|
Post by Reptisaurus! on May 25, 2018 6:32:37 GMT -5
I really think Sal Buscema got quite a bit better in the '80s... and better still in the early '90s.
|
|
|
Post by rberman on May 25, 2018 19:56:25 GMT -5
|
|
|
Post by rberman on May 26, 2018 21:02:53 GMT -5
New Mutants #5 (July 1983) {Spoiler}
Dani is still the favored team member by Claremont, getting solo time as a captive of Viper while the rest of the team has to compete for the limited space they are given in this issue. And, most importantly, Claremont is working harder than ever to distance the team from Xavier. I've explained in previous issues how much of a challenge Xavier presents to any X-Men writer. When he is with the team, he inhibits their ability to grow, mature, and even experience all that much tension as he is always guiding them every step of the way. It's bad storytelling, and even Stan Lee and Roy Thomas clearly struggled with this prior to Claremont. But, if you ditch Xavier entirely, the very X-Men premise is shaken, and you end up with just another superhero team lacking distinction. So Claremont has been trying for a different approach for this team, keeping Xavier and his school in the foreground, but constantly distancing the team from him and giving them (and us) reason to mistrust him. First, we had the whole Brood Queen fiasco, but now that this is resolved, we're receiving more clear signs than ever that the team and Xavier are not going to be one perfectly united front. Sure, Claremont is careful to show us by the close that Xavier is neither evil nor uncaring,but the mistrust is heavily sewed, and Buscema does his best to make the reader fear Xavier as well. Buscema is still deliberate in his penciling to make these kids feel like innocent, and often awkward, kids, but the pencils are never more awkward than they need to be. Rahne's transformation needed this facelift. Minor Details:- Berto has a sister. Further indication that his family is extremely wealthy, as well. A disappointing choice for a story, but nothing about the execution, itself, is lacking, and I love what Claremont and Buscema are doing with Xavier. grade: B• Team America, ugh. Why not foist this wrap-up plot on a book that wasn’t just five issues old? I can’t imagine Claremont was pleased with what surely must have been an editorial mandate. They are appearing at the county fair as an added, extra-cost attraction, to raise money for Cowboy’s cycle school. Is that a legitimate charity? Sounds like a for-profit venture. Does it teach homeless kids how to be Evel Knievel or something? • Does Xavier have a photo or painting of Jean Grey on the wall of his study? • The County Fair has a peep show? Weird. Sam definitely notices it. • Cowboy thinks Roberto is Spanish because he says “Obrigado.” I think Claremont is making fun of Cowboy for being a moron. • Xi’an’s power sounds great, but her track record is around 25% in actually choosing targets who are susceptible. I guess the saving throw against her attack must be pretty low. • I must admit it was chivalrous for Silver Samurai to refuse to unsheathe his sword when fighting children. Xi’an and Sam just get thwacked with his scabbard. He only pulls the blade out when the Dark Rider aims a motorcycle his way. • Where did Dani get the Dark Rider togs? • For the first time but not the last, Dani awakens a prisoner, in different clothes than those in which she was captured. She’s wearing a green jumpsuit which looks like a smaller version of Viper’s clothing. I guess that’s all the women’s clothing that Viper has lying around her lair. • When Stevie thinks of an unsettling point of comparison for Xavier, her mind goes to the world of orchestral music, namely Mussorgsky’s “Night on Bald Mountain.” That makes sense for a ballet dancer; Claremont continues to give the different characters different thoughts. • The colorist gave Roberto an Anglo hand during the meeting in Team America’s apartment. Whoops! • Xavier says that Team America is a “projecting gestalt.” Wait, the whole team is a single mutant? They’re not even the same age! It would make more sense if one of them was the mutant, or if the whole team got powers from some common exposure to weird magic or science. • Dani’s been captured by super-villains, and Xavier thinks the need of the moment is training Team America, “lest the random use of their power brings more harm to innocents”? That’s dumb. The kids know it. Even dumb Sam knows it. Can’t Tom Corsi help? He’s apparently just hanging around the mansion giving exposition.
