|
Post by dbutler69 on May 11, 2019 9:02:54 GMT -5
High heels. Partially joking, partially not. Perez was inconsistent, at first, depicting Raven in heels and flats; but, heels became the standard, especially when they began showing her more with the hood down. The one aspect of her costume I really dislike. I agree. Raven just does not seem like a high heels kinda gal.
|
|
|
Post by codystarbuck on May 11, 2019 17:40:38 GMT -5
The one aspect of her costume I really dislike. I agree. Raven just does not seem like a high heels kinda gal. Oh, I don't know; I could see Raven and Zatanna hitting the shoe stores together, checking out the sales. If Perez wanted to have fun, he should have done a sight gag of Raven opening her closet and have it filled with shoe boxes, because she keeps snapping off heels during combat.
|
|
|
Post by spoon on May 12, 2019 18:18:43 GMT -5
I liked #7 a lot. Wolfman is still a little loose with his writing, but I don't expect vol. 1 of NTT to be as sophisticated as X-Men from the same period. To me, this issue is primarily about the battle, and that works really well. The fight choreography works better than some earlier issues. I guess Perez is doing fuller pencilers, because this issue doesn't seem to suffer as much from Romeo Tanghal's Colletta-esque aversion to details. I like the panel where Mammoth knocks Wonder Girl through the window and Gar's transformation into a jellyfish. Given that Cyborg's origin and closure gets packed into a few pages at the end of the issue, the battle based in Tower does a good job tying things together. Silas Stone's construction of the Titans Tower is an unexpectedly effective way to make the structure of this story work.
There's also some good character development. The other Titans forgive Raven, and she has a reason to stay and feel like part of the team. Even though Kid Flash is sent away, it adds to his story with Raven. Also, much like the earlier fight with the Fearsome Five, I suspect this was an effort to even the odds. When the Titans have 7 to 5 numerical superiority, the Fearsome Five don't seem as credible of a threat. An avenue opens up for Victor to let down his guard, and his friendship with Gar moves a little more from antagonistic to friendly teasing.
|
|
|
Post by dbutler69 on May 13, 2019 9:10:58 GMT -5
I agree. Raven just does not seem like a high heels kinda gal. Oh, I don't know; I could see Raven and Zatanna hitting the shoe stores together, checking out the sales. If Perez wanted to have fun, he should have done a sight gag of Raven opening her closet and have it filled with shoe boxes, because she keeps snapping off heels during combat. Well, you could do that with any female superhero. They all wear heels, and it really doesn't make any sense. Look nice, but makes no sense. Good luck fighting supervillains in those things.
|
|
|
Post by codystarbuck on May 13, 2019 11:30:24 GMT -5
Oh, I don't know; I could see Raven and Zatanna hitting the shoe stores together, checking out the sales. If Perez wanted to have fun, he should have done a sight gag of Raven opening her closet and have it filled with shoe boxes, because she keeps snapping off heels during combat. Well, you could do that with any female superhero. They all wear heels, and it really doesn't make any sense. Look nice, but makes no sense. Good luck fighting supervillains in those things. American Maid made it work...
