|
Post by wildfire2099 on Sept 9, 2016 20:08:10 GMT -5
Invincible Iron Man #13 (Marvel)Script: Brian Michael Bendis. Art: Mike Deodato. I am a big Iron Man fan. I am not a fan of BMB's style of writing. So I picked up this series with some hesitation. I enjoyed the first several issues because I thought Bendis captured Tony's sarcasm well. However I decided to drop the title a few issues ago until I found out this volume would end with #14. So I decided to finish this volume. Last issue was all set up for Riri to be the next Iron Man. This issue begins the process that will lead to Doom being the other Iron Man. I have zero interest in either scenario. All the stuff that had me interested (like MJ being hired) has been pushed to the back burner. On top of that this issue was all a "talking heads" issue. UGH! The one bright spot is the art. Deodato has come along way from the 90's when he was an Image clone. Score: 1/5 story. 4/5 art. Total: 5/10. Yeah, I don't get why they made a big deal about Bendis writing when it's really clear he doesn't actually like Tony Stark. Just think, this is the GOOD Iron Man book.. the other one is pure dreck. I'm hoping the next writer actually has some interest in writing Tony Stark as Tony Stark (maybe Slott, since he's trying hard to turn Peter Parker into Tony Stark) Also, awesome job with the reviews... this is amazing!
|
|
|
Post by wildfire2099 on Sept 9, 2016 20:09:58 GMT -5
I can't quite make it out, who did the cover on that? It almost looks like Francavilla but I can make out the signature just well enough to see it isn't him. It is Deodato. As I said his art has become outstanding in the last 20 years. I agree... I remember back in the peak of the bad 90s he was practically a Liefield clone... he did some really bad Thor and Wonder Woman IIRC... that's been the only bright spot of this Iron Man volume.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 9, 2016 20:21:36 GMT -5
Also, awesome job with the reviews... this is amazing! Thanks. I am hoping more readers will contribute. I am hoping to find my groove writing them. I also think thwhtguardian is doing an amazing job getting this off the ground plus his reviews are what I aspire to. Round of applause for him.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Sept 9, 2016 20:22:15 GMT -5
Yeah, when done right that relationship is a lot of fun to see, that was the only part of the Rebirth issue I enjoyed but it just wasn't enough to get me to come back for another try. I don't have the issue you reviewed here yet (DCBS).. but I know where you guys are coming from.. I really disliked how Dick was made to look inferior to a third rater like Raptor. If they're trying to establish a support cast, fine, but you can't do it at the expense of the main character! My main issue, though, is having him in ANOTHER undercover situation.. that's so not Dick Grayson. I'm hoping after these first two arcs (he seems to get sucked into a Bat-cross over next) they let him connect more to the Titans the the Bat family. I didn't mind the undercover bit...I just hated that it was with the owls and it was so damned dreary and angsty. I hated the Court of Owls to begin with so more of them was a downer but that it wasn't upbeat just killed it for me; it could have been like say Agents of Atlas but it just seemed like it was going to be too dark and without any sense of fun. Wow, no kidding. I mean a lot of what I like about that cover is in the inking and coloring but still I wouldn't have guessed that was him. Was the interior art as good as the cover? Yes.
Wow, that is good. Again I think that its the coloring that really makes it stand out but it's great either way. While the choices for who will be "Ironman" aren't my cup of tea I may need to check this out in trade at least.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 9, 2016 20:31:02 GMT -5
Wow, that is good. Again I think that its the coloring that really makes it stand out but it's great either way. While the choices for who will be "Ironman" aren't my cup of tea I may need to check this out in trade at least. #1-5 were drawn by David Marquez although they looked great. #1-9 were interesting with some cool ideas by BMB (like hiring MJ for marketing). But with #10 I lost interest because it started to be less about Tony & more about Civil War II, Riri & Doom as the next Iron Men.
|
|
|
Post by String on Sept 12, 2016 16:48:23 GMT -5
Skybourne #1 (Boom!)