|
|
|
Post by rberman on May 27, 2018 13:26:09 GMT -5
New Mutants #6 (August 1983) Sure, the team only gets 12 out of 22 pages in their own book this issue, as nine pages are allocated (once again) to Team America, and one to setting up the plot for an upcoming X-Men storyline, but at least this dividing of attentions allows the team to once more test and define themselves apart from Xavier, free of both his overbearing persona and the safety net he provides. The team has now completed seven missions, zero of which were done under the supervision of Xavier. They are rapidly developing their own identity and sense of right and wrong, given a baptism of fire in a scary world that offers them no beginners' courses. This team is already proving themselves superior to their predecessors in that respect; Xavier has never been there to guide nor save them. Minor Details:- This is now the second time a member of the team has referred to themselves as "The New Mutants": I always assumed it was just a title and nod to Stan Lee. Within Marvel 616 continuity, who named them this...and why? A largely forgettable issue, especially with half of it given over to another team on a separate (but mildly related) mission. I think the cover, with the blasted letters and reactive corner box, is actually my favorite part. The story itself? Not so much. Grade: C+• The kids were at a county fair in New York last issue. Now they’re in… San Francisco? Did they steal Moria’s hovercar? This story has a lot of problems, but the biggest one is thematic, because it begins a series of issues that take our students out of the school environment. Surely the “school” aspect of the series hasn’t been exhausted already? • Xi’an believes that Xavier is “in Mexico aiding Team America” with the mission demanded of them by Viper, but actually Xavier has parked the Blackbird halfway between the Mexican border and San Francisco, so that he keep both teams barely within telepathic range. I thought his range was longer than that. Haven’t we seen him talk cross-country before? Especially with Cerebro. • Hey, Xi’an’s powers worked for a change! On her uncle’s bodyguards, who look more like call girls. • Xi’an has a new power: Not just to possess people, but to make them go to sleep. (Xavier shows that power later this issue also.) Does that mean she can make herself go to sleep? I would love that power. It’s the little things that count. • Silver Samurai advises Viper to kill Dani because he can see Dani’s “untamed spirit” as she paces her cell. Later, he tries to kill Rahne, though he only grazes her side. This goes against his chivalrous “don’t harm kids” behavior last issue. • Harada and Viper discus events from Wolverine’s mini-series and eventually go to Japan, where they tangle with the X-Men prior to Wolverine’s wedding. At first, Claremont did a good job of weaving these separate books into one coherent story. • Team America end up at the A.I.M. fortress “Black Mesa.” Does Black Mesa have a portal to an alien dimension, as it does in the Half-Life video games? I suppose it’s a generic enough name for the game to come up with independently, but it could also have been lingering in the subconscious of the game designers from when they read these comics as kids. • After Lobo and Reddy travel all the way from New York to New Mexico, then ride their bikes for hours over rugged terrain into Mexico, just as they get to the Black Mesa base, Xavier decides they need a nap, so he puts them to sleep, and they don’t contribute to the Black Mesa infiltration at all. Next time just leave them home! So it’s up to Wrench (the mechanic) and Honcho to sneak inside to steal the crystal. Hey, they rode just as far! Don’t they get a nap? I suspect the absurd “nap” part was Claremont papering over some problem that arose in writing or drawing this issue. He really didn’t have enough to do for all of Team America to justify their arduous cross-country journey through Mexico as a group. • A.I.M. was working on “Project: Matrix,” which was unfamiliar to me. This appears to be a new Claremont creation, not existing Marvel continuity. We never hear of Project:Matrix or Black Mesa again after this issue. • Both the Black Mesa base and Viper’s Big Sur base employs female as well as male goons. Claremont was big on this sort of gender equality, as previously seen with the male and female flunkies of the Hellfire Club. • At the moment the Black Mesa base explodes for unexplained reasons, someone in it (Apparently Xavier's old foe Farouk) psychically attacks Xavier, who is way up in Colorado. He also speaks to Xi’an (even further