|
Post by Deleted on Sept 23, 2016 14:14:32 GMT -5
Script: Ben Percy. Art: Stephen Byrne. Cover: W. Scott Forbes. The Killing Time. Continued from last issue. Conclusion of a 2 parter that showcases Emiko. Honestly I am not thrilled with her character. So this 2 part story bored me. If the next arc isn't great this book will get dropped. Both story & art were just OK. I really don't have much else to say except I wish I would have skipped these 2 issues. Total: 4/10.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 23, 2016 14:19:57 GMT -5
Superman #7 was pretty great, a country fair is just the place for Clark. I'll probably do a full review this weekend as I have it off. I can't wait to read your review. No reason we can't have several reviews on the same title. It was my favorite book this week with Trinity being a close second!
|
|
shaxper
CCF Site Custodian
Posts: 22,871
|
Post by shaxper on Sept 23, 2016 21:41:41 GMT -5
So no one's reading Marvel these days?
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 23, 2016 22:33:01 GMT -5
I read Marvel via my Unlimited subscription now, so I'm 6 months behind. But that's more than I read DC these days, which only gets read if my library gets it in and it's free and I have nothing else to read...
-M
|
|
|
Post by Slam_Bradley on Sept 23, 2016 23:43:26 GMT -5
Very little of what I read is by DC or Marvel. The majority is from Image with a strong minority from Dynamite, some Dark Horse and others.
|
|
|
Post by Ish Kabbible on Sept 23, 2016 23:56:28 GMT -5
I only get graphic collections from the library
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 24, 2016 0:26:50 GMT -5
I don't often do reviews, but I felt like doing a write up on this one, so here goes... Seven to Eternity #1-Published by Image Comics -$3.99 for 28 story pages, 4+ page sketchbook, story text page (journal entry from character p.o.v. setting up story), + back matter essay from author
Rick Remender-writer Jerome Opena-artist Matt Hollingsworth-color artist Russ Wooten-letterer Covers by Jerome Opena, Tony Moore and Andrew Robinson Genre: FantasyI happened to get the Robinson cover (cover C) off the rack at the shop, so that is the one I am showing... Premise/Synopsis: A demi-god known as The God of Whispers (a.k.a. the Mud King) has insinuated himself into the lives and power structure of the people of the city, but one man, Zebidiah Obsidis, refused to hear the Mud King’s offer and fled the city to avoid the war that ensured in this power struggle. Now a generation later, he remains the lone opposition to the God of Whispers who hunts him and his family down. Zebediah’s son Adam watches his father die in his arms and must now save his family, either by destroying the Mud King, or joining him. Writing: Solid world building and interesting characters that stand out as individuals. There are some standard fantasy tropes, but each is given a little flair to make them stand out and avoid clichés. Remender writes strongly flawed characters you can still cheer for and has a track record of putting them through the wringer. I am a fan of his creator owned stuff, especially FEAR Agent, but less so his work-for-hire stuff for Marvel, and this feels like it has the potential to be among his better creator-owned works, it starts strong and promises an interesting ride. Art: If you don’t like modern comic art that plays to the strengths of modern coloring techniques, you won’t like Opena’s art. That said, it is beautifully illustrated and the coloring enhances the feel and verisimilitude of the fantasy world. The visual storytelling is crisp and clear, you don’t need costumes to differentiate between characters, each looks like an individual and a real person. The fantasy elements are appropriately fantastic, yet believable, and the visual world building is a match for the literary/storytelling world building Remender does. Opena and Hollingsworth have a special collaborative symbiosis here, each enhancing the work of the other to present a visual tour de force, but again, if you don’t like “new school” comic art and it’s attendant coloring processes, you may not like it. Art samples: Story: 4/5 Art: 5/5 Overall: 9/10 -M
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 24, 2016 3:09:18 GMT -5
And one more… Black Hammer #3-Published by Dark Horse Comics -$3.99 for 22 story pages +4 page art process essay & sketches by artist
Jeff Lemire-writer Dean Ormston-artist Dave Stewart-color artist Todd Klein-letterer Cover by Dean Ormston & Dave Stewart, variant by Jeff Lemire
Ormston cover… Premise/Synopsis: The Golden Age heroes of Spiral City won a major battle but seemed to die in the battle. In reality there are trapped in a rural small town with no walls, everyone but them seems to come and go as they please, but they are stuck and cannot leave the perimeter of the town. They have been there for 10 years, and only one, the Black Hammer, managed to leave but it can at a great/unrevealed cost. One of their number, Talky Walky the robot sidekick of Dr. Weird has constructed a series of probes to try to find a way out for all of them, but all have failed. Meanwhile in Spiral City, the daughter of the Black Hammer, now a jopurnalist, believes they are all still alive and searches for a sign of their survival/location. In this issue, we get a focus on Barbalien, the Warlord of Mars (a J’onn J’onnz analogue) as he seeks to find