written & drawn by Frank Cho
Summary: Grace Skybourne, one of three immortal children of the biblical figure Lazarus, is, like her siblings, blessed with near-invulnerability and super-strength as well. She seeks to recover the mystical sword Excalibur through diplomacy at first and then violence at last. She does so only to run afoul of another mystical warrior whose after the famed sword. After an engaging battle, Grace finds a limit to her invulnerability as the sword is taken yet again. Plot: When I read the initial previews of this new mini by esteemed professional Frank Cho, I knew I had to read it. I'm a sucker for anything pertaining to or offering some new twist on Arthurian legends/fables. Tying in the biblical figure Lazarus as the father (after his resurrection) of these children was a nice touch. While I'm familiar with Cho's art, I'm not as familiar with his writing. Here, he presents a straightforward snatch and grab story with Excalibur as the loot in question only to have the job go sideways when someone new puts their hat in the ring for the sword. Grace's personality so far is equally straightforward, she's immortal, invulnerable, super-strong and she knows it. The violence herein is quite graphic but expected for someone with these abilities. There are the usual vague questions about who does Grace work for? Why do they (or her) want Excalibur? And who is the mysterious mystic warrior and what does he want with the sword? Then there are Grace's siblings, Thomas and Abraham. Thomas appears at the beginning but the rest of the story focuses on Grace. Abraham remains a mystery. It's not too complex but the first part of this serial is decent and interesting. Art: Terrific, clean, dynamic, it's what one would expect from Cho. Marcio Menyz's coloring makes the action (and gore) vibrant. Plot: 6/10 Art: 8/10 Overall: 7/10
Would I come back next issue: Being a five issue mini helps and Cho has laid out an interesting overall mystery with the Skybourne children. Do they all want the same thing/result? If not, why not? There's a good dynamic here and the touches of Arthurian and Christian imagery is enough for me to want to check out the next issue.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 12, 2016 17:04:42 GMT -5
Thanks string ! Great review. You piqued my interest. I am going to look for this book.
|
|
|
Post by String on Sept 12, 2016 17:16:39 GMT -5
Uncanny X-Men #12 (Marvel)
written by Cullen Bunn art by Greg Land
Summary: Psylocke and Sabertooth learn of Magneto's involvement with the Hellfire Club as he seeks to use them as part of his plans to safeguard mutants against the deadly Terrigen Mists and the rising surge of Inhumans. To show this, Erik lets Betsy in on what the Club has learned about the Someday Corporation, a entity whose public image is one of wanting to help those mutants fearful of being infected and possibly dying by the Mists by putting them into cryogenic sleep till the Mist crisis is resolved. Betsy sees firsthand when she leads the other X-Men (Sabertooth and Monet) in a covert assault on a Someday Corporation site that the company is actually brainwashing and weaponizing these mutants for some yet unknown purpose. Plot: Bunn acknowledges in broad strokes past canon which is always a good thing. This new Inner Circle of the Hellfire Club is different from past incarnations. While Sebastian Shaw is present and Erik is the new White King, we also have Monet as the new White Queen (ooh, how that must sit with Emma given their past history!) and Black Tom Cassidy, who makes a most welcome return to the forefront as the new White Bishop. Bunn also acknowledges his previous work in Magneto's last solo title with the return of Briar Raleigh as the new Black Bishop. Bunn's main strength continues to be his characterization. Throughout this run, he has built up the working partnership of Erik and Betsy and here, it's put to a big test as Betsy learns of one of Erik's (many) ongoing plans in fighting this new guerilla war against Inhumans. Her resolve is tested as it seems that Magneto is often right in what he is doing (as seen with this revelation about Someday), something she finds troubling. Art: With Greg Land, you basically know what you are going to get. Interesting poses, close-ups and yes, something akin to realism. But it also backfires when it's hard to distinguish between characters, in this instance, Betsy and Monet. It's a mixed bag of good and imperfect moments. Plot: 7/10 Art : 6/10 Overall: 7/10
Would I come back next issue: Bunn has been steadily building upon this storyline so this title may not be the easiest to just jump onto with this issue. But it's worth investigating for Bunn has consistently had (so far) good drama and characterization and the action has been good too. Land's art, depending on it's relative quality, is the only real factor that may hinder or draw down this title. Otherwise, if you're a passing X-fan, check out one of the more solid titles in the X-line. As for me, based on the continuing level of intrigue and drama, I'll be back next issue.
