|
Post by thwhtguardian on Nov 29, 2016 20:00:42 GMT -5
Here we are, another new week and another new batch of comics for you our ever faithful posters to read, rate and discuss!
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Nov 30, 2016 12:55:33 GMT -5
Witchfinder: City of the Dead #4Written by Mike Mignola and Chris Roberson Art by Ben Stenbeck Colored by Michelle Madsen Summary: With the vampire gone to ground Grey enlists the powers of the New Scotland Yard to assist him but in the end he finds himself alone, once again, against the threat.
Plot: While the last few chapters had been focused on building the mystery of the vampires in London and teasing connections to the wider Hellboy Universe in this issue Mignola and Roberson blew the whole thing wide open with some explosive action scenes. Their pacing was incredibly fast: moving from the encounter in Hecate's temple underground, to the police searching the sewers, Grey's initial battle with Vladimir Giurescu and then the final scene where Grey finally locates the vampire nest...and all with out feeling disconnected or rushed. There were definite transition scenes and the progression to them and then from them to more action felt both natural and meaningful which is the greater strength as more often than not those scenes can feel like filler simply there to connect the dots in the action scenes.
Art: What I really love is how well Stenbeck brings in Mignola's look to his art here, Giurescu originally appeared under Mike's pen in Hellboy and in drawing him Stenbeck uses those same heavy brush strokes to let the inky blackness define the vampires which gives it a great feel of continuity to Mike's own work.
Grade: 9/10
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 30, 2016 22:59:05 GMT -5
Written by Peter J. Tomasi and Patrick Gleason. Art and Cover by Jorge Jimenez. A drought is affecting the farm & this leads to a team up of sorts between Superman & Swamp Thing. This annual continues the fantastic writing of Tomasi & Gleason. The Superman Rebirth title has been stellar. And this annual continues that direction. The art also has been awesome & Jimenez turns in a beautiful job on this extra sized issue. Score: 8/10. Swamp Thing causes the drought to get Superman's attention. Why? Because this Superman is from another Earth & he absorbs solar energy differently than the new52 Superman. This caused a disturbance in the Green. When Superman touches Swamp Thing he (ST) goes a little off balance & starts talking in ancient Kryptonian. Needless to say after some beautiful art sequences Swamp Thing attunes Superman to this Earth.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 1, 2016 11:03:07 GMT -5
Cover by David Finch. Totally different from the Superman Annual. Here we get 5 separate Christmas themed stories with Ace the Bathound! & talent like Finch, Paul Dini & Neal Adams. I liked the first 3 stories. The last 2 were OK. Honestly it was fun reading an annual like this. I miss the old holiday themed issues...so this was a welcome return to older style tales. Score: 7/10. Good Boy - Tom King & David Finch. Alfred gives Bruce Ace as a Christmas present. Alfred gets all the best lines in this story. 9/10. Silent Night - Scott Snyder, Ray Fawkes & Declan Shalvey. Batman gets a rare moment of peace. Well Done. 8/10. The Not So Silent Night of the Harlequin - Paul Dini & Neal Adams. Batman shows some Christmas spirit to Harlequin. 8/10. Stag- Steve Orlando & Riley Rossmo. A good story. More suited for Halloween than Christmas. 5/10. The Insecurity Diversion - Scott Bryan Wilson & Bilquis Evely. Scarecrow. A bit of a dark story for a Christmas tale. 5/10.