peace of mind in his new home, we learn more of how he came to earth and took on the role of hero there. Meanwhile, the most recent probe sent out by Talky Walky, that they lost contact with after it left the town’s perimeter, crash lands through earth’s atmosphere through space, and the military crew who finds it recognized the tech as belonging to Dr. Weird and contacts Black Hammer’s daughter. Writing: Jeff Lemire is hit or miss for me. His DC Universe stuff was mostly a miss, but every one of his creator-owned projects hits with me. I suspected he just wasn’t suited for cape stories, but this series proves me wrong. He has a very deft hand handling these classic super-hero analogue archetype characters, and gives each a strong voice and identity despite their call back to more recognizable classic super-heroes. He is building and unraveling a mystery at a deliciously addictive paste, giving us enough hints and bread crumbs in each issue to keep us on our toes, but delivers a complete feeling story in every issue so far. Art: Dean Ormston’s stuff channels the feel of classic pulp heroes and pulp sci-fi and is perfectly suited for this series. He suffered a brain trauma while doing the second issue and has had to reteach himself to draw as he rehabilitates his ability to use the right side of his body (he’s right handed and draws with his right hand). The art however, feels seamless and his storytelling is top-notch. Dave Stewart is a master at capturing mood and tone with his colors, and his talents are on display in this series for all to see. sample pages... Story: 5/5 Art: 5/5 Overall: 10/10-M
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 24, 2016 6:12:33 GMT -5
So no one's reading Marvel these days? Only a few titles. Most of Marvel's heroes have been replaced. The Fantastic Four doesn't exist. I could care less about Doom as Iron Man or Cho as Hulk. And remember why Marvel made Peter single again? To go back to basics. So let's make him CEO of an international company (cause that makes sense).
And in chasing those mythical creatures (new readers) Marvel thinks hey let's change our heroes so if someone that saw the movies goes into a LCS looking for Thor he/she finds that Thor's a woman? Or that Tony Stark been replaced by Doom? Or that the Falcon is Capt America & Steve is an agent of Hydra? Because that makes sense....
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Sept 24, 2016 9:02:34 GMT -5
So no one's reading Marvel these days? Only a few titles. Most of Marvel's heroes have been replaced. The Fantastic Four doesn't exist. I could care less about Doom as Iron Man or Cho as Hulk. And remember why Marvel made Peter single again? To go back to basics. So let's make him CEO of an international company (cause that makes sense).
And in chasing those mythical creatures (new readers) Marvel thinks hey let's change our heroes so if someone that saw the movies goes into a LCS looking for Thor he/she finds that Thor's a woman? Or that Tony Stark been replaced by Doom? Or that the Falcon is Capt America & Steve is an agent of Hydra? Because that makes sense....
I'm in a similar boat, the changes they made just don't interest me...and that's coming from someone who's favorite runs often include "replacements". I liked JPV as Batman after Knightfall growing up, Dick as Batman during Morrison's run is one of my all time favorite comics period and Bucky as Cap is probably my favorite Captain America story...but these new changes don't feel organic and the stories they tell don't really interest me that much(although I haven't tried Thor).
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 24, 2016 9:15:06 GMT -5
Only a few titles. Most of Marvel's heroes have been replaced. The Fantastic Four doesn't exist. I could care less about Doom as Iron Man or Cho as Hulk. And remember why Marvel made Peter single again? To go back to basics. So let's make him CEO of an international company (cause that makes sense).
And in chasing those mythical creatures (new readers) Marvel thinks hey let's change our heroes so if someone that saw the movies goes into a LCS looking for Thor he/she finds that Thor's a woman? Or that Tony Stark been replaced by Doom? Or that the Falcon is Capt America & Steve is an agent of Hydra? Because that makes sense....
I'm in a similar boat, the changes they made just don't interest me...and that's coming from someone who's favorite runs often include "replacements". I liked JPV as Batman after Knightfall growing up, Dick as Batman during Morrison's run is one of my all time favorite comics period and Bucky as Cap is probably my favorite Captain America story...but these new changes don't feel organic and the stories they tell don't really interest me that much(although I haven't tried Thor). I liked Dick as Batman & Bucky as Cap too. Those changes made sense. I hate change when it makes no sense & comes out of nowhere.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Sept 24, 2016 10:26:05 GMT -5
Hellboy and the BPRD:1954 #1"Black Sun" Written by Mike Mignola and Chris Roberson Art by Stephan Green Colored by Dave Stewart
Summary: When an unknown creature attacks an American scientific party at a remote arctic outpost the BPRD sends out Hellboy and rookie agent Woodrow Farrier to investigate and what first appears to Hellboy as an open and shut case of yet another mutated animal turns out to be far stranger.
