|
Post by zaku on Apr 28, 2017 5:18:30 GMT -5
Superman 300, June 1976, "Superman, 2001!" A surprisingly good collaboration by Bates, Maggin!, Swan, & Oskner. This would've been very easy to mess up, but instead, it keeps what's central to the Superman mythos & adds new & interesting twists, making it every bit as good as the best of the 1990s "Elseworlds" Superman tales. Inspiring. 4/5 stars. Reprinted in Superman: Past and Future. Eh! I liked this one!
|
|
|
Post by wildfire2099 on Jun 16, 2017 19:26:11 GMT -5
So I got some Bronze Age Superman books cheap to save shipping on one of the Scalphunter lots I bought.. .I came here to see what Scott said about them, but apparently it's just after he stopped... so Superman #318 So telepathic space dogs are keeping a woman dressed as a pirate alive with their telekinetic powers.. they can apparently alter her cellular structure, but can work space ship controls. Yeah... when I type that it sounds silly, but it was actually a pretty good story that felt like it would be a fun 60s sci fi short story if Superman wasn't in it. It sorta felt like a life lesson for the big guy. Back in Metropolis.. Lana Lang is brought in to be his TV anchor co-host, so we get some flashbacks there. #322 Parasite has drained Superman of his powers, and has control of the space laser defense system, and is planning on destroying Metropolis if he doesn't get ONE BILLION DOLLARS. This one was clearly the final part of a 2 or 3 parter, but it was pretty clear what was going on. Oh, and Solomon Grundy was involved too in a very head scratching way. This one was a good example of a silly Superman story (at one point he dives into the ocean to push the Earth out of orbit so the laser misses, then puts it back.. while not being at full strength).. #318 was way better. Funnily enough, this issue has the letters from #318, which were very mixed... a couple people liking the seriousness, others critizing the terrible science. Not much character stuff, except at the very end with Lois (the letter page claims they'll be a wedding for the 40th anniversary.. for real. I assume Earth 2, or some other multi-verse sheninigans happened?) Talk about the worst present ever.. a ring that shows what you really want to happen? No relationship could survive that.
|
|
|
Post by wildfire2099 on Jun 22, 2017 7:40:15 GMT -5
#327 Superman Vs. Kobra Kobra 'the deadliest man alive' has a plot, and Superman has to stop him. It's pretty convoluted, and calls back to a few issues ago, when Superman stopped a runaway plane with a neurotoxin in it. Kobra apparently was scouring Metropolis with sand from the bottom of the sea to get the bits of toxin off the dust from the buildings and reconstituting it. Superman comes in because Kobra needs him to collect the sand back up after he covers Metropolis with it. He snatches Ma and Pa Kent from the past to blackmail him with. Superman does a bunch of ridiculous, silver age things to foil him. In the back up, 'Mr. and Mrs. Superman' survive a couple assassination attempts moving into their new apartment (seemingly a continuation of the Earth 2 wedding in Action a bit back.) The hook is Lois is the one that has to come up with the secret identity excuses, which is kinda fun.
|
|
|
Post by dbutler69 on Jun 24, 2020 14:19:27 GMT -5
Superman #292: Ah, a nice yellow cover. The story inside is interesting as well. Lex escapes from prison and battles Superman. Superman wins, of course. While he's rebuilding everything that was wrecked during their fight, Superman reminisces about the friendship he and Lex used to have when he was Superboy. Essentially, this issue is an extended origin story for Lex, as told by Superman. We find out they used to be pals, but then Lex lost his hair in an accident and turned heel, vowing to kill Superboy. Seems like an overreaction. Actually, seems like he suffered brain damage in the explosion, honestly. And... that's it! More on this in my notes below. THE END! In the Private Life of Clark Kent backup, Clark seriously violates his journalisitc ethics in order to protect his secret identity. He goes to a bar to meet an informant about a scoop. At the bar, a thug challenges him to a fight. Clark recognizes the thug as the guy his informant sold out and sent to prison. So he hems and haws until the informant shows up, then he rigs it so they fight each other while he ducks out. Talk about a jackass move. The thug beats the crap out of his informant as well; the informant has to be taken into protective custody to save him, meaning Clark doesn't even get the story out of it. All he does is save his own stupid hide. What a jackass. My Grade: B-. The lead was actually better than the backup for once. I'm finally making my way through some Bronze Age Supermans and randomly decided to start here. I agree that the lead story was very good, and your brain damage theory is quite interesting. I've always had trouble buying the idea that Lex was this great guy and this one incident turned him so evil and made him hat Superman so much. It just doesn't wash, for me. The backup story wasn't great by any means, but I didn't dislike it as much as you did.
