|
Post by MWGallaher on Dec 21, 2022 11:02:38 GMT -5
I did come up with one theory: Sekowsky did not leave room for credits in any of the usual spots, and judging by several other issues in his run, he didn't favor including credits at all. Looking over the pages of the book, this appears to be the only spot where a credit blurb would fit without significantly disrupting the composition. Maybe Jack Abel, who had already inked several prior issues which he may not have seen in print until working on this issue, realized this was happening (or rather, not happening) and insisted on getting a published credit this time (perhaps going over Sekowsky's head to publisher Carmine Infantino?).
Jack Abel did not ink any more of Sekowsky's remaining Supergirl stories, so this hypothetical insistence on credit may have ticked off the reputedly mercurial Sekowsky.
|
|
|
Post by MWGallaher on Dec 21, 2022 9:16:58 GMT -5
Random trivia question: what item of US currency, currently in circulation, prominently depicts the face of a historical figure with the initials J.B.C. on its front?
|
|
|
Post by MWGallaher on Dec 21, 2022 9:08:15 GMT -5
PHANTOM STRANGER #23, by Jim Aparo: I'm going to assume that this phantom is wearing an opera hat, so that between this and EdoBosnar's entry, we have two out of three of foxley's example alternatives covered. Who's going to step up with the stovepipe variant?
|
|
|
Post by MWGallaher on Dec 21, 2022 7:36:32 GMT -5
4. The HeadmenIf there's one thing I like almost as much as a good story, it's a good puzzle, and Marvel offered up an enticing one when Steve Gerber introduced this bizarre trio (expanded to a quartet as of the above issue): all of these memorably bizarre villains had appeared in the same Marvel comic in the previous year. That should have been easy; how could you miss a blob of a man with shrunken bones, a human with a gorilla body from the neck down, and a mystic?! (Well, Chondu, the mystic, wasn't all that memorable at this stage, but Gerber was going to mess him up real good in the issues to follow? I wish I could say I solved that puzzle, but I didn't, because it turned out that all these guys had appeared in a recent reprint comic, one that I did sometimes buy, but this issue of which I had passed up: Brilliant and devious of Steve Gerber to mine obscure Atlas horror comics to turn the unfortunate souls in a horror anthology into leading villains in a superhero book! It was a harbinger of one of the aspects of mainstream comics I loved in the 80's and 90's: digging up the forgotten characters, the wild ideas, the one-shot shorts and giving them a boost to bring them back into the comics universe. I was hooked on THE DEFENDERS from my first issue, #4, riding that book to the bitter end, but it was never as good as it was when Gerber and Sal Buscema were in charge. The Headmen were just so, so "Defenders" material, it's hard to imagine them being introduced anywhere else. And I dug the theme that united them: something weird involving their head: Arthur Nagan, a guy whose head was transplanted onto an ape body by a tribe of gorillas Chondu, a mystic who soon finds his brain transplanted into an ongoing series of stranger and stranger bodies Jerry Morgan, who developed a means of shrinking himself like Hank Pym, but found that his bones didn't come back to their full size, leaving him with a prominently deflated head Ruby Thursday, a woman with a "head" that is a globe of "organic circuitry" capable of many strange abilities Monstrous, diverse, thematically connected, and, for the time, exclusive to my favorite (non)team, The Headmen are an unforgettable team of super-villains that easily make it into my top echelon for this Christmas celebration. And since I take any opportunity to bring up my favorite obscure writer from the 20th Century, Harry Stephen Keeler introduced the world to the concept of a human brain in a gorilla body in his bizarre masterpiece, Sing Sing Nights, from which three motion pictures were adapted: Sing Sing Nights, The Mysterious Mr. Wong (which shaxper is surely familiar with, as it starred Bela Lugosi!) and, without giving Keeler any credit, The Monster and the Girl, which adapted the Gorilla's Brain segment of Keeler's novel in addition to the framing content Keeler used to link three of his outrageous short stories into a unified structure. (I played a part in bringing one of Keeler's unpublished novels, Strange Journey, to print, by transcribing scan's of Keeler's typewritten pages into Word!)
