|
Post by codystarbuck on Apr 16, 2018 23:06:52 GMT -5
The Me-262 was an actual plane; but, I would have to see the issue to say whether the one there is supposed to be a 262. The real one looked like this... I assume the more bloodless fighting was to prevent problems with the Code. Plus, Stan kept the Marvel war books a little less bloody than DC. Even stories where you saw people get hit, they tended to be far less graphic than the reality of combat. The Howlers were more about pulling one over on the Germans than bodycounts. On a side note, when I was a kid, I always misread "jawohl" as "ja-howl (or Ya-howl!), until I heard it uttered in a war movie and looked at a comic again. However, it was an Unknown soldier issue that taught me that a German Wehrmacht captain was a "hauptmann," not a "kapitan." The latter is a naval captain; but, Hollywood constantly gets that one wrong. Yes, that's what it looked like. Except this secret Nazi version had room for all the Howlers (I think, 7 of them). Someone even questioned how they were all going to fit into this plane and Eric responded along the lines of, this model having been modified to let high-ranking Nazi officers take a joy-ride in order to 'truly' evaluate it's success. Along with 'jawohl', I almost always see a 'Mach Schnell!' line somewhere too. I also didn't know about Pinky's usage of 'Wot?' about every fifth word or so (at least, that's what it felt like). American writers of Stan's generation always thought the British talked like Col Blimp and David Niven (or else Bertie Wooster). Niven was an influence on the look of the character, though, to me, he always looked like he should have been in Lord Lovat's commando unit.
|
|
|
Post by String on Apr 28, 2018 10:20:18 GMT -5
Unknown Soldier #250 by Bob Haney with art by Dick Ayers and Gerry Taloc "The Traitor without a Face!"
The Unknown Soldier seemingly defects to Nazi Germany after he unknowingly turns his friend, fellow spy Sparrow, into a mental vegetable after Sparrow radioed Nazi secrets he had acquired that the Prime Minister declared too dangerous for anyone other than very top officials to know. Thinking his side was just as worse because of this duplicity, the Soldier defects in order to more quickly bring an end to this war. Hitler loves his new confidant but Himmler and Count Von Stauffen, the Black Knight of Germany, aren't buying it. As Hitler takes the Soldier on various military tours, the Haunted Tank crew, Marie and her squad, and the Losers all launch attacks aimed at killing this traitor (and if they kill Hitler in the process, all the more the better). But the Soldier successfully counters all these efforts, further solidifying his role within the Reich. Even Himmler's attempts to set-up the Soldier for possible reveal are thwarted. Sgt. Rock and Easy Company launch the final attempt again only to be thwarted by the Soldier. Captured, Easy Company awaits their fate while the Soldier embarks on his true mission: acquiring the only sample of a weaponized new toxic gas the Nazis have developed called the Hell Fog. Regaining Rock's trust, the Soldier engineers Easy Company's escape and they all manage to escape. The Soldier explains to Rock that such subterfuge was necessary for Hitler to believe his defection was real (and thus why their attempts to kill the Soldier needed to look real). Rock and Co leave while the Solider destroys the gas sample. This is the first Soldier story that I've read and given that it's Haney writing it, it's full of zany action but questionable consequences. The Soldier claims that his unknowingly turning his friend into a comatose vegetable is what lead him to question the morality of his leaders. Yet while explaining the situation to Rock, the Soldier vaguely hints that Sparrow actually had to be sacrificed in such a manner to maintain the ruse. Then, given that every time an assassination attempt was made on the Soldier, Hitler was right next to him, I have to wonder why they didn't try to kill Hitler more before this if they can get to him so readily. (In fact, as part of Himmler's ruse to uncover the Soldier's true motives, the Losers are do manage to kill Hitler though it's later revealed that was a body double.) For that matter, since the Soldier claims he wants to end the war more quickly in order to save future lives, he's standing right beside Hitler this whole time. He's concerned about this new lethal Nazi weapon, sure, but he could possibly take out the head of the Reich right then and there. Of course if he did then we wouldn't see the rather amusing scene of Hitler crying for 'his Soldier' not to betray him after he has been told of the Soldier doing so. I know, it's comics but as an adult reading this for the first time, it's kinda of a gaping logic hole to see. Also, judging from the letters page, I gather Haney has a bit more flair for super sci-fi weaponry than is perhaps the norm in other DC war books. Freeze bombs in an earlier issue and now this Hell Fog gas. I can't really comment on that since I'm not sure how this story, for example, fits in with earlier Unknown Soldier stories. The art though was rather good and graphic, especially the scene where we learn the capabilities of the Hell Fog.