away up in Big Sur, California) and somehow rescues her from the ocean when Viper decides to detonate that base as well. Seems like a plot hole, but we’ve already discussed reasons for Claremont to excise Karma from the plot. • Xi’an possesses two Viper goons and has then “attack their comrades” off-panel. They were carrying guns, so should we assume that Xi’an had them shoot their comrades? But at the beginning of the issue, she was all “The New Mutants do not kill” where her uncle was concerned. But I guess he’s family. • Lobo embraces his mutanthood and summons the Dark Rider to possess him. I’m still not clear how this whole biker team are all mutants who happen to have the same power. Once again, changing his regular clothes into a black outfit and mask appears to be part of Dark Rider’s power. • By sunrise, Team America has ridden their bikes from Mexico halfway to San Francisco, where Xavier parked the Blackbird in the mountainous wilderness along the Colorado River. I think “infinite gasoline” and "teleportation" must be among their mutant powers as well. Xavier and Lilandra are unconscious when they arrive, having been knocked out hours ago by Farouk while Team America was still at Black Mesa. • There’s a colorist’s error: Honcho is shown carrying Cowboy up to the Blackbird after the two of them battled A.I.M. troops. Cowboy is blond, but here he’s shown as a redhead. Reddy is actually the redhead on Team America, because of course people surnamed Reddy (which is a surname for Asian Indians, by the way) are all redheads, right? • Xi’an jokes with Dani about how fetching she looks wearing Viper’s slinky suit. Dani is quite embarrassed, which is surprising from our Nature Girl. Next issue she boasts loudly about her willingness to wear skimpy Mardi Gras clothes, and then follows through on it with something far more revealing than the Viper catsuit she wears here. So this panel is just a writing blunder. Dani should have told Xi’an, “Heck yeah! I’m rocking this green slinky thang!” • I’ll give Claremont credit for packing plenty of both characterization and plot into this issue, while covering separate break-ins at bad guy bases by two different teams.
|
|
|
Post by rberman on May 28, 2018 7:12:47 GMT -5
New Mutants #7 (September 1983) But whereas Claremont previously would have used an unsupervised New Mutants adventure to further explore Dani or Shan (the characters he's favored up until now), he turns the spotlight instead on Berto, a character who has been woefully underdeveloped until now. No longer... There it is: grief over his lost girlfriend and a ton of survivor guilt. The happy-go-lucky cavalier of previous issues is gone, replaced with a character who makes more sense and elicits more empathy from the reader. And, as that final panel shows, Sam gets some much-needed development as well, playing the role of wise older brother to Berto (who recalls his own personal tragedy here for the first time since Marvel Graphic Novel #4) while also letting off a playful side that is overeager about meeting girls. If all of that wasn't enough, we get so many human moments in this issue, from the awkward fight between Roberto's parents at dinner that the entire team has to witness, to playing around in a costume shop like the children they are. This is a very (meta)human-centered story, the action feeling obligatory and almost unwelcome when it finally arrives. Claremont does characters best, and he's finally interested in characterizing the entire team. All the weird disconnect between MGN #4 and the first few issues of this story finally gets put aside as of this issue, as does the favoring of two characters at the expense of the rest of the team. In a weird way, THIS feels like the true New Mutants #1, and the stretch I love most gets started with the events of the next issue. Minor Details:From a characterization perspective, things are really getting cooking as of this issue. This finally feels like a true team, made up of characters I actually care about. grade: A-• After the first six issues being almost entirely about Danielle Moonstar, we shift focus in this issue to Roberto DaCosta, who is best understood in the context of his family, so our action has to shift to Rio de Janiero, even though this means that the kids are obviously not in school as they ought to be. It also has the salubrious effect of getting them away from Xavier, who always causes plot problems. Claremont gives us lots of information about Roberto’s family tree. His paternal grandparents grew up in rural squalor, moved to the city, and got jobs at a prince’s mansion. His