|
|
shaxper
CCF Site Custodian
Posts: 22,871
|
Post by shaxper on Dec 1, 2016 11:09:11 GMT -5
Cover by David Finch. Totally different from the Superman Annual. Here we get 5 separate Christmas themed stories with Ace the Bathound! & talent like Finch, Paul Dini & Neal Adams. I liked the first 3 stories. The last 2 were OK. Honestly it was fun reading an annual like this. I miss the old holiday themed issues...so this was a welcome return to older style tales. Score: 7/10. That cover is amazing. Very Mignola.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 1, 2016 11:12:27 GMT -5
Written by Ryan North. Art and Cover by Derek Charm. This is the conclusion of the 3 parter guest starring Sabrina. Reggie is also a big part of this story (just in time for next weeks Reggie & Me series!). Jughead continues to be the best series of the new Riverdale. It is fun, light hearted, and a nice change from all the drama in the books I read from DC & Marvel. Charm's art is perfect on this book. Score: 9/10. Highly recommended for readers that want something different from super heroes & like wholesome fun stories.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Dec 1, 2016 20:21:17 GMT -5
Cover by David Finch. Totally different from the Superman Annual. Here we get 5 separate Christmas themed stories with Ace the Bathound! & talent like Finch, Paul Dini & Neal Adams. I liked the first 3 stories. The last 2 were OK. Honestly it was fun reading an annual like this. I miss the old holiday themed issues...so this was a welcome return to older style tales. Score: 7/10. That cover is amazing. Very Mignola. That was my thought too it reminded me a lot of these images from Mike: In that annual cover Finch just really nails that use of shadow to define Batman really well, much as Mignola always has.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Dec 2, 2016 10:47:01 GMT -5
New Talent Showcase #1 review part 1Instructed by Klaus Janson, Andy Kubert, Jim Lee and Scott Snyder Preamble: As this is a showcase of new talent this review is going to look a little different as I'll be looking at each story here. To start with, even though it's not done by the new talent, I'm not loving the cover by Janson; I'm usually a big fan of his(especially his coloring and inking) but this just looks very flat like something out of a kids coloring book. I hope the art inside is more polished.
The Road to Hell...and All That Written by Adam Smith with Art by Siya Oum
Summary: Zatara has died and Zatana has taken Constantine to a magic shop where she's planning her estranged father's funeral. Constantine doesn't understand why she cares for the man and in his usual fasion he c@#&$ it up and decides to fix things by going to Hell and bring Zatara back with him. Once there he meets a demonic looking Zatara in a dive bar and learns that not only is Zatara damned but he some how tainted Zatana as well and so John returns not only being able to not bring Zatana her father but also with the secret knowledge that a cloud hangs over her head. Plot: I really wish they gave bios for these new guys as I'd really like to know more about them, and because they're new it's hard to do that on my own with any certainty. I have no idea what this guy has done in the past, if anything, but he has a strong showing here; he really gets the balance of tragedy and dark humor that I enjoy in a Constantine story and the ideas of lost souls hanging out in a dive bar in Hell was fun. On the downside, I don't think Smith is British and so Constantine's dialogue and interior monologues come off as sounding a weak, you can tell he isn't wholly comfortable with the dialect and so he goes subtle with it to try and avoid making it sound cliche but the effect is rather vanilla which definitely isn't Constantine. Other than that though it hits all the right emotional beats and has a fun hook so I really hope we see more work from Adam Smith in the future. Art: I was able to track down a little information about Siya Oum due to her unique name and from her resume she's had a fair bit of work over the last few years mostly with Aspen comics with her most notable being her own creation Lola XOXO. I can't find any scans of her work from this story but I picked a few that are indicative of the look here: She has a definite realistic bend to her art but a softness around the edges that reminds me a bit of the work of Becky Cloonan and Jill Thomson. In this story her strongest suit was in the scenes with Zatana, Oum really captured the complicated emotions of dealing with the death of an estranged father. You could see the sadness, the anger and the confusion in Zatana's face all at once and it was beautiful. Grade:8/10 Wonder Woman: Blood and GloryWritten by Utia Ayala with Art by Khary Randolph Summary: An army mythical beasts appear on Wallstreet and start going Godzilla on it but have no fear, Wonder Woman is here! Plot: It's a fairly straight forward, action oriented story with Diana facing off against a host of monsters and rebuffing the efforts of the Flash to help. At first I really enjoyed the juxtaposition of Wonder Woman's terse inner monologue and the over the top action scenes but as the pacing slowed down and the choice of language stayed the same it went from feeling like something out of an epic poem to being a one note warrior woman which is not a characterization I enjoy for Wonder Woman. This writer isn't the first to make that blunder but it shows a fundamental lack of understanding that really spoiled the promising start. Art: I went the opposite way with the art by Khary