|
Post by tarkintino on Dec 31, 2023 13:29:24 GMT -5
EDGAR RICE BURROUGHS’ TARZAN #100, January 1958, Dell I know Jesse Marsh has his fans, but his sketchy work is just not my kind of comics. Panels look like cels from a crudely animated mid-70’s cartoon to me. The staging feels static, and images such as Tarzan rising from river with water pouring off of him are unconvincing, establishing the point but not evoking any sensation in the reader. His Tarzan is almost always expressionless, intentionally evoking the stereotypical Weissmuller performance. Agreed--Marsh's work is the texbook example of bland and uninspiring, the last things any adventure comic needed. As far as i'm concerned, the Dell version would have benefited from the energetic, stylized pencil of someone like the great Alberto Giolitti, who would make a memorable mark on a number of Gold Key titles. Looking forward to that. By the time the early 80s rolled around, I was pretty sick of movie studios still trying to mine old novels (pulp or not), radio heroes and early newspaper & Golden Age comic book characters, all inspired by the success of 1978's Superman the Movie. After the Donner movie, suddenly studios were scraping every IP barrel trying to produce the next "vintage hero" film, from the abysmal Popeye, Flash Gordon (both from 1980), The Legend of the Lone Ranger (1981) to 1982's Annie (first a musical, but its comic strip roots made it a candidate for adaptation to film). As seen throughout film history, the success of one film or concepts usually spawns imitators, which are almost always crap. I beg your pardon.... Hey, I stand by that. Popeye is the kind of character--unlike superheroes--does not lend himself to odd interpretations. Outside of the strips, he will always be best served by animation, namely the Fleischer / Famous Studios cartoons.
|
|
|
Post by tonebone on Jan 4, 2024 11:59:58 GMT -5
EDGAR RICE BURROUGHS’ TARZAN #100, January 1958, Dell I know Jesse Marsh has his fans, but his sketchy work is just not my kind of comics. Panels look like cels from a crudely animated mid-70’s cartoon to me. The staging feels static, and images such as Tarzan rising from river with water pouring off of him are unconvincing, establishing the point but not evoking any sensation in the reader. His Tarzan is almost always expressionless, intentionally evoking the stereotypical Weissmuller performance. Agreed--Marsh's work is the texbook example of bland and uninspiring, the last things any adventure comic needed. As far as i'm concerned, the Dell version would have benefited from the energetic, stylized pencil of someone like the great Alberto Giolitti, who would make a memorable mark on a number of Gold Key titles. Looking forward to that. Hey, I stand by that. Popeye is the kind of character--unlike superheroes--does not lend himself to odd interpretations. Outside of the strips, he will always be best served by animation, namely the Fleischer / Famous Studios cartoons. Since I am in the vast VAST minority in thinking that movie is a masterpiece, nevermind watchable, I will hold my tongue... but I will be watching you.....
|
|
|
Post by MWGallaher on Feb 13, 2024 18:21:17 GMT -5
JUNGLE TALES #1, September 1954, Atlas Comics (Marvel) The cover, by Joe Maneely, is inconsistent with the interiors: the blonde jungle queen does not look like the dark-haired Jann, neither of the natives battling near the volcano look like Waku, and the specific scenes of the white hunters appear nowhere in the interior pages, although the fellow in the upper left is mustachioed like Cliff Mason. Future issues would retain this four-panel sampler, but with all four of the individual ongoing features generally recognizable and labeled. Jann of the Jungle appears for the first time in “Rampage”, an origin story illustrated by Art Peddy. It opens with Jann coming to the rescue of a white man being pounced upon by a lion, but all is not as it appears: this is a movie being directed by one Pat Mahoney, a filmmaker who has relocated permanently to Africa, where he specializes in jungle films. The star is Eva Dawn, a pampered actress who relies on her stunt double to perform all the action scenes. The natives, friendly to “B’wana Pat”, urge the stuntwoman to ask Pat to cease production: it is a time of drought, and the local wildlife is restless, dangerous, and unnerved by the bustle of the production crew. When they learn that this is Jane Hastings, “former circus trapeze artist and animal trainer”, they inexplicably begin cheering her as “Jann! Jann! Jann!” Pat insists on continuing the filming, but before Jane can explain why the natives are calling her “Jann”, the camp is stampeded by a menagerie of beasts, led by a ferocious rhino. “Jann” leaps on the back of the rhino, uses her bow like reins to redirect the beast away from camp, and the rest of the animals follow. Before she can return to camp, she is attacked by a huge snake, and she dispatches it with a knife to the neck. Finally, Jane explains her new name: the natives have a legend of a white woman years ago who served and protected the tribe. This original Jann left with a white lion-hunter, and they see Jane as their returning protecting jungle goddess. Pat scoffs at the tale, but is told that the original Jann was Jane’s grandmother: Jane, like her mother, was trained by Grandma in the ways of the jungle. As the filming crew prepares to leave, “Jann” vows to stay in this, her second home, and Pat stays, too, “to watch over the new Jann!” While I have my doubts that Grandma could very effectively teach Jane and her mom the ways of the jungle without actually being there, it’s a good touch to make Jane a legacy jungle heroine. I also doubt that Pat is qualified to “watch over” Jann, but patronization was not exactly uncommon in comics of the era. And it’s probably just an excuse to give Jann a supporting (white) character and romantic interest to interact with. It’s unclear how and why these natives recognize the new “Jann”, but perhaps it was not intended as “recognition” so much as fate bringing Jane Hastings back to reclaim Grandma’s role in the tribe: a coincidence that was no coincidence at all. Next, Waku, Prince of the Bantu makes his bow in “Fire Spirit!” with art by the wonderful Ogden Whitney. This is Waku’s origin story, beginning with