|
Post by thwhtguardian on Oct 4, 2016 20:52:11 GMT -5
As Lee Falk used to say, " For Those Who Came in Late..." here at the classic comics the reviews are not put up by paid writers but rather by users just like you! If you're reading modern books as they come out and want to share your views(good or bad) here's the place to put them. As the reviews start to pour in I'll link them here, until then here's the list of what's coming out this week: Aftershock:Shipwreck #1Archie:Archie Meets the Ramones Boom!:Big Trouble in Little China Escapes From New York #1 Giant Days #19 Regular Show #40 Dark Horse:Bounty #4 Rise of the Black Flame #2DC:Aquaman #6 Batman #8 Cyborg #2 Deadman: Dark Mansion of Forbidden Love #1Death of Hawkman #1Flintstones #4 Future Quest #5Green Arrow #8 Green Lanterns #8 Harley Quinn and Her Gang #6 Harley Quinn #5 He-Man/Thundercats #1 Justice League #6Midnighter and Apollo #1Nightwing #6 Shade the Changing Girl #1Superman #8 and thoughts by thwhtguardian Dynamite: Army of Darkness/Xena #1 Betty Boop #1 Boo World's Cutest Doll #2 Evil Ernie #3 Great Divide #2 James Bond #10 Shadow: Death of Margo Lane #5 IDW:Angry Birds #10 Archangel #3 D&D #5 Ghostbusters International #9 Godzilla #2 Ragnarok #10Revolution #2 Transformers #57 Image:Autumnlands #13 Cannibal #1 Green Valley #1Midnight of the Soul #5 Moonshine #1 No Mercy #10 Papergirls #10 Red One #4Walking Dead #159 Spawn #266 Eclipse #2 Romulus #1Marvel:All New Wolverine #13Amazing Spider-Man #19 Cage #1 Deadpool and the Mercs for the Money #4 Death of X #1Enchanted Tiki Room #1 Doctor Strange #12 Invincible Iron Man #14 Jessica Jones #1Scarlet Witch #11 Spider-Man 2099 #16 Spidey #11 Uncanny X-Men #14As always, if I missed a title and you want to review it just shoot me a PM and I'll add it to the list with a link to your review. Last Week: 9/28
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 5, 2016 14:11:29 GMT -5
No reviews for me this week. I leave Thurs evening for a week spent with my family in the Poconos. I love fall!
Thumbs up for Aquaman & Superman this week!
|
|
shaxper
CCF Site Custodian
Posts: 22,871
|
Post by shaxper on Oct 5, 2016 19:29:23 GMT -5
I really need to know how the new Deadman is!
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 5, 2016 21:58:41 GMT -5
I really need to know how the new Deadman is! Early reviews have been positive. However it is described as gothic romance...
|
|
|
Post by Dizzy D on Oct 6, 2016 4:19:49 GMT -5
I have Midnighter and Apollo and Dr. Strange, I'll see if I have some time this evening to write something up. Looked at the #1s of Image, but nothing that I directly wanted to pick up.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 6, 2016 8:24:44 GMT -5
Death of Hawkman #1-I enjoyed it, although the story in the first issue was more about Adam Strange. The issue revolves around Adam not being able to be Zeta beamed back to Rann to be with Alanna (who looks nothing like the Alanna I am familiar with. I am assuming this is one of the new 52 changes). Apparently there is some conflict with Rann and Thanagar that both Hawkman and Adam will be drawn into, based on the first few pages of the book. The story was interesting enough to keep my interest and Adam was very relatable. I bought the book mainly for Hawkman, so hopefully he will appear more as the series progresses. Hoping he doesn't die as the title implies, haha! The art was nice. Very clear and classic. The panel layout was easy on the eyes. Not a bad start for the series, looking forward to see where this all goes. 7/10
Justice League #6-Probably dropping this title very soon. This new storyline seems more interesting than the last one. Something is striking fear into the JL, they unite and think it is defeated. Later in the story, the female Green Lantern and Superman start behaving strangely. Aquaman and Wonder Woman have a quick moment. Flash and the female Green Lantern have some nice moments. For me, the best part of the book was Superman returning home to Lois and his son, telling them about his day much like a real-world husband and father would do. The art was ok, nothing special. For this to be a team book, the JL doesn't feel much like a team. It's like they just come together when needed. No sense of real friendship or camaraderie like the satellite era. I realize that era is long gone, but so far the JL book just isn't clicking for me. 5/10
I plan or reading Superman tonight. Flipped through it and it looks fun!
