|
Post by Deleted on Sept 23, 2017 10:48:32 GMT -5
Your first paragraph about which books at Marvel and DC are the most interesting nowadays is spot on. Batman, Avengers and Spider-Man have such ridiculous amounts of editorial oversight and corporate meddling nowadays (often if only in terms of mandated events and crossovers) it's virtually impossible for a creative team to get much steam going. People wonder why those old runs from the 60's, 70's and 80's still hold so much weight? Well, they were self-contained, reflected the creative teams vision with a small amount of editorial oversight. Hell, Kirby edited his own Fourth World stuff. I kind of agree, in that I think event books are a plague on the industry - partly because they derail so many series and spawn so many really crap tie-ins, but most because it means that really significant stories never happen in the characters' own books any more. OTOH, I completely disagree about the editing thing - in the 70s, there were some truly terrible books put out under the writer-editor combination - and most writers need good editorial oversight, and Kirby is a classic example of someone who desperately needed an editor when he was writing. The problem now is I'm not sure what the editors at the big 2 do, but most of the time they're not in position because they're the most experienced writer around, they've leveled up from office assistant etc through the ranks*, compared to someone like Shooter or Goodwin, who knew the mechanics of storytelling inside out. (* at risk of derailing the thread, the same is true in politics - people come into politics having never done anything "real" in their lives - they've just been SPADs or political gofers)
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 23, 2017 11:04:57 GMT -5
Bug! the Adventures of Forager! Really. This book is so incredibly fun it's silly. And it is the absolute perfect tribute to Kirby in the year of his centennial. I can't recommend it enough! I read all 4 issues in one sitting the other day and I cannot agree enough. It's all out fun and Kirbyesque ideas pouring from every page, all bigger than life in the grand Kirby tradition. But it's the Allreds emulating Kirby's creative approach to comics without slavishly imitating what was on the page. -M
|
|