|
Post by thwhtguardian on Oct 13, 2016 17:05:32 GMT -5
Flash #8: The ending to the Godspeed arc wasn't too bad. Williamson had Wally II become Kid Flash & help Barry stop Godspeed. I still think DC needs to stop creating these new evil speedsters. I miss the old rogues. Flash has some of the best villains in comics! Use them! The art was spectacular. 7/10. Superwoman #3: What happened? One of the best titles of Rebirth just became a confusing mess. Jimenez has too many subplots he is trying to juggle. He needs to wrap up some subplots before adding new ones. The art by Emanuela Lupacchino and Ray McCarthy was good. It looks like they may be the new art team? I am going to finish this first arc... 5/10. Yeah, that's why I dropped Superwoman, it had a cool concept but it wasn't allowed to grow into its own before adding in all the other stuff.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 13, 2016 17:56:18 GMT -5
Flash #8: The ending to the Godspeed arc wasn't too bad. Williamson had Wally II become Kid Flash & help Barry stop Godspeed. I still think DC needs to stop creating these new evil speedsters. I miss the old rogues. Flash has some of the best villains in comics! Use them! The art was spectacular. 7/10. Superwoman #3: What happened? One of the best titles of Rebirth just became a confusing mess. Jimenez has too many subplots he is trying to juggle. He needs to wrap up some subplots before adding new ones. The art by Emanuela Lupacchino and Ray McCarthy was good. It looks like they may be the new art team? I am going to finish this first arc... 5/10. Yeah, that's why I dropped Superwoman, it had a cool concept but it wasn't allowed to grow into its own before adding in all the other stuff. It's weird I felt Phil did the same thing on his WW run. The first arc was too much & then he settled into it. IMO it became one of the better WW runs. So I'm hoping the same thing happens here with Lana as Superwoman.
|
|
|
Post by Hoosier X on Oct 13, 2016 20:16:31 GMT -5
I am so glad I picked up Doom Patrol on a whim! I loved the second issue as much as the first. And I'm really looking forward to the coming of Rita Farr. She's great!
And Wonder Woman is great! I liked the Barbara Minerva issue a lot. I had a few problems with the first few issues but this series got really good really fast.
Among the other comics I got this week, I liked Batgirl and the Birds of Prey #3, Astro City #39 and Haunted Horror #24.
As for Detective Comics #942 ... let's say my reaction was a little more ... muted.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Oct 13, 2016 21:14:05 GMT -5
I am so glad I picked up Doom Patrol on a whim! I loved the second issue as much as the first. And I'm really looking forward to the coming of Rita Farr. She's great! And Wonder Woman is great! I liked the Barbara Minerva issue a lot. I had a few problems with the first few issues but this series got really good really fast. Among the other comics I got this week, I liked Batgirl and the Birds of Prey #3, Astro City #39 and Haunted Horror #24. As for Detective Comics #942 ... let's say my reaction was a little more ... muted. Doom Patrol has been a lot of fun, I love how weird it is and the art is fantastic. And I feel your pain on Detective, I really disliked the Monster Men story and dropped everything that crossover with it and I may not pick them up after it's done unless the reviews are good.
