|
Post by Slam_Bradley on Oct 22, 2023 13:32:09 GMT -5
Bart Simpson’s Treehouse of Horror Spine-Tingling SpooktacularVarious creators, 2001 I got a pretty good buy on the two Omnibus editions of these books, so they are on their way. The Simpsons comics are pretty fun reads, though probably best in small doses over a bit of time.
|
|
|
Post by MDG on Oct 22, 2023 14:48:13 GMT -5
I had a little time over the last two weekends to sit down and re-read Sam Glanzman's A Sailor's Story. I owned the two graphic novels by Marvel where these were originally published back in the 80s, but they really aren't readily accessible and it's nice to have both of them in a single volume with the added material, including a new story by Glanzman and some really nice tributes by folks from the comics world. These two stories were really extensions of Glanzman's U.S.S. Stevens stories that ran as back-ups in DC's war books in the 70s. Glanzman served on the Stevens during World War II and these are really graphic memoirs of his war years on the ship. It's a truly amazing insight into the lives of normal "tin can sailors." Glanzman's diagrams of the ship and of the various sections lead to a lot greater understanding of what the sailors lived through. And while both stories were short enough that you didn't get a great feel for any single sailor (except maybe Sam) you did feel empathy for them, particularly in small way, such as when their mail from home was being transferred from ship to ship and ended up in the ocean, lost forever. I wasn't a reader of war comics as a kid. I have learned to appreciate them much better now, recognizing their strengths and limitations. DC had the advantage of some amazing artists, including Glanzman, Kubert, Russ Heath and Jerry Grandinetti. Yeah, these particular books were done for Marvel, but Glanzman honed his craft as to war comics at DC. Highly recommended...and now I will double down on efforts to get Dover's reprint of the complete U.S.S. Stevens. I'd really like to see Glanzman recognized more as one if the true pioneers of autobiographical comics.
|
|
|
Post by EdoBosnar on Oct 22, 2023 15:09:25 GMT -5
I got a pretty good buy on the two Omnibus editions of these books, so they are on their way. The Simpsons comics are pretty fun reads, though probably best in small doses over a bit of time. I got five of the six paperback volumes for pretty cheap over the past year or so - it's pretty easy to find like-new used copies online, and I've never paid more than the equivalent of a few dollars for each of them. And yeah, I've only read a little of these Simpsons comics so far (the Bartman collection earlier this year and now these Treehouse books). They're indeed enjoyable, but I can see getting a bit tired of them after a while. Although the Treehouse books have a bit more variety given that so many different writers and artists contributed to them.
|
|
|
Post by Slam_Bradley on Oct 22, 2023 15:11:05 GMT -5
I got a pretty good buy on the two Omnibus editions of these books, so they are on their way. The Simpsons comics are pretty fun reads, though probably best in small doses over a bit of time. I got five of the six paperback volumes for pretty cheap over the past year or so - it's pretty easy to find like-new used copies online, and I've never paid more than the equivalent of a few dollars for each of them. And yeah, I've only read a little of these Simpsons comics so far (the Bartman collection earlier this year and now these Treehouse books). They're indeed enjoyable, but I can see getting a bit tired of them after a while. Although the Treehouse books have a bit more variety given that so many different writers and artists contributed to them.
If you get the chance to read Radioactive Man they are pretty great satire of various comic book tropes through the years.