Waku’s father, Chief Kaba, forcing Waku to vow he would never rely on force to rule the Bantu. Kaba dies at peace, but Waku’s vow prevents him from accepting the tribal tradition that calls for a prospective chief to beat the strongest of the tribe in combat. Consequently, the strong and wicked Mabu assumes the chieftainship, while Waku is exiled, much to the dismay of Waku’s lover, Lalei, who overheard Waku’s vow and knows why Waku stoically refused to meet the challenge. Mabu proves to be as cruel a leader as Waku had feared, forcing the tribesmen to fight for his amusement and planning to sell them as slave laborers. During a ceremony to honor the late Chief Kaba, Lalei masquarades as the spirit of the deceased chief, proclaiming that Waku has been released from his vow of pacifism. Waku, watching from the trees, realizes that it is a ruse by Lalei, but breaks his vow anyway when the angry Mabu protests. He drops from the trees and engages Mabu in silent combat, kicking his opponent to a death in the fire! The tribesmen are happy to have Waku back as Chief, but Waku must make penance for breaking his vow, and prepares to sacrifice himself in the flames. Lalei argues that she should pay the price, and Waku decides that they both will willingly walk into the fires and perish together. Before they enter the inferno, the real spirit of Kaba materializes; he had indeed inspired Lalei to speak for him, and it was his genuine intent that Waku be freed from the too-restrictive oath. The people celebrate, and Waku and Lalei live to have adventures in future issues of JUNGLE TALES! Was this the first serious solo feature for a Black character at Atlas/Marvel? I wouldn’t be surprised if there were some caricatured Blacks taking the lead in some of their humor series, but I can’t think of any other straight adventure characters, certainly none that made the covers. My research indicates that Waku never appeared after his 8 issue run here; the series was retitled JANN OF THE JUNGLE AND OTHER JUNGLE TALES as of issue 8, after which Waku was displaced in favor of multiple Jann of the Jungle stories. In an era when few characters from Marvel’s extensive catalog avoid being dragged back into the Marvel Universe, Waku is an oversight who could easily be worked into a modern-day Black Panther story. (What a kick it would be to see a Black Panther story that featured T’Challa, Waku, “Black Brother” from SAVAGE TALES #1, and a grown up Calvin “Li’l Kid” Kidd in Africa!) I liked this one a whole lot. Of all the jungle comics I’ve sampled in this project, few have focused on native characters. That is a big draw in itself, but the story was a fun one in its own right. I liked the surprise of Waku’s lethal dispatching of his enemy, the unexpected element of the supernatural with Kaba’s spirit. “Strange Valley” is the two-page text story, with author and spot illustrator uncredited. The bar for text stories is pretty low, but this one is very readable and fairly interesting. An artist moves to Africa to paint scenes from deep jungle life, but communications with his agent suddenly stop. The agent travels to the jungle, where he learns that his client disappeared in the taboo region on the other side of the blue hill. The agent goes to his rescue, discovering pygmies in a frigid zone on that far side, pygmies who have enslaved the artist and others to mine the blue coal that heats their village. It is the residue of the blue coal that has given the hill its blue tint! The agent uses a discarded blowgun to fire matches at the pygmies’ grass huts, and the ensuing fire allows the artist and other slaves to escape. The agent has had his fill of African adventure, but the artist remains there to paint on the peaceful side of the hill with his native friends. The Unknown Jungle debuts with the story “The Challenge of the Pit”, drawn by Jack Katz. This feature was to focus on the wildlife of the jungle rather than humans. The narrative captions provide ongoing commentary on the experiences of Numa, the lion, as he guides the runt of his litter to maturity. These captions impose human-relatable emotions on the felines, as might the voiceover on a nature film for children: Numa is chastised by his mate, the lioness Nami, for bringing meat to his newborns, and feels embarrassed not to have realized they subside only on milk for now. Nami pacifies him with assurance that his time to participate in the cubs’ lives will yet come, and Numa feels great pride in his family. Of his cubs, one is weaker and thinner, and in him Numa takes the most care in protecting and teaching, but the young one falls into a pit dug as a lion trap, and does not know how to escape it. Numa chooses to take the risk of jumping into the pit with his son so that he can demonstrate how to leap to the edge of the pit and climb out, but the cub doesn’t understand the lesson. Numa dives back in and feigns anger at his slow-witted offspring, engaging his son in fierce battle. Fueled by rage, the son leaps out of the pit on his own, in pursuit of the fleeing father, and turns to comprehend the lesson. They leave in harmony again, both confident that the young lion is ready for the dangers of the jungle. This one was quite a bit more fun than I usually expect from “nature comics”. The art was quite nice—who better to assign this to than Jack Katz, right!—and the narration was engaging, illustrating how effective it is to anthropomorphize animals’ thoughts in stories like this. Skimming through the other installments of The Unknown Jungle, I see that each issue spotlights a different jungle animal. Although lions will return to the spotlight in issue 7, it’s not this Numa, so there is apparently no continuity linking these installments, unlike some of the other animal-centric jungle features seen in previous comics. Finally, Cliff Mason, White Hunter makes his first appearance in “The Fangs of the Big Cat!” It’s drawn by Sid Greene, one of my favorite artists at Silver Age DC. Greene had a lush, detailed inking style, and while his page compositions and poses weren’t always the most dynamic and exciting, his human figures were authentic and appealing. Cliff Mason, at least in this issue, is among the minority of jungle comics features set in India rather than Africa, so the “big cat” in the story title is, of course, a