father Emmanuel grew up in that mansion, somehow became very wealthy by the time he was 20 years old (we’re not told how, but in the 80s, the drug trade comes to mind). He bought the mansion and moved his own family, and his parents, into it. We never see these grandparents, though; perhaps they are dead by now. • Roberto’s mother is a (Brazilian?) archeologist who grew up with money and spends all her time on the job. Nevertheless, she somehow gets to Big Sur to meet the kids within a few hours of the explosion of Viper’s fortress there. • Storm shuts down Rahne’s offer to try to track Xi’an, saying she wishes Logan were here. But he’s not! So why are you turning down the tracker you do have? Dumb, dumb. Also, Rahne wouldn’t have asked permission to look for Xi’an. She would have just done it. • Good characterization with the kids’ varied reactions to seeing Roberto’s parents arguing. Also, Rahne’s eyes are colored green in this issue, but they’re usually blue. • More good characterization with the kids’ varied reactions to Carnivale. Sam gawks at the pretty girls and tells Rahne that she is beautiful. But then he calls her “sport” to cover over his attraction to her. Dani is back in full Nature Girl mode here, declaring her intent to dress skimpily and then calling her eye-popping outfit too modest. Rahne dresses like Belle from Beauty and the Beast (before that movie came out, mind you). Roberto dresses like Conan, prefiguring the Hyborian adventure the kids are about to have in the Amazon rain forest. • Bobby again assumes that his daddy’s money can fix all his problems. The perils of growing up with everything!
|
|
|
Post by sabongero on May 28, 2018 7:34:03 GMT -5
I need to get the entire run of this series and check it out. This thread has me itching to read the entire run. It seemed like it has depth in storytelling.
|
|
|
Post by badwolf on May 28, 2018 9:11:35 GMT -5
That scene of Bobby's parents fighting (and the kids' reactions) really hit home with me at the time.
|
|
|
Post by rberman on May 29, 2018 5:32:36 GMT -5
New Mutants #8 (October 1983) Thus begins what feels like a new chapter for this franchise. At first, The New Mutants were the fill-ins Xavier needed while the X-Men were presumed dead, and Xavier got to dominate the scope of the title as their sometimes-benefactor/sometimes-shadowy-nemesis in that time. But now, with the X-Men returned, the New Mutants have the option of either becoming young copies of The X-Men or of becoming something entirely separate and different. Claremont goes for the latter, having the team set off on an adventure in the vein of the classic Golden Age adventure comics, from Terry and The Pirates to Uncle Scrooge: Uncharted worlds and lost civilizations. It seldom gets more fun than this! Minor Details:- Dani can now summon precise images from people's heads without exhausting herself - Sam can now maneuver while blasting - In New Mutants #2 we were told that Berto becomes near-invulnerable in his mutant form. This is blatantly contracted here, when we are expressly told that invulnerability is not part of his power. Grade: A-• So, time for a “lost world” romance right out of Doyle and Burroughs! I complained about Buscema previously, but this page of Wolvesbane stalking through the jungle is just gorgeous, and also well colored to give depth of field to the different foliage. • The first five pages are a typical “Meet the team; let’s see all their powers in action” routine that we’ve seen many times in the Danger Room, cluing new readers in on who everybody is. • Of all the people to get surprised by Rahne’s “Hide and Seek,” the one character who shares psychic rapport with her (Dani) would have been at the bottom of my list. • I like seeing a character get sunstroke in a hot environment; we ought to see more of that. But Dani acts as if the X-uniform is part of the problem. I thought those suits somehow helped protect against both temperature extremes. But it does make sense that Rahne alone wears her suit near-constantly, given the nature of her mutation. • Dani’s blizzard is only in Rahne’s mind, so it won’t actually help if she really is overheated. In fact, by encouraging her to move around more, it could make things worse. • I wonder what “telemetry readings” they can send Xavier from the jungle that will give him any sort of basis to evaluate their performance. I continue to wonder whether they have any academic subjects in their school. • Nature Girl Dani is back for four pages in a bikini. It’s fan-servicey, especially for a teen character, but at least she’s not drawn as a DD. • Dani and Sam are accosted