|
|
|
Post by MWGallaher on Dec 21, 2022 6:29:22 GMT -5
Writer and penciler Mike Sekowsky, so far as I can tell, doesn't have his credits printed for his work in ADVENTURE COMICS #406, but inker Jack Abel does...on page 14?!?!?!
|
|
|
Post by MWGallaher on Dec 20, 2022 9:35:39 GMT -5
5. Dr. Doom and the Sub-MarinerMy first complete series review thread here, Bad Tidings, was devoted to Marvel's mid-70's series, SUPER-VILLAIN TEAM-UP, so how could I not include the leads of that uneven-but-never-uninteresting run here in this year's CCC? You may well argue, as did readers of the day, that Namor didn't merit "super-villain" status, but there's no arguing against the logo, people! Doctor Doom was one of my favorite villains early on. I think my first exposure to him was in MARVEL TRIPLE ACTION #4, the cover logo of which promoted Doom (along with the Thing and the Silver Surfer) as one of the three leads, rather than the Fantastic Four, from whose comic the interior was reprinted. But I've established the significance of logo several times already this year, so even if Doom's billing here wasn't quite as formal as I'd like, it counted in my 12-year-old mind. Namor took a lot longer to grow on me, but he would eventually become one of my favorite Marvel characters, which he remains to this day. The pairing of these two as a highly unstable but menacing team made sense to me, both of them royalty dealing with tragic circumstances. What I found most fascinating was that unlike more carefully calculated teams, this pairing forced together very similar personalities rather than intentionally contrasting ones. Both were haughty, boastful, aggressive men, who should have been in opposition according to their nature, constantly trying to get the upper hand on one another, but men of honor, in their own way, bound by oath, obligated to the letter of their pact. Yes, it was better in concept than in execution, which we could say about many of this year's entries, but in comics, an intriguing concept can often make up for a flawed production, and for me, S-V T-U did just that, thanks to this memorable and menacing match-up!
|
|
|
Post by MWGallaher on Dec 20, 2022 7:40:57 GMT -5
foxley
|
|
|
Post by MWGallaher on Dec 19, 2022 11:00:19 GMT -5
What was Superman's first team-up with another DC hero, excluding Batman and ensemble comics like the JSA and JLA? And for Batman (also excluding Superman and ensemble comics)? It seems way too late to be the case, but the first I can recall is The Flash, in WORLD'S FINEST 198, November 1970. Other characters from the Weisinger editorial wing like Aquaman and Green Arrow showed up as guests (not really team-up partners) here and there before that, but I think Mort kept Superman as isolated as possible, allowing him only in JLA, and not using anyone else's characters in his own subline of Superman Family books. When Mort left, Julius Schwartz took over WF and immediately brought in his boy, The Flash for the first non-Batman/Robin team-up.
|
|
|
Post by MWGallaher on Dec 19, 2022 10:51:23 GMT -5
Roquefort Raider , you got Bushwhacker and Ammo the wrong way round. Bushwhacker is the one can form his arm into a gun, and Ammo is the Village People reject with an eyepatch and blonde dye job. Thanks! All fixed now. Being unfamiliar with any of them, this was pretty confusing, since on that cover, the guy with the gun-arm also had blond hair and a patch over his eye. Evidently the Ammo character doesn't appear on this cover? Anyway, "Ammo" seems like a more appropriate name for the gun-arm guy, so I was really befuddled! Edited to respond to a later post, because I don't want to clutter this thread with too much discussion: --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- I don't know how I missed Ammo on the cover there, but I didn't see him. I wouldn't say this is a poorly composed cover, but somehow that figure just didn't register in my brain.