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Oct 6, 2016 9:53:38 GMT -5
I really need to know how the new Deadman is! Ask and ye shall receive.... Deadman: Dark Mansion of Forbidden Love #1
Written by Sarah Vaughn Art by Lan Medina Colored by Jose' Villarrubia Summary: A young couple, Berenice and Nathan, move into an old Gothic mansion so that Matt can finish his novel while enveloped in the proper atmosphere. But while for Nathan this is a fantastic experience Berenice is becoming more and more troubled as being sensitive to the supernatural she feels as if the house is...awakening. Enter Deadman, who is attracted to the house after hearing an undeniable plea for help on the ethereal plain...but once he enters the mansion he finds that he cannot leave. It's obviously a trap...but for who? Plot: Sarah Vaughn, the author of my friend Lexi's favorite book Alex+Ada, is a writer known for her intensely introspective plots full of rich, well developed interpersonal relationships and she certainly brings that here to Deadman. And with the page count that comes with the Prestige Format from DC she has a lot of room to fill, and she does; she takes her time slowly introducing the cast of characters(and allowing them to develop), she establishes a beautifully eerie mood just dripping with suspense and intrigue and then gives us just enough action to keep us on our toes. After tearing through this I quickly handed it off to another friend of mine whom sadly only made it ten pages into it before commenting, "Where's the gore? There's nothing scary here." and ostensibly he is correct; there is no gore, no monster, nothing shocking...but that doesn't mean it isn't a great horror book. In fact, much of its appeal to me is just how akin this feels to the works of such great, classic horror writers as Marry Shelley and Sheridan Le Fanu with it's complex, realistic characterizations and emotional intrigue Sarah Vaughn's Deadman is a perfect example of horror. "But how can that be?" you say, "How is it horror with out the blood and guts?" and to that I say you have a grave misconception of the genre of horror and what it can be. Horror isn't all blades flashing in the night and monsters lurking in the shadows just waiting to splash you with buckets of blood, it's larger than that; it's an entire genre of fiction whose purpose is to provoke a negative reaction from its audience. True, that reaction can be a scream of fright but it can also be as subtle as a slight shiver up your spine, a contraction of your facial features into a grimace, a tightening of your grip or as small as a slight widening of your eyes. Horror is a convocation for that seldom used, primal fight or flight instinct still lurking in the back of your brain, that prehistoric holdover from before we became civil beasts. Horror, at it's best, makes us think, confronts us with ideas we might rather ignore, challenges our preconceptions of everyday life and shakes us out of our warm complacency, but unlike pure Science Fiction which tends to evoke a sense of hopefulness horror asks those questions of us and presents the darker answers. Horror can be blood and guts, and if that's what you want there's plenty to find but it can also be more than that and unfortunately these days the horror story that strives for that is a much rarer beast which is why Vaughn's work here is all the more fascinating. Vaughn's Deadman is full of poignant back stories that really make you feel for the people she's introducing us to, and the ominous sense of brooding she creates with her slow narration really makes you feel Berenice's dread that the old house is waking up. And as a fan of DC's old, 70's horror anthologies I love that she brings back the title The Dark Mansion of Forbidden Love which although created as a short lived companion to Secrets of the Sinister House I always felt it was the superior book because it did strive to be different than the schlocky B-Movie horror stories of its brethren. And now, after all that gushing above I have to bring up one negative...and that's the fact that Deadman almost feels like an afterthought here; although his awkward first introduction to Berenice was fantastic, his battle with the living shadow that keep slowly building behind Berenice made that presence somewhat cheaper. It went from an unknowable, ominous threat to something you could punch and drive away which was much more interesting. I think the story would have been that much stronger if it were allowed to be its own thing...but truth be told that's how my favorite Deadman stories usually are as well; I tend to love the ones where he's more of an observer than active participant so I'm hoping that happens here in the future with Deadman taking more of the back seat to the other characters. Art: Artist Lan Medina of Fables fame and colorist Jose Villarrubia use all 48 pages of art to create a setting that would make the old Hammer Horror guys swoon. It's hard to talk about one or the other in terms of praising the art as both are so complimentary in making the house feel like it's own characters. The detail that Medina includes in each scene make it look like it was actually a place that was lived in with its own sense of history while Villarrubia's subtle colorwork gives the whole thing a look that is reminiscent of an old, oil based painting with it's muted colors and deep, dark, inky shadows and wonderful textures. Both artists are obviously skilled but together they create a whole that is truly greater than its parts. Conclusion: This slow burning Gothic tale is a true breath of fresh air, there really isn't a book like it out there right now and its very existence is cause for celebration and hope that DC does more like this...although if you were hoping for fistacuffs and action you best look elsewhere. Grade: 9.5/10
|
|
shaxper
CCF Site Custodian
Posts: 22,871
|
Post by shaxper on Oct 6, 2016 10:16:54 GMT -5
It takes a lot to make me pick up a DC or Marvel book these days, but the premise combined with your review has made me excited!