by four “savage women” armed with spears and long daggers. Even if we accept that Dani and Sam are well trained enough in combat to win 2-1 without using their powers, why does Sam take one of these three apparent savages captive? What does he intend to do with her? And why do the other three abandon her? Especially when she turns out to be a Nova Roma noble who wouldn’t have been sent on shore patrol in the first place. It’s a series of surprising reveals, but they make no sense in retrospect. • Is the boat captain an American? He calls the tribeswomen “Indians.” • Archeologist mom comes in handy for pointing out the incongruities in the “Indian’s” weaponry. It also gives Claremont a chance to mention the fictional Hovito tribe that we all came to know in Raiders of the Lost Ark. Mom also mentions the Jivaro tribe, a real tribe, which she claims is Amazonian, but actually they are further northwest, in Ecuador and Peru. • The Amazon River expedition arrives at the fictional “Maderia” mountains, which Dani claims are more impressive than the Rocky Mountains. The name is close to the actual Portugese word “Madeira” which gives its name to a mountainous island off the coast of Europe. • Castro’s death plot involves letting the ship with the kids go down a “tributary” of the Amazon with a waterfall. But the ship has been traveling upstream away from the ocean into the jungle, and tributaries feed into rivers, not out of them. So if the boat drifts, it will simply glide downstream, back toward safety. Come on, Claremont! They would have to have come up a waterfall at some point to be in danger now of going down a waterfall. • We discover that Amara is actually a blonde Roman. I doubt that is a thing.
|
|
|
Post by rberman on May 30, 2018 6:02:15 GMT -5
New Mutants #9 (November 1983) I'm not sure I'm buying into the political intrigues of Nova Roma here, with two factions vying for power. The New Mutants, themselves, are drugged for much of this story and have no real horse in this race beyond the leader of one faction being the one who threw them in the arena and has secret plans for them. This actually felt a lot like issue #7, where we spent all this time on the complex relationship between Berto's parents without it really involving the team at all. While Claremont writes these kids extremely well, it still sometimes feels like he's trying to avoid using them -- Team America, the DaCosta marriage, and now all this Nova Roma stuff while the team functions as drugged, mindless minions for almost the entire issue. Can we get a little New Mutants in The New Mutants? Important Details:- 1st appearance of Selene Minor Details:- Amara begins experiencing early symptoms of her mutant powers. What are the chances that The New Mutants would run into a mutant in Nova Roma right before her powers began to manifest?? Random moment of reflection: As much as I loved (and love) this team in its classic iteration, it's sad to consider just how forgotten most of these characters will become down the road. I don't know the current state of the X-comics (and, from what I hear, neither does Marvel ), but even a decade after this issue, Dani, Amara, and Shan will be all but forgotten, Berto will be a secondary character in the X-Force mythos, and only Sam and Rahne will be getting any real use in the Marvel Universe. Prior to this, it seems like virtually every new mutant in the X-Men universe mattered, but this team will prove to be the first disposable mutants in the Marvel Universe. Generally forgettable issue with too much setup and not enough New Mutants. Grade: C+• Roberto wants to bust free from the Roman guards and find his mom; Dani counsels patience and plans to ask the guards for help. When the kids get locked up instead, Roberto sarcastically retorts, “They certainly are being helpful, Dani.” • Amara claims that half of the city is descended from Incas. We will not see a single citizen who appears Incan. Even Selene, who claims to be Incan, looks Anglo. Then again, Dani herself is colored Anglo throughout most of this issue. (See pics below.) • Amara claims to have been roaming the jungle in blackface and loincloth because she’s part of a political opposition that would embarrass her politician father. This is a lie. Actually, her father sent her out of the city to keep her from getting sacrificed to the volcano-gods by Selene. Her lie doesn’t even make sense, because she tells the kids that her father is a known member of the political opposition himself. • The quarrel in Nova Roma is whether their society should stay a Republic, like ancient Rome, or become a