Roquefort Raider
CCF Mod Squad
Modus omnibus in rebus
Posts: 17,410
Member is Online
|
Post by Roquefort Raider on Jul 6, 2014 12:46:30 GMT -5
The battle of the towersPart 3 of the adaptation of the Robert E. Howard Conan story, the people of the black circleScript by Roy ThomasArt by John Buscema and Alfredo AlcalaAs is readily apparent right from page one, there's something different with this issue's art. Unlike the fine brushwork typical of Alcala's inking, evocative of the master Gustave Doré, here the art seems to have been finished in heavy B pencil or charcoal. I have honestly no idea what medium was actually used, but it was clearly a choice dictated by the need for speed: first that's what Roy tells us in the editorial pages, and second it does look rushed in several places. Some pages also look nothing like Buscema, and more like pure Alcala: perhaps Alfredo could gain time by redoing these pages entirely, straight to ink, without following John's breakdowns. Alcala was a master inker who could go straight to ink without requiring pencils or breakdowns (something I haven't dared to in decades!!!); he had devised his own set of brushes that had an ink reservoir to go even faster. Why was he in such a hurry? Well, because he was an amazing professional who understood what a deadline was (as was Big John). Alfredo was at the time up to his nostrils in work, and to meet the deadline of this issue two things had been made necessary: first, split the end of the tale in two (People of the Black Circle was initially supposed to ene din issue 18) and… use a faster inking technique than the usual fine brushwork. There are three main types of inking typical of Alcala, and all three would eventually be seen in SSoC: his usual fine style, this one that I call "charcoal style", and another, the "grey ink wash" style. I prefer the first, naturally, but the other two also deliver pretty good art. (Alcala on a bad day is better than half of the other inkers in the business)! Here is the splash page, where nothing looks like it came from John Buscema's pencil: and here's an example of how rushed this approach can make the art look: Still good, but, y'know… An explanation for the first page is that since the story is now cut in two, it would require an extra splash page. And if the splash page for the third part of the story was more decorative that an actual part of the storyline, perhaps it could have been used for the new part four, leaving Alfredo in charge of producing a new one for part three. However, looking at the splash for part four, it is most definitely a part of the storyline and follows the last scene of part three. So... I don't know! We should ask Roy, perhaps he may remember!
|
|
Roquefort Raider
CCF Mod Squad
Modus omnibus in rebus
Posts: 17,410
Member is Online
|
Post by Roquefort Raider on Jul 6, 2014 13:30:01 GMT -5
The story so far: The queen of Vendhya, the Devi Yasmina, wants revenge against the Black Seers of Mount Yimsha, powerful sorcerers who seldom interfere with human affairs but have this time decided to kill her brother, the erstwhile king. This was done at the request of King Yezdigerd of Turan, who means to expand his empire in Vendhya. Yasmina is then abducted by Conan, at the time a hill chieftain in northern Vendhya; he means to trade her for the freedom of seven of his sub-chiefs who have been taken by the authorities. But the abduction presents an opportunity for two other factions: first a Turanian spy, Kerim Shah (who was there to observe the murder of the king), follows Conan at the head of a few hired swords to steal back the queen and take her to Yesdigerd. Second, Khemsa, the acolyte of the Black Seers who oversaw the king's magical murder, is driven by his lover's ambition to betray his masters, go get Yasmina for himself, and sell her to Yezdigerd. (Khemsa's lover was Yasmina's own handmaiden). High up in the hill country, in sight of Mount Yimsha, Khemsa manages to catch up with Conan and Yasmina. He easily defeats the Cimmerian, but is then confronted by his masters, who reach the spot by way of a magical cloud. They throw Khemsa and his paramour off a cliff and make off for their haunt, taking the queen with them. And so our tale begins. Recovering from the sorcerous battle, Conan rides in pursuit of the cloud toward Mount Yimsha. He meets his Afghuli tribesmen who have been following him, but these are in a decidedly foul mood: the seven chiefs who were in jail have been murdered (we readers know it was by Khemsa, who wanted to destroy any chance of Conan's bargaining to succeed) and they blame Conan for it. The Cimmerian has to escape his own men. As he rides hard upon the mountain trails, he happens upon the broken form of Khemsa, still barely alive; the hapless sorcerer sees in Conan his last chance to get even with his former masters. He