tiger. (A peek at later installments shows Cliff hunting in Africa, Asia, and unspecified islands that might have been in the South Pacific, so I guess Mason was a globe-trotting trophy-seeker.) The story is pretty slim: a portly hunter named Meneer wants to hire Cliff to help him hunt, but Cliff is busy hunting a man-eating tiger that has been terrorizing the village. This is no sport hunt, and he has no time for the thrill-seeking Meneer: Cliff begins tracking the tiger, but when he has a clear shot, Meneer stumbles on the scene: he’s been trailing Mason uninvited. To no surprise, the tiger attacks Meneer and drags him off, forcing Mason into a rescue operation. He tracks the tiger to a cave, where it has dragged the unconscious Meneer. Wary of the tiger’s unmatchable reflexes, Mason must execute a slow-motion aim to avoid triggering the big cat’s pounce: Mason successfully bags the Bengal, and rescues Meneer, who shucks off the experience, mindless of how risky his actions had been. The furious Mason chases Meneer off with rifle fire, and commiserates with the carcass of the man-eater: “Well, old tiger, I guess both our troubles are over! You’re free of being hunted…and I’m free of that pest that would have gotten me killed!” Well, the “slow motion” scene was something I haven’t seen before in any of the jungle comics I’ve read. With the compactness of these tales, it’s surprising that they allotted for four consecutive panels of incremental movement, but it was effective. The story offered up some colorful Indian language hunting terminology, and Mason’s role as a hunter was central to the tale. White hunters are common leads for jungle comics backups, and too often, the hunting is just a convenient excuse to put the character in conventional jungle adventures. So, JUNGLE TALES #1? It’s a Jungle Gem, for me. The Atlas jungle comics are always fun, quick reads, never a grind to read like some of the other jungle comics I’ve had to plough through. Atlas’ policy of short tales with focused plots make for easily digestible treats, the art is always competent if not always impressive, and the variety of features in this issue hadn’t been seen since the glory days of Fiction House’s early JUNGLE COMICS. Two origin stories of two worthy character concepts each provide some relatively fresh twists on the usual jungle heroes. The Unknown Jungle evokes the more memorable nature films that kids have always had to sit through in school. The text story is really worth reading, and the story I most expected to dislike, with the generic and well-worn white hunter character turns out to be an enjoyable yarn. I'm a bit sad that I have only one more Atlas jungle comic on my list, and it's only there on a technicality...
|
|
|
Post by codystarbuck on Feb 13, 2024 23:02:10 GMT -5
Re: the blond on the cover. Maybe Lorna was intended for that comic or they repurposed an image from her own series.
|
|
|
Post by MWGallaher on Feb 14, 2024 10:35:56 GMT -5
Re: the blond on the cover. Maybe Lorna was intended for that comic or they repurposed an image from her own series. Well spotted! That is definitely Lorna; I guess these jungle girls all blurred together in my mind. It would have been consistent with the Atlas approach to bolster the anthology jungle comic with a character that had their own solo series, as they did with WILD WESTERN and MISS AMERICA at the same time.
|
|
|
Post by tarkintino on Feb 14, 2024 17:59:44 GMT -5
JUNGLE TALES #1, September 1954, Atlas Comics (Marvel) So, JUNGLE TALES #1? It’s a Jungle Gem, for me. The Atlas jungle comics are always fun, quick reads, never a grind to read like some of the other jungle comics I’ve had to plough through. Atlas’ policy of short tales with focused plots make for easily digestible treats, the art is always competent if not always impressive, and the variety of features in this issue hadn’t been seen since the glory days of Fiction House’s early JUNGLE COMICS. Two origin stories of two worthy character concepts each provide some relatively fresh twists on the usual jungle heroes. The Unknown Jungle evokes the more memorable nature films that kids have always had to sit through in school. The text story is really worth reading, and the story I most expected to dislike, with the generic and well-worn white hunter character turns out to be an enjoyable yarn. I'm a bit sad that I have only one more Atlas jungle comic on my list, and it's only there on a technicality... In all honesty, I was not too impressed with Jungle Tales, since so many of the stories were not treading on new ground to take the genre in an interesting direction. The one thing I can appreciate about the issue is the format, where stories--as you point out--were short & easily digestible, a format Atlas would use in the original Marvel Tales and other anthology titles running into the early Silver Age of Marvel (before transitioning to superhero titles). If anything, I wish Atlas had tried their hand at more adult "jungle" stories, whether as a series or one-shot (e.g. what was happening in various E.C. titles at the same time), just to take the genre out of the sort of dry adventure copied time after time in pulps and serials for decades up that point.
|
|
|
Post by MWGallaher on Feb 15, 2024 7:33:36 GMT -5
True, I wouldn't say I was "impressed" with JUNGLE TALES, either. Maybe my bar for a Jungle Gem is too low, but I appreciate a comic in this genre where every story is coherent and pleasant to read and to look at. I do think JT gets some extra credit for giving Waku a solo feature and cover visibility, with no white characters at all in the story. Your comment makes me wonder what might have happened if EC had tried a jungle comic as part of their New Direction restart. Wally Wood and Jack Kamen did their share of jungle comics elsewhere, to fine result. I'd have loved seeing Jack Davis and Will Elder bringing their talents to the genre!
|
|
|
Post by MDG on Feb 15, 2024 12:32:31 GMT -5
Your comment makes me wonder what might have happened if EC had tried a jungle comic as part of their New Direction restart. Wally Wood and Jack Kamen did their share of jungle comics elsewhere, to fine result. I'd have loved seeing Jack Davis and Will Elder bringing their talents to the genre! There were a few stories in Two-Fisted Tales that flirted with the genre.