monarchy like the Incas. I like the idea of villains whose goal is more clearly defined than “take over the world.” Both sides show themselves plenty ruthless, including Amara’s father. • During the girls’ drunken bath scene, Rahne says again that her hair doesn’t grow: • If we’re going to see the girls in the bath, at least there’s some equal opportunity with the boys chained to the wall in diapers. If it’s equal opportunity, does that make it less exploitative, or more? • In the arena, the boys fight giant spiky steamrollers driven by unclear locomotive force. • It makes no sense to claim that Roberto is super-strong but not super-tough. The two must go together. If not, his super-strong muscles would rip his regular bones to shreds with every contraction. You can’t fire a bullet out of a gun made of tissue paper. • And despite this claim, Bobby survives not one but two collisions with full-speed Sam with minimal effect on him. • Drugged Rahne admits her love for Sam:
|
|
|
Post by rberman on May 31, 2018 5:57:44 GMT -5
New Mutants #10 (December 1983) Nope. Not enjoying this portion of the run as much as I did the first time. Maybe I need to give it a few more issues, wait for Illyana, Warlock, and Doug Ramsey to enter the equation. While Claremont still throws us bursts of great characterization, a lot of the time it still feels like he's fumbling with these characters. Throwing in obligatory romantic tensions, for example (Rahne for Sam, Dani and Berto for each other) is appropriate for the age group but feels forced and inorganic here. Claremont just chucks it to us as if to say, "Here. Characterization. Have some." It didn't develop naturally over a span of issues; it was just told to us all at once. I DO like how he handles Berto here, though. The once care-free cavalier womanizer shows a very different side of himself: The rest of the story is what it is; political intrigue with the New Mutants as pawns in a larger game, a generic evil mutant setting herself up as an evil goddess, conveniently preparing to unleash herself upon the world right after she deals with this one last sacrifice, and Amara's first appearance as Magma (itself an absurd convenience). Important Details:- 1st appearance of Amara Aquilla as MagmaMinor Details:- Rahne has a crush on Sam - Dani and Berto have crushes on one another - Claremont previously stirred the pot by putting a devout Catholic (Nightcrawler) and an agnostic Jew (Kitty Pryde) on the X-Men, but scores another point for diversity by having TWO devout Christians on this team, finally giving them space to have a fleeting discussion about their shared beliefs in this story: - Should we be offended by this? I mean, even though we've never been told what tribe Dani is from, they are North American natives, not South American natives. I've got to think they'd look a little different from one another, especially to Dani and the Inca themselves. - This is now the second time in four issues that Dani has woken up in captivity, someone having changed her clothing into something inappropriately seductive while she was sleeping: More uncomfortable yet, in both cases, all of the villains' minions appeared to be adult men. Who exactly undressed and redressed her while she was unconscious?? This story still isn't doing it for me, but at least the team gets to play a vital role in the story this time. grade: B-• Dani tells us again that the city is half Inca. Still haven’t seen any Incas. • Castro, pretending to be Gallio’s enemy rather than his employee, spits in his face. That seems a bit too far. • As you mentioned, for the second time in this series, Dani awakens to find herself a captive dressed in suggestive clothing, for a sequence that takes up a full seven pages. This time she’s one of three bikini-and-chainmail-loincloth clad sacrificial victims headed for the volcano to rejuvenate Selene, the succubus/sorceress. What, the volcano rejects virgins dressed in togas? Nah, it's just more teen cheesecake. At this point, we’re in a straight-up Conan homage. Dani being Dani, she’s not embarrassed by the (lack of) clothing but recognizes its significance. • Bobby’s knowledge of Latin was protested in a subsequent letters column on grounds that the language in Nova Roma would have evolved over the previous 2,000 years to become unintelligible from ancient Latin. Quite right, probably combined with the Inca tongue as well. But it is an opportunity to remind us that Bobby is high bred, with a fancy education. Sam certainly wasn’t learning Latin in Kentucky’s public schools, even before he dropped out to become the family breadwinner.