|
|
|
Post by Slam_Bradley on Oct 6, 2016 10:33:29 GMT -5
DC seems to be doing some good stuff right now, just outside the mainstream Universe. I'll almost certainly pick up this Deadman book on the strength of the reviews I'm seeing in trade. Also looking forward to picking up Future Quest, The Flintstones, Frostbite, Wacky Raceland and the initial review of Shade, The Changing Girl seem strong.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Oct 6, 2016 10:55:22 GMT -5
It takes a lot to make me pick up a DC or Marvel book these days, but the premise combined with your review has made me excited! I think you're going to love it, and it seems like it's only going to get better as it goes. I'm not sure of the endgame, but with the different types of romantic relationships introduced and being physically trapped in a house and being hunted by an immense shadow I'm digging the metaphorical possibilities. DC seems to be doing some good stuff right now, just outside the mainstream Universe. I'll almost certainly pick up this Deadman book on the strength of the reviews I'm seeing in trade. Also looking forward to picking up Future Quest, The Flintstones, Frostbite, Wacky Raceland and the initial review of Shade, The Changing Girl seem strong. The level of experimentation is definitely heartening, and the level of quality is pretty great and although it is definitely focused primarily outside the main universe there are some titles in universe that are nearly there on those terms which makes them worth reading; for instance Superman has a very Fliesher, All-American, bombastic feel to it that I love,Jurgens is doing a great ode to silver age plots in Action and the character work in Batgirl is fantastic. Overall, I think it's a great time to be a reader.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Oct 6, 2016 11:43:38 GMT -5
Shade the Changing Girl #1 Written by Cecil Castellucci Art by Marley Zarcone Colored by Kelley Fitzpatrick Summary: Meet Loma, an Avian from the planet Meta, enamored with the alien poet/fugitive Rac Shade she steels his fabled madness vest and travels to Earth(the Blue Planet) to break away from her old life and experience big feelings only life on Earth in the body of teenage coma patient Megan isn't exactly what she planned on. Plot: I never read Peter Milligan's run on the character but after reading this I think that's a mistake I really need to rectify. In the first issue of Shade the Changing Girl Castellucci really manages to bring to life two truly fascinating characters in Loma and Megan(the girl she possesses with the Madness Vest). Neither one is a cookie cutter creation; Loma owes money to "bad men" has multiple lovers and uses sex to attain her own ends while Megan is a girl whose parents and "friends" seem thrown into despair when they find out she's awoken from her coma. It's fresh, fast paced and the mysteries of why Megan was in a coma and why Loma wanted to escape so badly are tantalizing and promise a lot of fun to come in future issues. About the only drawback is that the plot is so manic that although the characters are introduced and immediately interesting they don't have a lot of room to really streatch out their legs and show us a lot of who they are, but hey I'm confident that'll come later. Art: If you're a fan of Andy Warhol or the music videos for Dan Deacon songs (seriously check that link!) then you're going to love Zarcone’s art. There's a serious surrealist streak that although it occasionally makes you have to slow down and really go over it all again to catch the narrative truly fits the tone of the book. It's perplexing to look at at times, and definitely isn't traditionally comic-booky, but it's enjoyable to look at in and of itself even seperate from its ability to tell the story at hand so it's worth the effort to follow. Conclusion: The Young Animal imprint continues to really bring the thunder in terms of providing new and refreshing comic book experiences with the addition of Shade the Changing Girl. I don't think I'm a dangerous human yet, but I may be when these books are done with me. Grade:8.5/10
|
|
shaxper
CCF Site Custodian
Posts: 22,871
|
Post by shaxper on Oct 6, 2016 20:33:14 GMT -5
Shade the Changing Girl #1 Written by Cecil Castellucci Art by Marley Zarcone Colored by Kelley Fitzpatrick Summary: Meet Loma, an Avian from the planet Meta, enamored with the alien poet/fugitive Rac Shade she steels his fabled madness vest and travels to Earth(the Blue Planet) to break away from her old life and experience big feelings only life on Earth in the body of teenage coma patient Megan isn't exactly what she planned on. Plot: I never read Peter Milligan's run on the character but after reading this I think that's a mistake I really need to rectify. In the first issue of Shade the Changing Girl Castellucci really manages to bring to life two truly fascinating characters in Loma and Megan(the girl she possesses with the Madness Vest). Neither one is a cookie cutter creation; Loma owes money to "bad men" has multiple lovers and uses sex to attain her own ends while Megan is a girl whose parents and "friends" seem thrown into despair when they find out she's awoken from her coma. It's fresh, fast paced and the mysteries of why Megan was in a coma and why Loma wanted to escape so badly are tantalizing and promise a lot of fun to come in future issues. About the only drawback is that the plot is so manic that although the characters are introduced and immediately interesting they don't have a lot of room to really