|
Post by thwhtguardian on Oct 24, 2018 18:01:23 GMT -5
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Oct 24, 2018 18:54:14 GMT -5
Tales From Vader's Castle #4Written by Caven Scott Art by Derek Charm and Robert Hack Summary: While the Rebels are picked off one by one a tale of a daring Ewok adventure unfolds. Plot: While the framing narrative still doesn't hold up I'm a sucker for Ewoks and it looks like Scott was a fan too as he includes references to both the cartoon and the two stand alone films. I might be alone in this but I've loved the Ewoks since I was a kid and I think that both the films and the cartoon still stand up really well so it was fantastic to see someone who obviously felt the same write a new fun adventure for them that included the Duloks, boar-wolves and a Gorax! On top of that I really liked the horror elements here like the allusion to the Wicker Man with the giant wicker Ewok sacrifice to the Gorax and the just desserts the Ewok shaman got. While not perfect it was definitely the best story presented so far and something I'll definitely re-read in the future. Art: Along with the much improved storytelling the art here is also much better than previous chapters: The characters are really well done, looking not only totally on book to the films but also being really rich in characterization and emotion. On top of that the sharp contrast in the coloring really went a long way in creating that horror movie feel which was fantastic. Even the framing art by Charm looked better here, especially his Vader: Grade:8/10
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 24, 2018 22:48:35 GMT -5
Action 1004 by Bendis, Sook, Von Grawbadger: Wow...where to start...a bit about what Lois has been up to and possibly a new status quo for Superman and his family. The scenes with Superman and Lois were incredibly earnest, sexy, sensual, and realistic for Mr and Mrs Superman. Excellent scenes at the Daily Planet too and I’m very much enjoying seeing both Clark and Superman. The art by Sook and Von Grawbadger is stunning. Some of the most beautiful art in a comic I’ve seen. No gimmicks, just classic and clean work. I did get annoyed with Lois using the word “baby” every other breath, but overall this was one heck of an issue. If you are not reading Action Comics, now is the time to hop on board. The metallic cover by Steve Rude is beautiful as well. 9.5/10
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 25, 2018 13:12:35 GMT -5
The Terrifics #9.Written by Jeff Lemire. Art by Jose Luis. First the two negatives. This is the 5th artist on this title in 9 issues! And the foil cover reminds me of the worst of the 90's. Now the good stuff. Tom Strong & Co. and the Terrifics "team up". We also get Swamp Thing! And Dr Dread's ID is revealed on the last page. Lemire gives us a nice action packed issue that feels fast paced. However there are nice "quiet" moments interspersed. Just a well done series that "feels" like the Silver Age. 8/10.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 25, 2018 13:21:56 GMT -5
Amazing Spider-Man #8.Written by Nick Spencer. Art and Cover by Humberto Ramos. The Thieves Guild pull off the Heist of the Century as all the heroes equipment is stolen. Missing: Spidey's web shooters. Cap's shield. Tony's armors. Thor's hammers. And the list goes on. The Black Cat shows up at the end. And we get some really nice Peter & MJ scenes. Spencer starts off this new arc strong. Hopefully he can do better than the first arc which started strong but quickly became bland. I like his take on Spidey. I like MJ being his girlfriend again. And this mystery of the heroes missing weapons is interesting. 8/10.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 25, 2018 13:28:41 GMT -5
Action Comics #1004.Written by Brian Michael Bendis. Art by Ryan Sook. The Bad: I agree with @mrjupiter. Lois' dialog was annoying at times. And I think her reasons for their "sort of" separation is just lame. The Good: Everything else. We find out where Jon is. Bendis writes a perfect Superman/Clark. And does an outstanding job writing the supporting cast at the Planet! Also Sook's art is absolutely beautiful. 9/10.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 25, 2018 14:11:55 GMT -5
md62 I agree with you, the reason for the separation is lame....and upon a rereading, I wonder if there is something more going on with Lois. Bendis seems to have really gone out of his way to have just Superman and not his family around. It also struck me as odd that Lois, being the good mother she is, would leave her son with Jor-El. Of course, I could just be reading more into it and Bendis simply wants to focus on Superman and Clark rather than what he (Bendis) may consider baggage weighing Superman down?