bequeaths upon the barbarian a magical girdle that's supposed to help him later on when he comes to something called "the golden vein"; he also gives him some cryptic instructions: "break the crystal globe with the four pomegranates… beware the master's transmutations". And then he dies. Conan is the met by Kerim Shah; the Turanian and the Cimmerian agree to join forces temporarily and decide who will keep the queen once they have recovered her. Meanwhile, Yasmina wakes up in the castle on top of Mount Yimsha, the abode of the Black Circle. She meets its master, an enigmatic and scary foddermucker. (Notice that the charcoal style doesn't her this page at all; it's very moody and efficient. The same goes with the next shown below). The master plays a little with Yasmina to show off his power: although she finds a dagger that seems to have been forgotten by an unbelievably happy coincidence right within her reach, she trips over absolutely nothing as she tries to stab the Master with it; and anyway, when she looks at her weapon again, it is after all naught but a lotus bloosom. The msater states that "all substance is one to him who holds the key of the cosmos. To an adept, nothing is immutable". For all his highfalutin' claims about being beyond human frailties and blahblahblah, the Master admits that he's still got an eye for a pretty girl (well, not in such crude terms of course) and that he's considering keeping Yasmina as his slave. She claims that she'll never yield to him, and to humble her he magically sends her consciousness down history's corridors, having her relive all the indignities suffered by women at the hands of men since the dawn of time. Badly shaken up, she awakes from her trance just as the Master makes his move, revealing that his personal hygiene leaves something to be desired. (This scene is the one that Margaret Brundage used for the cover of Weird Tales (september 1934 issue) where the prose story was first serialized). Conan, Kerim Shah and the latter's hired men reach Mount Yimsha, but the path up the mountain is watched by a tower where men say the Black Seers' acolytes reside. The band approaches the tower on foot, attacked in turn by a mad dog and by a big hawk. A cloud then comes rolling down the slope and whoever touches it with steel is electrocuted. Finally, an acolyte blowing in a massive horn, atop the tower, triggers an earthquake that would have put an end to the invaders had Kerim Shah not shot the man with a well-placed arrow. Conan reaches the tower door (locked!) and is almost cooked by boiling oil the acolytes send cascading down the walls. Kerim Shah's bow once again solves that problem, and after tearing down the door the men enter the tower that has now been abandoned: the acolytes fled through a back door, heading toward the castle atop Mount Yimsha. Between the tower and the mountain is a chasm filled with fog; the acolytes are already at the bottom, and the fog proves to be reflecting arrows as if it were solid. Conan notices that a golden line can be seen going down the wall and across the floor of the chasm, and that the acolytes seem to be following it; this must be the "golden vein" mentioned by Khemsa, and it following it might be the way to reach Yimsha across the foggy valley. The fog is poisonous (as revealed when one of the men dies from it) but if one remains atop the golden vein, first climbing down the wall and then walking across the valley below, then crossing is possible. Climbing the wall at the other end, the men are attacked by the acolytes who were wanting in ambush; but when sowrds and not magic is used, the latter don't stand a chance and are quickly dispatched. To be concluded next issue!
|
|
Roquefort Raider
CCF Mod Squad
Modus omnibus in rebus
Posts: 17,410
Member is Online
|
Post by Roquefort Raider on Jul 6, 2014 13:33:01 GMT -5
A page of publicity that had me dreaming back in the '70s: one for those elusive Robert E. Howard books that were so hard to get in Rimouski, QC. Their description and the teeny tiny covers by Jeff Jones were like doors unto magical worlds of action, adventure and wonderment!
(I eventually found that edition of "Sword of the Gael" in a second-hand bookshop in Montreal, years later. The other books I do not own, but the stories they contain have since been reprinted in many different volumes).
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 6, 2014 13:39:02 GMT -5
I have a ton of those Zebra books, all picked up second hand. Off the top of my head from the ad I know I had Sword of the Gael, The Vultures of Whapeton, The Lost Valley of Iskander, The Book of Robert E. Howard, and the Sowers of Thunder. I might have Worms of the Earth too, not sure on that one. There nice little collections, but yeah I have picked up the stories collected in other collections over the years as well.