|
|
|
Post by dbutler69 on Jun 24, 2020 14:23:01 GMT -5
Superman #293: A guy at STAR Labs messes up an experiment, which happens a lot. I'm starting to think those guys at STAR labs aren't all that great at this science stuff. Anyway, the upshot is that everyone in Metropolis develops a sudden pathological fear of water. They all become wicked thirsty as a result. Superman decides the only way to save everyone is to put the whole city to sleep with sleeping gas. When everyone wakes up the next day, the fear is gone, as the effects have worn off. All of this is observed by a bunch of time travelers from the future who have come back in time to figure out the mystery of "Thirsty Thursday." They go back to their own time periods, all still stumped. THE END! My Grade: B-. The water plot was dopey, but the time traveler stuff led to some funny bits. Yeah, I thought this one was pretty dopey. Superman's solution was t put everybody to sleep? Wouldn't all of the drivers crash? What about a doctor in the middle of surgery? The people in the future in these Superman stories have some ridiculously advanced technology.
|
|
|
Post by dbutler69 on Jun 24, 2020 14:29:56 GMT -5
Superman #294: A guy named Brain-Storm, who apparently is a JLA villain, uses his super helmet to wish away all the inhabitants on Earth. Only Superman and Clark Kent are left. Brain-Storm seemingly murders Clark, then explains to Superman quite helpfully, and in some detail, that he needed everyone gone so he could absorb the power of a quasar without everyone else interfering. It actually does make slilghtly more sense when he explains it. Anyway, he's about to do just that when he sees Clark, alive and well! Since that will mess up his plan, he attacks Clark, but can't seem to kill him! Because he's Superman. Caught off guard, Brain-Storm is defeated and Superman forces him to return everyone to Earth. THE END! In the Private Life of Clark Kent, Clark is kidnapped by a crook who switches clothes with him to pose as Clark Kent. Clark does some super speed stuff and swallows his costume! Clark then manages to fake out the crook's assistant by pretending to be the crook. He stalls long enough for the cops to show up and arrest the real crook. As for the swallowed costume, Clark assures us that "everything will come out all right." My Grade: C+. That is a mental image I did not need to have. As Michael Kors would say: The lead story had some hokey "science" but was fun. I think I'll be saying that about a lot of these stories. Goofy, but fun, as long as you cal roll with the goofiness. I'd call the tattoo switch impossible, but hey, it's Superman.
|
|
|
Post by dbutler69 on Jun 24, 2020 14:32:37 GMT -5
Superman #295: I hate to say this, because it sounds completely absurd, but... this issue was actually interesting. A guy calling himself "Father Time" attacks Superman. But what he really wants is... superman's costume! He manages to get it. Superman then tracks the costume, only to find that it's somehow in the 30th century! And it isn't the 30th century he knows, with the Legion of Super-Heroes and everything, but rather a desolate, ruined Earth. Superman travels there and discovers a guy named Jaxon wearing his stolen costume. They fight each other, and we realize that Jaxon a) has most of Superman's powers and b) didn't get the costume from Father Time, but rather from... the animal people who previously ruled the world! Yes, Superman is in Kamandi's timeline! Only, he's in Kamandi's future, a future where humanity has risen again thanks to Jaxon. The two of them keep fighting, but as they do, the barriers of time break down. Jaxon and the others disappear and Father Time shows up again. He explains that he's actually the Green Lantern of Sector 2814 - from the 30th century. And he's set this up in order to escape a plot by the LSH villain Time Trapper, who was trying to erase the LSH by shifting Earth to Kamandi's timeline instead, where the LSH doesn't exist. THE END! My Grade: B+. The continuity juggling in this issue is impressive, picking up the "Superman's costume" thread from Kamandi #29 and interweaving it with LSH stuff. Very interesting! I dunno. I thought this story was just plain weird. But yeah, it was kinda interesting, and the way you explain it makes me like it more, actually.