|
|
|
Post by Dizzy D on Oct 15, 2016 7:02:59 GMT -5
The Fix #6 Written by Nick Spencer Art by Steve Leiber Colours by Ryan Hill What went before: Roy is a criminal. Roy is a cop. These things are not contradictory, as Roy already figured out at a young age that the police can get away with anything. But Roy is not as smart as he thinks he is, so he and his equally corrupt partner Mac are now heavily in debt to a psychopathic crimelord. In order to pay him off, Roy is now taking any sidejob that comes his way. His recent turn as bodyguard to a local celebrity ended with her being murdered though. But no worries! Roy is on the case and he already found the killer... because he hired him. Summary: Roy has tracked down Matty, the meth-addict Roy hired to break into the celebrity's house to steal her stuff (a reporter Roy met years ago has a side-business selling celebrity objects). Matt brings Roy to his accomplices and quickly Roy figures out that these guys are actually not the killers, but maybe there is a clue among the items they stole? Plot: The second story-arc of The Fix is coming along nicely. We get some new characters and like always they are all corrupt, fitting along the two corrupt police officers, the corrupt IA officer, the corrupt Mayor, the corrupt producer and many others. I think Mac's new partner in customs is the only character I've seen so far that is not corrupt. I'm waiting for Roy and Mac to meet up again though, as that part of the story is interesting me the most: in a previous issue Mac was assigned to customs in order to smuggle some drugs past custom, but during that time he became true friends for the first time in his life with the police dog he's partnered with. We jump for some short scenes to characters previously introduced, but with little introduction here, so it's not very new-reader friendly. Like many of Image's titles, this is a title best right in full. Still the individual issues have enough happening in them. Art: drawing comedy without going too cartoony is tough, but Lieber is doing a great job and Spencer lets him have some pages without text to show his craft at storytelling. I'm having a hard time thinking of artists that could replace him without losing the spirit of this comic. The Spencer/Lieber team are becoming like Brubaker/Phillips to me: they are mostly doing one type of story, but they are really good at it. Grade: 8/10
|
|
|
Post by Dizzy D on Oct 15, 2016 7:21:03 GMT -5
Moon Knight #7 Written by Jeff Lemire Art by Francesco Francavilla (Jake Lockley) and James Stokoe (Marc Spector). No Torres this time as we get no Steven Grant chapter. No Greg Smallwood either this time, but he did the cover. What went before: Moon Knight has escaped from Khonshu's attempt to possess him and woke up as movie producer Steven Grant who is working on the Moon Knight movie. Meanwhile Jake Lockley travels through the crime-ridden New York nights in his cab and space pilot Marc Spector defends Moon Base from the Space Wolves fleet. What is real? What is not? What is happening? I have no idea, but it's really nice to look at. Summary: In this issue we only get to see Jake Lockley and Marc Spector's stories, while they slowly start to overlap and interact. Plot: It's really hard to judge this as a single story. Taken as a single issue, it's nearly incomprehensible as we constantly switch between swashbuckling space-action and crime noir, but the parts were the stories overlap shows that there is a plot and a plan here. Art: While the plot is still mysterious, the art is still this series strongest point. Nothing against Lemire, but the artists have just been that great. It must have taken a bit of coordination as well as the stories sometimes switch on the same page, so it's not that they just had Francavilla do half the pages and Stokoe the other half. Grade: 9*/10*= providing we get a satisfying conclusion to this story arc, as a standalone it's carried by the art alone.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Oct 15, 2016 8:48:48 GMT -5
Moon Knight #7
Grade: 9*/10*= providing we get a satisfying conclusion to this story arc, as a standalone it's carried by the art alone. One of the reasons I signed on to Marvel Unlimited was because I wanted to read the Moench run on Moon Knight...only to learn they didn't have that. I've tried a few of the more modern runs that they did have though and I enjoyed those. Is this run something that's pretty easy to jump into or should I get some back ground info?
|
|
|
Post by Dizzy D on Oct 15, 2016 9:55:54 GMT -5
It's just 7 issues so I would start at #1. No backstory needed beyond knowing who Moon Knight and his major cast (Frenchie, Gena, Marlene and Crawley) is for this run. But like I said at the moment things are weird so the story can go anywhere.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Oct 15, 2016 10:31:23 GMT -5
It's just 7 issues so I would start at #1. No backstory needed beyond knowing who Moon Knight and his major cast (Frenchie, Gena, Marlene and Crawley) is for this run. But like I said at the moment things are weird so the story can go anywhere. I'm not that familiar with the supporting cast but I imagine a little google-fu would catch me up, I might try and see if I can pick up the first few issues on the cheap...or actually if it's at #7 the first few might be on Unlimited.
|
|
|
Post by Dizzy D on Oct 15, 2016 11:04:07 GMT -5
I can easily sum them up:
Frenchie: former driver/pilot for Moon Knight, friend from way before Marc was Moon Knight. Gena: Waitress at a diner. One of his informants and friends. Crawley: Older homeless person, but with a lot of contacts. One of his informants and friends. Marlene: His love interest, the one who helped Marc become Moon Knight. Also one of the best love interests in superhero comics.