|
|
|
Post by codystarbuck on Apr 29, 2018 21:42:28 GMT -5
Unknown Soldier #250 by Bob Haney with art by Dick Ayers and Gerry Taloc "The Traitor without a Face!"
The Unknown Soldier seemingly defects to Nazi Germany after he unknowingly turns his friend, fellow spy Sparrow, into a mental vegetable after Sparrow radioed Nazi secrets he had acquired that the Prime Minister declared too dangerous for anyone other than very top officials to know. Thinking his side was just as worse because of this duplicity, the Soldier defects in order to more quickly bring an end to this war. Hitler loves his new confidant but Himmler and Count Von Stauffen, the Black Knight of Germany, aren't buying it. As Hitler takes the Soldier on various military tours, the Haunted Tank crew, Marie and her squad, and the Losers all launch attacks aimed at killing this traitor (and if they kill Hitler in the process, all the more the better). But the Soldier successfully counters all these efforts, further solidifying his role within the Reich. Even Himmler's attempts to set-up the Soldier for possible reveal are thwarted. Sgt. Rock and Easy Company launch the final attempt again only to be thwarted by the Soldier. Captured, Easy Company awaits their fate while the Soldier embarks on his true mission: acquiring the only sample of a weaponized new toxic gas the Nazis have developed called the Hell Fog. Regaining Rock's trust, the Soldier engineers Easy Company's escape and they all manage to escape. The Soldier explains to Rock that such subterfuge was necessary for Hitler to believe his defection was real (and thus why their attempts to kill the Soldier needed to look real). Rock and Co leave while the Solider destroys the gas sample. This is the first Soldier story that I've read and given that it's Haney writing it, it's full of zany action but questionable consequences. The Soldier claims that his unknowingly turning his friend into a comatose vegetable is what lead him to question the morality of his leaders. Yet while explaining the situation to Rock, the Soldier vaguely hints that Sparrow actually had to be sacrificed in such a manner to maintain the ruse. Then, given that every time an assassination attempt was made on the Soldier, Hitler was right next to him, I have to wonder why they didn't try to kill Hitler more before this if they can get to him so readily. (In fact, as part of Himmler's ruse to uncover the Soldier's true motives, the Losers are do manage to kill Hitler though it's later revealed that was a body double.) For that matter, since the Soldier claims he wants to end the war more quickly in order to save future lives, he's standing right beside Hitler this whole time. He's concerned about this new lethal Nazi weapon, sure, but he could possibly take out the head of the Reich right then and there. Of course if he did then we wouldn't see the rather amusing scene of Hitler crying for 'his Soldier' not to betray him after he has been told of the Soldier doing so. I know, it's comics but as an adult reading this for the first time, it's kinda of a gaping logic hole to see. Also, judging from the letters page, I gather Haney has a bit more flair for super sci-fi weaponry than is perhaps the norm in other DC war books. Freeze bombs in an earlier issue and now this Hell Fog gas. I can't really comment on that since I'm not sure how this story, for example, fits in with earlier Unknown Soldier stories. The art though was rather good and graphic, especially the scene where we learn the capabilities of the Hell Fog. Gerry Taloc's art was always good; but, Haney was not the writer for war comics. The other Soldier stories tend to be of higher quality. His masks are about the only recurring sci-fi element.