|
|
|
Post by dbutler69 on Jun 24, 2020 14:39:24 GMT -5
Superman #296: I'm going to discuss this in some length in the notes section, because this is - somewhat unexpectedly, I think, and probably not entirely by design - a watershed issue for Superman and the Superman line of comics. But for now, let's just do the synopsis. Another alien agent shows up on Earth. We see him settle in many years ago, when Clark was still Superboy. Now, in the present, he's finally ready to make his move. He does... something... that causes Superman to develop a strange split personality: He now only has his powers when he's in his Superman costume. If he's wearing anything else at all, he has no powers and is just Clark Kent. He barely survives a few encounters, including an attack by an Intergang robot, and starts to think he might need to make a decision: Either Clark or Superman full time. But both just no longer works. Meanwhile! We learn that the alien has been hired to destroy Earth, and somehow he's planning to use Superman to accomplish this. TO BE CONTINUED!! My Grade: B+. Much more below. Yeah, I thought this one was great! Very intriguing. I haven't read a ton of Superman stories so the alien using an unwitting Superman as his weapon isn't as familiar to me. This story had its goofy elements, but was a lot of fun (there I go saying that again) and I found the ending compelling. I was surprised to see a multi-part story in a 70's Superman comic and I couldn't wait to read the next issue!
|
|
|
Post by dbutler69 on Jun 24, 2020 14:54:59 GMT -5
Superman #297: Finally! This is the story I've been waiting for all along! After foiling an Intergang plot, Superman decides he can't keep on like this, so he decides to try being Clark Kent for a full week without turning into Superman. His resolve is sorely tested when there's a disaster in the subway, but the quick response of the fire and police departments assure him that he can stay as Clark - and maybe people don't really need him as much as he thought anyway. This is a different Clark, though: Without the need to protect his secret identity, he can stop pretending to be a milksop. Things change immediately. First he decks Steve Lombard, then he tells off Morgan Edge, resulting in Clark getting a raise! Lois is taken by the confident new Clark - and two embark on a whirlwind love affair! And Metropolis does just fine; even a near riot is calmed when Gregory Reed, the actor who sometimes doubles for Superman, shows up as Superman and calms everyone down. Clark realizes he still has unfinished business with Intergang, though, so he has Professor Pepperwinkle whip up some high tech gadgets. Clark uses them to infiltrate an Intergang hideout, take out the bad guys and steal evidence proving their latest plot against Superman. Everything is going perfectly... except the alien agent uses this down time to steal some alien artifacts from Clark's apartment. Artifacts that will allow the alien to destroy the world! To Be Continued!! My Grade: A++. World's Finest #236: Bear with me, guys. A dude falls ill, then a girl does. Superman uses his supervision to discover they are infected with infinitesimal humanoid monsters, which are attacking their cells! The only hope: Shrink down, jump into the blood stream and dump poison on them. Obviously. Duh. Science. For some reason, Superman says he can't be shrunk down small enough to deliver the poison, so he gets the Atom to do it. Even the Atom can't shrink as small as they need to, so they come up with an ingenious plan: Superman will smash him so hard he breaks down to a molecular level, then they will inject him, and somehow a centrifuge will put him back together again. Or something. You know what, don't ask. Atom doesn't ask until it's too late - they give him a big explanation about how Superman's super clap will create a force field that will protect him, blah blah blah. Either that... "or obliterate you." Atom's like, wait, what? Than Superman obliterates him! But through apparently random chance, he survives. They inject him into the body and he does his Fantastic Voyage thing. But when he comes to the mite-monsters, they trap him and defeat him! Meanwhile, the world's greatest detective gets bored, so he decides to try and find how these people got sick. Turns out it's from a space rock - which seems to happen an awful lot in the DCU. When he traces it back, though, he realizes the carrier is actually the disease and the mite-monsters are actually alien antibodies trying to save the victims! He fights the carrier - who somehow has become Miss Gotham City - and she falls onto the third rail, transforming back into a giant alien cockroach thing. He rushes back, gives the news to the others and they rescue Atom. Then allt he sick people just get better. THE END!!! My Grade: H+. This is pure Haney at his Haniest. Yes, this Superman issue was really good and yeah, I already feel sorry for Lois because I know things are going to go back to the status quo when this story arc is over. As far as World's Finest, this was the first superhero comic I ever owned, so I am going to give this a pass. I'll admit that Bob Haney has written more insane comics than anybody, but I have to put this one in the "goofy, but fun" category. Plus, I loved the Dick Dillon art.
