|
Post by codystarbuck on Jun 3, 2024 20:18:58 GMT -5
The Greatest Batman Stories Ever Told was subjective, but it did have a pretty decent mix of stories, from different eras. Loved the cover (I bought the hardcover)
I really wanted to like Black Orchid and really didn't. She was far more interesting in Adventure Comics and John Ostrander used her better in Suicide Squad. Gaiman just kind of copied the Swamp Thing aesthetic and it didn't really fit.
Mister Miracle was fun, totally intended to be a suburban sitcom. JLI got the ball rolling when you'd see Barda on the phone, with Scott, from their suburban home, wearing bunny slippers and shorts and a t-shirt, nagging at him for listening to Oberon.
DC was largely focusing on what they could sell to bookstore buyers, which meant stuff that was getting featured in Rolling Stone and similar magazines and newspapers, showcasing how mature comics were now. The Greatest Stories Ever Told books were testing the waters of collectors, in shops. Slowly, they started doing trades; but always top books, like JLI and similar. As they moved into the 90s, they upped their selection. DC had the advantage of having a book publisher under the same corporate roof, which got them into bookstores more than Marvel (apart from their Waldenbooks spinner display, for a short period). Marvel was always a bit more haphazard and still, in recent years, has geared their trade publishing around comic shops, with very finite print runs in retail markets. The American Bookseller Associationwas forever lamenting that Marvel trades would be out of print, just as they were selling in bookstores and members couldn't get reorders.
|
|
|
Post by commond on Jun 4, 2024 15:30:50 GMT -5
DC Direct Currents #11 (Books shipping Dec 6 thru Dec 20, 1988)
This time round, we've got The Greatest Joker Stories Ever Told. It's a good month for Batman villains actually as Catwoman also gets her own four issue New Format mini-series. I've never head of this book. It's apparently a continuation of Batman: Year One. It was written by Mindy Newell and penciled by J. J. Birch. The black and white art looks pretty decent. More letters -- Poor Arvind Suri is struggling to find any DC comics for sale in India. Jeff from Canada wants to know if he can order promotional posters directly from the Direct Currents people. Graig Matsuda from Honolulu wants to know what decides if a book should be cancelled or not and gets a stock answer. The interview this month is with Denny O'Neil, who is so important he gets a longer interview than everyone else. The cover of the month is yet another Superman cover. The back cover is Adventure Comics #300, the issue where The Legion of Super-Heroes became the cover feature. This is a tease for next month's Direct Currents, which will introduce us to L.E.G.I.O.N '89.
|
|
|
Post by codystarbuck on Jun 4, 2024 20:55:14 GMT -5
The Joker book made a nice companion to the Batman one and it was great to see "The Laughing Fish" and"Sign of the Joker," from the Englehart Rogers run, just as the Batman volume had the Deadshot story (with the redesigned costume).
Mindy Newell's Catwoman mini was great and did a lot to wash some of the bad taste from my mouth, from the Year One portrayal. This gave her a more rounded personality and introduced her sister, The Sister and also had her evolve a costume from something put together out of dominatrix gear to what she ended up with, in Year One. It also had her train with Ted Grant, in physical combat and to learn how to use the whip, as a weapon. It starts out with Selina beaten up by her pimp, Stan and ending up in the hospital. A cop passes her Ted's name and phone number and he teaches her to defend herself, then she brings the whip to him to teach her. Stan introduces the first costume, for a client into BDSM. You see Selina, in the beginning, under the thumb of the pimp, afraid to leave him, afraid to stand up to him. Training with Ted and then the influence of Bruce Wayne's activities and debut as Batman are seen from her POV and they inspire further changes, as she becomes more empowered. meanwhile, her sister, the nun, works in the area around the same neighborhood, and searches for her sister, eventually meeting her, but Stan uses this to get back at Selina, before the final showdown. It is a much better portrayal of Selina and details both the abuse and exploitation of prostitutes, and then Selina finding her strength and taking control of her life, as a natural progression. Really nice work, that was flushed down the toilet when they launched the Catwoman series as cheap T&A. Thankfully, Darwyn Cooke and some others steered her back on course.
Newell was a damn fine writer; but, comics being a boys club........... She trained as a nurse and continued working as one, while writing comics (she was the first woman to write Wonder Woman; at least, with a credit) and ended up leaving comics behind to continue nursing. She and Gray Morrow also collaborated on a nice Lois Lane mini-series, dealing with missing children. The Wonder Woman gig came with tons of editorial interference, which didn't help things.