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Oct 25, 2018 19:12:15 GMT -5
Usagi Yojimbo: The Hidden #7Written and Illustrated by Stan Sakai Summary: Our fearless Rabbit Ronin and Inspector Ishida find themselves between a real rock and a hard place only to find an unusual ally. Plot: Endings are often the hardest part of a story to get right, especially in a thrilling story such as Sakai's look at the intrigue of Hidden Christians in in feudal Japan; there were so many plot twists and characters involved along the way that it's difficult to imagine so many loose strings being tied up so neatly in a single issue...but The Hidden arrives at its conclusion and delivers upon every single character introduction, mystery, and thematic thread he introduced across the previous six issues. It's truly a master stroke of storytelling that will in time, I think, make it one of my favorite Usagi stories to date. Art: Sakai is a legend of cartooning, he's able to bring so much pathos to his animal characters that at the end you're left forgetting that they aren't people which is a wonder to see. While the big action scenes in this issue with all the bandits attacking Usagi and Ishida do get a bit muddled at times, and the bandits come across as a little too generic to the point where they all look the same after a while the book is still fantastic. Grade:9/10
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 25, 2018 22:21:58 GMT -5
The Terrifics #9: I feel like I get my money’s worth each month with The Terrifics...interesting stories and characters, great if not consistent artists, drama, and action. Issue 9 provides it all, even some humor. Loved the last page and I was not expecting that character to be Dr. Dread. Great, quick moments between the characters, especially Mr Terrific and Tom Strong. Nice Swamp Thing guest appearance too. Very silver age team up vibe to this book along with 80s New Teen Titans/Legion of Super Heroes style interactions/drama. I love this book! 9/10
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Oct 27, 2018 10:23:22 GMT -5
Books of Magic #1Written by Kat Howard Art by Tom Fowler Summary: Jumping in where the original series left off we find Tim Hunter at the cross roads of magic and mundane, he chooses magic but learns it isn't as simple as that. Plot: I love Neil Gaiman's original Books of Magic nearly as much as I love his Sandman, and I even enjoyed a few of the sequels not by him so I felt this iteration in the Sandman Universe would be a sure thing when it was announced...but as the other titles came out and seriously underwhelmed me I became more and more worried that this would be another miss...and in that regard it sadly didn't disappoint. It's not that this new Books of Magic is a bad book, the pacing is good, it lays out it's premise well quickly introduces its cast before introducing a mysterious threat at the end...but it's over all content isn't exciting. The original Tim Hunter was a bit of a two dimensional stock character, it's true, but he didn't have to be more as he was just the plot device needed to string the history of magic in the DC universe together, but here we get a straight forward fantasy adventure story, and in a world populated by Harry Potter, Percy Jackson and literally a hundred other young fantasy heroes Tim really had to be something different to stand out...but yet he remained that same old every man character. As I said though, it's a technically well crafted tale, so it's not as if Howard has no skill, and maybe Tim will become something more down the line...but with the way the rest of the Sand Man Universe books have gone my hopes are not terribly high. Still I think I'll go for atleast one more issue and see for myself. Art: As pedestrian as the plot may be, the art by Fowler definitely fares better. Fowler had the unenvious task of encapsulating the entirety of Gaiman's previous Books of Magic into a few short pages, and the heavy lifting of that retelling was laid squarely on his shoulders with only a few captions to lead the way. In the hands of another artist that easily could have come off just as rote as the rest of the plot, but Fowler showed us he's no ordinary artist as he gave us that summary in the style of an illuminated text which really fit perfectly with the subject at hand. I'm thinking my will to trudge on may be largely thanks to the art here as I'd love to see how he'd render a more magical world, but even that hope will only get me so far. Grade:6/10
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Oct 27, 2018 11:56:35 GMT -5