|
|
|
Post by rberman on Jun 1, 2018 6:17:38 GMT -5
New Mutants #11 (January 1984) I'm beginning to see Roquefort Raider 's point about Selene. Last issue, she had telepathic powers. Now she can shape stones and shoot energy beams. How many mutant abilities does she possess?? I'm glad to see this storyline concluded. While I liked the idea of finding a lost world and getting the New Mutants away from Professor X long enough to find their own identity as a team, I had zero interest in the political intrigues of Nova Roma, and really, neither did The New Mutants until one of the two leaders tried to kill them. Selene, as an additional complication, presents no specific personality nor threat to the team beyond the obvious attempts to kill them. All in all, this three parter made for a wholly forgettable story, good only for delivering an under-characterized new teammate and a generic villain. Important Details:- 1st full appearance of Magma Minor Details:- Berto is reunited with his mother and learned his father was behind the sabotaging of her expedition - Berto attempts to kill Selene (twice) Grade: C-• We open with another six pages of bikini Dani and Magma tangling with Selene, who gives Dani a psychic taste of ecstasy, thinking it will bind Dani to her. Dani certainly enjoys it but turns out not to be so easily controlled. However, Claremont would return to this same theme in the regrettable issue #4 of the X-Men/Micronauts miniseries, when evil Xavier gives Dani a psychic orgasm that makes her his mind-slave. • Selene (who just called Dani and her friends “The New Mutants”, by the way) sucks the life-force from Amara, who crumples into Dani’s arms. But a few pages later, Amara bursts through the floor of Gallio’s court, powered up, if disoriented. I feel like we missed a scene of Selene failing to stop Amara’s recovery and escape. Also, Selene appears to be sparing the New Mutants to be her minions because they have mutant powers. So why doesn't this change her plans to suck the life force from Amara, once Amara also is revealed as a mutant? • Coming to rescue his friends at Gallio’s court, Roberto swings in from… somewhere. Surely he would have just run into the room, but artists never miss an Errol Flynn opportunity. Also, he too calls his friends “The New Mutants.” • Once again, Dani has been forcibly re-wardrobed into the spare clothing of her villainous captor. (The last time that happened was with Viper, and last issue her clothes were changed from toga to bikini while she was unconscious.) • Bobby doesn’t hesitate to throw Selene into the lava pool. He later says he suspects that she can survive it, but obviously he has no way of knowing that.
|
|
|
Post by rberman on Jun 2, 2018 7:52:44 GMT -5
New Mutants #12 (February 1984) When I read this run for the first time back in my twenties, it never once occurred to me that Amara was going to join the New Mutants. She had no characterization, a terrible visual look that seemed to be concocted as an after-thought, her only purpose in the Nova Roma story seemed to be to connect the team to one of the two warring political factions, and, as that story borrowed heavily from the Golden Age adventure comics, the native allies those adventurers ran into never became regular recurring cast members. So I really didn't see this coming. And I'm still not sure I understand it. Only a handful of issues back, Claremont discarded Shan (who everyone now seems to have forgotten about) presumably because Claremont didn't know what to do with her, and now we've got a new under-characterized team member to deal with. Amara's one fascinating characteristic thus far, revealed late in the story, being her inner hatred for herself and for all mutants. But how weird to suddenly jump from last issue (in which Amara was a supporting character) to this one, in which the entire focus of the story is Amara fitting in as a new member of the team? The entire thing feels completely forced, including our having to be told (never shown) that Sam has a crush on Amara and that Dani and Amara are now best friends. Nothing subtle about any of this. It isn't bad; it's just that you can so clearly see the strings Claremont is trying to pull, and so the illusion isn't really working. I'm not accepting this new teammate as easily as Claremont wants us to believe the team has in the space between last issue and this one. The one powerful part of this story was Berto's confrontation with his father; less the confrontation itself and more Berto's mature realization afterward that