Randolph, on the first splash page I was a little turned off by the slightly simplistic and angular Manga/cartoony style he used but as the story progressed it really started to make me smile. Although not as detailed as the work of others his slim look lends itself well to fun, kinetic action and he has a great eye in how to compose his panels so that the story moves really slowly. In the end he gave off a kind of Bruce Timm/Tad Stones kind of feel that I really enjoyed. Grade:6/10Dead BeaconsWritten by Michael Moreci with Art by Barnaby Bagenda Summary: White Lantern Kyle Rayner and Star Sapphire fight monster on their Anniversary. Plot: I'm not sure if this is a tie to an actual on going story or not but I didn't enjoy the cliff hanger ending employed here. Moreci starts off with two new characters on a salvage mission and we get the interior monologue of how one of them wanted to be a lantern more than anything but lost hope...right before they are attacked by a mysterious antagonist. We then flash to an alien planet where Kyle and Carol are fighting monsters and talking about their relationship. Both the sort of Alien inspired beginning and the conversation between Kyle and Carol were well done but there was nothing to connect them and being just a short feature and with out knowing if the story would ever really be picked up again that kind of storytelling felt misplaced. In a long form story you can have that kind of structure as you can allow the reader to fill in the gas and make connections to previous scenes as they go but with a much shorter time constraint you can't do that so it comes off as feeling unfinished rather than thrilling. Art: Bagenda had a great sci-fi feel to his art, the combination of slightly clunky technology and the sleek look of the characters was a great aesthetic choice that really fit a green lantern story well. That said, although there was a lot of style it was a little simlistic otherwise, no real show of emotion and the action though easy to follow wasn't very thrilling. Grade:5/10
Conclusion: While I'm only half way through I definitely get the feeling that this is a mixed bag, which is really to be expected as this is a showcase of developing talent. So far the team of Smith and Oum has really stood out as the brightest though I also enjoyed the art of Randolph as well and I hope all three hit it big after this.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Dec 2, 2016 13:04:26 GMT -5
New Talent ShowcasePart TwoHawkgirl: Weapons of WarWritten by Erica Schultz with Art by Sonny LiewSummary: The Great Old Ones of Thannagar have come to Earth and only Hawkgirl can stand and face them. Plot: Schultz starts off the story with a big, "The world is doomed!" set piece as we see Hawkgirl getting thrashed about but quickly flashes back to a more quieter scene that establishes both Shayera in her civilian persona as well as Detective Will as a supporting character. It's a great kind of police procedural set up with Hawkgirl using her civilian identity to investigate weird crimes that lead her to stock pile Thannagarian weapons which would be an interesting hook to form an ongoing Hawkgirl book. And although it's not as abrupt as the lantern story the cliffhanger ending that tied back to the opening did feel a little off as it's unclear if the plot will ever continue although it at least thematically tied into the hording of lost thannagarian weapons. Art: Liew's thin, scratchy art style is a fun component of the story giving it a real sense of enery to the action scenes and a feeling of warmth to the quieter scenes. Grade: 7/10Killing TimeWritten by Christopher Sebela with art by David MessinaSummary: Deadman takes us through a day in the afterlife as he muses on the pros and cons of his existence. Plot: Sebela's plot is pretty straight forward and although I can't come up with an exact issue number I feel like the the day in the afterlife with Deadman has been done already...maybe more than once and other than the brief scene in a ghost bar which was pretty neat there wasn't anything all that original. Still, that said, although rout in plot Sebela really got Deadman's voice down which is something that can't always be said of other writers. Art: Messina does a great job of portraying both the weightless of Boston Brand as well as the emotions possible for his hollowed out face. The angles of his body while in action really came across as other worldly and the movement felt light and quick but overall it was as by the numbers as the plot, the style lacked that sort of psychadelic look in displaying the supernatural that I think is integral in the visual look of a good Deadman book. Grade:6/10Digging Up DemonsWritten by Hena Khan with Art by Emanuella Lupacchino Summary: While on vacation in Jordon Wonder Girl comes under siege by a Jinn which leads her into a chase for the lost Pentacle of Solomon. Plot: In this short piece Khan introduces a mystery involving a myth, gives a run down on who Wonder Girl is and what her origin and supporting cast is like and attempts to provide a narrative structure for a continuing story. There's a lot going on there at once and while it never feels rushed it does come off as feeling a little vanilla. It's all structurally sound for something that feels like a first issue but it misses out in characterization as it never really makes you feel anything for Cassie and that significantly hampers my desire to read more. Art: Like the plot, while fundamentally sound Lupacchino's art doesn't have a lot of heart to it. It feels very mid-2000's house style, and