Marc has lost contact with them over the years due to.. ahum... superhero lifestyle I guess is the best explanation.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 17, 2016 8:20:56 GMT -5
Wonder Woman #8: an interesting break in the current story to spotlight Barbara Ann Minerva. For me, the story had a very golden age feel to it. Barbara has had trouble with men, starting with her father striking down her flights of fancy as a child and in her career as an adult. It seems her fate has been intertwined with Wonder Woman's since the beginning as Barbara has been searching for the Amazons and Paradise Island. I am sure all this will tie in and be part of the big mystery of Wonder Woman's now convoluted past and why she cannot find her way home. A great read and nice art. 8/10
Superwoman #3: I used to complain that modern comics could be read in three minutes or less. It took me a solid 20+ minutes to get through Superwoman #3. Lots and lots of words. It is almost like this issue would be a script for a tv show. I applaud Jimenez for being so ambitious, but there was so much going on in this issue--and it didn't work for me. The scenes regarding the treatment of prisoners came across as preachy and I did like Lana's reaction (she wasn't having any of it). The art was nice and reminded me of Dodson art. The scenes with Luthor and his sister were very melodramatic. I had very high hopes for this book, but I am finding that this book is not for me. 3/10
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Oct 17, 2016 10:15:56 GMT -5
Wonder Woman #8: an interesting break in the current story to spotlight Barbara Ann Minerva. For me, the story had a very golden age feel to it. Barbara has had trouble with men, starting with her father striking down her flights of fancy as a child and in her career as an adult. It seems her fate has been intertwined with Wonder Woman's since the beginning as Barbara has been searching for the Amazons and Paradise Island. I am sure all this will tie in and be part of the big mystery of Wonder Woman's now convoluted past and why she cannot find her way home. A great read and nice art. 8/10 Superwoman #3: I used to complain that modern comics could be read in three minutes or less. It took me a solid 20+ minutes to get through Superwoman #3. Lots and lots of words. It is almost like this issue would be a script for a tv show. I applaud Jimenez for being so ambitious, but there was so much going on in this issue--and it didn't work for me. The scenes regarding the treatment of prisoners came across as preachy and I did like Lana's reaction (she wasn't having any of it). The art was nice and reminded me of Dodson art. The scenes with Luthor and his sister were very melodramatic. I had very high hopes for this book, but I am finding that this book is not for me. 3/10 The break for the Minerva story was a great idea, it provided a nice breath of fresh air and gave a clean break before the next story which is something I wish they'd done in action comics.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 17, 2016 10:47:58 GMT -5
I agree. I am hoping Rucka is setting Barbara/Cheetah up to be a reoccurring adversary/ally for Wonder Woman. The world he is creating for Wonder Woman is slowly coming into place and I hope the big mystery of where the Amazons and Paradise Island are will be a big payoff. So far, Rucka's set up has me hooked! Future stories I hope to see involve Wonder Woman and Steve's relationship, the Diana Prince ID, and establishing Donna Troy's past. Based on the Titans book, I am assuming Donna's true past will mostly be restored and the Donna recently seen in Wonder Woman was caused by the timeline being messed with.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Oct 17, 2016 14:14:14 GMT -5
I agree. I am hoping Rucka is setting Barbara/Cheetah up to be a reoccurring adversary/ally for Wonder Woman. The world he is creating for Wonder Woman is slowly coming into place and I hope the big mystery of where the Amazons and Paradise Island are will be a big payoff. So far, Rucka's set up has me hooked! Future stories I hope to see involve Wonder Woman and Steve's relationship, the Diana Prince ID, and establishing Donna Troy's past. Based on the Titans book, I am assuming Donna's true past will mostly be restored and the Donna recently seen in Wonder Woman was caused by the timeline being messed with. I think we're going to see a lot of the build up on the Steve/Wonder Woman relationship in the Year one story, which has been pretty good so far too and I'd also like to see Diana Prince make a come back too.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 17, 2016 14:38:10 GMT -5
I agree. I am hoping Rucka is setting Barbara/Cheetah up to be a reoccurring adversary/ally for Wonder Woman. The world he is creating for Wonder Woman is slowly coming into place and I hope the big mystery of where the Amazons and Paradise Island are will be a big payoff. So far, Rucka's set up has me hooked! Future stories I hope to see involve Wonder Woman and Steve's relationship, the Diana Prince ID, and establishing Donna Troy's past. Based on the Titans book, I am assuming Donna's true past will mostly be restored and the Donna recently seen in Wonder Woman was caused by the timeline being messed with. I think we're going to see a lot of the build up on the Steve/Wonder Woman relationship in the Year one story, which has been pretty good so far too and I'd also like to see Diana Prince make a come back too. I think so too. I recall in the New 52 mess that Wonder Woman and Steve had been close at one point and the relationship soured. I wonder if that is still the case and now they will be reconciled and back together. They seemed awfully friendly in the last WW issue that took place before the Barbara Minerva issue. Some would say WW doesn't need a boyfriend, however I found that part of her story to be a favorite. An immortal princess gives up everything she has ever known to follow someone who steals her heart.
|
|