|
|
|
Post by Slam_Bradley on Oct 22, 2023 15:12:16 GMT -5
I had a little time over the last two weekends to sit down and re-read Sam Glanzman's A Sailor's Story. I owned the two graphic novels by Marvel where these were originally published back in the 80s, but they really aren't readily accessible and it's nice to have both of them in a single volume with the added material, including a new story by Glanzman and some really nice tributes by folks from the comics world. These two stories were really extensions of Glanzman's U.S.S. Stevens stories that ran as back-ups in DC's war books in the 70s. Glanzman served on the Stevens during World War II and these are really graphic memoirs of his war years on the ship. It's a truly amazing insight into the lives of normal "tin can sailors." Glanzman's diagrams of the ship and of the various sections lead to a lot greater understanding of what the sailors lived through. And while both stories were short enough that you didn't get a great feel for any single sailor (except maybe Sam) you did feel empathy for them, particularly in small way, such as when their mail from home was being transferred from ship to ship and ended up in the ocean, lost forever. I wasn't a reader of war comics as a kid. I have learned to appreciate them much better now, recognizing their strengths and limitations. DC had the advantage of some amazing artists, including Glanzman, Kubert, Russ Heath and Jerry Grandinetti. Yeah, these particular books were done for Marvel, but Glanzman honed his craft as to war comics at DC. Highly recommended...and now I will double down on efforts to get Dover's reprint of the complete U.S.S. Stevens. I'd really like to see Glanzman recognized more as one if the true pioneers of autobiographical comics. The plus to Glanzman's autobiographical work is that it's actually interesting. I find the vast majority of them to be naval-gazing. But it's not a genre that I much like.
|
|
|
Post by Cei-U! on Oct 22, 2023 15:43:32 GMT -5
The U.S.S. Stevens stories were the only comic book feature my dad made any effort to follow when I was a kid on those rare occasions that a DC war title found its way into my stash. He had served on a vessel much like the Stevens during the war and he said Glanzman really captured the look and feel of those days. Many years later I encountered Glanzman and told him that, which pleased him but didn't surprise him. Many other fans of my age had told him much the same thing.
Cei-U! And, Slam, "naval-gazing?" Really?
|
|
|
Post by EdoBosnar on Oct 22, 2023 15:47:03 GMT -5
If you get the chance to read Radioactive Man they are pretty great satire of various comic book tropes through the years. I've got the hardcover Radioactive Man book; it's been sitting on my shelf (of shame) for longer than any of the other Simpsons books I have. I hope to get to it soon...
|
|
|
Post by Slam_Bradley on Oct 22, 2023 15:51:20 GMT -5
The U.S.S. Stevens stories were the only comic book feature my dad made any effort to follow when I was a kid on those rare occasions that a DC war title found its way into my stash. He had served on a vessel much like the Stevens during the war and he said Glanzman really captured the look and feel of those days. Many years later I encountered Glanzman and told him that, which pleased him but didn't surprise him. Many other fans of my age had told him much the same thing. Cei-U! And, Slam, "naval-gazing?" Really? Was it a typo or did he do it on purpose? I’ll never tell.
|
|
|
Post by EdoBosnar on Oct 23, 2023 2:52:46 GMT -5
And my visits to Bart's treehouse continue with: The Simpsons Treehouse of Horror Fun-Filled FrightfestVarious creators, 2003 These books keep getting better; some of the highlights of this volume – which collects stories from the sixth and seventh issues of the yearly 'Treehouse' specials – include a story called “Homererectus” written and drawn by Troy Nixey, about some late 19th century scientists discovering what they think is the ‘missing link’ in a glacier, but we all recognize as something else: And this great take on chest-bursting aliens, written by Garth Ennis and drawn by John McCrea: And a Wizard of Oz-themed story by none other than Stan Sakai: There’s also a story scripted by Mark Hamill (yep, Luke Skywalker himself), which features a Bizarro Homer (i.e., he’s slim, good-looking and hard-working) and a really fun story by Jim Mahfood, in which demons take over Rod and Tod’s bodies so Flanders, with Homer, Bart and Lisa in tow, take a portal to hell (conveniently located in the Simpons’ basement) to retrieve their souls. I found this bit in particular quite funny (esp. since Styx came up a few months ago in the music notes thread):
|
|
|
Post by spoon on Oct 23, 2023 20:22:53 GMT -5
I read Superman: The Man of Steel vo. 2 & 3 TPBs, reprinting Superman (vol. 2) #1-6, Adventures of Superman #424-429, and Action Comics #584-589. I read some of the Superman and Action Comics issues back when they originally came out, and 1 or 2 more recently. For all except maybe one issue of Adventures, though, this is my first time reading those.