(an aside: I love mentioning to younger folks that "jungle" used to be a pretty popular genre in movies and comics.)
|
|
|
Post by MWGallaher on Feb 15, 2024 18:21:16 GMT -5
Your comment makes me wonder what might have happened if EC had tried a jungle comic as part of their New Direction restart. Wally Wood and Jack Kamen did their share of jungle comics elsewhere, to fine result. I'd have loved seeing Jack Davis and Will Elder bringing their talents to the genre! There were a few stories in Two-Fisted Tales that flirted with the genre. (an aside: I love mentioning to younger folks that "jungle" used to be a pretty popular genre in movies and comics.)
Thanks for the heads-up! TWO-FISTED TALES #41, with jungle stories drawn by Krigstein and Wood, is now on my agenda!
|
|
|
Post by MWGallaher on Mar 3, 2024 15:19:02 GMT -5
LORNA THE JUNGLE GIRL #26, August, 1957, Atlas (Marvel) Comics Cover by Bill Everett, who was evidently incapable of drawing a bad cover: great composition, lush vegetation, menacing villain, dangerous gorilla. Man, do I love his work! I’ve already sampled LORNA THE JUNGLE QUEEN, and although the name change to “Girl” did not reflect a monumental change to the character or content, I am happy to back to the well for one last time (as promised!), since I’ve been enjoying the Atlas jungle comics so much. This issue’s three Lorna stories are all illustrated by Jay Scott Pike, and written by Don Rico. First up is “Return of the Outcast”. It opens with Lorna defending the safari’s limited water supply from the thirsty Mort Hoskins: For his attempted water theft, Lorna’s co-star Greg Knight expels Hoskins to survive alone in the dry season, a harsh punishment for breaking “jungle law”! Hoskins vows vengeance against Lorna as he heads into exile, while Lorna and her chimpanzee companion, Mikki, swing off into the trees to look for a water source (she has to justify her desperate attempt to the chauvinistic Greg: “I know you feel I shouldn’t risk my life because I’m only a girl, but we’ve got to try something!” Hoskins follows Lorna with a rope and a plan to get to Lorna “through Mikki”. He manages to lasso the simian, then holds the approaching Lorna at gunpoint. When Mikki saves the Jungle Girl by pulling on the rope and spoiling Hoskins’ aim, the man breaks down sobbing: “You’re against me! Everybody’s against me!” Lorna proves him wrong by attempting to save him from an attacking boa constrictor, and Hoskins tries to help, aiming his gun at the snake, but Lorna is alarmed by how weak the snake is; it turns out that this is a thirst-weakened boa that was defending a newly-discovered water stream in the rocks! Lorna graciously allows Hoskins to claim credit for discovering the water, which allows him to get back in Greg’s good graces, accepting Greg’s sexist closing remarks: I suppose this is the kind of story wildfire2099 was talking about in response to my original post on the “Jungle Queen” era of Lorna’s run. This is a pretty distasteful way to treat the lead character; she’s still competent and kind-hearted (although she did accept Greg’s draconian punishment of poor Hoskins without objection), but the way she smilingly accepts Greg’s attitude makes me cringe. “The New Chief” is the requisite two-page text story and it’s kind of a weird one: explorer Harry Fenner has brought his buddy Mike on safari. Mike is a non-serious galoot who makes his living in pro wrestling pretending to be “a raw primitive, fresh from the wild lands.” When Mike roughhouses with his guide, the native bearers disappear on them, leaving both of them concerned that they are hallucinating the dozens of seven-foot-tall, spear-wielding men who aren’t supposed to be in this uninhabited part of the jungle. The men are real, and they engage Mike in a wrestling match?! It turns out that these men were exploring a distant area of the jungle, and had seen Mike’s tussle with Harry. Impressed with Mike’s skill, they just wanted to try him out, all in sport! The natives tell the pair how to find “a rare Skoodaloo, a small bear-like creatures who lived on the leaves and slept standing up” and an unusual jungle fruit, then they go on their way. Mike muses about bringing some of the natives back to the States as wrestlers, or about himself retiring to become a jungle chief. “Doom Walked the Jungle” is the second Lorna story. It seems the cover conflates both the previous Lorna story and this one, where Lorna is trapped in a pit with a gorilla, all thanks to our villain, a hunter who wants Lorna out of the way so that he can hunt the albino lion in the protected jungle preserve: The gorilla in the pit proves not to be a threat: he has injured his leg in the fall, and Lorna relieves his pain with a splint, and all of them escape thanks to the agile Mikki bringing a vine for them to climb. Lorna pursues the hunters, finding an assortment of animals snared in the men’s rope traps all along the way. When she catches up to them, they have the albino’s mate dangling from a rope over a pit, as a lure to their quarry. Lorna’s got no options: if she moves on the men, they’ll cut the rope and kill the lioness, but if she does nothing, the precious albino will be taken! The balance of power is shifted with the arrival of the gorilla, and then with the approach of the snared beasts Lorna has unleashed: Well, that’s a little more like it! Without Greg and his sexist dismissiveness, Lorna’s the sort of highly competent friend to the jungle beasts she ought to be. The bad guy is lucky to have escaped an attacking water buffalo! The Jungle Adventures of Greg Knight presents “The Last Hunt!”, drawn by John Romita, and also written by Rico. Greg has been appearing in backup stories ever since he first appeared as a supporting character in the second issue of Lorna’s comic book series, back when she was “Jungle