|
Post by pinkfloydsound17 on Sept 11, 2017 20:24:09 GMT -5
Now, I know what you are thinking...what about the Invaders reviews?
Rest assured, I will complete that. But sometimes, you need a break and I have a lot of reading to do. One of the things in my long box of reading is The Cat #1-4. Perhaps this has been done, but I feel like I should review it with my own perspective. Once again, I know very little about this character. I do know that The Cat (along with Night Nurse and Shanna The She-Devil) were three creations that Stan and Roy came up with after they felt the need for books with a female solo lead. And correct me if I am wrong, but in terms of the Silver/Bronze Age, the Cat would be the very first "female superhero" book that Marvel produced?
So join me (and please contribute with any thoughts and ideas of your own) as we dive into this short-lived series.
The Cat #1
The Cover Everything about this cover is perfect for me. You have the eye catching yellow title and captions. You have the central character, front and center. You also have some murky background images cast in an eerie red colouring. It is wonderful. Marie Severin gets the credit with Wally Wood contributing as well (the interiors are tackled by this same duo). To me, this is one of her best covers and I do not know how often she teamed up with Wood but it seems something that should have happened lots.
The Story It kicks of with the Cat in action right off the hop. She is making her way through the rooftops of Chicago to a penthouse en route for some revenge. She alludes to some training with a Dr. Tumolo but that is all we get for now. She breaks into the penthouse and battles some henchmen. One of them radios to that boss that she is there, and the room fills with knockout gas that puts the Cat down for the count. As she drifts off to sleep, we are treated to part one of her origin.
We are treated to this flashback which shows our heroine, alias Greer Nelson, on her way to class when she bumps into police officer Bill Nelson. Well the two end up eventually becoming a couple and Greer is just a good stay at home wife. One night while they are out, they come across a robbery in progress. Bill tries to intervene and ends up shot and killed. Greer is thrown into a world of sorrow. She eventually tries to get back on her feet but no matter where she applies for a job, she is turned away (apparently a woman with some education has a hard time back in the day). She is about to give up when she bumps into her old college professor, Dr. Tumolo. She is offered a job as a lab assistant, goes back to school and starts to get her life back on track.
At this point, Cat wakes up. She has been captured by a man name Mal Donalbain, a creepy cat (not literally) who despises being touched by anyone (one of his henchmen is pushed into him by Cat and he freaks out). He has some cooky plan using some science machines to replicate Cat's abilities and create superior beings like her. These beings will then work at health clubs and train people, I guess? These superior beings will wear some headgear that allows Donalbain to control them, putting him in control of all these super-powered beings. Crazyness.
Anyways, Cat escapes her bindings. Donalbain sends one of his mutant humans, Zabo, after her, but she escapes to the roof. Secretly, she sneaks back into the building and waits for things to calm down before planning her next move. During this rest, she reflects on the rest of her origin. Turns out Donalbain was funding Dr. Tumolo on some crazy project that would amplify a woman's abilities to she could overcome the constraints society placed upon her by being stronger, smarter and faster. Of course, he just wanted to create a super-army he could control, but he disguised his plan in this way and even provided a subject for them to experiment on named Shirlee Bryant. Well, she was not a very good subject so Dr. Tumolo and Greer conducted the experiments on Greer as well. They work on her and she becomes stronger and faster.
Eventually, Dr. Tumolo decides to tell Donalbain that his subject, Shirlee, just isn't taking to the treatments. Tumolo goes to his place, discovers his lab and sees Shirlee in some Cat costume. Turns out, she was picking up on something and that was the machinery and methods that Dr. Tumolo was using, which she shared with Donalbain so he could recreate these machines. Donalbain puts one of the control collars on Shirlee and starts commanding her to do things. She is told to climb to the ceiling but because she did not take to the experiments, she falls to her death. Donalbain knows that Dr. Tumolo witnessed this and he has his henchmen go and murder her. At this point, the only proof Greer has of all this is the costume (Dr. Tumolo stole it as evidence) and so she sets off to confront Donalbain.
Finally...all caught up on backstory. The Cat is rested now, and she attacks again and takes out Zabo by throwing him into the super-human-making equipment. He is killed, the equipment destroyed and now it is just Cat and Donalbain. The explosion triggers a blackout and in the dark, Cat threatens to touch Donalbain. He freaks out thanks to his fear and ends up killing himself. The story end with Greer contemplating the recent events and whether these powers she has have made her a better person or not.