Mars Attacks #1Written by Kyle Starks Art by Chris Schweizer Summary: Unaware that the world is under siege from a a Martian horde Spencer seeks out his father, Marjor Carbutt, to hit him up for cash only to end up on the run with his old man. Plot: I really, really, really wanted to like this book. I was honestly excited to see it announced and although I didn't have any experience with the creative team I put it on my pull, because as a kid this was huge with my friends and I. We were really just the right age for Mars Attacks in the early 90's as it appealed perfectly to that collecting stuff mentality that all ten year old boys seem to have, and it's dark "edgy" art made it feel like it was something adult that we shouldn't have. We started with the cards, then the comic and then were blown away by the movie...so when it was announced a new book was coming out I really wanted to recapture some of that nostalgic feeling, but maybe it's true when they say you can't go home because this really fell flat for me. The jokes were rushed, with no time to really hit home and the humor in general, "They look like testes" just wasn't my bag. Maybe my ten year old self would have found it funny to hear the aliens described as ugly testicles, but I'm not sure that it would have landed even then despite my then enjoyment of dick and fart jokes. Art: Schweizer's overly simplistic art style didn't really help things either when you get right down to it. The fun of the cards was their gruesome violence paired with the dry wit of the captions: And with out that reality it just doesn't work : Grade:2/10
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Oct 27, 2018 15:33:28 GMT -5
Action 1004 by Bendis, Sook, Von Grawbadger: Wow...where to start...a bit about what Lois has been up to and possibly a new status quo for Superman and his family. The scenes with Superman and Lois were incredibly earnest, sexy, sensual, and realistic for Mr and Mrs Superman. Excellent scenes at the Daily Planet too and I’m very much enjoying seeing both Clark and Superman. The art by Sook and Von Grawbadger is stunning. Some of the most beautiful art in a comic I’ve seen. No gimmicks, just classic and clean work. I did get annoyed with Lois using the word “baby” every other breath, but overall this was one heck of an issue. If you are not reading Action Comics, now is the time to hop on board. The metallic cover by Steve Rude is beautiful as well. 9.5/10 md62 I agree with you, the reason for the separation is lame....and upon a rereading, I wonder if there is something more going on with Lois. Bendis seems to have really gone out of his way to have just Superman and not his family around. It also struck me as odd that Lois, being the good mother she is, would leave her son with Jor-El. Of course, I could just be reading more into it and Bendis simply wants to focus on Superman and Clark rather than what he (Bendis) may consider baggage weighing Superman down? See, while I do enjoy the way he writes Clark/Superman, the supporting cast at the Planet and Lois and I loved the "day in the life of Superman" two page montage of all the bad guys he stops on a regular...I just really hate the dissolution of the Kent family. That simple development was probably the single best addition to the mythos of Superman since he went from leaping buildings to flying, and to see it so easily casually cast off here was just so disappointing, even if it was well written. I guess this is how long time Spider-Man fans felt after One More Day.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Oct 27, 2018 16:06:03 GMT -5
The Whispering Dark #1Written by Christofer Emgard Art by Tomas Aira Summary: Trapped behind enemy lines and low on supplies Hannah Vance must reconcile her faith in God in the face of war. Plot: This is another book I tried out just for the cover, I mean just look at it...that skull faced moon is just fantastic! That said, while it didn't blow me away what was behind the cover actually proved to be worth reading which is seldom the case whenever I make an impulse buy based only on a cool cover. The character work Emgard provides for Hannah as she reluctantly leads a group of Army Rangers through the mountains is incredibly solid, and the urge to learn more about her is incredibly strong. However, although I like a character study as much as the next guy(maybe more) the pacing is a little too slow for its own good and it doesn't really reveal enough about what is going on to truly immerse you in the world or even give you anything to look forward to next which means that I'm unlikely to buy the next book, and I imagine I won't be alone. Art: Aira has the difficult task of providing illustration for such a character driven narrative and he does a great job in keeping it interesting. Through out the whole book he really packs in a fantastic amount of details in not only the environments but also the weaponry, and clothing which really imbues the whole affair with a tremendous amount of realism. However, probably his best quality is his attention to detail when it comes to drawing facial expressions. While expressive faces on characters is a big plus in any book in an intensely character driven drama such as this its an absolute necessity as characterization an emotional states are subtle business and here he does it with ease. Grade:6/10
|
|