|
|
Post by wildfire2099 on Apr 19, 2024 21:28:54 GMT -5
Oh no… MeShould more members of the Classic Comics Forum participate in the wrestling thread? ChatGPTIt ultimately depends on the interests of the individual members. If there is a significant interest in wrestling among the current members, then it may be worth considering inviting more members to join the wrestling thread. However, if the majority of members are not interested in wrestling, it may be better to focus on other topics that are more popular among the group. Ultimately, the decision should be made based on the preferences and interests of the members of the Classic Comics Forum. ChatGPT is really good at composing paragraphs that say nothing.. perhaps that why people think they can help corporate types with emails. |
|
|
|
Post by wildfire2099 on Apr 19, 2024 21:44:52 GMT -5
'skyscapers that scape the sky' I don't think the world's writers have anything to fear.
At least it seems to know about Iron Man
Me: what is the best issue of Iron Man
ChatGPT
Determining the "best" issue of Iron Man can be subjective, as it often depends on personal preferences regarding storylines, artwork, character development, and other factors. However, there are several iconic issues of Iron Man that are widely regarded as significant within the comic book community:
"Demon in a Bottle" (Iron Man #120-128): This storyline, written by David Michelinie and Bob Layton, is often considered one of the best Iron Man stories ever told. It explores Tony Stark's struggles with alcoholism and its impact on his personal and superhero life.
"Armor Wars" (Iron Man #225-231): Another storyline by David Michelinie and Bob Layton, "Armor Wars" features Iron Man's quest to reclaim his stolen technology from various villains and allies. It's known for its intense action and exploration of themes related to technology and ethics.
"Extremis" (Iron Man (vol. 4) #1-6): This modern storyline by Warren Ellis and Adi Granov redefined Iron Man for the 21st century. It introduced the Extremis virus, which allowed Tony Stark to merge his biology with the Iron Man armor, enhancing his abilities.
"The Invincible Iron Man" (Iron Man #1-6, 2015): Written by Brian Michael Bendis and illustrated by David Marquez, this series rebooted Iron Man's origin story for a new generation of readers. It delves into Tony Stark's struggle with rebuilding his life and reputation after facing numerous challenges.
These are just a few examples, and there are many other notable issues and storylines in Iron Man's extensive comic book history. Ultimately, the "best" issue of Iron Man is subjective and may vary depending on individual tastes and interests.
me: ok but what's your favorite?
ChatGPT
As much as I'd love to have a favorite, I don't possess personal preferences or emotions like humans do. However, based on popular opinion and critical acclaim, "Demon in a Bottle" is often regarded as one of the most impactful and memorable storylines in Iron Man's history. Its exploration of Tony Stark's struggles with alcoholism added depth to the character and remains a significant part of his narrative legacy.
It doesn't have an opinion on Lee vs. Kirby though:
Me: who was more important to Marvel Comics, Stan Lee or Jack Kirby?
ChatGPT
Both Stan Lee and Jack Kirby were instrumental in shaping Marvel Comics into the iconic institution it is today, and it's challenging to definitively say who was more important. They were collaborators and contributed significantly to Marvel's success in different ways.
Stan Lee, as a writer and editor, played a crucial role in creating many of Marvel's most beloved characters, including Spider-Man, the X-Men, the Fantastic Four, and the Avengers. He was known for his dynamic storytelling, relatable characters, and catchy catchphrases, which helped define the Marvel Universe.
Jack Kirby, on the other hand, was a prolific artist and co-creator of many of Marvel's most iconic characters alongside Lee. He had a distinctive art style and a boundless imagination, bringing to life the visual aspects of characters and stories that continue to resonate with fans today.
While Stan Lee often received more public recognition due to his role as Marvel's spokesperson and his frequent appearances in media, Jack Kirby's contributions to character design, world-building, and storytelling were equally significant.
In essence, both Stan Lee and Jack Kirby were essential to Marvel Comics' success, and their collaborative efforts laid the foundation for the Marvel Universe as we know it. It's their combined talents and creativity that truly propelled Marvel to greatness.
me: ok, but who would you pick if you had to pick one or the other?