Birch keeps things consistent with David Mazzucchelli's art, in Year One, while maintaining his own style. Very tough, noirish atmosphere.
|
|
|
Post by commond on Jun 5, 2024 15:42:36 GMT -5
DC Direct Currents #12 (Books shipping Jan 3 thru Jan 31, 1989)
The cover feature this month is another doomed to fail ongoing series. I've never really thought about how many books DC cancelled within a year or two of their debut. They seemed quicker to pull the plug on a book than Marvel, though that may be because Marvel had higher overall sales. Inside, there's a preview for L.E.G.I.O.N '89. This another one of those books that used to captivate me as a kid. I always wanted to read this series, but it was a New Format book and that immediately put it out of my price range. The price of comic books in New Zealand was adjusted for shipping costs, government savings tax, and whatever mark up the retailer put on them. If a comic cost a dollar in the States, it was closer to $2.50 in New Zealand. If I had $5 to spend, it was a simple economic choice between two standard books or one new format book. There's a spinoff of the Andy Helfer/Kyle Baker Shadow series called Justice, Inc. I have yet to finish their Shadow series. I took a break from it a while back and it's on the backburner. This is a prestige format book that's fully painted by Baker. That may be interesting. It appears that Blackhawk is the first series to get a spinoff from Action Weekly, though sadly it's not written by Mike Grell. Finally, there is a new New Gods series by Mark Evanier and Jim Starlin. If you don't like the way they handle Kirby's characters, you can blame his assistant. George Gustines from New York City (not our George, I presume) says his local comic book shop hides Direct Currents behind the counter. I never had that problem. My comic book shop would display it alongside the new releases. George asks why so many DC books have been shipping late. I was never aware of this as I couldn't make it into the store weekly and would patch together runs through the comic shop, the newsstands and second hand book stores. It does make me wonder how many of the books they preview actually appeared on schedule. They're starting to show the prices on the books now. I didn't realize there were still some 75 cent books in 1989. Man, looking over these prices I can totally understand why all the DC books I'm familiar with from this era cost a buck or less. I realize DC were appealing to the direct market, but man was their stuff pricey. Doom Patrol has switched to the New Format and is now being written by Grant Morrison. If I had to choose my all-time favorite runs, Morrison's Doom Patrol would have a decent crack at making the top 10. I doubt it would have appealed to me as a kid, though. This month's interview is with Kyle Baker, which is nice. The cover of the month is another Superman book. Carlin must have been up to something with these covers. The back cover is the first appearance and origin of The Huntress from DC Super-Stars #17 (1978).
|
|
|
Post by codystarbuck on Jun 5, 2024 17:36:33 GMT -5
I loved the Huntress, since her debut; but, this revamp, necessitated by Crisis, really didn't have the same feel, despite Joe Staton on art. It wasn't a bad series; but, the character just didn't have the same attraction when she was no longer the daughter of Batman and Catwoman. Yet another reason why Crisis messed up a lot of great stories.
Blackhawk's ongoing was more a spin-off of the Howard Chaykin mini-series than the Action Comics Weekly feature. It more closely matched the cyincal tone of the mini and brought back Natalie Reed, as the female Blackhawk. Grell kind of riffed on Caniff, but this was more of using Blackhawk to explore the CIA, under Allen Dulles, in the late 40s and 50s. Grell was doing more of a Steve Canyon meets Terry & the Pirates, but this has a harder edge, though it does bring in Grell's daughter of Pat Ryan and the Dragon Lady, while looking at things like the CIA's operations in Italy, to sway the post-War elections away from the Communist Party, the Chinese civil war, Korea, and Operation Paperclip, the operation which brought Nazi scientists to the US, to work on such things as the space program and experiments in pharmacology, like LSD and the MK Ultra tests.
New Gods starts out okay, but Starlin had poisoned the well with the death of Forager/Bug, one of the more intriguing characters. Evanier helps recover things a bit, by giving us an earlier figure from the past, who makes Darkseid look like a choirboy. Paris Cullins does some nice art; but, it wouldn't last.