Queen”. Backup features at Atlas, at least in the adventure titles, didn’t seem to take place in the same continuity as the main feature back then, and I think that as a reader, I would have appreciated that aspect. In this story, Greg is assisting Terry, an over-the-hill safari guide whose poor aim is disappointing his clients: The group’s hunting trip gets even more dangerous when they are attacked by a herd of rhinos, causing the jeep to wreck. Terry’s final shot kills off the stampeding rhino, and the rest of the herd abandons the attack. Terry has earned the respect of his client, who promises to give him a recommendation that won’t endanger his pension: It’s a bit too much glorification of senseless killing for my tastes, but attitudes toward trophy hunting were different back then. I can’t quite swallow the premise that Terry’s pension would be forfeited if this final hunt didn’t go well, but I doubt the young readers gave much thought to pensions. Tales of the Jungle presents “King of the Beasts”, drawn by Syd Shores. The leader of a herd of water buffalo, Koddo, drinks from a watering hole that has been polluted with poison berries. The water buffalo runs wild and attacks a lion, while the water buffalo herd observes. Koddo dominates the battle (which, to my understanding, is true to nature; the water buffalo is reputed to be among the most dangerous and powerful of jungle creatures), but before he can kill the lion, the other buffalo turn on their own leader. This revolt is neither clearly depicted nor clearly explained, but evidently they realize the lion was fighting to protect all of the creatures from the poison-maddened Koddo. Before the herd can act on their betrayal, Koddo dies from the poisoning, and the animals part ways (and the magenta and yellow plates also part ways from their proper registration: It’s a sloppily-rendered tale that side-steps the gruesome qualities inherent in its slim plot. Syd Shores is competent with the animal depictions, but it’s not an exemplar of his artistic skills, which I greatly admire. “It Stalks by Night” is the final Lorna story in this issue, and the final Lorna story of the original run. It opens with Greg and Lorna (in a smart pink dress with an animal fang necklace) in “the big city”, with Greg condescendingly declaring that “ This is where you belong, Lorna…not in the jungle!” (It’s not clear where this big city is; it looks like an American city and all the people here are white.) The big city proves dangerous, as a lurking silhouette thinks “I could never get Lorna out of the way in the jungle…but now that she’s here, she’s in my territory…and this is her finish!” He loosens a “Boots” sign than nearly lands on her and Greg, and Lorna leaps onto the fire escape to chase down their assailant. She finds “Karl”, an enemy she had chased from the jungle. Karl has unleashed “the night beast”, a creature Lorna had prevented Karl from huntil (It’s illegal to hunt the night beast!). So what is this night beast? It’s part ape, part lion, all demon: Karl bails, leaving Lorna, Greg, and his own accomplice behind to deal with the night beast—as Greg puts it, “it’s a destroyer of mankind”! The cops prove receptive to the trustworthy Lorna’s explanation that the night beast hides during the day and only comes out at night, and that it will pursue the man who captured it. Karl is in danger, no matter where he hides! The beast does indeed track down Karl, and Lorna doffs her pink dress for her jungle garb as she takes to the telephone lines to head up to the rooftop where the beast holds Karl’s unconscious body. She rescues Karl after the beast flees and the cops trap the creature in spotlights, when it is fooled into thinking it’s daylight: Were it not for that final panel, I’d have wondered whether this tale was retooling the feature for a non-jungle setting. Tarzan’s New York Adventure was one of the most popular and successful of Weismuller’s Tarzan films, so translating Lorna’s jungle skills to a civilized environment might have been a successful change. But if such a change were pondered, it was never to be implemented, because this was the final issue. With the cancellation of LORNA THE JUNGLE GIRL, Atlas ended its burst of jungle comics. JUNGLE TALES became JANN OF THE JUNGLE and ran for 17 issues, from September 1954 to June 1957. LORNA THE JUNGLE QUEEN became LORNA THE JUNGLE GIRL and ran for 26 issues, from July 1953 to August 1957. JUNGLE ACTION ran for 6 issues, from October 1954 to August 1955. Four years, forty-nine issues, halted by the dramatic implosion of the Atlas line down to a mere 8 titles per month in 1958. Except for issues 8 through 17 of JANN OF THE JUNGLE, and issues 17-26 of LORNA THE JUNGLE GIRL, all the rest has been reprinted in hardcover in MARVEL MASTERWORKS ATLAS ERA: JUNGLE ADVENTURE Volumes 1-3. It’s a pity that Marvel couldn’t finish the job, but it’s astonishing to know that that much has seen print in a high-quality format in the 21st century. While I’ve generally enjoyed all of the Atlas jungle comics, this one is mediocre, neither a Jungle Gem nor Jungle Junk. Lorna limps to the finish line. Within a couple of months, Charlton would cancel NYOKA, and the jungle comics niche would be ceded to Tarzan and other characters such as The Phantom and Jungle Jim who had established recognition from other media.
|
|
|
Post by codystarbuck on Mar 3, 2024 15:42:31 GMT -5
Mike Grell got himself into a bit of a storm, when he recounted his safari hunt, in Jon Sable. They at least actually consumed the meat of what they killed; but, I have no use for trophy hunting or fishing. I grew up hunting and fishing, as my dad and grandfather had. We ate everything we killed. I never "got" fishing shows, where they would release their catch. Okay, they didn't kill it; but, they did probably injure it, with the hook.