|
|
|
Post by EdoBosnar on Jun 4, 2018 14:32:16 GMT -5
Just realized this might interest regular readers of this thread: I kind of recently read The Night Witches, Motherland and the Fall & Rise of Anna Kharkova, three related mini-series in the Battlefields meta-series by Garth Ennis. It tells the story of Soviet combat pilot Anna Kharkova from the beginning of her career in the early stages of World War II to (in the last 2 installments of the final trilogy) her life and travails in the postwar years. Through Kharkova, Ennis puts the focus on a very real bit of history that's not as well known outside of the former Soviet Union (and other former Eastern bloc nations): the many women who served in combat roles in the Soviet armed forces during World War II, especially as pilots, navigators and ground crews in the Soviet air force. Kharkova is shown starting off as one of the daring night-time bombers, nicknamed the 'Night Witches' by the Nazi troops they harassed, and then becoming a formidable fighter pilot as the war continued. The art throughout is by Russ Braun, and while his work didn't set my world on fire, it was very effective for the story being told here. Although I thought the last parts that covered Kharkova's postwar life were not as strong, and probably could have been done better, I can still warmly recommend this. (By the way, I did a bit of a longer write-up on this series and another book on the same topic for the Atomic Junk Shop).
|
|
|
Post by String on Aug 30, 2018 12:36:14 GMT -5
Unknown Soldier #251
Thou Shalt Not Kill! by Bob Haney, art by Dick Ayers and Gerry Talaoc Risking the dangers (both natural and human) of the Pyrenees, the Soldier arrives at an isolated monastery. His quest - to seek out a priest there, a German who, though he strongly opposes Hitler's regime, escaped to this solitude because he's a pacifist at heart and cannot condone the taking of a life regardless of the need or cause. However, the priest's brother joined the local underground and has since risen to a prominent role. The Nazis are closing in on him though, forcing his brother into hiding. For if they get him to talk, the local underground may be undone. Thus, the Soldier is tasked with getting the priest's help in finding his brother and getting him out of Germany before all is lost. Sounds simple enough, right? Well, Haney throws in the usual twists and action such as disguises being undone, presumed deaths, an elaborate Gestapo trap, and double crosses (by both sides). The local criminal elements chime in to help the Soldier when the Nazis start closing in and ultimately, the priest must decide if committing such a cardinal sin is worth saving one person's life. Ayers and Talaoc do a good job on the art, I'm growing to like their style. (Also, the scene on the cover does in fact occur within the story, kudos!) Hell in the Heavens: Part One I, the Executioner by Kanigher, art by John Severin At a party held in his home, even the beauty of a famous German woman cannot dissuade the feelings of death that Von Hammer experienced just that morning. He recounts to her of how his Jagdstaffel encountered a squadron of British RAF planes over Cambrai. Combat ensues, as the Baron downs enemy planes, grateful that his bursts kill the pilots as their planes crash earthward, sparing them the agony of being burned alive, a release that Von Hammer hopes for himself when his time is up. As the fight continues, a British pilot streaks by Von Hammer without attacking, the Baron realizing that the pilot's guns were jammed. Von Hammer can only watch as one of his fellow pilots attacks this helpless British plane. Angered by this lack of honor, Von Hammer follows his wounded enemy, landing behind him as the British pilot somehow manages to land his damaged craft. It's too late though, as Von Hammer drags the boy from the plane as it explodes, he dies but not before asking Von Hammer to fulfill a dying request - return a family heirloom necklace to his sister. Von Hammer gives his word that he will do so but is at a loss over how to keep his promise since he knows neither the pilot's name or his sister's name. Kanigher maintains the the great level of tension and honor of this concept, as Von Hammer metes out what merciful death he can in the skies. Severin's art is just a joy to behold, the most haunting panel being a shot of Von Hammer in his cockpit behind his Spandaus, the only dialogue that of a British pilot hauntingly begging the Baron to shoot him before he burns in his damaged plane. A very strong start here. Eternal Sentinel by Kanigher , art by Tenny Henson A two page story where a Japanese and an American pilot shoot both of themselves down over the Pacific. Splashing down in the water, the two combatants continue their fight unaware of the natural predator swimming towards them, a shark that prefers no side in this man-made conflict. The letters page was interesting. Seeing as this issue was released in '81, I'm not surprised at all to find the lone letter printed here is from TM Maple. He compliments editor Len Wein on the expanded pages of the title now (roughly 17 pages for the Soldier from the former 11 pages). The extra pages allow for more variety as possible back-up, for which fans are asked to send in who all they would want to see spotlighted at a future date. More perplexing is the asst. editor's response over what seems to be a reduction in the amount of fan letters the title is receiving, a loss they hope to offset by offering unique prizes to those writers whose letters they do print. (If I read this response right, Maple received an original cover stat to an issue of UNK just like the one sent to the printer. Free art as a reward for printing a fan letter you send in? How about that!)