Justice Inc isn't a spin-off of the Shadow. It is a second attempt to adapt the Avenger pulp stories, published by Street & Smith, under the same house name as Doc Savage (Kenneth Roberson), but not written by Lester Dent. The Avenger is Richard benson. He and his family board an airplane, flying to Canada. During the flight, Benson is asleep (I think, I haven't read the first novel, justice Inc, in 30+ years) and wakes up to find his wife and daughter gone and no one has any memory of them. the shock of the event turns his hair white and alters his facial muscles, so that he can mold his face into other features, disguising himself. he uses his vast wealth to battle crime, as The Avenger, with a group of assistants, including an African-American couple, who are graduates of the Tuskeegee Institute and often go undecover as servants. Despite attitudes of the period, they are always depicted as brave and intelligent people, with the servant cover being a logical extension of the limited opportunities of minorities, in that era.
Where the modernization came in, in this story, was in explaining the mystery behind his origin. previously, DC published 4 issues of Justice, Inc, in 1975, when they had The Shadow license. Jack Kirby drew issues 2-4, to fulfill his page quota, after his books were cancelled. Issues 1 and 2 adapted pulp stories, while 3 and 4 were new tales. Dc again picked up the rights from Conde Nast, who controlled the Shadow and Doc Savage. The original pulp series wasn't long lived, as there were only 24 Avenger pulps, plus 5 short stories, in Clues Detective. Warner Paperback Library picked up reprint rights, in the 70s and published the originals, plus 12 new novels, by Ron Goulart. I had the bulk of the series, after discovering them in a used book store, in Columbia, SC. I only read the first one, before putting them in storage, with other things, and eventually getting rid of them. It wasn't quite as exciting as The Shadow or Doc Savage, or the Spider, in the pulps and that is part of why it never succeeded in comics, either.
|
|
|
Post by commond on Jun 6, 2024 4:09:47 GMT -5
Justice, Inc. was a spinoff in the sense that Helfer and Baker brought back an "updated" version of the character in The Shadow #17-18 and then the same creative team did the prestige series.
|
|
|
Post by codystarbuck on Jun 6, 2024 11:28:14 GMT -5
Justice, Inc. was a spinoff in the sense that Helfer and Baker brought back an "updated" version of the character in The Shadow #17-18 and then the same creative team did the prestige series. I think I would label that more "in the style of," or "the same approach as...". To me, "spin-off" implies that it grew out of the previous work or was launched within that work, like the tv series Laverne & Shirley originating in Happy Days, or the Flashman series picking up the story of Harry Flashman, from Tom Brown's Schooldays.
|
|
|
Post by Calidore on Jun 6, 2024 12:49:51 GMT -5
Justice, Inc. was a spinoff in the sense that Helfer and Baker brought back an "updated" version of the character in The Shadow #17-18 and then the same creative team did the prestige series. I think I would label that more "in the style of," or "the same approach as...". To me, "spin-off" implies that it grew out of the previous work or was launched within that work, like the tv series Laverne & Shirley originating in Happy Days, or the Flashman series picking up the story of Harry Flashman, from Tom Brown's Schooldays. "Backdoor pilot" maybe?
|
|
|
Post by codystarbuck on Jun 6, 2024 13:06:14 GMT -5
I think I would label that more "in the style of," or "the same approach as...". To me, "spin-off" implies that it grew out of the previous work or was launched within that work, like the tv series Laverne & Shirley originating in Happy Days, or the Flashman series picking up the story of Harry Flashman, from Tom Brown's Schooldays. "Backdoor pilot" maybe? Yeah; but that would imply that The Avenger appears in a Shadow story, which is not the case. More like, "From the team that brought you The Shadow, comes Justice, Inc!" "Another Andrew Helfer/Kyle Baker production!"
|
|
|
Post by commond on Jun 6, 2024 15:53:19 GMT -5
Justice, Inc. was a spinoff in the sense that Helfer and Baker brought back an "updated" version of the character in The Shadow #17-18 and then the same creative team did the prestige series. I think I would label that more "in the style of," or "the same approach as...". To me, "spin-off" implies that it grew out of the previous work or was launched within that work, like the tv series Laverne & Shirley originating in Happy Days, or the Flashman series picking up the story of Harry Flashman, from Tom Brown's Schooldays. Well, the preview certainly sets it up as a spinoff... "By the time you met him in the pages of The Shadow"... "the critically acclaimed team that reintroduced us to The Avenger in The Shadow." In the Shadow series, he's an old man, but the mini-series is set in 1948. Apparently, it's quite good according to this CBR review -- Collect This Now! Justice Inc.