Opinions Wow...a lot happens in a short period of time. First off, the artwork is excellent. I like Cat and the origin story, while obviously similar to many (loses someone loved at the hands of a criminal, gains powers, seeks revenge against criminals), this one felt different. Donalbain and his scheme was definitely silly and a little confusing at times. The story was by Linda Fite...I have no idea if this is her first foray into superhero comics or not but it definitely was interesting and has me wanting to see more. I think there is something that can be used and taken a lot further here.
Quote of the Issue "The incompetent fool! Apparently this cat didn't have nine lives!" - Donalbain's exclamation when Shirlee falls to her death...brutal joke for a brutal death but, sadly, I liked it.
|
|
|
Post by Rob Allen on Sept 11, 2017 21:37:20 GMT -5
Issue #1's villain, Mal (presumably short for Malcolm) Donalbain is a Shakespeare reference. Malcolm and Donalbain were the sons of King Duncan in Macbeth.
I remember buying this series as it came out and enjoying it. I don't think Marie Severin and Wally Wood worked together much, unfortunately. And I seem to recall Linda Fite writing a story or two earlier - maybe a Marvel Girl backup in X-Men?
|
|
|
Post by pinkfloydsound17 on Sept 11, 2017 23:07:48 GMT -5
Nice catch on the Shakespeare reference. And yes from what I read on Fite she did pen some Xmen backup stories.
|
|
|
Post by chaykinstevens on Sept 12, 2017 12:08:47 GMT -5
The Cover
Everything about this cover is perfect for me. You have the eye catching yellow title and captions. You have the central character, front and center. You also have some murky background images cast in an eerie red colouring. It is wonderful. Marie Severin gets the credit with Wally Wood contributing as well (the interiors are tackled by this same duo). To me, this is one of her best covers and I do not know how often she teamed up with Wood but it seems something that should have happened lots.
GCD says "Inker Wally Wood reportedly inked the cover figure of "The Cat" totally nude causing penciler Marie Severin to have to go back and white out details of the female anatomy so that the suit would look to be skin tight, but not skin. Reported in "Marvel Comics: The Untold Story" to be a problem throughout the interior artwork as well." Perhaps this explains why Severin didn't do more work with Wood. Woody inked Marie's brother John's pencils in Creepy #78, though.
|
|
Crimebuster
CCF Podcast Guru
Making comics!
Posts: 3,959
Member is Online
|
Post by Crimebuster on Sept 12, 2017 13:05:17 GMT -5
I thought this first issue was really great. A lot of promise. And then I read the next three issues.
|
|
|
Post by Rob Allen on Sept 12, 2017 15:20:34 GMT -5
Nice catch on the Shakespeare reference. And yes from what I read on Fite she did pen some Xmen backup stories. Finally got to the GCD for Linda Fite's credits: www.comics.org/credit/name/Linda%20Fite/sort/chrono/She wrote two Western stories and one Marvel Girl backup prior to The Cat #1. The Marvel Girl story is reprinted in the last issue of The Cat.