Jungle Action included some Lorna reprints, when Panther's Rage was going, which was my first exposure. I recall one with a lookalike replacing her. Pretty sexists stuff within it, even though she gets herself out of a jam.
|
|
|
Post by MWGallaher on Mar 3, 2024 20:57:11 GMT -5
A rough count indicates that Marvel would have been able to publish around 53 issues of the 70's reprint series JUNGLE ACTION had it sold well in its initial format, with the majority of the content being Lorna stories. Although judging by their Western reprints of OUTLAW KID and RINGO KID, they wouldn't have hesitated to reprint the reprints on a shorter cycle if, as might well be the case, they didn't have usable film for some of their 50's jungle comics. Feature | Number of stories | Lorna | 78 | Greg Knight | 25 | Jann | 34 | The Unknown Jungle | 17 | Cliff Mason | 17 | Tales of the Jungle | 10 | Waku Prince of the Bantu | 8 | Jungle Boy | 6 | Man-oo the Mighty | 6 | Leopard Girl | 6 | Lo-Zar (a.k.a. Tharn) | 6 |
If they had been willing or able to dig into the Golden Age material, they could also have reprinted the original Ka-Zar, Trojak the Tiger Man, and Zara of the Jungle, but these stories would have been pretty crude work to pass off in the 70's, even given the more lax standards that Marvel's genre reprint books of the era held.
|
|
|
Post by wildfire2099 on Mar 5, 2024 1:07:19 GMT -5
I have the first two of those Atlas reprints... that last story was definitely where the series was headed, with Lorna saving Greg in spite of himself and them letting him take credit. That IS really interesting that the last story feels like a format change that never happened... supernatural Lorna adventures, perhaps, to change with the times?
Very interesting stuff!
|
|
|
Post by MWGallaher on Mar 5, 2024 23:11:07 GMT -5
JO-JO CONGO KING, Part I Hey, don’t laugh. Well, okay, you can laugh at first, because JO-JO COMICS debuted from Fox Feature Syndicate as a humor book featuring a variety of funny animals and humorous humans, none of whom went by the less-than-imposing monicker of “Jo-Jo”. Why “JO-JO”? Maybe Fox thought it sounded funny—it does!—or perhaps the series began development as “HO-HO COMICS” and either another publisher had already trademarked the name. I can’t find evidence of a competing HO-HO COMICS being published, but “HO-HO” may have been considered potentially infringing on Four Star Publications’ HI-HO COMICS or ACG’s HA HA COMICS, both of which hit the stands earlier. So for whatever reason, JO-JO COMICS it was, and it began with a Spring 1946-dated issue cover-featuring the “O’Brine Twins”, a cartoony pair of sailors whose stories had already been running as backups in other Fox anthologies. In July 1947, though, the initial premise was scrapped, and with its seventh issue, the cover read “Jo-Jo Congo King”. The formal title, according to the indicia, was still “Jo-Jo Comics”, occasionally simplified as “Jo-Jo”, sufficient to cover Fox’s claim that it was the same comic, to avoid paying a new fee to establish the desirable second class mailing privileges in the United States. (It appears that earlier in the history of comics, publishers were more concerned about plausibly claiming continuity between two obviously different comics being in some sense the same series, so name changes, when necessary, were more subtle, such as the classic example of EC’ MOON GIRL becoming A MOON…A GIRL…ROMANCE! As the years went on and the Post Office apparently demonstrating little concern, title changes were more abrupt, leading to instances such as Marvel/Atlas treating publishing BLAZE CARSON, REX HART, WHIP WILSON, and GUNHAWK as different issues of the same comic, at least for the purpose of postal registration.) Jo-Jo Congo King took over with the 7th issue, but it appears to have been a hastily-arranged coup, with only two Jo-Jo stories—a total of 12 pages--backed with a couple of adventure features yanked from inventory: the last Bronze Man story, following the character’s previous appearances in BLUE BEETLE, and The Purple Tigress, a costumed heroine who had previously appeared in ALL TOP COMICS, and a non-jungle 2-page text story. The first two Jo-Jo stories show him involved with two different women. The first, Gwenna, is queen of the Bonangi tribe. The synopsis on the GCD suggests that Gwenna is Jo-Jo’s “first mate”, but a careful reading of that story does not suggest that they are lovers, but friends. The second story, involving a mad scientist who makes plant life into dangerous monsters, clearly establishes another woman, Geesa, as Jo-Jo’s “betrothed”. The next issue was mistakenly also number 7, so these issues are listed as 7a and 7b at the GCD. 7b has 22 pages of Jo-Jo Congo King, a jungle-themed text story, and a humorous Western back up, Popgun Pete. As of the 8th issue, Jo-Jo seems to be romantically attached to Tanee—with Geesa long forgotten. Tanee will remain as Jo-Jo’s girl through the remainder of the feature’s run. But before getting to the stories, I’ve got to address the elephant in the room—uhh—jungle… Back in this post ( classiccomics.org/post/480474/ ) on DOROTHY LAMOUR, JUNGLE PRINCESS, also published by Fox, I speculated on what I assumed would have been a controversial aspect of the comic in 1950, perhaps