while that competently tells the story there's nothing that really draws you in and makes you want more. Grade:4/10The Amazonian JobWritten by Emma Beeby with Art by Minkyu JungSummary: Wonder Woman hires Catwoman to steal a box containing the power of the Gods from Themyscira. Plot: Of all the "First in a new series" type stories in this collection this may be the best; in a few short pages Beeby gives us solid characterizations of Catwoman, Wonder Woman,a peak at the villain and an intriguing hook that has a pulpy feel that really makes you want to read more rather than leaving you feeling like the story is just unfinished. Although it feels like an odd pairing, it's not jarringly so which really makes for a creative and new direction for both Wonder Woman and Catwoman. Art: While Jung's art does look very DC house style the facial expressions she captures of the faces of Catwoman and Wonder Woman as they discuss the plot are really fun which puts me in a slightly forgiving mood. Grade:8/10
The Man in BlackWritten by Michael McMillian with Art by Juan FerreyraSummary: A strange vistitor from another world touches down in Smallville...but it isn't Superman, and how is this connected to a new crime spree by the Joker targeting the Man of Steel? Plot: While perhaps not strong enough to stand on its own this mysterious story of Superman, the Joker and a strange visitor by Michael McMillian is solid enough that it feels like it could be a back up story for Action Comics or Superman. The plot line is certainly compelling enough and I liked the use of Superman's heat vision to burn off the Joker virus inside Lois and the back and forth with Batman I got the feeling that Mcmillian wasn't that comfortable with the"newer" more fatherly Superman currently appearing in the books as that part of his characterization was totally absent here making me initially unsure if this was a flash back to the"old" Superman or the one in the new continuity. Art: While I really liked the softness to Ferreyra's look, especially in the scenes with the Sherif in the beginning I got the feeling that he might not have the fullest grasp of what's going on despite the line about Lois and Clark having a son in the story as both his Lois and his Superman looked very young here but that's more a continuity thing than a real flaw in the art. Grade:7/10Conclusion: Another mixed bag in the second half but I really enjoyed the Wonder Woman/Catwoman pairing and the intro to Hawk Girl while Superman's entry was decent as well. Overall, although there were some missteps here( to be fair these a new batch of people) this was a fun experience although I think most of the teams would have perhaps been better served if they shot for telling solid one shots rather than aiming for truncated first issue pitches. Over all Grade: 7/10
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Dec 3, 2016 19:35:11 GMT -5
Cover by David Finch. Totally different from the Superman Annual. Here we get 5 separate Christmas themed stories with Ace the Bathound! & talent like Finch, Paul Dini & Neal Adams. I liked the first 3 stories. The last 2 were OK. Honestly it was fun reading an annual like this. I miss the old holiday themed issues...so this was a welcome return to older style tales. Score: 7/10. Good Boy - Tom King & David Finch. Alfred gives Bruce Ace as a Christmas present. Alfred gets all the best lines in this story. 9/10. Silent Night - Scott Snyder, Ray Fawkes & Declan Shalvey. Batman gets a rare moment of peace. Well Done. 8/10. The Not So Silent Night of the Harlequin - Paul Dini & Neal Adams. Batman shows some Christmas spirit to Harlequin. 8/10. Stag- Steve Orlando & Riley Rossmo. A good story. More suited for Halloween than Christmas. 5/10. The Insecurity Diversion - Scott Bryan Wilson & Bilquis Evely. Scarecrow. A bit of a dark story for a Christmas tale. 5/10. Ace the Bathound was great, and I really liked Silent Night and Insecurity but I think my favorite was Stag and it looks like it's the beginning of a fun story to come.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Dec 4, 2016 19:25:14 GMT -5
Written by Peter J. Tomasi and Patrick Gleason. Art and Cover by Jorge Jimenez. A drought is affecting the farm & this leads to a team up of sorts between Superman & Swamp Thing. This annual continues the fantastic writing of Tomasi & Gleason. The Superman Rebirth title has been stellar. And this annual continues that direction. The art also has been awesome & Jimenez turns in a beautiful job on this extra sized issue. Score: 8/10. Swamp Thing causes the drought to get Superman's attention. Why? Because this Superman is from another Earth & he absorbs solar energy differently than the new52 Superman. This caused a disturbance in the Green. When Superman touches Swamp Thing he (ST) goes a little off balance & starts talking in ancient Kryptonian. Needless to say after some beautiful art sequences Swamp Thing attunes Superman to this Earth. The art certainly was beautiful and the team up between Superman and Swampthing was fun but other than that it felt a little flat too me, especially in comparison to the Batman Annual.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Dec 4, 2016 20:33:44 GMT -5
Tarzan on the Planet of the Apes #3Written by Tim Seeley and David Walker Art by Fenando Dagnino Colored by Sandra Molina Summary: As Tarzan attempts to broker peace with his ape brother Milo, now calling himself Cesar, the two must fight for their lives against a horde of dinosaurs as their mother learns about where the creatures come from...but can tell no one!