|
|
|
Post by pinkfloydsound17 on Sept 12, 2017 15:24:43 GMT -5
Wow so she was green. Well she put a lot out there for a first ish. I hope to review the second one by tomorrow (tonight I'm gonna hit up the Invaders:)
|
|
|
Post by pinkfloydsound17 on Sept 13, 2017 18:32:02 GMT -5
The Cat #2The CoverA solid cover by Romita. I feel like you would be hard pressed to find a cover of his that is not attractive. The Owl looks good, the Cat looks great and the background scenery is excellent. We get people on the roof shooting at the Cat, we get pedestrians down below on the street, we get people in the windows of the building even! Very nice. The StoryThe tale starts with The Cat on the roof of a hospital. She reveals that some sixth sense guided her here and she felt that Dr. Tumolo was responsible. Then, three owl-esque henchmen arrive on scene. She battles them and then narrowly avoids a gun attack from none other than…the Owl! Angered that his plan has been thwarted (whatever it was), he shoots down his own henchmen so the police cannot interrogate them and flies off. Ruthless! The Cat jumps away as cops arrive but stops outside a hospital window. Inside, she is shocked to see Dr. Tumolo. She is unconscious and her nephew is there, talking with doctors about moving her somewhere else. They all leave and Cat crawls in. While beside Tumolo, she can hear her thoughts…and the doctor tries to tell her that the nephew is not her actual nephew. Greer does not seem to get the message (she seems to relieved that her colleague and mentor is alive) and tells her to rest before heading home for a much needed nap. During said nap, we are put through FIVE FULL PAGES of flashback from last ish. Now I know part of the comic/Marvel formula does this but man, did this feel like overkill. Especially having just read the last ish. Anyway, the next day rolls around and Greer heads back to the hospital. The mysterious nephew is there and after Dr. Tumolo's attorney tells Greer that she was named sole beneficiary if anything happened to her, Greer realizes the nephew must be a phony. However, she is too late as the "nephew" kidnaps Dr. Tumolo in an ambulance. Greer gives chase but is captured once she follows the criminal to a warehouse. The Owl is the man behind the kidnapping. He explains to Greer that his device will take knowledge from Dr. Tumolo's brain and he will add it to his computer systems, giving him more access and genius. Greer is knocked out by a henchman and thrown in a closet. When she wakes, she dons her costume (they left her with her purse...silly henchman). She attacks and makes her way back to Dr. Tumolo but her mind has been wiped. She takes the doctor and tries to rush her back to the hospital but is stopped by the Owl. They battle and the Owl quickly realizes how strong the Cat is. Also, Cat pulled an alarm and the police are arriving at this point, so Owl decides he better flee. He goes back to his lab to get his mind device and all his precious information...only to find the "nephew" trying to use it to have all the information translated to his own mind. This goes horribly as the device gets destroyed by a stray bullet and the nephew dies when it overloads his mind with info. The story ends with Cat trying to stop Owl from flying off. She knocks him off a roof but he floats away to safety. Cat/Greer is left to wonder yet again if this superhero thing is a good idea, as Dr. Tumolo is now mindless and she has failed to capture the Owl. OpinionsNot the worst story. Where I found it dragged the most was the five pages of recap. I felt this could have been done shortened greatly which would have allowed for a better battle between her and the Owl. I still feel that the series has potential moving forward. The artwork is good both inside and out and I don't feel this book differs from others in that they are trying to establish the character before they move into an advanced storyline. Obviously, the series never gets to that point as there are only two more issues but I am waiting to see where the negative turning point is. Quote of the IssueInsufferable clod! Years of planning ruined!- The Owl's exclamation when the "nephew" guy (his name is Broussard) shoots at Owl, misses and destroys his computer database.
|
|
|
Post by pinkfloydsound17 on Sept 13, 2017 20:16:36 GMT -5
The Cat #3
The Cover So far, this is the worst cover. The villain just looks like Inigo Montoya mixed with Hook mixed with one of the three muskateers…a three pronged hook hand? Who is this Kraken joke? Why use him? He takes up 75% of the drawing and there is nothing special to see. I get the feeling this issue is where the book starts to nose-dive. Credits say it was Rich Buckler on the cover and for me, he can be hit and miss. Definite miss here. However, I found this with Romita's name on it so I don't know if he had a hand in it or not
The Story Our tail (excuse me, tale) starts off with the Cat on a boat being chased. She tries to evade the vessel but crashes on a rock and is thrown into the water. Her unconscious body is hauled aboard by the pursuing vessel and they wonder what she was doing out on Lake Michigan. During her “time out”, we are treated to a flashback explaining how Greer got here. After last issue, she snuck back into civilian clothes and pretended she had been trapped by the Owl. She is taken by the police back to the hospital with Dr. Tumolo.
Then, days later, the doctor is released from hospital. She is now staying with Greer in the country, and it appears the poor doctor is still suffering some memory loss from the Owl’s device. Dr. Tumolo’s lawyer, Bill, comes to visit and Greer ends up going on a scuba diving date with him in Lake Michigan. During this dive, the Cat’s heightened senses pick up some sonar signals. She does not investigate for fear of Bill learning about her powers. However, the does steal his boat keys and that night heads out to investigate the weird signals she sensed. This is when she got chased and then captured.