|
|
shaxper
CCF Site Custodian
Posts: 22,874
|
Post by shaxper on May 18, 2019 13:08:33 GMT -5
New Teen Titans #8 (June 1981) "A Day In the Lives..." Script: George Pérez (plot); Marv Wolfman (plot, script) Pencils: George Pérez (breakdowns); Romeo Tanghal (finished art) Inks: Romeo Tanghal Colors: Adrienne Roy Letters: Ben Oda Grade: B+ Contrary to what the cover and title may promise, these are not 25 pages of pure and unhindered character development. A significant amount of time is allotted to a non-sensical Raven conflict that is lighter on significance than Perez and Wolfman might like us to believe. Raven considers becoming a student at "Manhattan University" (I guess DC was afraid NYU might sue?), and, immediately upon checking it out with her soul self, she conveniently wanders upon three terrorists who have taken hostages and are about to blow the place up. Ugh. She saves the day, but as she is doing so, Perez and Wolfman decide for the first time that Raven has a five minute limit on how long her soul self can be apart from her body. Wow. EXACTLY 300 seconds. Funny how nature and magic conform to our artificial measurements of time. Anyway, after a really long, prose-heavy, and generally unnecessary struggle, she discovers it's actually pretty damn easy to push past the five minute limit. And this somehow gives her a renewed sense of purpose since the followers of Azar were wrong. I really could have done without this segment. Fortunately, in the moments where Perez and Wolfman stop pushing an obligatory conflict on us and trust that they can maintain our interest with pure character-building, they fare much better. Precious little time is spent on Dick, but we are told that he is now working at a circus again (a nod to the events of DC Comics Presents #31, which are about to continue into his new backup feature in Batman, beginning next month). Gar also doesn't get much attention, but that's likely because a second conflict introduced here and being set up for next issue is going to feature him heavily. Donna and Kory get a little bit of on-panel time where we finally learn Donna's day job is as a relatively high-profile freelance fashion photographer, and that she is dating divorcee Terry Long. Donna is getting Kory into modelling, apparently her skin and hair tones being just within the realm of human possibility to the point that no one really questions it. and a completely heinous and unnecessary complication is first suggested in there clearly being mutual attraction between Terry and Kory: I don't remember this from my previous readings and sincerely hope it's going to get abandoned. I used to LOVE Terry and Donna together -- a truly normal and loving post-feminist relationship. Don't f**k with my adolescent impressions, please! Raven's conflict really doesn't convince me she has grown all that much, and Perez and Wolfman's attempts to finally explain how her soul self works is weirdly contradictory, even within the span of a single comic book page: So...she isn't tangible, but she can affect tangible things?? But the real star of this issue is Vic, who has (by far) the most significant and powerful character evolution within these pages, first visiting his pre-accident girlfriend: And then (perhaps a little too conveniently) stumbling upon new purpose in Central Park: This scene always resonated with me as a kid, and I wonder if it didn't subconsciously help inspire me to become a teacher. By the way, we discussed Sarah Simms earlier in this thread, and why Wolfman and Perez abandoned what was clearly originally intended to be an interracial romance between her and Vic. Ready to resume that discussion? Oh yeah. Whining Wally ain't gone yet, and I have to wonder WHY. All the introspection Perez and Wolfman try to give to him which largely comes of as whining is ultimately handled far better with Dick. But I suppose it was ambitious to have a costumed hero spend significant time debating whether or not he wanted to continue devoting his time to that pursuit. Then again, hadn't Peter Parker done all that (better) almost two decades earlier? And, speaking of that aspect of this story, I'm a little bothered by just how patriarchal Perez and Wolfman depict this family that's clearly being passed off as their concept of the middle class ideal nuclear unit: Mom does all the work while dad sits back and is the credible voice of authority, reason, and merit in the West household. Even a decade earlier, this depiction would have felt more than a little outdated. And, once again, I have to note the continuing evolution of Perez's art. He isn't trying anything as big and ambitious as we saw from him in New Teen Titans #6, but he's taking more time with the fine details, especially faces, and proving just how brilliantly he can work with smaller panels and story moments for perhaps the first time: IMPORTANT DETAILS- 1st appearance of Terry Long, Donna's divorced boyfriend. - 1st appearance of Sarah Simms and her students. Vic begins working with them. - Donna is a professional photographer - Kory becomes a model - Dick is now working at a circus - 1st appearance of The Puppeteer MINOR DETAILS:- Well I guess we're retconning this little lapse of logic from NTT #2: with the opening of this story: unless Perez and Wolfman are suggesting Earth gets colder than Tamaran in Winter, but warmer than Tamaran in summer. Maybe Tamaran always maintains the exact same axis angle in relation to its sun?? - Man, this depiction is offensive and unnecessary: - I'm bothered by the fact that Gar drives around in a high-priced sports car and parks it right out front in Vic's slum: Not only doesn't he need it (dude can fly anytime he likes), but it really doesn't suit the persona we've seen previously where Gar doesn't feel like he fits within the billionaire lifestyle into which he has been thrust. Plus, can he even be old enough to legally drive on his own yet?? - This may be my favorite image of Vic ever. Last issue, I noted that Perez and Wolfman tied up nearly all of their plot points and character arcs. Now, they're setting the bar higher and making it clear they are far more invested in personal journeys than super-powered ones.
|
|
|
Post by wildfire2099 on May 18, 2019 13:39:12 GMT -5
That Purple outfit of Vic's is painful! I remember really liking Sarah Simms, and being sad they never pulled the trigger on that relationship. I guess Vic isn't allowed that much happiness.