ChatGPT
As an AI, I don't have personal preferences or opinions, so I don't have the ability to pick one over the other. Both Stan Lee and Jack Kirby were indispensable figures in the history of Marvel Comics, and their contributions were complementary. It's their collaboration and combined efforts that contributed to Marvel's enduring legacy.
|
|
|
|
Post by codystarbuck on Apr 19, 2024 22:21:42 GMT -5
I love how this mixes Terry Pratchet's Discworld series with DC Comics Captain Carrot and the Zoo Crew. Yeah, I was going to rerun it with it spelled out more clearly, but the answer just works for me as is so I left it. And in odd some way, I'd like to think Sir Terry would have approved as well. Nobby would have fit in with the Zoo Crew; though as what species is still in question. |
|
|
|
Post by zaku on Apr 20, 2024 3:29:13 GMT -5
ME:
Why was Lois Lane such a psycho during the Silver Age of Comics?
Lois Lane's characterization during the Silver Age of Comics (roughly from the late 1950s to the early 1970s) was influenced by the prevailing gender norms and storytelling conventions of that era. In many Silver Age comics, female characters, including Lois Lane, often exhibited behavior that would be considered stereotypical or exaggerated by today's standards. Here are a few reasons why Lois Lane might have been portrayed in a way that could be perceived as "psycho":
1. **Romantic Rivalry with Superman**: In many Silver Age stories, Lois Lane's primary role was as a love interest for Superman. Her intense desire to win Superman's affections often led her to engage in extreme or impulsive behavior, such as risky stunts or schemes to attract his attention. These actions were driven by her romantic infatuation and the competitive nature of her relationship with other female characters, such as Lana Lang.
2. **Plot Device for Humor and Drama**: Silver Age comics often employed exaggerated and melodramatic storytelling techniques to entertain readers. Lois Lane's "psycho" behavior, such as her relentless pursuit of Superman or her outlandish schemes to discover his secret identity, served as comedic or dramatic fodder for the stories. These antics were designed to add humor and excitement to the plots, even if they sometimes stretched the bounds of believability.
3. **Reflection of Gender Stereotypes**: The portrayal of female characters in Silver Age comics was often influenced by traditional gender roles and stereotypes prevalent in society at the time. Lois Lane's behavior may have been exaggerated to fit the stereotype of the "obsessive" or "emotionally unstable" woman, which was a common trope in popular culture during that era.
4. **Limited Character Development**: Compared to modern comics, Silver Age comics generally had less emphasis on character depth and development. As a result, characters like Lois Lane were often depicted in broad strokes, with their personalities and motivations simplified for the sake of storytelling convenience. This lack of nuance may have contributed to the perception of Lois as "psycho" or one-dimensional in some stories.
Overall, Lois Lane's characterization during the Silver Age should be understood within the context of the time period and the conventions of comic book storytelling at that time. While some aspects of her portrayal may seem outdated or problematic by today's standards, they were reflective of the cultural norms and storytelling trends of the era.
I must say that for general questions it is an ok tool. I think such a response would be perfectly adequate
|
|
|
|
Post by zaku on Apr 20, 2024 3:30:53 GMT -5
Me:
I don't want my son to read superhero comics. Find me some arguments to convince him.
If you're looking for reasons to convince your son not to read superhero comics, here are a few arguments you could consider:
1. **Diverse Reading Experience**: Encouraging your son to explore a variety of genres and styles of literature can help broaden his interests and perspectives. While superhero comics can be entertaining, there are many other types of books and graphic novels that offer different kinds of stories and themes to explore.
2. **Critical Thinking Skills**: Some superhero comics may prioritize action and spectacle over nuanced storytelling or character development. By reading a wider range of literature, your son can develop critical thinking skills as he engages with more complex narratives, diverse perspectives, and thought-provoking themes.
3. **Time Management**: Reading superhero comics, especially if your son becomes deeply invested in following multiple ongoing series, can be time-consuming. Encouraging him to explore other hobbies or interests that offer a balance of activities can help him manage his time more effectively and develop a well-rounded lifestyle.
4. **Exploring New Ideas**: While superhero comics can be fun and imaginative, they may not always encourage exploration of new ideas or intellectual curiosity. Encouraging your son to read books that tackle different topics, cultures, and historical periods can broaden his understanding of the world and stimulate his curiosity about diverse subjects.
5. **Social Interaction**: Engaging in hobbies and activities that involve social interaction with peers can be beneficial for your son's social development. Encouraging him to participate in group activities, clubs, or sports teams where he can interact with others face-to-face may offer more opportunities for meaningful social connections and friendships than solitary reading of superhero comics.