Plot: What's really fun about this series is the chance to see Hellboy grow as a character. That isn't to that Mignola never developed Hellboy over the last 20 years, in fact the opposite is true as the changes the readers went through with Hellboy have been the main selling point, but while that growth has been great to see we never saw how he became the agent we first fell in love with which is exactly what Hellboy and the BPRD is giving us. In the first outings in the 1940's series we saw a young boy struggling to find his identity, in the 1950's we saw him develop from a reluctant, unsure agent to a young man who's discovered he's pretty good at monster slaying...and in this outing we see Hellboy in his sort of sophomore year; he feels he's the expert now and approaches his first mission in charge with an almost jaded outlook. It's an organic growth that just makes you smile because you know what will come of that view because you yourself likely went through a similar phase. Mignola and Roberson do a fantastic job of creating a truly human story in the midst of a supernatural world, and the juxtaposition of those elements is amazing to see. It would be easy to lose the balance between those two disparate elements but they manage to thread the line beautifully.
Art: Stephan Green is a new artist on the scene, we're told by Scott Allie at the end of the issue(where the letter column usually is) that he met Green at the North Carolina Comicon in 2014 and that he just knew he'd be perfect for Hellboy and I have to say I agree. He has a bright youthful energy to he work that perfectly fits this younger Hellboy without feeling out of place in Mignola's world which is probably equal parts his own talent and the work of Dave Stewart whose pallet choices always highlight the strengths' of the artists he works with while maintaining a coherent over arching look for the whole world. In all of comicdom I don't think there has ever been a colorist given that level of power in a narrative and I'm not sure there is another one that could pull it off.
Conclusion: This is yet another exciting look at Hellboy's early years, and although Roberson and Mignola strike an excellent balance between creating a very human story and a supernatural thriller this first issue is ultimately all set up but it promises an excellent follow through.
Grade: 9/10 (story:4, Art: 5)
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Sept 24, 2016 11:45:42 GMT -5
Aliens: Life and Death #1 Written by Dan Abnett Art by Moritat Colored Rain Beredo Summary: A unit of Colonial Marines is trapped on LV-223 and under siege from a whole army of Aliens.
Plot: I had dropped out of the last round of Aliens comics because I didn't want to have read a bunch of other comics I had no interest in what-so-ever in order to get the whole story. When I picked this up I was really hoping that was no longer the format and that if it was at least Abnett would make it interesting...boy was I wrong. The characters are just card board cut outs so there's no one to really latch onto and rout for and there's no attempt to provide any real exposition to readers, like myself, who haven't read the previous minis which makes the violence seem pointless.
Art: I'm actually at a loss here, I normally enjoy Moritat but the art here was really inconsistent, so much so that I had to flip back to the credits to see if there were multiple artists and was blown away by the fact that not only was there only one artist but one I actually enjoy. The tone shifts wildly from a cartoony look to the action to a gritty look(that felt much more appropriate) when it shifted to one soldier isolated from the rest. On top of that the pallet chosen by Beredo didn't help matters, the colors were just too bright for a horror story and there weren't any real gradients used to add depth so it gave it an amateurish look.
Conclusion: I used to love Dark Horse's Aliens line but the last story was frustrating and this one was a total dud which is surprising because I generally like the work of both Abnett and Moritat.
Grade: 2/10
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Sept 24, 2016 13:17:35 GMT -5
And one more… Black Hammer #3-Published by Dark Horse Comics -$3.99 for 22 story pages +4 page art process essay & sketches by artist
Story: 5/5 Art: 5/5 Overall: 10/10-M I've been loving this series right along but this one was the best by far. A lot of that has to do with Barbalien, so far he's the most intriguing character in terms of what he wants but there's also the great sc-fi look to him too which is visually fun. I hope this book goes on for a good long time.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 24, 2016 13:21:40 GMT -5
And one more… Black Hammer #3-Published by Dark Horse Comics -$3.99 for 22 story pages +4 page art process essay & sketches by artist
Story: 5/5 Art: 5/5 Overall: 10/10-M I've been loving this series right along but this one was the best by far. A lot of that has to do with Barbalien, so far he's the most intriguing character in terms of what he wants but there's also the great sc-fi look to him too which is visually fun. I hope this book goes on for a good long time. I picked up the first 3 issues the other day when I splurged on some new comics at the lcs, and read them in one go last night before writing the review, so all 3 were fresh in my mind as I write up #3. I originally intended to trade wait on this, but Ormstron's covers were irresistible, and since I wanted to read this anyways, I took the plunge. -M
|
|