I have no recollection of that car at all, and I agree it's jarring.
Not sure if the Italian stereotype or the belitting of the women is more offensive there... but I remember that one well and feeling guilty after I read it.
|
|
shaxper
CCF Site Custodian
Posts: 22,874
|
Post by shaxper on May 18, 2019 13:50:44 GMT -5
I remember really liking Sarah Simms, and being sad they never pulled the trigger on that relationship. I guess Vic isn't allowed that much happiness. I mean...it's realistic. No matter how good a heart someone has, getting into a serious exclusive relationship with a dude who is at least half metal is a difficult decision to make. Sex and physical attraction have got to factor into the equation, there. For Sarah to just ignore that because she's such a good person is unrealistic and (perhaps) unfair. I could fall in love with someone who isn't physically complete, but it's not the kind of thing that would happen casually. There would have to be a profoundly deep connection, earned over a long period of time, before our romantic connection would outweigh the other factors. Things like a warm, deep, flesh-on-flesh hug, Sarah would be saying goodbye to that forever. You really really need to know the person you are choosing is worth something like that. Of course, some people very much are. The difference being that Perez and Wolfman are clearly judging the belitting of the women. Not so much the portrayal of Italian Americans. Yeah...
|
|
shaxper
CCF Site Custodian
Posts: 22,874
|
Post by shaxper on May 18, 2019 14:36:16 GMT -5
Giving it a little more thought, I realize part of what I love about Vic's transformation here transcends his own character evolution, as well as the powerful symbolic meaning it holds for anyone who feels "less than complete" for any number of reasons. More than anything else, as a fan of the original Teen Titans, Vic's big moment of realization/transformation seems like the end of the journey we were always waiting for Mal Duncan to arrive at. I've argued previously that Raven and Cyborg are really just updates/exaggerations of Lilith and Mal, albeit infused with a little Dark Phoenix and Ben Grimm. So, when I see Vic's internal anger, both at the world that rejects him and at the inner voice that tells him he doesn't belong with the Titans, I hear Mal Duncan, who resents a white world that rejects him and who resents himself for not fully "fitting in" as a Titan. Vic's realization here is Mal's realization too; only the specifics have changed. Maybe Mal would have said this to a white girlfriend who was forbidden to date him and then gone on to volunteer with a group of inner-city black kids.
|
|
|
Post by Duragizer on May 18, 2019 16:24:45 GMT -5
Donna is getting Kory into modelling, apparently her skin and hair tones being just within the realm of human possibility to the point that no one really questions it. I certainly question it. I know this is a superhero comic and I'm supposed to suspend disbelief, but I find it really hard to belief no one's looked at this gold-skinned woman with knee-length auburn hair and failed to at least notice a resemblance to a certain alien superheroine sporting the exact same skin and hair.
|
|
|
Post by codystarbuck on May 18, 2019 16:30:24 GMT -5
My single favorite 1st year issue (after the intro of Deathstroke, obviously); mainly for the stuff with Vic. The walking ball of anger was a little tiresome, after several issues and I wasn't looking forward to more of that; but, after getting some closure with his father, then introducing Sarah and the kids. I distinctly recall the panel where Vic first sees that one of the ballplayers has a prosthetic limb and they all think his are way cooler just made me smile, then and now. It really helped to push Vic into a more mature and accepting realm. It may seem a bit abrupt when you read these; but, the passage of time across issues was a bit fluid. Given how early they are in the series, and how shaky the market had been, I can understand maybe not developing things over several issues. As for the Italian stereotype; well, Dick Giordano was managing editor, by this point (or soon would be); so, if anyone should have had a problem, it was him. Maybe it was an inside joke.
|
|
|
Post by Icctrombone on May 18, 2019 17:17:42 GMT -5
Maybe it's the time that's passed from the first time I read it but I find it to be an average issue. C+ at best. Of all the small vignettes , I would have rather have seen more about Dick in the circus.