Ultimately, it's important to approach this conversation with empathy and understanding, and to encourage your son to explore his interests while also considering the potential benefits of diversifying his reading habits. By having an open dialogue and offering support and guidance, you can help him make informed choices about how he spends his time and what he chooses to read.
|
|
|
|
Post by wildfire2099 on Apr 20, 2024 8:54:22 GMT -5
yeah I agree.. it seems to be able to generate bullet pointed lists for general questions pretty well... you just can't get specific.. clearly there is no fact check.
|
|
|
|
Post by spoon on Apr 20, 2024 9:43:27 GMT -5
If you ask hypothetical or general question it's ok, but it suffers from hallucinations when you ask things like the plot of this or that issue. Which is strange since that's very very easy to google. It really comes across like ChatGPT is the kid who didn't do the reading and is now trying to bluff its way through the book report. Inventing a plot summary for Brother Power the Geek #3 is a good example. |
|
|
|
Post by spoon on Apr 20, 2024 9:50:05 GMT -5
MeDid Roy Thomas create Wolverine? ChatGPTNo, Roy Thomas did not create Wolverine. Wolverine was created by writer Len Wein and artist John Romita Sr. The character first appeared in "The Incredible Hulk" #180 (cover dated October 1974) in a brief cameo, and then had a full appearance in issue #181. The character was later developed further by writer Chris Claremont and artist Dave Cockrum in "Giant-Size X-Men" #1 (1975) and became a central figure in the X-Men comics. Roy Thomas, however, made significant contributions to Marvel Comics during his tenure, including co-creating characters like the Vision, Ultron, and Iron Fist, among others. It's a pretty big breakthrough in comic book historiography that ChatGPT discovered Claremont was the actual writer of Giant-Size X-Men #1. |
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 20, 2024 10:15:18 GMT -5
You guys can try to stump the tech all you want, I'm just sayin' this virtual bro "gets me":
Me
If the Muppet Roosevelt Franklin from Sesame Street joined the Avengers as their leader, how would he lead the team to defeat villains and also help them learn about counting and the alphabet?
ChatGPT
Roosevelt Franklin leading the Avengers would be quite the sight! He'd probably bring a unique blend of charisma, education, and superhero know-how to the team. Here's how I imagine he might approach leading the Avengers to defeat villains while also incorporating counting and the alphabet:
1. Team Huddles with Educational Twist: Before every mission, Roosevelt would gather the team for a huddle, where he'd not only discuss the plan but also sneak in some educational tidbits. For example, he might say, "Alright team, we've got 5 Infinity Stones to track down. Let's count them off and make sure we've got each one covered."
2. Battle Strategy Sessions: During strategy sessions, Roosevelt would use the alphabet to help organize their approach. "A for Ant-Man's stealth infiltration, B for Black Widow's brilliant tactics, C for Captain America's leadership on the front lines..."
3. Combat Training with Counting: When training, Roosevelt would incorporate counting into their combat drills. "Thor, let's see if you can summon your lightning strikes 10 times in a row! Hulk, can you smash through those 20 simulated barriers?"
4. Post-Mission Reflections: After each mission, Roosevelt would gather the team for a debriefing where they'd not only discuss what went well and what could be improved but also reflect on the educational aspects of the mission. "Did you notice how we used teamwork to solve that puzzle? And we counted on each other to get the job done!"
By blending superhero action with educational reinforcement, Roosevelt Franklin would lead the Avengers to victory while ensuring they never stop learning. Who knows, maybe they'd even add a few new members from Sesame Street along the way!