|
|
|
Post by dbutler69 on Jun 24, 2020 14:58:35 GMT -5
Superman #298: You knew this was coming after last issue, where Superman decided to spend his time exclusively as Clark Kent. Now, he decides to try it the other way - becoming just Superman 24 hours a day. He discovers that people expect a lot from Superman; now he has no time to unwind, and even his friends are constantly demanding that he rush off to one disaster or another. However, he also realizes this is necessary, after a crazy supervillain nearly blows up Metropolis. he's made up his mind - he knows what has to be done! But will it be in time? After all, that alien agent has stolen even more data from Superman's apartment, and is now ready to destroy the Earth... My Grade: B. Not quite as compelling as last issue, and most of what Superman experiences suggests he needs to be Clark more than Superman. Team Clark! I did like the implication here that Superman needs Clark, perhaps as much as the world needs Superman. I'm still interested to see what the alien's plan is to "assassinate earth" and having seen the cover to #299, I'm wondering if all of those Superman foes will really appear in the issue!
|
|
|
Post by dbutler69 on Jun 25, 2020 8:27:19 GMT -5
February, 1976
Superman #299: This gets confusing, so I'll try to keep it as simple as possible. Clark's neighbor/alien has set it up so that Superman has become a living bomb, and when he exerts enough energy, he'll blow up the whole planet. To get him to exert that much energy, the alien teleports his 9 deadliest villains into his apartment, then beams them around the world. Superman chases them down and defeats them all so easily you have to wonder what the big problem usually is. He figures out the alien's plot, too, and realizes that the whole "powerless as Clark Kent" thing is just because all of his business suits have been treated with an alien chemical. Well, that's pretty pedestrian. Superman captures the alien, and with the powerless thing no longer an issue, he decides to keep living his double life, because he is both Clark Kent - and Superman! THE END! My Grade: C. Kind of a boilerplate Superman adventure, which is a letdown, but not a surprise. Notes: The ending to this big three part Superman story was depressingly status quo. It started with so much promise, but they had to just go back to standard operating procedure. And the defeat of his 9 biggest enemies in about four minutes flat really made them all look like incompetent saps. And, by extension, Superman, given his usual struggles against each of them. I don't think this served anyone well. Also... so, Clark's neighbor teleports 9 of Superman's deadliest archenemies, including Brainiac and Lex Luthor, into Clark Kent's apartment. And none of them are curious enough about this sudden kidnapping to even explore the room? And thereby learn Superman's secret identity? Is Terra Man really that enthralling of a conversationalist? Your review of Superman #299 is spot on. I really enjoyed the first three parts of this story, so I was disappointed in the conclusion. They also didn't really explain how Superman using his superpowers is going to destroy the earth, but I imagine that's typical for a Superman story of this era. Also, like you, I was struck by how quickly and easily Superman defeated nine of his toughest foes. It would be tough to take any of them seriously again after this.
|
|
|
Post by brutalis on Jun 25, 2020 8:43:57 GMT -5
Starting around issue 300 is when I would pick up the occasional Superman issues when flipping through comics at the rack. When I had a few extra nickels or had already purchased my regular go to series, Superman and Batman and Wonder Woman were my 3 DC alternatives from my regular Marvel haul. It would depend upon several things for me buying an issue, mostly from flipping through and seeing if the story had enough occurring for me to invest my money and second was the artist inside. Occasionally a cover might be the initial attention grabber but it was usually the one and done stories combined with the always superb Curt Swan or Jose Gonzales-Lopez art inside which had me buy them. Superman was always a bit of a mixed bag during this time, sometimes really fun, others boring, many just plain dumb and others silly. Cannot imagine this version of Superman comics being able to survive in today's market. Back then, it was always a nice diversion, a feel good kind of a comic, like visiting your grandparents feeling: something good to enjoy and remember but not what you wanted to read every day.