Shax, I'm surprised that you didn't like the Raven interlude. Wolfman was defining the abilities and Limits of a relatively new character. And the time limit flaw is something that all characters that do that astral type separation have . I think Negative Man from the Doom Patrol has the issue.
The Vic portion was okay and introduces his ex girlfriend as an unsympathetic person. Don't worry she gets a taste of Karma later on in the series.
It wasn't until many years later that I heard that Terry Long was considered a type of perv , that might possibly have been dating student after student. He certainly flirts with Kory , which is a kind of sleazy.
As I said, It's possible I don't think much of this issue because it's 39 years old but , at the time, it was an important piece in building the newcomers. It's a common thing to have a down issue after high action arcs in the comic biz, this fills the bill.
|
|
|
Post by spoon on May 18, 2019 18:48:17 GMT -5
New Teen Titans #8 (June 1981) "A Day In the Lives..." Script: George Pérez (plot); Marv Wolfman (plot, script) Pencils: George Pérez (breakdowns); Romeo Tanghal (finished art) Inks: Romeo Tanghal Colors: Adrienne Roy Letters: Ben Oda Grade: B+ Contrary to what the cover and title may promise, these are not 25 pages of pure and unhindered character development. A significant amount of time is allotted to a non-sensical Raven conflict that is lighter on significance than Perez and Wolfman might like us to believe. Raven considers becoming a student at "Manhattan University" (I guess DC was afraid NYU might sue?), and, immediately upon checking it out with her soul self, she conveniently wanders upon three terrorists who have taken hostages and are about to blow the place up. There is a Manhattan College, although it actually moved to the Bronx a long time ago and just kept the name. Making up fake universities seems to be commonplace in comics. Even Marvel, which uses real cities more than DC, put it's New York college student heroes in Empire State University or Metro College. It's definitely self-indulgent, but I like the sequence. I think I'd probably respond differently to this depending on how I'm feeling when I read it. I like it because it allows Perez to be inventive, but it could get tedious if I'm not in the mood for it. Yes, it's good to get a slower issue. NTT has had a lot of action so far; so the balance is needed. This is interesting, because I can't really remember Dick having a job. I think he went back to the circus in the A Lonely Place for Dying story arc that introduced Tim Drake, but my recollection is that was a temporary thing for that arc. Yeah, the individual spotlight is hard to fit in for everyone, but since his personality is more established, this seems like a fine choice. This portion of the story seems to straddle all sorts of territory in the realm of sex symbols vs. female empowerment vs. feminism. Donna is in fashion! But she's a photographer, not a model! But she's taking a photos of topless models! But she berates one of them, who's a dumb model stereotype! I have heard that Terry Long is essentially Marv Wolfman writing himself into the story. I don't know how true that is. But there does seem to be some wish fulfillment in there. Terry gets to eat his cake and eat it, too. He's got a younger girlfriend, who's smart and assertive. But he also gets to hit on his girlfriend's exotic, naïve, model-like friend. I agree that Vic's plotline is the best one in this issue by far. I think it's an atypical but welcome twist to have his girlfriend reject him. With Ben Grimm or the Hulk, we usually get the general public being horrified, but their friends accepting them. Marcy's dialogue is very good, with her trying to deflect and blame her attitude on her parents. It would be nice for the meeting with Sarah Simms deferred to later, to have a delayed payoff and let the rejection linger. But Wolfman seems more inclined to the simple, immediate payoff than Claremont's drawn out stories in X-Men. I love to see that the kids are so accepting. I think it's not just about their own disabilities but that kids don't have certain judgmental attitudes baked in yet. It's a nice detail that Cyborg wants to live in his old neighborhood, perhaps an effort to return to normalcy and prove to himself that he's still the same man. This is the weakest part of the issue. Wally doesn't seem to have a developed story. It's more of a cliché, although at least he gets to express his feelings a bit. The era of Wally West that I'm most familiar with are the early issue of his post-Crisis solo Flash series. It's a little jarring to see his all 'Murican traditional family here. In the solo Flash series, I think his parents were divorced and his family was dysfunctional. I believe his father ended up being a dirtbag who works with the Manhunters.