-M
|
|
Roquefort Raider
CCF Mod Squad
Modus omnibus in rebus
Posts: 17,410
Member is Online
|
Post by Roquefort Raider on Jul 6, 2014 13:42:33 GMT -5
A handbook shall be born, by Fred Blosser Reviewing the book The annotated guide to Robert E. Howard's sword and sorcery, by Robert Weinberg. Those were the early days of Howard scholarship, and in this book Mr. Weinberg stresses the difference between real Howard stories and the ones that were modified of adapted by later authors, most notable L. Sprague de Camp. (Even as a kid I never could understand why Howard's stories needed editing, although I was to naive to realize it might have simply been for one of the oldest reasons in the world: money). The article is illustrated by a B&W reproduction of the book cover, with a Conan looking like an actor from an old Italian Hercules movie, and one of John Buscema's sketches that, as I understand, were commonly found on the back of his comic-book pages. (Roy, as editor, managed to send some money John's way by using such beautiful but uncommissioned pieces in such a way. A pretty clever editorial decision, since it made the artist and the reader a little happier).
|
|
Roquefort Raider
CCF Mod Squad
Modus omnibus in rebus
Posts: 17,410
Member is Online
|
Post by Roquefort Raider on Jul 6, 2014 13:47:04 GMT -5
Crimson blades of dark Vendhyaby Fred Blosser reviewing the book "The swords of Sharazar" by Robert E. Howard, published by FAX Collecotr's Editions. This book includes the three Kirby O'Donnell adventures, and they're gorgeously illustrated by Mike Kaluta. (Many of these Kaluta images could be found in that lovely art book, The Studio). Kirby O'Donnell is an action hero in the tradition of El Borak, his theatre of operations being Afghanistan. His adventures would later be adapted as Conan tales in SSoC.
|
|
Roquefort Raider
CCF Mod Squad
Modus omnibus in rebus
Posts: 17,410
Member is Online
|
Post by Roquefort Raider on Jul 6, 2014 13:51:52 GMT -5
Rattle of bonesScript by Roy Thomas Art by Howard Chaykin adapting the Solomon Kane story by Robert E. Howard. A minor tale of revenge beyond the grave, the kind you'd find in a typical issue of "The witching hour" or "house of mystery". Chaykin manages to infuse a lot of emotion in Kane's features and the clothes and background in this tale look very fine, but the skeletons in that tale look a bit goofy. (The striped sleeves, also… they just look odd on the dour Puritan). Next issue: People of the Black Circle concludes!
|
|
|
Post by benday-dot on Jul 6, 2014 21:40:20 GMT -5
The "charcoal style" of Alcala works to fantastic effect on that last panel of the skull faced Master menacing Yasmina. The texture is perfect. And that so-called sketch of Conan wrestling the lion that JB dashed off is a real beauty. It's rough details with wash finish (that lion's mane is fantastic)makes me long for a whole story illustrated in like manner. I think his Tarzan work for Marvel was very good (especially the first 3 issues or so), but that drawing suggests it might have been even better. Speaking of might have beens...
|
|
|
Post by berkley on Jul 6, 2014 22:14:13 GMT -5
I can't remember if I read this somewhere or just got the idea myself from the look of it, but is it possible that the woman in that Adkins cover was originally nude and that the bikini was painted over because they thought it was too provocative? Great work by Adkins, though, and once more a reminder that as good an inker as he was, it's a bit of a shame he wasn't able to put more time into his own artwork.
I rank Alcala's three styles or inking techniques in the order in which RR listed them - 1. the fine line, 2. the charcoal, 3. the grey wash. I quite like the charcoal technique on display in this issue, but the fine line style is so beautiful and so perfect for the genre that it was always a disappointment when he didn't use it. The grey wash was and is the one I like least, though even it wasn't bad in itself and would have looked better in a science fiction story or something like that.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 6, 2014 22:29:14 GMT -5
I can't remember if I read this somewhere or just got the idea myself from the look of it, but is it possible that the woman in that Adkins cover was originally nude and that the bikini was painted over because they thought it was too provocative? Great work by Adkins, though, and once more a reminder that as good an inker as he was, it's a bit of a shame he wasn't able to put more time into his own artwork. I rank Alcala's three styles or inking techniques in the order in which RR listed them - 1. the fine line, 2. the charcoal, 3. the grey wash. I quite like the charcoal technique on display in this issue, but the fine line style is so beautiful and so perfect for the genre that it was always a disappointment when he didn't use it. The grey wash was and is the one I like least, though even it wasn't bad in itself and would have looked better in a science fiction story or something like that. Not sure, this did happen with Dark Horse's Conan comic though, issue #24. The original cover was this linky to NSFW coverand this then was the altered version with the top painted on... -M
|
|
|
Post by berkley on Jul 6, 2014 22:39:22 GMT -5
Pretty nice cover, except that if the panther is meant to be between the Conan and the sleeping woman in the foreground there's no way it could be that big.