I may end up commenting on specific issues in more detail in Shaxper's post-Crisis thread, although I don't want to derail it too much referencing issues he posted about years ago. It's interesting experience, because some of the Byrne issues are familiar, but the Wolfman/Ordway Adventures is most a new world to me. Even moreso as I've never heard of some characters/groups like The Circle. I tend to like the Byrne stories more, although I admire what Wolfman was going for. There's a bit more focus on real human dynamics and stories. The story in Adventures #429, when Clark learns about Cat Grant's out-of-wedlock child and tries to confront the baby daddy is interesting both in how non-judgmental Clark (and by extension Wolfman) is toward Cat, but also how it reflects upon judgments in society. I just wish the Adventures stories were more dynamic. Ordway is an artist that I like in theory, but in practice, his work often seems workmanlike but not excited. Also, some of the Qurac story hit a wrong note for me. It felt like there was some Orientalism there. Also, if Qurac is a stand-in, at least partially, for Iran, I feel like there's an oversimplification which clashes with Wolfman's attempts to be more nuanced in other ways. And yes, Perry White's son is super-annoying.
I remember the stories from #1 (Metallo), #2 (Luthor investigating the Clark/Supes connection) and #4 (Bloodsport) well from back in the day. One of Byrne's flaws in my opinion is trying to explain things that don't necessarily need a new explanation. Like making Superman's strength especially tied to willpower, like he's a Green Lantern. But I do think the effort on explanation in Superman #2 makes for a clever story - how a man as smart and with the resources of Lex Luthor doesn't figure out that Clark is Superman.
A couple of my favorite stories in these two TPBs were Byrne stories I'd never read before. One is the Host two-parter from Superman #5 and #6. The other is the Demon team-up from Action Comics #587. My opinion on the Action team-ups is mixed. They seem to de-emphasize the involvement of supporting cast, and Byrne really work in the personalities enough of his guest stars to add to their mythos. For example, I'm a fan of this Green Lantern Corps era, but the GLC guest appearance in #589 is lacking the insight or interesting interplay of personalities that I get out of reading Englehart's writing on GLC. But that's a flaw that plagues a lot of team-up books. I like the New Teen Titans story that launched the run, although like Shax (from his review thread), I found the portrayal of Dr. Gundersen and Superman's lecture for him cringey at times.
|
|
|
Post by EdoBosnar on Oct 24, 2023 2:51:10 GMT -5
The Simpsons Treehouse of Horror Hoodoo Voodoo BrouhahaVarious creators, 2006 This fourth volume contains reprints of the eighth and ninth annual ‘Treehouse’ specials, and the quality remains consistent, with stories written and drawn by Ty Templeton (“Night of Nineteen Screams”), Scott Shaw (“Krustine”), Hilary Barta (“The Power Plant of Pain”) and Gary Spencer Millidge (“From Hell and Back or: The Truer Story of Jack the Ripper”), as well as one written by Gail Simone and illustrated by Jill Thompson (“Tales from the Kwik-E Mart”)... ...and two with art by Dan Brereton, the first (“Ring Around the Simpsons”) co-scripted by Ian Boothby... ...and the second (“The Cask of Amontilla-D’oh”) scripted by Paul Dini: As I mentioned in my review of the first book in this series, all of them contain a bunch of extras, like fake movie posters or ads (usually featuring everyone’s favorite Rigellians, Kang and Kodos), costume or trick or treating tips from Bart, Lisa and so forth, or little one, two or three-page shorts, like this one: They’re completely uncredited, and there are no credits for these at the GCD, either – in fact, the GCD has absolutely no information for this specific book. I’m curious as to whether the more recent Treehouse of Horror omnibuses include this material ( Slam_Bradley , when you get yours you should check). I'll close off with this one - from another one of those 'extra' bits - which highlights some almost real-life horror:
|
|
|
Post by EdoBosnar on Oct 26, 2023 14:09:54 GMT -5