streatch out their legs and show us a lot of who they are, but hey I'm confident that'll come later. Art: If you're a fan of Andy Warhol or the music videos for Dan Deacon songs (seriously check that link!) then you're going to love Zarcone’s art. There's a serious surrealist streak that although it occasionally makes you have to slow down and really go over it all again to catch the narrative truly fits the tone of the book. It's perplexing to look at at times, and definitely isn't traditionally comic-booky, but it's enjoyable to look at in and of itself even seperate from its ability to tell the story at hand so it's worth the effort to follow. Conclusion: The Young Animal imprint continues to really bring the thunder in terms of providing new and refreshing comic book experiences with the addition of Shade the Changing Girl. I don't think I'm a dangerous human yet, but I may be when these books are done with me. Grade:8.5/10 Went to the store today, hoping to grab both this and Deadman. They were out of Deadman but had one copy of this left. Having just read the original Ditko series last year, I see absolutely nothing that feels familiar in this beyond the name "Rac Shade". I suspect this series is either building more off of the 1990s Peter Milligan revival or is yet another new interpretation entirely. I generally enjoyed the story and concur with an 8.5 grade. What concerns me is that, while this was a well-told first issue, I don't have a clear sense of where the series is heading. I felt like the mystery was pretty much already solved by the end; itt felt like the author played all of his/her(?) cards already. If there's any mystery left beyond "girl who tried to control everything ended up turning everyone against her," I'm missing it.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Oct 7, 2016 7:24:34 GMT -5
Shade the Changing Girl #1 Written by Cecil Castellucci Art by Marley Zarcone Colored by Kelley Fitzpatrick Summary: Meet Loma, an Avian from the planet Meta, enamored with the alien poet/fugitive Rac Shade she steels his fabled madness vest and travels to Earth(the Blue Planet) to break away from her old life and experience big feelings only life on Earth in the body of teenage coma patient Megan isn't exactly what she planned on. Plot: I never read Peter Milligan's run on the character but after reading this I think that's a mistake I really need to rectify. In the first issue of Shade the Changing Girl Castellucci really manages to bring to life two truly fascinating characters in Loma and Megan(the girl she possesses with the Madness Vest). Neither one is a cookie cutter creation; Loma owes money to "bad men" has multiple lovers and uses sex to attain her own ends while Megan is a girl whose parents and "friends" seem thrown into despair when they find out she's awoken from her coma. It's fresh, fast paced and the mysteries of why Megan was in a coma and why Loma wanted to escape so badly are tantalizing and promise a lot of fun to come in future issues. About the only drawback is that the plot is so manic that although the characters are introduced and immediately interesting they don't have a lot of room to really streatch out their legs and show us a lot of who they are, but hey I'm confident that'll come later. Art: If you're a fan of Andy Warhol or the music videos for Dan Deacon songs (seriously check that link!) then you're going to love Zarcone’s art. There's a serious surrealist streak that although it occasionally makes you have to slow down and really go over it all again to catch the narrative truly fits the tone of the book. It's perplexing to look at at times, and definitely isn't traditionally comic-booky, but it's enjoyable to look at in and of itself even seperate from its ability to tell the story at hand so it's worth the effort to follow. Conclusion: The Young Animal imprint continues to really bring the thunder in terms of providing new and refreshing comic book experiences with the addition of Shade the Changing Girl. I don't think I'm a dangerous human yet, but I may be when these books are done with me. Grade:8.5/10 Went to the store today, hoping to grab both this and Deadman. They were out of Deadman but had one copy of this left. Having just read the original Ditko series last year, I see absolutely nothing that feels familiar in this beyond the name "Rac Shade". I suspect this series is either building more off of the 1990s Peter Milligan revival or is yet another new interpretation entirely. I generally enjoyed the story and concur with an 8.5 grade. What concerns me is that, while this was a well-told first issue, I don't have a clear sense of where the series is heading. I felt like the mystery was pretty much already solved by the end; itt felt like the author played all of his/her(?) cards already. If there's any mystery left beyond "girl who tried to control everything ended up turning everyone against her," I'm missing it. Although I never read it, from a little research I did this is definitely a play off Milligan's take on the character. In a continuity porn kind of light, wikipedia did mention that Ditko's work was canon...only it was just a story Rac Shad made up for himself as he was traveling to Earth. Think of it sort of Sandman versus Neil Gaiman's Sandman. I also agree about the direction, in the issue itself it doesn't give a clear thrust for continuation other than the simple desire to see where Loma/Megan goes next but in the character bio at the end it did give some interesting tidbits that could be fun.