|
|
|
Post by dupersuper on Sept 13, 2016 13:07:53 GMT -5
Aquaman #6 (DC)
Script: Dan Abnett. Art: Brad Walker & Andrew Hennessey. The Conclusion of The Drowning. Basically the USA is at war with Atlantis. Mera & Aquaman are on the run trying to figure out what is happening & trying to stop the war. The US government sends Superman to try & get Aquaman to stop Atlantis. Superman ends up trusting Aquaman to make the situation right. Obviously this new organization NEMO is manipulating events to cause chaos. Manta kills the leader of NEMO & is now in control. Of course we have the usual misunderstanding & Superman, Aquaman & Mera fight. I really like Abnett's writing here & on Titans. He "gets" the characters voices. I don't think this is the greatest Aquaman story but it is one of the better ones. I did like how Aquaman "vented" about being the black sheep of the JLA. The art is OK. I am not crazy with this style of art. I like Briones style more. Although there was a great scene where Aquaman told the Atlantean military to stand down. Score: 4/5 script. 3/5 art. 7/10 overall. I realize Supes wasn't really fighting back, but I still find the idea of Aquaman and Mera being able to knock him about at all just silly. Also, Arthur seemed to be talking to Superman like an old colleague, but he barely knows this Superman.
|
|
|
Post by String on Sept 13, 2016 13:49:59 GMT -5
Justice League #4 (DC)
written by Bryan Hitch art by Jesus Merino
Summary: The Kindred, an ancient alien force of unknown origin and purpose, continues their extinction-level assault upon the Earth and humanity, stretching the League to their upper limits in trying to stop them. Wonder Woman, trapped within one of the Kindred giants, tries to maintain a dialogue with these aliens while showing resolution that the League will stop them if they continue this attack. Flash maintains his efforts to halt the Kindred's tech creatures attacks globally. Meanwhile, Batman seeks out Cyborg, who suffered a massive attack from those same creatures and comes away with some new insights into their methods and purpose. Batman feels it's time to move on to the next step, feeling Superman has failed in his attempt to stop the deadly machines who are causing devastating worldwide earthquakes from deep within the Earth's core. Lois bravely talks him into trusting her husband, who we see has discovered a way to destroy these infernal machines but does he have the strength and resolve to finish the mission? Aquaman feels he may have the answer to this crisis and off in space, the two Green Lanterns reach the supposed alien world that's the source of this invasion and make a disturbing discovery.... Plot: With this title and his previous JL work, I think Hitch has done rather well with this team and characters. The Justice League should face the gravest of threats and emergencies and Hitch has provided a massive one here with the Kindred, aliens who apparently have had some previous ties to humanity at some point in the distant past. It takes a bit of juggling to give all these characters their proper due face time but Hitch has done well with the pacing, with each issue, moving each character's individual storyline forward. He's also done well with the new dynamics of this team, especially with Superman. Wonder Woman and Flash may trust this 'new' Superman but Batman doesn't. He's hesitant over involving him yet can't deny that his power is needed in facing this severe threat. Batman wants Clark to prove himself while Clark simply wants to help stop this menace. Here, Lois' defense of needing to trust Clark when Batman is ready to quit on him is handled very well. Plus, the rookie GLs, Simon and Jessica, come off better as a partnership than they do in their solo GL title. Last, this story just feels epic, like any proper JL story should. Art: Merino's art matches the epic feel of the story. His character work is strong and graceful especially his facial work. The determination on Diana's face, the fear and shock from Victor, but really the sheer grit on Clark's face as he pushes himself to his own super limits. From the backyard of the Kent household to the vastness of an alien world, Merino encompasses it all with terrific style. Plot: 7/10 Art: 8/10 Overall: 7/10
Would I come back next issue: Hitch is pushing the team to their limits, the threat is exotic and menacing, and the art properly supports the scope of the story. How will the League stop this? I'm eager to find out.