even so controversial as to lead to Fox leaving the comics market. That aspect was what appeared to be interracial relationships between dark-skinned African men and light-skinned women with conventionally Caucasian features and hair. Well, judging from JO-JO CONGO KING, published several years earlier, I suppose that if there were any objections, they weren’t strong enough to drive Fox from the stands, because Jo-Jo lives in a version of the African jungle where all the native women are colored and drawn to look like white women, while the native men are all brown-skinned, with hair and facial features more generically characteristic of Black men. It’s a very curious convention to adopt, and I can only guess that Fox wanted to take advantage of the prurient appeal of having lots of scantily-clad women, but thought that only light-skinned, Caucasian-looking women would appeal to the comics’ readers. As a commenter on comicbookplus.com put it, in reference to a similar comic, ZAGO JUNGLE PRINCE (which I’ll cover later): Zago exists in a strange universe. He is claimed to be a "Jungle Prince", but unlike, say Dell's BROTHERS OF THE SPEAR, that title is never explained. Zago exists without benefit of origin or hint of a backstory of any kind. He lives in a native village where all the females are light-skinned like himself, but all the males besides himself are dark-skinned. There are several instances where we see a dark-skinned native refer to a light-skinned girl as his daughter, or his mate (or the light-skinned girl refer to a dark-skinned male as father or husband). In addition, all of the women are young and attractive; and children or elders are never seen -- either female or male. In the one story where a child seems to appear, he actually turns out to be a 20-year-old midget! That not only seems to present an extremely odd picture of Africa but seems especially puzzling when you remember these stories were published in 1948. Native women are, without exception, whether good or evil, portrayed as light-skinned. We never, ever see a dark-skinned woman, yet all the male natives are dark-skinned (as you would expect for Africa). At first when I noted this in a couple of stories, I simply wrote it off as a mistake of the colorist (they are notorious for not actually reading the scripts), but after a goodly number of stories, it became obvious that this policy was not only consistent, but quite deliberate, and somewhat baffling.This also raises the question of whether Jo-Jo’s girl-friend Tanee is supposed to be one of the native females or a white like Jo-Jo…assuming that Jo-Jo is white! After all, in his first appearance, he addresses the bad guys as “white”, almost as if he doesn’t consider himself to be of the same race: Or does any of that even matter in Jo-Jo’s fantasy jungle world? Are we to imagine Jo-Jo’s world is a utopia where skin color is irrelevant to society? If so, though, why the gender distinction between light and dark skins? Heck, this is one of the most difficult-to-write-about issues that’s arisen in these jungle comics, riding some line that feels racist to me, but I can’t clearly articulate why—it’s some kind of racist/sexist/exploitative/fantastic jumble of hard-to-process choices. Help?! More Jo-Jo could be found in ALL GREAT JUNGLE ADVENTURES, which was (sort-of) a one-shot release, 132 pages for 25 cents, published by Fox in 1949. Fox published several of these extra-long giant comics by removing the covers from four unsold, leftover, regular-length comics and reassembling them under one new cover. I say “sort of” a one-shot because the contents to be found behind these covers might vary, even between copies with the same cover. Fox published several such collections of their romance comics and superhero comics, but this appears to be the only giant jungle comic Fox attempted to recycle. The format might have seemed like quite a bargain, but as I mentioned in prior post, Fox had a policy of printing the first story page of its comics on the inside front cover, colored in tones of a single print color (cyan or magenta), plus black, of course. Consequently, four of the stories in each giant--stories which would have been the lead story in their respective original releases—would start on the second page, lacking splash or title page! The copy that you can read at comicbookplus.com/?dlid=16553 evidently collates interiors from ALL TOP COMICS #16 and JO-JO COMICS #18, but as I said above, collections of other Fox jungle comics were also issued between these same covers. From a stack of cover-stripped unsold jungle comics, they would grab four and rebind them under this cover, so there’s really no telling what combinations might have been released. Since the component comics are considered elsewhere in this thread (or are not relevant to the topic of jungle comics), I’ll refrain from digging into the stories on this one. The inside front cover is a one-pager in black and magenta called “Man Eater”, about the Bengal tiger. The stories feature Rulah, Jo-Jo Congo King, Phantom Lady, “Tropical Topics”, and a “True Crime” story narrated by Phantom Lady. That's a lot to say about Jo-Jo, so I'm splitting this into multiple parts. Coming up, a proper sampling of an issue of JO-JO CONGO KING...