|
|
shaxper
CCF Site Custodian
Posts: 22,871
|
Post by shaxper on Oct 7, 2016 7:34:19 GMT -5
Went to the store today, hoping to grab both this and Deadman. They were out of Deadman but had one copy of this left. Having just read the original Ditko series last year, I see absolutely nothing that feels familiar in this beyond the name "Rac Shade". I suspect this series is either building more off of the 1990s Peter Milligan revival or is yet another new interpretation entirely. I generally enjoyed the story and concur with an 8.5 grade. What concerns me is that, while this was a well-told first issue, I don't have a clear sense of where the series is heading. I felt like the mystery was pretty much already solved by the end; itt felt like the author played all of his/her(?) cards already. If there's any mystery left beyond "girl who tried to control everything ended up turning everyone against her," I'm missing it. Although I never read it, from a little research I did this is definitely a play off Milligan's take on the character. In a continuity porn kind of light, wikipedia did mention that Ditko's work was canon...only it was just a story Rac Shad made up for himself as he was traveling to Earth. Think of it sort of Sandman versus Neil Gaiman's Sandman. I also agree about the direction, in the issue itself it doesn't give a clear thrust for continuation other than the simple desire to see where Loma/Megan goes next but in the character bio at the end it did give some interesting tidbits that could be fun. I'd imagine there's going to be a sort of redemption arc where Loma begins to see that the way she ran her life was comparable to the way her host body led hers, ultimately making restitution with the parents and the friends. Clearly, there's going to be a rivalry between her and the girl on the swim team who took her place and wasn't initially invited to the late night party. None of that sounds particularly interesting to me, though, unless some impressive quality is found in the characterization of Loma as she seeks to make things right. I haven't seen anything particularly distinct or likable about her yet. So I enjoyed it, but I'm not coming back for issue #2 unless you manage to sway me with another compelling review
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Oct 7, 2016 7:46:42 GMT -5
Although I never read it, from a little research I did this is definitely a play off Milligan's take on the character. In a continuity porn kind of light, wikipedia did mention that Ditko's work was canon...only it was just a story Rac Shad made up for himself as he was traveling to Earth. Think of it sort of Sandman versus Neil Gaiman's Sandman. I also agree about the direction, in the issue itself it doesn't give a clear thrust for continuation other than the simple desire to see where Loma/Megan goes next but in the character bio at the end it did give some interesting tidbits that could be fun. I'd imagine there's going to be a sort of redemption arc where Loma begins to see that the way she ran her life was comparable to the way her host body led hers, ultimately making restitution with the parents and the friends. Clearly, there's going to be a rivalry between her and the girl on the swim team who took her place and wasn't initially invited to the late night party. None of that sounds particularly interesting to me, though, unless some impressive quality is found in the characterization of Loma as she seeks to make things right. I haven't seen anything particularly distinct or likable about her yet. So I enjoyed it, but I'm not coming back for issue #2 unless you manage to sway me with another compelling review Yeah, that's about where I see it going as well and as far as human drama goes it could be interesting as long as it steers away from feeling like a teen soap opera from the CW. I'm game for at least one more issue so we'll see how it goes.
|
|