All caught up now, we see that they are headed into a rocky cave. From there, her captors take her down to a dome underwater where men are working on something. Cat is conscious now by the way. She is taken to the leader, a Mr. Belag. He questions her appearance here. Suddenly an alarm goes off and Mr. Belag leave Cat with another guard, who she quickly overtakes. Greer finds a room with US Navy attire in it and assumes she has stumbled on some secret US base. She ventures further and then sees who set off the alarm…Commander Kraken and his pirate lackeys. He explains how he escaped his last battle with Subby and is seeking refuge in Lake Michigan while he regains his footing. The Cat then leaps out, and a fight ensues which ends with Kraken zapping Cat unconscious. He manages to escape. The Cat then decides to share her story with Mr. Belag and the crew of this underwater research facility. She feels her secret is safe with them and that she will keep their research location safe. She departs and gets to shore only to turn back and see the underwater dome explode as a spaceship takes off. She realizes that the people there were actually aliens and she feels bad that she did not sense that when talking to them.
Opinions Well despite the not so great cover, the interior art was great! Layouts by Patty Greer and inks by Everett…and for me it works. The characters looks great and the detail on things like the boat Cat is driving on the first page really appealed to me. Even Kraken when he appears looks a little better. The main problem was the ending. To just finish with a “oh they were aliens, watch them take off never to be seen again” ending was terrible. Also, why did they look like humanoid wolves?
Anyway, a terrible end to what could have been an okay story…if it just ended without aliens. It would have been another one and done type tale but at least it would have been complete. This just adds a stupid mystery and the Cat’s dialogue at the end is silly, as she laments about thinking she knows everything when really she knows nothing. Once again, I don’t feel like it was the worst thing I have read. And again, the art was great minus the cover. With one issue left, I am wondering what kind of tale Fite will end with. Obviously they were having difficulties keeping things consistent with the title, as artwork has been varied (still good) and the release dates irregular (first ish in November, second in January, third in April).
Quote of the Issue “Sorry, there’s no rum in this punch”- The Cat exclaims as she knocks out a pirate.
Odd End Caption The end caption reads “The Cat…spawn of the Devil? So cries the Witch!”. Sounds intriguing but I know Man-Bull is on the cover of the next ish so we will see if this blurb proves accurate.
|
|
|
Post by EdoBosnar on Sept 14, 2017 4:26:06 GMT -5
Just noticed this thread now. Nice to see some love for Greer Nelson, a character I've always had a fondness for, whether as the Cat or Tigra (the pre-'80s Tigra, before she was turned into a flighty, and cowardly flirt, and then a devolving head-case catching mice in the kitchen). As for the series itself, I've only ever read Cat #1 because it was reprinted in Marvel Super-hero Women, and I liked it. It really showed promise, as another commenter above noted. It's my understanding that the rest of the series didn't quite live up to that promise (the guys at the now defunct Traveling Through the Bronze Age podcast did some entertaining reviews of them a few years ago). Anyway, thanks for the posts.
|
|
|
Post by Roquefort Raider on Sept 14, 2017 5:56:41 GMT -5
The Cat #3
(...) He explains how he escaped his last battle with Subby and is seeking refuge in Lake Michigan while he regains his footing.
Reading that issue way back when, I wondered how Captain Kraken and his crew of miscreants could end up in Lake Michigan. Did their sub sail up Niagara Falls?
|
|
|
Post by Slam_Bradley on Sept 14, 2017 9:40:21 GMT -5
The Cat #3
(...) He explains how he escaped his last battle with Subby and is seeking refuge in Lake Michigan while he regains his footing.
Reading that issue way back when, I wondered how Captain Kraken and his crew of miscreants could end up in Lake Michigan. Did their sub sail up Niagara Falls? It snuck through the Welland Canal.
|
|
|
Post by Roquefort Raider on Sept 14, 2017 10:53:24 GMT -5
Reading that issue way back when, I wondered how Captain Kraken and his crew of miscreants could end up in Lake Michigan. Did their sub sail up Niagara Falls? It snuck through the Welland Canal. Ninja submarine!
|
|
Crimebuster
CCF Podcast Guru
Making comics!
Posts: 3,959
Member is Online
|
Post by Crimebuster on Sept 14, 2017 10:55:18 GMT -5
There's a pretty obvious answer to this one, guys.
|
|
|
Post by pinkfloydsound17 on Sept 14, 2017 10:56:26 GMT -5
Well since it's a comic my imagination gets more of a kick outta the idea of it swimming up through the falls.
|
|