|
|
Roquefort Raider
CCF Mod Squad
Modus omnibus in rebus
Posts: 17,410
Member is Online
|
Post by Roquefort Raider on Jul 7, 2014 5:39:53 GMT -5
That Conan vs Tarzan picture is gorgeous, b-d! Where does it come from?
Mrp, I remember the controversy over that cover. One could wonder why boobies are less acceptable on a cover than gory violence is, but that's how things have been for many decades now.
And berk, I fully agree that Adkins is far, far more than just an inker: I still can't get over his dramatic vistas in Doctor Strange (when he pencilled as well as inked). What a great comic-book artist he was!
quick note that has nothing to do with SSoC: I just read in the newspaper that there is a strongman competition where on top of lifting big stones and carrying massive weights around, the competitors have to push something called "Conan's wheel". This example of how the dreadful Millius movie is still the most common way the general public is made aware of Conan, rather than either Howard's masterful stories or Roy Thomas equally brilliant adaptations, makes me sink into a gigantic melancholy.
|
|
|
Post by foxley on Jul 7, 2014 16:41:08 GMT -5
Pretty nice cover, except that if the panther is meant to be between the Conan and the sleeping woman in the foreground there's no way it could be that big. I think the panther is supposed to be in front of the woman, looking over her at Conan.
|
|
|
Post by foxley on Jul 7, 2014 17:03:30 GMT -5
A page of publicity that had me dreaming back in the '70s: one for those elusive Robert E. Howard books that were so hard to get in Rimouski, QC. Their description and the teeny tiny covers by Jeff Jones were like doors unto magical worlds of action, adventure and wonderment!
(I eventually found that edition of "Sword of the Gael" in a second-hand bookshop in Montreal, years later. The other books I do not own, but the stories they contain have since been reprinted in many different volumes). I had The Sowers of Thunder and The Incredible Adventures of Dennis Dorgan. It was interesting to find collections of Howard's more obscure stuff. And The Sowers of Thunder contains "Sahdow of the Vulture" with the proto-version of Red Sonja. However, all of the stories in The Sowers of Thunder are now available in Del Rey's vastly superior Sword Woman and Other Historical Adventures, which I heartily recommend. Have all the Sailor Steve Costigan/Dennis Dorgan stories ever been collected in a single volume?
|
|
Roquefort Raider
CCF Mod Squad
Modus omnibus in rebus
Posts: 17,410
Member is Online
|
Post by Roquefort Raider on Jul 7, 2014 17:55:17 GMT -5
A page of publicity that had me dreaming back in the '70s: one for those elusive Robert E. Howard books that were so hard to get in Rimouski, QC. Their description and the teeny tiny covers by Jeff Jones were like doors unto magical worlds of action, adventure and wonderment!
(I eventually found that edition of "Sword of the Gael" in a second-hand bookshop in Montreal, years later. The other books I do not own, but the stories they contain have since been reprinted in many different volumes). I had The Sowers of Thunder and The Incredible Adventures of Dennis Dorgan. It was interesting to find collections of Howard's more obscure stuff. And The Sowers of Thunder contains "Sahdow of the Vulture" with the proto-version of Red Sonja. However, all of the stories in The Sowers of Thunder are now available in Del Rey's vastly superior Sword Woman and Other Historical Adventures, which I heartily recommend. Have all the Sailor Steve Costigan/Dennis Dorgan stories ever been collected in a single volume? In French, they were all collected in four books published by NeO. (Here is one of them). In English, Del Rey never got around to do a fight stories compendium... But you can look for Waterfront fists and others, which includes many, many Steve Costigan stories. It was published by Wildside Press.
|
|