|
|
|
Post by codystarbuck on Aug 30, 2018 15:59:33 GMT -5
RIP Russ Heath We have the main thread; but, Heath was a part of so many of the great Sgt Rock stories (as much as Kubert, if not more) and the debut of the Haunted Tank, and things like Garth Ennis' later Enemy Ace WW2 two-parter.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 30, 2018 18:29:24 GMT -5
RIP Russ Heath We have the main thread; but, Heath was a part of so many of the great Sgt Rock stories (as much as Kubert, if not more) and the debut of the Haunted Tank, and things like Garth Ennis' later Enemy Ace WW2 two-parter. Wow, that's an incredible pencil job and done just too darn perfect! ... This made my day of how well he drew that Tiger Tank and did it just flawlessly with a dash of realism into it. I was stunned seeing it today and thanks for posting this gem!
|
|
|
Post by Roquefort Raider on Oct 8, 2018 19:52:59 GMT -5
I’ve just re-read The ‘Nam #1-13, which are all the issues I own.
I really like that book, as would be expected since it’s drawn by Michael Golden (with a fill-in by Wayne Vansant, quite competent, and another by the godly John Severin).
The real-time nature of the mag is something we don’t see that often anymore in comics, but while it is welcome it was not, I think, all that necessary. In fact, considering how many characters are developed as the story proceeds, it might have been better to drag things out a little; the series’ first main character, private Ed Marks, finishes his tour in issue #13. We hardly knew him!
Some of the characters had the depth of some of Marvel’s classic creations; Mike, Rob and Sgt Polkow have nothing to be embarrassed about in a comparison with any of the Howlers or Sgt. Fury himself.
I heard that the mag started including superheroes later on. What a sad, sad, sad idea.
The only criticism I might have is that (a) the script is outright propaganda in a few places, which distracts from what otherwise appears to be a realistic depiction of the Vietnam war, and (b) writer Doug Murray, not quite mastering comic-book writing yet, tends to use captions to describe what the images show. But other than that, these comics are definitely worth seeking out, especially since they used to be quarter bin fodder and are probably still inexpensive.
|
|
|
Post by codystarbuck on Oct 8, 2018 23:26:48 GMT -5
I’ve just re-read The ‘Nam #1-13, which are all the issues I own. I really like that book, as would be expected since it’s drawn by Michael Golden (with a fill-in by Wayne Vansant, quite competent, and another by the godly John Severin). The real-time nature of the mag is something we don’t see that often anymore in comics, but while it is welcome it was not, I think, all that necessary. In fact, considering how many characters are developed as the story proceeds, it might have been better to drag things out a little; the series’ first main character, private Ed Marks, finishes his tour in issue #13. We hardly knew him! Some of the characters had the depth of some of Marvel’s classic creations; Mike, Rob and Sgt Polkow have nothing to be embarrassed about in a comparison with any of the Howlers or Sgt. Fury himself. I heard that the mag started including superheroes later on. What a sad, sad, sad idea. The only criticism I might have is that (a) the script is outright propaganda in a few places, which distracts from what otherwise appears to be a realistic depiction of the Vietnam war, and (b) writer Doug Murray, not quite mastering comic-book writing yet, tends to use captions to describe what the images show. But other than that, these comics are definitely worth seeking out, especially since they used to be quarter bin fodder and are probably still inexpensive. Ed Marks turns up again, later, as a journalist. Don't think he worked quite as well, in that role. Later issues are pretty decent, though it struggled for a POV, for a while. Vansant does fine work on the series. Don Lomax takes over the writing, at one point; but, it is not as compelling as Vietnam Journal, due to the Code and editorial restraints. Superheroes are teased early on, but it is a soldier reading some Marvel comics musing about if they existed. Punisher does turn up later and it is a horribly unrealistic story and pretty much signaled the end of the series. he shows up in 52-53, by Roger Salick. Don't know much about his background, other than he also wrote for Black Belt magazine and some of his comics work was martial arts related (as is his site). He wrote some Punisher; but, didn't seem to know jack about Vietnam, the military or combat. Second appearance was #67-69, by Chuck