|
|
|
Post by String on Sept 13, 2016 14:06:35 GMT -5
I loved Superman #6. Great ending to this initial story arc, the focus on Clark and Jon's relationship, it held strong emotional depth amidst all the punching and hitting. Gleason's art was great, the shot of Clark standing in front of the restored Lunar module with the American flag behind him, very inspiring. The ending was great too with Jon's reveal. Plus, now we know that with 10 billion dollars, you too can have a Batcave of your own, even on the moon. Supergirl #1 was very interesting. Yes, the elements of the Danvers and the DEO feel forced because of the show but Orlando does a good job of weaving these elements into the book, showing Kara's adjustment to her new life contrasted by her former life on Krypton. Given the youthful elements of the book, Ching's art feels like a natural fit, capturing that youthful exuberance within his line strokes. It definitely added to the overall enjoyment of the book. Daredevil #11, I'm not so sure about. There seemed to be a lot of exposition here although seeing the focus back on Matt's ADA job is nice (also how it pertains to this new mystery). It seems strange me though why this man would be allowed to have a gallery show of a painting mural that is clearly connected to a series of murders. Shouldn't this painting be classified as evidence instead? The inclusion of the Inhumans raises the stakes now. Matt's conversation with Foggy (few that they have been in this run so far) was good though I feel Soule needs to soon reveal just how Matt resolved his secret identity problem. But yes, that last page, very creepy. Invincible Iron Man #13 will have to wait till my copy arrives in the mail. Though I can relate to others' feelings of how Riri and Doom have somewhat stolen the limelight from Tony under Bendis' handling. Being a major player in CW II and now having reached his tie-in issues with that event, I don't foresee the situation getting any better anytime soon.
|
|
|
Post by wildfire2099 on Sept 13, 2016 20:09:37 GMT -5
I didn't like Hitch's first JLA (the pre-rebirth one).. I felt like he was trying too hard to make his villains be threatening by having the heroes be really, really dumb. Has that gotten better? With Superman, Wonder Woman, Flash, and TWO Green Lanterns on the team seems like it would be really hard to have a credible villain without doing so.
|
|
|
Post by String on Sept 14, 2016 17:43:24 GMT -5
With the Rao storyline from the pre-Rebirth JL title, I never felt that from the team. Superman's crisis of faith over Rao was interesting but I think the main focus Hitch was aiming for was, a being like Rao appears, see what he accomplishes in solving some if not most of humanity's ills and then see the moral questioning that arises from that. For example, if Rao cures poverty or disease, then is it wrong to oppose him and perhaps reverse these solutions? Hitch seemed to take quite a bit of time to explore those consequences with Batman being the main opponent and pragmatist.
In this new Rebirth title, the dynamic has changed. They don't know 'this' Superman and they seem split on whether to involve him or not in their missions. Diana is convinced of his sincerity (based in part on her experiences from Action Comics which was a nice touch), Barry is trusting from the start while Bruce is wary and unconvinced. With this threat, I think Hitch has shown them as capable while dealing with this new dynamic. The wild cards are the rookie GLs. They were kinda forced upon the League by Hal but they are not Hal, they do not have his experience nor knowledge and it shows. I do think they come off better portrayed than in their own current GL title though.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Sept 14, 2016 19:06:42 GMT -5
With the Rao storyline from the pre-Rebirth JL title, I never felt that from the team. Superman's crisis of faith over Rao was interesting but I think the main focus Hitch was aiming for was, a being like Rao appears, see what he accomplishes in solving some if not most of humanity's ills and then see the moral questioning that arises from that. For example, if Rao cures poverty or disease, then is it wrong to oppose him and perhaps reverse these solutions? Hitch seemed to take quite a bit of time to explore those consequences with Batman being the main opponent and pragmatist. In this new Rebirth title, the dynamic has changed. They don't know 'this' Superman and they seem split on whether to involve him or not in their missions. Diana is convinced of his sincerity (based in part on her experiences from Action Comics which was a nice touch), Barry is trusting from the start while Bruce is wary and unconvinced. With this threat, I think Hitch has shown them as capable while dealing with this new dynamic. The wild cards are the rookie GLs. They were kinda forced upon the League by Hal but they are not Hal, they do not have his experience nor knowledge and it shows. I do think they come off better portrayed than in their own current GL title though. That pre-rebirth story-line seems pretty decent I might need to check that out.
|
|
|
Post by wildfire2099 on Oct 10, 2016 10:35:46 GMT -5
Red One #3 Dorison/Dodson I remeber really liking the first 2 issues of Red One, back last year when they came out, and was really sad that was all there was. It's back, now, but barely recognizible to me. The original was a fun, exaggerated period piece, this one is now clear parody. Red One now wants to be a porn star for.. reasons... so that the fringes of society can be represented, I guess. The bad guy is 'The Carpenter' who is from a old move is is basically the Christian Right personified. I'm not sure 1977 makes sense for that sort of character, (earlier or later, sure). Dodson's art is great (especially for 'Good Girl' art fans), but the story has totally gone off the rails. Plot: 1/5 Art 4.5/5 Overall: 5.5/10
|
|