Plot: For a fan of Edgar Rice Burroughs like myself Seeley and Walker throw out a lot of elements that made me smile. I mean, I don't remember the last time I saw David Innes and Pellucidar mentioned never mind featured in a modern book so it really filled with some serious nerd love to see them here...but it almost felt like too much too fast as there wasn't enough time to really introduce these elements in the story so if you weren't already a fan you wouldn't have even know what they were. And then on top of all that there is a battle planned against the masters of Pellucidar and although emphasis is placed on coming up for a plan before attacking we never see what that plan is before we get the attack which summarizes the problem I have wit the issue in a single example in that before it sets up the element it jumps ahead. It's a beautiful world they're giving us but they're not letting us really breath it in which is ultimately disappointing.
Art: As disappointing as the plot was Dagnino really came up big in making this issue worth while. The back grounds were lush, detailed and alive in a way that made you feel like if you pushed aside that frond over there you'd find another surprise and that the teeming jungle wasn't contained by the borders of the panels and the width of the page but rather continued on in either direction hiding yet more adventures just around the corner. On top of all that he draws a mean monster! I loved the look of the dinosaurs, they were recognizable enough as realistic creatures that we've been familiar with since childhood but they were grotesque in an exaggerated manner as to fit into what a Victorian mind would imagine the creatures would look like which really fits the time period of the story.
Conclusion: While Seeley and Walker lose track of the characterization that made the first two issues so much fun in an effort to load up on Burroughs references and action scenes Dagnino really steps up to the plate with some fantastic art to keep things moving.
Grade:6/10
|
|
|
Post by Dizzy D on Dec 11, 2016 16:03:30 GMT -5
Seven to Eternity #3 Written by Rick Remender Art by Jerome Opeña Colours by Matt Hollingsworth
What went before: Adam Osidis, our main character, has travelled to the court of the Mud King/God of Whispers, offering himself to restore his family's honor, but the Mud King has offered to cure his deadly disease instead. Before Adam can chose, a group rebels enters the court in an attempt to slay the tyrant. Summary: So the first three issues turn out to be intro to the main concept of the series: the rebels manage to knock out the Mud King (with some losses and the assistance of Adam). The leader of the rebels explains that they can bring the King to a certain wizard, he can severe the connections between the King and his followers without killing them. So the seven survivors (Five rebels, the King's former concubine and Adam) set out to bring the King to the wizard, but they will have to travel through hostile territory filled with the King's loyal subjects. Plot: It's pretty quick read as most of the story is one long fight scene, but most of the characters get some establishment (we get to see most of their abilities and a few of the King's strongest allies) and we get the main premise explained. So there's enough happening. The world is still fascinating and I'm eager to see more of it. Art: I love Opeña's work and he's one of the big draws to this series. There are some great designs for various characters and a shame that some of them don't make it into the rest of the series (though who knows?) Grade: 9/10
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 12, 2016 10:45:41 GMT -5
Superman Annual #1: Finally read it this weekend. The team up of Superman and Swamp Thing was interesting, but I was expecting more for an annual story. The story might have been better as a 2 part Superman story in the regular title. The art though was fantastic. The scenes of the parched land, Swampthing transforming...very well done and the colors suited the story. Spectacular artwork and interesting to see that Superman's arrival on this earth put nature out of tune. 7/10
|
|