Dixon, who is definitely NOT a veteran, though he at least (usually) does his research. His wasn't much better, as I recall. It undermined the previous stuff. It is symptomatic of what a mess Marvel was in '91-92. Don Lomax's Vietnam Journal is a vastly more compelling read, since it lacked Code restrictions and it had a greater variety to things. Journal gets around a bit and we get a taste of the grunts in the bush, AirCav, Navy Seals, USMC (the Khe Sanh mini), Green Beret (High Shining Brass, which was a CIA-run recon program, with Special Forces and groups like the Nungs, an ethnic group of Chinese descent). He also gets a bit into back home. It doesn't sugarcoat things, apologize for things or condemn things. It is a pretty even-handed (though veteran POV) series, with little or no BS and a much rawer tone and look. The Nam was still pretty good for at least the first 3 years; then it varies a bit. Semper Fi never really found its footing and suffers from some bad to mediocre writing, though Sam Glanzman has some good stuff in there and John Severin contributed a story or two (art).
|
|
|
Post by String on Dec 9, 2018 11:47:29 GMT -5
Unknown Soldier #244
The Sub That Would Not Die! by Haney with art by Ayers and Talaoc The Unknown Soldier teams up with Capt. Storm of the Losers and his PT boat crew in trying to take out a Japanese sub whose legend has grown supernatural. Ally convoy ships are being destroyed in a strait they use as a short-cut key to the whole South Pacific (yesss) by a Japanese sub that eerily escapes detection by sonar and radar before a convoy moves through the strait and is seemingly indestructible for the few times that naval ships have thought to have destroyed it with torpedoes and depth charges, the sub returns upon the next convoy trip like a ghost from the grave. Capt Storm plots a trap to ensare this Jap sub with the help of a fellow friend sub skipper and his sub. The trap goes awry of course but later, Storm believes he and his crews succeed in destroying the sub at last. Soldier is not convinced though and susses out the truth through a number of clues (including a talking parrot). It's a truth that Soldier is hard pressed to make Capt Storm believe (hence the cover image, a shot that is included in the narrative) and it involves Nazi-trained operatives disguising themselves in a unique way as a Japanese sub helped by a traitor within the Ally ranks. It's a Haney story alright with unusual geography and extraordinary efforts to pull off this particular type of deception. Ayers and Talaoc's art continues to impress though Big Daddy by Kanigher, art by Tom Yeates A two page story about a B-17 bomber crew, told from a certain point of view about failure not being an option on their final bomb run. Effective with good art. Dateline:Frontline Homefront! by Cary Burkhett, art by Ric Estrada Wayne Clifford, war correspondent, has now been stateside for some time as he eagerly tries to return to the war front ( "the greatest story of our time!") However, does Wayne really take into consideration the human cost of this greatest story? He begins to when he encounters a woman filling in for her father as a mailman as he has gone off to fight in the war. Wayne quickly becomes smitten with her even as she appears smitten with doing her own duty, in this instance, by wanting to enlist to serve a nurse/medic. Wayne is taken aback by his own reaction, wondering about the lasting effects of war upon families and when sacrifice may become too big a cost to bear for a family. An interesting tale told from the homefront as we are shown how woman are taking up roles to help in the war effort in a variety of unsung ways. Wayne is distracted from his own job by this girl, her determination to serve shocks him in a way that hits more personal than perhaps anything before. Estrada's art is decent. The letters page was engaging, yet another TM Maple letter (hey, it's the 80s!) One writer though points out possible historical inaccuracies and even canon discrepancies about the Soldier's origin (which the reply to his letter indicates will be resolved shortly in an upcoming all exclusive origin for him). One point that I found interesting was the apparent over-depiction of Tiger tanks in German forces. The writer indicates that Nazis only utilized the Tigers in specific battalions of which they were only 11 throughout the European theater and not the wide usage that may be often seen in DC's war comics. Of course, the reply to this observation is neat, that if the Tiger is seen as more glamorous now, then DC using artistic license to showcase it more is alright.