|
|
|
Post by MWGallaher on Dec 19, 2022 9:09:14 GMT -5
6. Luthor and BrainiacQuite honestly, I'm surprised by this team being on my list, but once it occurred to me it kept sticking around. I'm not a huge Silver Age Superman fan, but I'm almost always entertained by any of those stories, and reprints from that era were a big component of my early comics reading. Whenever this duo teamed up, the stories stuck with me, leaving me with permanent impressions of specific Curt Swan-- always Curt Swan!--panels and splashes. The team almost always elevated a standard Superman story, and that makes it deserving of my high esteem. Given how ridiculously overpowered Superman was, it makes sense that the most promising avenue towards defeating him is brain power, and with Luthor and Brainiac, you're doubling up with two villains whose primary "power" is intelligence. But the pair don't feel superfluous to each other, even in the limited characterizations of the Silver Age. Brainiac must have had the edge in raw intellect, and he had the advantage of countless alien technologies available to him. But these two tended to be more cooperative than competitive in pursuing their goals, something we'd expect of super-intelligent beings. While I can enjoy a good double-cross, it's not something that's in my nature, so I like villains smart enough to see the wisdom in not backstabbing each other. As an AI, Brainiac showed a lot more emotion in the Silver Age than he did in more robotic--that admittedly cooler looking!--later years, but Luthor always seemed to be the more emotionally driven, bringing a critical human venality to the team-ups. Of the two characters, I admit a much greater fondness for Brainiac, right down to those freaky looking interconnected lights on his scalp, but Luthor's never better than when he's got the superintelligent android from Colu as his partner!
|
|
|
Post by MWGallaher on Dec 18, 2022 15:05:59 GMT -5
Sometimes an explanation raises more questions than it answers. Consider this scene from CAPTAIN MARVEL PRESENTS THE TERRIBLE 5 issue 1: This guy's main superpower is to split his body at any joint to transform himself into flying, independently functioning body parts. So what happens to that invisible business suit when his legs and arms and torso are all flying off in different directions? And how comfortable can it be to wear those blue boots underneath the brown dress shoes?
|
|
|
Post by MWGallaher on Dec 18, 2022 9:55:36 GMT -5
7. The Terrible 5The version of Captain Marvel presenting this troop of trademark transgressors was the star of the first superhero comic I ever remember reading and owning, so while it's largely the nostalgic call-back to my roots that earns them their spot here, this comic is fascinating in ways beyond any run-of-the-mill picking from 1966 would be. Myron Fass, of M.F. Enterprises, chose to start his superhero comics line by appropriating what he figured to be defunct trademarks, starting with a biggie, Captain Marvel, the body-splitting robot in a hideous magenta onesie. Riding the camp wave behind tv's Batman, Fass must have concluded that the colorful villains were as big a draw as the caped crusaders, so he quickly spun off this title from the ongoing CAPTAIN MARVEL, highlighting several of the villains already established along with a few new ones. It's really just another issue of CAPTAIN MARVEL, and it includes a recap of Marv's origin and powers for the new readers he hoped would be drawn in by this cringingly non-euphonious title. Fass had, apparently, already been put on warning from DC's lawyers, since the former "Plasticman" was redubbed "Elasticman" as of this issue. That didn't stop him from introducing his own "Dr. Fate", though. The "Dr. Doom" listed on the cover is "Prof. Doom" inside, but I wouldn't assume that Marvel Comics had come calling just yet; more likely, they didn't want two "doctors" in the book. "Tinyman" is Doll Man under a different name, "Atom-Jaw" is essentially Iron Jaw from BOY COMICS. While Prof. Doom only appears in a solo encounter against Marvel, the Terrible Four Out of Five do get together in the rest of the book, although Tinyman quickly bows out of the action, flirting with becoming a superhero himself, as will be seen in later issues. But the Terrible Three Out of Five finally get together. Of course, they're still outnumbered by the hero who can split into as many independent parts as there are joints in the human body, and as the big CCA stamp on the cover demands, all of them face justice in the end. The following (final) issue had a different "Terrible Five", apparently including the now-heroic Tinyman, or else Fass was confident that the readership of this stuff couldn't count that high. That time, the villains included the Ray (formerly the Bat, who had trampled on both Batman's trademark name and visual representation), the Destroyer (a better name for a villain than the then-defunct Marvel superhero, I must admit, Tarzac, who is not a jungle lord but instead a third-rate Sub-Mariner), and Big Max and his Ghost Patrol; apparently Fass had a nice collection of Golden Age comics from which to loot names! None of them teamed up this time around, so it may be pushing things to call "the Terrible 5" a true team, but hey, the logo counts for a lot with me, as I've already established! I'm not trying to convince anyone that these are gems that anyone else would love. I've got a soft spot for this Captain Marvel, and I get a kick out of the jaw-droppingly bad comics that littered the stands over the decades. So here they are!