|
|
|
Post by dbutler69 on Jun 25, 2020 10:02:51 GMT -5
Starting around issue 300 is when I would pick up the occasional Superman issues when flipping through comics at the rack. When I had a few extra nickels or had already purchased my regular go to series, Superman and Batman and Wonder Woman were my 3 DC alternatives from my regular Marvel haul. It would depend upon several things for me buying an issue, mostly from flipping through and seeing if the story had enough occurring for me to invest my money and second was the artist inside. Occasionally a cover might be the initial attention grabber but it was usually the one and done stories combined with the always superb Curt Swan or Jose Gonzales-Lopez art inside which had me buy them. Superman was always a bit of a mixed bag during this time, sometimes really fun, others boring, many just plain dumb and others silly. Cannot imagine this version of Superman comics being able to survive in today's market. Back then, it was always a nice diversion, a feel good kind of a comic, like visiting your grandparents feeling: something good to enjoy and remember but not what you wanted to read every day. All of what you say is true. It's sort of like a comic version of comfort food. Just turn off the brain and enjoy.
|
|
|
Post by brutalis on Jun 25, 2020 11:46:09 GMT -5
Starting around issue 300 is when I would pick up the occasional Superman issues when flipping through comics at the rack. When I had a few extra nickels or had already purchased my regular go to series, Superman and Batman and Wonder Woman were my 3 DC alternatives from my regular Marvel haul. It would depend upon several things for me buying an issue, mostly from flipping through and seeing if the story had enough occurring for me to invest my money and second was the artist inside. Occasionally a cover might be the initial attention grabber but it was usually the one and done stories combined with the always superb Curt Swan or Jose Gonzales-Lopez art inside which had me buy them. Superman was always a bit of a mixed bag during this time, sometimes really fun, others boring, many just plain dumb and others silly. Cannot imagine this version of Superman comics being able to survive in today's market. Back then, it was always a nice diversion, a feel good kind of a comic, like visiting your grandparents feeling: something good to enjoy and remember but not what you wanted to read every day. All of what you say is true. It's sort of like a comic version of comfort food. Just turn off the brain and enjoy. Indeed, I like a nice bowl of stew or chili or cornbread and beans. Superman in the 70's is like that, very filling and tasty and comforting without fail. A nice reminder of simpler, kinder and happier times found within the world of comic books. When a decent story and good artwork carried the tales without all the BIG events or requiring a year long investment of dragged out plot and filler stories to getting to the point. 1 or 2-3 issues was plenty and you were happy!
|
|
|
Post by zaku on Jun 25, 2020 12:44:13 GMT -5
Starting around issue 300 is when I would pick up the occasional Superman issues when flipping through comics at the rack. When I had a few extra nickels or had already purchased my regular go to series, Superman and Batman and Wonder Woman were my 3 DC alternatives from my regular Marvel haul. It would depend upon several things for me buying an issue, mostly from flipping through and seeing if the story had enough occurring for me to invest my money and second was the artist inside. Occasionally a cover might be the initial attention grabber but it was usually the one and done stories combined with the always superb Curt Swan or Jose Gonzales-Lopez art inside which had me buy them. Superman was always a bit of a mixed bag during this time, sometimes really fun, others boring, many just plain dumb and others silly. Cannot imagine this version of Superman comics being able to survive in today's market. Back then, it was always a nice diversion, a feel good kind of a comic, like visiting your grandparents feeling: something good to enjoy and remember but not what you wanted to read every day. All of what you say is true. It's sort of like a comic version of comfort food. Just turn off the brain and enjoy. The problem is that in the 70s you had Action Comics, Superman, Superman Family, wherever they published Superboy, World's Finest... One can get tired of even the best comfort food if there is too much of it. In hindsight one can choose the best stories in the pile and say they were not bad, but try to imagine having to read month after month another story of how Luthor wants to destroy the world because of his early baldness and how Superman don't know how to decide between Lois Lane and Lana Lang ...
|
|