|
|
|
Post by codystarbuck on Dec 10, 2018 0:07:34 GMT -5
Sound's like Haney is confusing the "Slot", the channels that the Japanese ran through the Solomon Island chain, to try and reinforce their soldiers during the Solomons Campaign (Guadalcanal onward) with the US. For the most part, Japanese subs didn't inflict as much damage on US supply shipping as the Germans. For one thing, the Germans used the wolf pack strategy to attack convoys in groups. Japanese subs tended to operate independently. They also weren't as advanced as the germans in this realm, though they did have a few interesting variants, including one model with a retractable hangar, for a plane to launch an aerial attack.
Kanigher was far better at this stuff.
Tiger Tanks made for better visuals than other German tanks; so, of course they got used. Especially if Russ heath was drawing them. Look at WW2 films of the 60s and later; it's always a Tiger Tank.
You got all kinds of inconsistencies in the war books, from incorrect uniform elements (almost no one was seen wearing the standard gaiters) to the webbing, to even weapons (either using the wrong version, poorly drawn, or using them before they were introduced). Seems like every German had an MP-40, not a Mauser carbine. Officers always had Lugers, not P-38s or PPKs (or Mauser pistols). Still, DC's war comic were way better at this stuff than anyone else's, for years. Atlas was all gung ho nonsense, with whatever weapon the artist could draw, and Charlton varied wildly, depending on the artist. Guys like Sam Glanzman did their research or drew on personal experience (Sam had both, doing research on the Army and experience for the USS Stevens stories). Still, even the worst war comics artists were way more accurate than 90% of the people who drew the Punisher and his ilk. My favorite was someone who had a laser aiming sight on a grenade launcher. They fire in an arc; the laser doesn't help. A laser range finder is a different story. Of course, these are the same guys who draw a silencer/noise suppressor on a shotgun. File that under Hollywood westerns, where a six-shooter fires 8 rounds, without reloading.
|
|
|
Post by String on Dec 28, 2018 12:20:38 GMT -5
Unknown Soldier #252
Bomber's Moon by Haney, art by Ayers and Talaoc Moon madness, hidden Nazi traps and German soldiers on ice skates, what's not to love here? A full moon, a bomber's moon, a natural guide light for English bombers to use on their runs. However, now it's rumored that the full moon is causing madness in bomber crews as they flee back to their home bases, their missions unfulfilled. Soldier soon discerns that some form of strange music heard by the crews during their flight to Germany is the cause of this madness. Tracing the source of this music to Denmark, Soldier infiltrates a small Danish village to ferret out the Nazi plot, enlisting the help of a resistance boat captain and a young waif who's been causing problems for the local Nazi attendant after his father was murdered by the man. Tracking the possible source to a local church, things look grim as another bomber flight looks to fall victim to this Nazi plot only to have Soldier ingeniously use the bombers to help end the threat. I dunno, this was fun in a way, plenty of action and intrigue, Soldier displaying his talent for disguises (one as a tulip salesman, the other as a woman looking to have a wedding). I just felt confused by the ending for it was never really explained how the music was causing madness, how the Nazi created the music in the first place or even if those bomber crews affected by this madness were ever cured of it. I'm really growing to like this art team here though, a very distinctive style. Hell in the Heavens Pt 2 - Midnight Spy by Kanigher and John Severin von Hammer is still wrestling with the vow he made to a dead English pilot to deliver his locket to his sister. He admonishes the German pilot under his command who shot down that English pilot (who was defenseless at the time thus breaking Hammer's code of honor). Later, during a flight skirmish with another squadron of English pilots, the German pilot seeks to take out Hammer himself during the melee confusion but Hammer turns the table on him. Afterwards, having witnessed earlier sneak attacks upon German zeppelins heading to London, Hammer potentially spots the source of those attacks. Landing, Hammer confronts the enemy spy and it's the last person he expected to see! Kanigher weaves yet another blood-soaked honor tale with a great cliffhanger over who the spy is and what will Hammer do now? Severin's art is just gorgeous to behold, from the flight battle scenes to the emotions on display here from all involved. A fantastic back-up feature so far. A few more letters printed in the letters page this time around (yes, including another one from TM Maple) and as a reward for having their letters printed, those fans received art pages from the DC sampler. It's kinda sad the editors resorted to this measure to try and encourage fans to write in, still that is a cool reward to receive in return.