|
|
|
Post by MWGallaher on May 20, 2024 21:14:34 GMT -5
ATOMIC COMICS #4, July 1946, Green Publishing Read this comic at comicbookplus.comALL TOP COMICS #8, November 1947, Fox Publishing Read this comic at comicbookplus.comOne of the flaws in my plan to randomly sample jungle comics with little regard to order is that I discover unexpected dependencies. Jo-Jo has proven to have had one of the most complicated histories in comics, and so, rather than take a deep dive into an issue of JO-JO CONGO KING (and trust me, it’s going to be a real doozy when I get to it!), I need to back up a year prior to Jo-Jo’s first Fox Feature Syndicate appearance (in July 1947), to ATOMIC COMICS #4 from Green Publishing (in July 1946). Green Publishing is one of the lesser-known small publishers of the Golden Age. According to the GCD, Green published a total of 28 individual issues, spread across 11 titles. In 1945 through 1946, they published LIBERTY COMICS (5 issues), MISS LIBERTY (1 issue), ROLY-POLY COMICS (7 issues), and ATOMIC COMICS (4 issues). Green left the market then, but returned in 1952 with one issue of ROMEO TUBBS, then halted, returning for the last time in 1957 with ALL TOP COMICS (1 issue), ANIMAL CRACKERS (1 issue), COSMO CAT (2 issues), RIBTICKLER (3 issues), and WOTALIFE COMICS (2 issues), all of which were titles previously released by Fox. They also published one issue of ADVENTURES OF PATORUZU which was cover dated Winter 1946, but which appears to have been released in the 1950’s, using a previously-printed but unused cover as wrapping to repackage remaindered random 50’s era comics from publishers such as Charlton and Fox! I can’t find any solid information on Green Pubishing, but there was clearly some cross-pollination going on between it and Fox: besides Green publishing several former Fox comics in the 50’s, ZAGO, JUNGLE PRINCE #1 reprinted the “Lucky Wings” story from ATOMIC COMICS #4 under the new title “Toni Luck”. One of the features in the anthology title ATOMIC COMICS was “Congo King,” which ran from issues 2-4. Congo King was a clone of Weismuller’s Tarzan, with the white Congo King living in the jungle with his woman Tonda, accompanied by a young white boy named Kuta. A year after this final Congo King story, Fox debuted Jo-Jo, Congo King. Jo-Jo looked just like Green’s Congo King, with a woman named Tanee. It seems certain that Fox obtained leftover Congo King stories that had gone unpublished when Green left the stands, dubbed the lead character “Jo-Jo, Congo King” in order to justify him taking over the lead in the former humor comic JO-JO COMICS. This supposition is confirmed by the fact that Fox later published this very story in ALL-TOP COMICS #8. And now the story gets complicated… There’s evidence that Green’s “Congo King” story was altered from the originally prepared version. In the assorted panels reproduced below, “Congo King” is extending outside the panel borders in the dialog balloons, a quirk that only occurs when “Congo King” appears in the first line of a balloon that aligns with the upper panel border. Note that in every instance, a shorter name would have easily fit in the space available below the upper panel border. I have no doubt that this dialog was altered to replace some shorter name with “Congo King.” In Fox’s reprint of this story, the same panels confirm that a shorter name fits easily: But that’s not the only difference. The earlier Congo King is on the left, the later Jo-Jo is on the right: Immediately obvious is that Kuta is presented as a native with dark skin in Jo-Jo’s world, where he is a white, blond boy in Congo King’s. But notice also that Tanee’s outfit is skimpier. Did Fox alter the art to amp up the sex appeal? No, I don’t think so! I contend that both Fox and Green started with the unaltered original pages; Green covered up Tonda’s cleavage and navel, Fox didn’t. Green changed the original name to “Congo King”, requiring extension of the dialog balloons, Fox changed the original name to “Jo-Jo”, preserving the original boundaries of the dialog balloons. Except for the splash, “Congo King” doesn’t appear anywhere in the ALL-TOP version. Since Jo-Jo was also a “Congo King”, Fox wouldn’t have changed all of those occurrences if they didn’t have to. Oh, and there’s much stronger evidence that Green published an altered version ( before Fox “reprinted” a version closer to the original): Fox’s version has two and a quarter more pages, with the Green version picking up with page 3 of the Fox version: And the reason I’m certain Green expurgated Tonda’s sexiness? The Fox version features an explorer and his sexy daughter, the Green version features an explorer and his male assistant, Baker: The pages that were excised from Green’s version make it clear that the male Baker was the alteration, since a male wouldn’t have fit the panels or story as appropriately, and the art looks more consistent. So, in an attempt to summarize the key points and deductions so far: Green created, or, more likely, obtained from some comics producing studio, some jungle hero stories. They altered the hero’s name to be “Congo King”, they covered up the female companion, and published four installments of the feature, at least one of which was edited down and revised to feature a male victim instead of the more titillating female character. Fox obtained those stories from Green. Comicbookplus doesn’t have scans of Green’s first two “Congo King” stories, so it may be that all of Fox’s initial round of Jo-Jo stories were the ones Green had already published. Some of the early Jo-Jo stories include the “Congo King” monicker in the dialog, making me suspect they were from ATOMIC COMICS #2 and #3. Either to minimize text alterations or just because they liked the sound of it, Fox dubbed this character “Jo-Jo, Congo King”, so that the stories would be appropriate in a series already called JO-JO COMICS. Fox had access to at least one copy of a story that Green had published in a censored version. Fox was not leery about being lurid, so they published the original version, again, altered to replace the character’s unknown original name with “Jo-Jo.” And that leads to one more mystery: what was the character’s original name? Kuta might be one hint. Kuta is referred to as “our friend” in the Green version, with no explanation as to why a white boy would be living in the jungle alongside Congo King and Tonda. The word “friend” in that panel appears to be altered (as does “Tonda”). Might this originally have read “our son, Kuta”? Or perhaps, “our son, [name replaced]?” This feature has an obvious debt to the Weismuller Tarzan films, with its Tarzan, Jane, and Boy analogs. I have two competing hypotheses: The original name of the character was something very close to “Tarzan”, say “Zartan” or “Tarzac.” Green realized this might be treading too close to trademark infringement and replaced the character’s name with “Congo King”, and made the boy a friend instead of a son, to further reduce similarities. Alternatively, there is the possibility that this was prepared as a straight-up “Tarzan, Jane, and Boy” story, adapting the Weismuller version of the Lord of the Jungle. Was it done in hopes of obtaining the valuable license from Edgar Rice Burroughs, but it failed to do so? Was it done under the naïve assumption that no one would care if someone did an unauthorized version, and found out after several stories had been produced? Or could it have been prepared as a new direction for the authorized TARZAN comic, but rejected in favor of continuing something more faithful to ERB’s original?
|
|