|
|
|
Post by MWGallaher on Dec 17, 2022 11:40:23 GMT -5
8. The Mud PackPreston Payne was the villain who drew me fully back into DETECTIVE COMICS when Marshall Rogers and Len Wein created the third villain to bear the title of Clayface in 1978. The previous versions hadn't shown up much in either new or reprint form in my 8 years of comics reading, so I don't know how much I knew about them when Alan Grant and Norm Breyfogle brought all of them, along with a new "Lady Clayface", together under the inspired group name of "the Mud Pack". And hey, they got their own logo on the issues of SECRET ORIGINS and DETECTIVE COMICS where they appeared, and I've already established what a level of prestige I always attached to that accomplishment! Clayface is a great name for a supervillain, evocative and sinister and unnerving, but vague enough that it could mean a lot of things, as it in fact did with the variety of evildoers here--a psychotic version of Lon Chaney, a shapeshifting lug, a tragic melting monstrosity with a deadly touch, all wonderful riffs based on a simple phrase. Is this the only supervillain team where everybody has the same code name? I think it is!
|
|
|
Post by MWGallaher on Dec 16, 2022 22:19:00 GMT -5
9. The Un-MenSWAMP THING was the first DC series I got in on from issue 1, and I loved it. Issue 2 brought forth the unforgettable Un-Men. I've seen a zillion horror stories about mad scientists and their "unspeakably obscene" creations, but I don't think anyone ever rendered that description as accurately as Berni Wrightson--these lab-grown abominations were truly freaky, disturbing, unsettling things, and I was mesmerized by this army of distortions, each a drastically different variation on a mix-and-match human form. And decades later, someone else recognized this concept as one worth building an entire series on, with a 13-issue run at Vertigo: Here, a core group of the originals were given distinctive personas, distinguishing them from the horde-like bunch that probably would have skirted the constraints of this year's contest. Monsters were what drew me into comics, and I don't think any other comics monsters ever satisfied my appetite for the horrific quite like these creepy creatures did. Once you see a head-on-a-hand, you never forget it!
|
|
|
Post by MWGallaher on Dec 15, 2022 21:34:03 GMT -5
10. The Forgotten Villains from DC COMICS PRESENTS #77-78 Atom-Master, who took on Superman, Batman, and Robin in WORLD'S FINEST #101! Enchantress, star of her own feature in STRANGE ADVENTURES #187, 191, 200! The Faceless Hunter from Saturn, who menaced humanity in STRANGE ADVENTURES #124,142,153! Kraklow, the ancient wizard who turned Rip Hunter into a "time creature"! Mr. Poseidon, who dared to face the Sea Devils! Ultivac, early foe of the Challengers of the Unknown! Since I was a kid, I considered getting an official logo on the front of a comic as a special honor of formality, a promotion from the minors into the big leagues. That feeling still held sway with me in 1978 1984* when these guys ranked for cover billing alongside Superman, displacing the previously listed co-stars, The Forgotten Heroes, in the second of a two-parter. And I've always gotten a kick out of revivals of long-forgotten characters who held--even if ever so briefly--their own comics features (I'm still waiting for someone to revive Black Brother and Calvin at Marvel!). So how could I not have a soft spot for this resurrection of bottom-of-the-barrel menaces, even if I'd never heard of most of them? But they got a logo, they were now legit in my eyes! Enchantress I knew, from reprints of one or two of her solos in the 48-page era of ADVENTURE COMICS. All the others were ciphers to me, coming into comics when reprints of DC's lesser features like Sea Devils, Challengers, and Rip Hunter were extremely rare. With all the forgotten villains who had littered DC's history, Marv Wolfman went the extra mile by recruiting from the forgotten features, as well! I was delighted! The biggest treat was the Faceless Hunter from Saturn, one of the few menaces to make multiple return appearances in DC's science-fiction anthologies...and I'd always been fond of "faceless" characters like The Question and Red Tornado, don't ask me why! DC must have agreed with me about the logo thing, because this team merited a page in WHO'S WHO, over who knows how many villains that were passed over. We may never see this team again...at least until a new generation searches through the library for more forgotten characters to revive, and the Faceless Hunter shall hunt again! *Thanks for the correction, EdoBosnar! I had the issue number on my mind when I (mis)typed that!
|
|