|
|
|
Post by codystarbuck on Dec 28, 2018 13:24:41 GMT -5
During this era and beyond, a lot of frequent (and articulate) letter writers would be sent advanced review copies, to have a response to a new series early on (like in the 2nd issue, sometimes in the first!). TM Maple was on just about everyone's comp list and even got an obituary when he passed away.
|
|
|
Post by String on Feb 22, 2019 11:16:00 GMT -5
This issue collects stories by Kanigher and Kubert (as seen on the cover), a story drawn by Neal Adams about a solider's near obsession to obtain a medal (any kind of medal), story by Kanigher and Alex Toth about a Japanese soldier's abrupt dissolution of the image of American 'white devils' (and how right he may in fact be about that perception), Kriegstein's short story about a soldier's luck with a gift sent to him on the war front from his mother and even two 1 page humor shorts by Sergio Aragones. A solid issue with great art however I do have a question. There are a couple of instances throughout these stories where someone manages to get close to an enemy target (be it a tank, armored car, pill box) then proceeds to fire into that target via a slit in hopes of catching the ammo stored inside; when they do, they jump as the ammo explodes, destroying the target. Now, I've very little experience with firearms so I don't know how accurate that action is. Does such a manuever actually work to some degree?
|
|
|
Post by codystarbuck on Feb 22, 2019 13:49:59 GMT -5
This issue collects stories by Kanigher and Kubert (as seen on the cover), a story drawn by Neal Adams about a solider's near obsession to obtain a medal (any kind of medal), story by Kanigher and Alex Toth about a Japanese soldier's abrupt dissolution of the image of American 'white devils' (and how right he may in fact be about that perception), Kriegstein's short story about a soldier's luck with a gift sent to him on the war front from his mother and even two 1 page humor shorts by Sergio Aragones. A solid issue with great art however I do have a question. There are a couple of instances throughout these stories where someone manages to get close to an enemy target (be it a tank, armored car, pill box) then proceeds to fire into that target via a slit in hopes of catching the ammo stored inside; when they do, they jump as the ammo explodes, destroying the target. Now, I've very little experience with firearms so I don't know how accurate that action is. Does such a manuever actually work to some degree? No. It is theoretically possible for a bullet fired into an ammo box to impact a round and set off the primer. The chances are pretty slim, though. The tactic they mean to show; but might run afoul of the Code, is that firing into an observation slit was a tactic meant to kill the crew inside. Better if you could get a grenade in there or flame thrower. A bigger danger, to ammunition, was an exploding charge (grenade, artillery shell, mortar round, etc) that would set of primer charges and also create a fire, which would then cook off rounds, where the intense heat sets off the primer. Outside of Kirby, not too many war comics were particularly good about infantry tactics. If you look at Kirby's, especially the Losers, he has the men covering each other and handling their weapons correctly, though sometimes layout of the page messed with that. Most went more for drama. A few comic artists were actual combat veterans (Kirby, Nick Cardy and Sam Glanzman, to name 3). Many had rear echelon jobs, because of their talents. Kirby's actually put him in greater danger, since his CO figured that if he could draw, he could create maps and he was made a scout. Others, like Joe Kubert, served in the peacetime army. Kubert excelled at the drama of the story; but, not always the authenticity. They did put considerable effort into getting the uniforms, equipment, and vehicles right; but the writers generally dictated the story and drama was always their first concern. Same is true of Hollywood. Sam Fuller, who served in the 1st Division, in WW2, depicted things accurately; but, his films were never the big box office hits.
|
|