|
|
|
|
Post by Hoosier X on Apr 20, 2024 10:27:54 GMT -5
You guys can try to stump the tech all you want, I'm just sayin' this virtual bro "gets me": MeIf the Muppet Roosevelt Franklin from Sesame Street joined the Avengers as their leader, how would he lead the team to defeat villains and also help them learn about counting and the alphabet? ChatGPTRoosevelt Franklin leading the Avengers would be quite the sight! He'd probably bring a unique blend of charisma, education, and superhero know-how to the team. Here's how I imagine he might approach leading the Avengers to defeat villains while also incorporating counting and the alphabet: 1. Team Huddles with Educational Twist: Before every mission, Roosevelt would gather the team for a huddle, where he'd not only discuss the plan but also sneak in some educational tidbits. For example, he might say, "Alright team, we've got 5 Infinity Stones to track down. Let's count them off and make sure we've got each one covered." 2. Battle Strategy Sessions: During strategy sessions, Roosevelt would use the alphabet to help organize their approach. "A for Ant-Man's stealth infiltration, B for Black Widow's brilliant tactics, C for Captain America's leadership on the front lines..." 3. Combat Training with Counting: When training, Roosevelt would incorporate counting into their combat drills. "Thor, let's see if you can summon your lightning strikes 10 times in a row! Hulk, can you smash through those 20 simulated barriers?" 4. Post-Mission Reflections: After each mission, Roosevelt would gather the team for a debriefing where they'd not only discuss what went well and what could be improved but also reflect on the educational aspects of the mission. "Did you notice how we used teamwork to solve that puzzle? And we counted on each other to get the job done!" By blending superhero action with educational reinforcement, Roosevelt Franklin would lead the Avengers to victory while ensuring they never stop learning. Who knows, maybe they'd even add a few new members from Sesame Street along the way! That’s awesome. Much better than Infinity War. |
|
|
|
Post by MDG on Apr 20, 2024 10:40:16 GMT -5
ME: Compare the editorial styles of Al Feldstein and Harvey Kurtzman at EC comics
This one feels a little less solid to me, ignoring how Feldstein was pretty open to artists doing anything as long as it fit on the pre-lettered pages, while Kurtzman was adamant about artists following his layouts exactly. In fact, the last sentence about Kurtzman, "He encouraged his collaborators to explore unconventional ideas and approaches to storytelling," probably fits Feldstein better.
|
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 20, 2024 10:51:11 GMT -5
Why is Alan Moore grumpy? He hates it when others use his Watchmen characters but has no problem helping himself to characters created by others.
ChatGPT Alan Moore's stance on his creations, particularly Watchmen, stems from a mix of personal principles and experiences within the comic book industry. Moore is known for his strong beliefs regarding creator rights and the integrity of artistic work. His dissatisfaction with the industry's treatment of creators and their creations has led him to distance himself from mainstream comics and the commercialization of his own characters. Moore's creation of Watchmen was a response to the prevalent superhero tropes of the time, and he intended it to be a self-contained story with a definitive conclusion. He has expressed disappointment with the way DC Comics, the publisher of Watchmen, has handled the characters and their universe after he relinquished control. Regarding his use of characters created by others, Moore has been involved in projects that draw upon established characters, such as his work on "League of Extraordinary Gentlemen." However, Moore's approach to using existing characters often involves reimagining them in ways that subvert or critique established conventions, rather than simply exploiting them for commercial gain. Ultimately, Moore's views on intellectual property and creative ownership have led to conflicts with publishers and other creators, but they also reflect his commitment to artistic integrity and respect for creators' rights. Whether one agrees with his approach or not, his stance has undoubtedly left a significant mark on the comic book industry's discussions about creator rights and the treatment of intellectual property. |
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 20, 2024 10:58:38 GMT -5
Why are Bruce Wayne's knobby bits such a controversy in Batman Damned? Superheroes have them too
ChatGPT The controversy surrounding Batman's "knobby bits" in "Batman: Damned" stems from a scene in the comic where Batman's full frontal nudity is depicted. This was unexpected for many readers and caused quite a stir upon its release. The controversy primarily revolved around the explicit nature of the depiction and its departure from the more traditional portrayal of Batman as a character. Superheroes, including Batman, are often depicted with idealized physiques, but full frontal nudity, especially in a mainstream comic book, is relatively rare. The controversy sparked discussions about the artistic choices made by the creators, the boundaries of what is acceptable in mainstream comics, and whether such explicit content was necessary for the story being told. While superheroes may indeed have physical attributes, the controversy in "Batman: Damned" was less about the presence of those attributes and more about the explicitness of their depiction. It prompted debates about censorship, artistic freedom, and the expectations of audiences when it comes to mainstream comic book content. |
|
|
|
Post by Calidore on Apr 20, 2024 11:08:14 GMT -5
This thread has shown me that if nothing else, AI seems like a good idea seeder for What If/Elseworlds type stories. Also, that adding Jack Kirby to a seven-page Hulk story automatically expands it to ten pages.
|
|
|
|
Post by Roquefort Raider on Apr 20, 2024 12:03:28 GMT -5
Why are Bruce Wayne's knobby bits such a controversy in Batman Damned? All this time I thought the name "Batman" referred to the winged mammal!!! |
|