|
|
shaxper
CCF Site Custodian
Posts: 22,874
|
Post by shaxper on May 18, 2019 21:55:49 GMT -5
This is interesting, because I can't really remember Dick having a job. I think he went back to the circus in the A Lonely Place for Dying story arc that introduced Tim Drake, but my recollection is that was a temporary thing for that arc. This all might have been designed to coordinate with this story that would be hitting shelves with a cover date of March 1981. In it, Dick is first reunited with Waldo the Clown, whom he knew while still at the Circus with his parents. By the end of the story, it's suggested Dick will be hanging around for a while to reconnect. Perhaps someone at DC was considering giving Dick an ongoing (backup?) solo feature over at DC Comics Presents, where he'd continue to reconnect with his past by rejoining a circus? Or it could just be a massive coincidence. I considered noting that, but the guy hiring Donna for the jeans ads (not the walking Italian stereotype) notes that what makes Donna so in-demand is her classical aesthetic taste -- essentially her Grecko-Roman upbringing on Paradise Island. And the Greeks and Romans LOVED their nude and partially nude women. So I think these things might not be in conflict for Donna. And, from a feminist perspective, Perez is an equal-opportunity cheese-cake himself, often designing costumes that have the men showing as much flesh as the ladies, sometimes more (could you imagine a woman wearing Cyborg or Nightwing's original costumes?? That's A LOT of chest!), so I doubt he saw a problem with this. Interesting. Certainly, the classy, feminist, shy guy who gets the amazon would be a tempting avatar for the writer. But then does Wolfman think Terry's panting after Kory is acceptable? Well said, all around.
|
|
|
Post by tarkintino on May 18, 2019 23:25:37 GMT -5
I remember really liking Sarah Simms, and being sad they never pulled the trigger on that relationship. I guess Vic isn't allowed that much happiness. I mean...it's realistic. No matter how good a heart someone has, getting into a serious exclusive relationship with a dude who is at least half metal is a difficult decision to make. Sex and physical attraction have got to factor into the equation, there. For Sarah to just ignore that because she's such a good person is unrealistic and (perhaps) unfair. Reposted earlier in the thread: Marv Wolfman on Cyborg and Sarah Simms: MW: "At first I thought of it. And then decided there was nothing wrong with a good healthy friendship that is not based on a sexual background between them. I received a letter that sort of helped me change my mind, from a black leader who felt that we had seen a lot of interracial relationships, but we haven’t seen that many good, solid black-black relationships to show that a black hero doesn’t always go together with a white heroine and vice-versa. And that sort of got me thinking. That came very early in the relationship, that it made a lot more sense in terms of their needs to be very good friends. He has no girl friend who he is totally in love with in a sexual way at this time. He’s just very good friends with her, And that in itself is a slightly different relationship. ”Upthread, my original response was: The more I think about it, and the consistency of having black characters only date black females, I must conclude that the Simms issue was more than a concession; that the same problem I pointed out about an obvious, potential connection between Mal and Lilith in the original Teen Titans comic appeared to be forced to hit a brick wall, either by the writers, or editors. That brick wall was the idea of an interracial relationship in a mainstream superhero comic, particularly with a black male with white female. This kind of pairing might seem ubiquitous today, but it remains the most controversial of any in the mainstream media, with endless people on the streets and in social media still complaining whenever they see such a paring. If its still a hot-button issue today (and it is), it was undoubtedly a live grenade of an idea in 1981. ...but someone had to be brave and stand against public, corporate and/or administrative racial stonewalling. Unfortunately, The New Teen Titans and its creative team was not going to be the site of that stand in 1981.
|
|