|
|
|
Post by commond on Jun 6, 2024 16:18:54 GMT -5
DC Direct Currents #13 (Books shipping in February, 1989)Hey, it's Justice League Europe! Despite being a huge Justice League International fan (then and now), I only ever read Justice League Europe casually. I was quite loyal to the core titles in those days (Uncanny X-Men, Amazing Spider-Man, etc.) and seldom collected the other books. From what I recall, the early issues of Justice League Europe were quite good. Inside, DC are bringing back The Phantom, since they appear to bringing back literally everything. Luke McDonnell is on art. Not sure if he's a good fit for The Phantom, but it would be interesting to see. There's a Jim Starlin project called Gilgamesh II, which Starlin actually draws. Hero Hotline looks like a comedy book, and The Private Files of The Shadow collects the Denny O'Neil and Mike Kaluta stories with a brand new 15 page story by Kaluta. In this month's Secret Origins, there's a Grant Morrison Animal Man story I've never read. I always glossed over Secret Origins as a kid. I wonder how much good stuff I've missed out on. DC Currents is putting a shipping disclaimer on the books now. This month's interview is with Kurt Schaffenberger, who is inking the Hero Hotline series. He has an interesting life story having immigrated to the US from Germany in 1927. By this time, he had worked in comics for 48 years. Nice to see him get some recognition even if it's just a free leaflet. The cover of the month is Starlin's Gilgamesh II. The back cover is Justice League of America #1 from 1960.
|
|
|
Post by badlydrawnkano on Jun 6, 2024 16:36:23 GMT -5
I was a huge Animal Man fan so picked up that Secret Origins, but I remember very little about it (unlike the main series, which I reread in 2020 and loved more than ever). There's a fairly decent Batman's villains issue from around this time which contained a bunch of stories by Neil Gaiman, and a couple of issues which told the origin stories of various Justice League members.
On the JLE front, as with JLI, I was a big fan at first, but after about twenty issues it began running out of steam, and the core group never seemed to work as well as those in the main title.
|
|
|
Post by codystarbuck on Jun 6, 2024 16:54:15 GMT -5
I quite Liked Justice League Europe, it was different enough from JLI, while still providing similar entertainment and Bart Sears, who had worked on the Hero Alliance graphic novel and single issue from Wonder Comix (which was part of the mix of companies that Scott Rosenburg was funding, which evolved into Malibu.) on the art. His art had faults, including the butchest looking Power Girl ever; but, I would take it over the Image crew any day.
I bought the Shadow HC...finally, able to get my hands on Kaluta's work, in one go.
The Phantom was really good. Joe Orlando handled the mini-series, which tested the waters, with Peter David writing. The regular series was written by Mark Verheiden, who had come over from Dark Horse, where he had written Aliens and The American. He was a greatly underrated writer, in comics, who did quite well in television and film. Luke McDonnell had the right kind of moody line that worked well, with The Phantom. It wasn't Don Newton or Jim Aparo, but it was vastly better than the brief Marvel attempt and I would rate it better than the Wolf comics stuff that followed, from Australia. They also depicted a more modern Africa, which made for a nice change from the stereotypical. Of course, they had to answer to King Features and it lasted just over a year. Mandrake turned up for the wedding of the Phantom and Diana Palmer, just as he did in the strips.
Not sure of DC had the license for Mandrake or not (didn't publish any comics, aside from the cameo, in the final Phantom issue). Flash Gordon was the same time and the three properties had just been part of the Defenders of the Earth cartoon and Marvel had a 4 issue tie-in, for that, in 1987. Kind of surprised that DC didn't try for Prince Valiant, given some of the talent they had working for them, at the time (Jan Dursema would have been perfect).
I bought Gilgamesh II, both for Starlin on art and because of the tie-in to the myth: but, it was a bit of a disappointment, at the time. I haven't read it since it was originally published, so I don't really recall why. Ought to look at it again.
Secret Origins had some real gems in there and it could rise above Roy Thomas continuity fixes. The Manhunter issue, during Millennium, was one of the few good things associated with that mess (aside from Suicide Squad and the crossover issues between it, Captain Atom, Spectre and Detective comics, all of which took place in the swamp setting that week). They did a cute little story that revealed that Rex The wonder Dog was related to Pooch, the dog that accompanied Gunner and Sarge (before they were part of The Losers). The Ape issue is good and the Doom Patrol one was very good and did a lot to reintroduce them to a modern audience.
|
|
|
Post by codystarbuck on Jun 6, 2024 17:01:40 GMT -5
ps Here is a sample page from issue 1 of the regular series.....
|
|
|
Post by commond on Jun 6, 2024 17:07:34 GMT -5
That Phantom page looks good. I haven’t read much Phantom despite the Australian comics being ever present during my childhood.
|
|