The Simpsons Treehouse of Horror Dead Man’s JestVarious creators, 2008 Well, this is my last trip to Bart’s Treehouse, at least for the time being, as I don’t have any of the other reprint books (and don’t think I’ll be getting the omnibuses anytime soon). But in many ways, this is one of the “best for last” situations. Among other things, this volume collects all of the stories in the tenth issue of the annual Bart Simpson’s Treehouse of Horror series, all of which were plotted or ‘conceived by’ famous rock/pop stars, to wit: Rob Zombie, Gene Simmons, Alice Cooper and - Pat Boone. The Rob Zombie story, “House of a Thousand Donuts” was actually scripted and drawn by Ty Templeton, while the Alice Cooper story, “The Legend of Batterface” was scripted by Chris Yambar with art by Bill Morrison and Ken Wheaton. Yambar also scripted the Gene Simmons story, “Bart Simmons, God of Thunder” (art by Tone Rodriguez and Andrew Pepoy). That one has an amusing premise, i.e., that Simmons is actually Bart’s real father, the result of a hook-up with Marge after after a Kiss concert: Otherwise, all of the guest ‘writers’ are characters in their stories to some extent or another, so, for example, Rob Zombie appears as a hitch-hiker in a few panels, while Pat Boone comes in to save the day (or rather, night) by exorcising some demons: My favorites in this book, though, are all from the eleventh issue of Treehouse of Horror, though. They include “Squish Thing” written by Len Wein and drawn by Berni Wrightson... ...a set of interlocking stories under the overall heading “Two Tickets to Heck,” written by Chris Bonham and Steve Ringgenberg, which are homages to the various EC titles of the 1950s, and they include sequences drawn by Angelo Torres, Mark Schultz and John Severin... ...and finally, “The Sub-basement of Dracula,” written by Marv Wolfman and with art by Gene Colan:
|
|
|
Post by Hoosier X on Oct 28, 2023 9:53:16 GMT -5
I finished World’s Finest #232. The last story in this 100-Page Super-Spectacular is “The Composite Superman,” reprinted from WF #142 from 1964. It is absolutely nuts! The Composite Superman outwits Superman, Batman and Robin and basically beats the snot out of them at every turn. They only survive the encounter because his powers are only temporary and he gets amnesia.
And the Composite Superman’s main motive is that he’s a petty, vengeful jerk who’s jealous of Superman. He’s a narcissist who suffers from a severe persecution complex.
It’s a classic of the Silver Age!
|
|
|
Post by EdoBosnar on Oct 28, 2023 12:09:08 GMT -5
Dominique Laveau, Voodoo Child: Requiemwritten by Selwyn Seyfu Hinds, art by Denys Cowan and John Floyd, 2012 I may have left Bart’s Treehouse, but I’m continuing my spooky season reading and this one has been sitting on my shelf for a few years now (another one of those books I picked up for real cheap somewhere). The basic story is set in New Orleans, and initially takes place a few months after Hurricane Katrina devastates the city. The titular Dominique Laveau just finds out that she is in fact a direct descendant of Marie Laveau, the famed 19th century voodoo practitioner (an actual historical figure). In this, though, she and her progeny are voodoo queens who govern a court of witches, houngans and supernatural creatures that keep the peace in the city. And now it’s apparently Dominique’s turn to don that mantle, although there are those who would rather see her dead. There are many elements here that I like: the supernatural aspects with voodoo and the associated loa like Baron Samedi, Papa Legba and Damballah, and vampires, werewolves, etc. as well as the historical aspects, with flashbacks to various points in the 19th century. The attempt to tie in the events of Katrina and comment on the tragic way that the hurricane and its aftermath played out is also quite laudable. And the art is quite lovely (I generally like Cowan’s work): However, the story is a bit choppy – by that I mean there are odd transitions in which you’re really not sure what just happened, and generally there are several points where key events seem to take place off panel and then the various characters later have to explain it., Also, I get the impression that this was probably supposed to be a much longer story, because the story the conclusion seems quite rushed. Overall, I wanted to like this more than I did, as it left me a bit unsatisfied.
|
|
|
Post by Slam_Bradley on Oct 28, 2023 13:07:25 GMT -5
Just finished up “Battle Flag of the Foreign Legion” from Danger Trail #3 by Robert Kanigher and Alex Toth, courtesy of Genius Illustrated: The Life and Art of Alex Toth. Three of the eight pages are reproduced showing Toth’s original art. Just gorgeous work that illustrates Toth’s mantra of “strip away what isn’t necessary and then draw the hell out of the necessary parts. In less than ten years of comics work the dude had become an absolute master.
|
|