ever read, this one takes the cake. HOW is this considered a classic Avengers tale?!! I was really hoping that there would be a big payoff at the end, but it was just more tedium. There were only a couple of decent moments in this story and that's about it. Not garbage by any means, but it was the very definition of mediocre at best. What a disappointment this was. Grade: 5.0IRON MAN #74 "The M.O.D.O.K. Machine!"
Written by Mike Friedrich. Art by Arvell Jones, Keith Pollard, and Dick Ayers. Cover by Gil Kane. The War of the Super-Villains kicks into high gear as M.O.D.O.K. and the Mad Thinker accept the Black Lama's challenge. The Mad Thinker seizes control of Shell-head's armor and sends Iron Man to kill M.O.D.O.K. Meanwhile, Firebrand escapes from prison. (Note: The series returns to monthly publication with this issue.) The Black Lama story is starting off extremely interesting. This guy has approached the Red Skull, Dr. Doom, Fu Manchu, and MODOK and lived to tell the tale. Impressive. The supervillain war is also intriguing. I hope that Friedrich doesn’t pull a Gerry Conway and deliver a weak ending to this story because I’m all in, at this point. Grade: 8.0KA-ZAR #9 "The Man Who Hunted Dinosaur!"
Script by Gerry Conway, pencils by John Buscema (layouts) and Sonny Trinidad (finished art), inks by Sonny Trinidad. Cover pencils by Gil Kane, inks by John Romita.
A Savage Land tribesman named Tomas hunts to please his father but becomes angry when his father proclaims his brother, Gregor as the chief. He strikes his brother down and in turn, is slain by the mate of the dinosaur he killed. A story swiped from Cain and Abel in the Bible. Only this "Cain and Abel" are tribesmen in the Savage Land. This was a good one-and-done, but nothing more. I'll say this: even though the stories haven't always been stellar, John Buscema has been a great addition to this series. His work always seems to raise the grade by half a point. Grade: 7.0
MARVEL PREMIERE #22 "Death Is a Ninja"
Written by Tony Isabella, pencils by Arvell Jones, inks by Aubrey Bradford. Cover pencils by Gil Kane. The Cult of Kara-Kai strengthens their attack against Iron Fist, and the Ninja joins the fray! On an alternate dimensional plane, the Ninja reveals his Samurai origins. Colleen and Lee Wing learn more about Daniel Rand. 1st appearance of Master Khan. There may not be much in the way of dialog in this book, but there is plenty of action. Part of what makes superhero comics fun is the constant back-and-forth between the combatants. Yet, this book just bombards you with narration in the second person. Iron Fist is a character that rarely speaks in his own book. Even the taciturn Shang Chi is considered chatty compared to this guy. Anyway, the Ninja storyline is over, and the book seems like it's about to head in a new direction. Hopefully, that new direction (and new writer Chris Claremont) can inject some personality into the character. One more thing: Arvell Jones crushed it with the fight choreography. Grade: 7.5MARVEL TEAM-UP #33 "Anybody Here Know A Guy Named Meteor Man?"
Written by Gerry Conway. Art by Sal Buscema (layouts) and Vince Colletta (finishes). Cover by Gil Kane and Frank Giacoia.
Nighthawk requests the aid of Spider-Man to track down the Looter, a brazen thief who has stolen a natural artifact from Nighthawk! Cameo appearance by Jeremiah. This story might have been more appropriate for a book called MARVEL TWO-IN-ONE because, while the two characters are in the book, they never really "team up". It's a good story, but it also felt a bit inconclusive. The stars meet but don't team up and the issue of the Looter/Meteor Man is never resolved. I know that there is another part to this story, but if memory serves me correctly, the story just moves on from both of those issues as if they never happened. I’m not sure, really. I guess I’ll find out next month. Good, but an odd little tale. Grade: 7.0
WEREWOLF BY NIGHT #29 "A Sister of Hell"
Written by Doug Moench, art by Don Perlin. Cover pencils by Gil Kane, inks by Klaus Janson.
Jack Russell, as the Werewolf, battles his sister, Lissa, who has become a werewolf. As the battle ensues between the beast-versions of the Russell siblings, Buck and Topaz try to keep the two from killing each other! Part 3 of "The Amazing Doctor Glitternight" story. Sometimes, I want to drop this book and sometimes I don't. I keep reading because I told myself, good or bad, to stick with a series as long as it's connected to the Marvel Universe. (Even though the Westerns are connected, they became too redundant) This storyline had a really good ending in chapter 2, but it didn't pay off this issue. Just two growling creatures fight and Jack Russell narrating the play-by-play. I believe this story concludes in the next issue. I wish it were the conclusion of Perlin's tenure on the book because he is part of the problem with this book. Grade: 6.0THANKFULLY, The Celestial Madonna Saga is over!!!!! Once again, only 4 books rated lower than 7.0 and two of them were from that vastly overrated storyline. As I think back on every AVENGERS story that I’ve reviewed, this one is, probably, the worst. So, enough of that. Overall, a very strong month. Nine of the 25 books that I read received an 8.0 or above. Next month: The Gwen Stacy Clone Saga begins, Englehart pens his last CAPTAIN AMERICA AND THE FALCON issue, the last issues of GS DRACULA and GS MASTER OF KUNG FU, Shang Chi begins his classic era, and last, but not least…THE INVADERS!!! See ya next week, gang, and as always, take care.
Top 5 Books of the Month:
1. TOMB OF DRACULA #32 – 9.0 2. THE DEFENDERS #23 – 8.5 3. THOR #235 – 8.5 4. FANTASTIC FOUR #158 – 8.0 5. IRON MAN #74 – 8.0 Top 5 Covers of the Month:
1. AMAZING ADVENTURES #30
2. GIANT-SIZE MAN-THING #4
3. THE FRANKENSTEIN MONSTER #16
4. JUNGLE ACTION #15
5. THE AVENGERS #135
|
|
|
Post by EdoBosnar on Jun 21, 2024 3:28:46 GMT -5
Definitely agree that the Man-Thing stories, both in the Giant-size and regular series, are quite good. I think Gerber did some of his best work in that series, together with Defenders (although I like it, I'm not as fond of Howard the Duck, which seems to be his best-regarded work in that early, 1970s period of his career). And yeah, "Panter's Rage" in the pages of Jungle Action is also a personal favorite. Otherwise, though, I guess I liked the Celestial Madonna story better than you did.
|
|
|
Post by Calidore on Jun 21, 2024 9:57:52 GMT -5
Very happy to see another one of these. Long may they continue!
|
|