righteous indignation doesn't win the war. His mother gives the sagely advice that: Pretty mature moral to insert into a superhero mag, especially as we watch Berto's anger at his father drive the man to accept the Hellfire Club's invitation. For once in comics, love and restraint, not moral outrage, is the solution to the problem, and Berto has fumbled in that execution. Important Details:- Magma joins (or rather already has joined) The New Mutants Minor Details:- Wait. If Sam grabs Berto while in flight, Berto can use his super strength to lift stuff while Sam's blasting makes him invulnerable to the strain? Couldn't Sam just lift the damn thing himself since he's carrying all that weight with his own powers anyway?? - Thus begins an unsettling trend in which a team that originally seemed grounded in a sincere attempt at diversity begins recruiting blonde haired/blue eyed white kids at an alarming speed. We've got Amara in this issue, illyana in two issues, and Doug a few more issues down the road. Pretty soon the roster will look as follows: White, blonde haired, blue eyesSam Amara Illyana Doug WhiteRahne Non-whiteDani Berto (and, of course, these two end up romantically interested in one another) Non-humanWarlock Give it up for diversity... A better issue than the last few, but it hinges upon our abrupt and unbridled acceptance of Amara. I did like Berto's confrontation with his dad. Grade: B-• Now it’s time for the kids to teleport from deep in the Andes of the Amazon, back to Rio de Janiero. Three problems: First, how did they make this journey? Their boat was smashed. • Second, are the Nova Romans really going to risk letting these outsiders go blab about their long-hidden land? Seems dubious. • Third: There are no mountains deep in the Amazon in the first place. The Andes run along the Western border of South America, through Peru, Bolivia, Argentina, and Chile. Brazil is further east. So Claremont’s attempt to place this story along the Amazon but also nestled in an Andean valley would be like having the kids sail up the Mississippi Rriver for an adventure set at NORAD, in Colorado. (in fairness, there was an airport scene at one point.) See the yellow section on the map below: • This issue has a nice contrast between two fathers. Emmanuel da Costa was partially restraining his own evil ambitions to maintain his relationship with his son Roberto. So when Roberto leaves, Emmanuel runs immediately into partnership with Sebastian Shaw. Senator Aquilla, on the other hand, would prefer to keep his relationship with his daughter but must send her away in order to protect his community from her uncontrolled lava powers. • Now, we’ve previously seen that Senator Aquila is not a sentimental guy; he will sacrifice individuals, even innocents, for the Cause. And he’s already had his daughter running around in the jungle dressed in blackface for who-knows-how-long, so this latest banishment may come even easier to him. I don’t recall that we get to see Amara grappling with abandonment issues much down the line, though. • It seems that Claremont “killed off” Karma to make room for Magma on the team. It’s a missed opportunity that he made her a blonde Anglo, from a society where we’re told that half the people are Inca. Her dad is even a commoner elevated to nobility (just like Roberto’s dad! Parallelism!), so surely he would have some Inca blood. Then the team could have had two mixed-race Brazilians, from different cultures yet similar family backgrounds, to provide some interesting opportunities for conflict and romance. But Amara’s extraordinary background rapidly fades into the background, and she becomes just another one of the many white blondes on the team. • I don’t think we ever did learn how all the Nova Romans speak English, did we? • Where does Dani take Amara in Rio? To the beach of course? So cue the Nature Girl again. Claremont never misses an opportunity for that. This issue's central plot conceit is that Amara, who's been living out in the open in the steamy Amazon jungle, can't handle the heat of the beach weather, even though her mutant power is to become a lava monster. I call shenanigans. • The center of this issue is a cautionary tale about sexual harassment, as Amara’s “Me Too” moment turns volcanic. • Rahne finally gets a snippet of personal development. She’s lovesick over Sam, who is paying more attention to princess Amara, and worried about the differences between Catholicism and Presbyterianism. She’s also miffed at being appreciated only as a tracker, and sure enough, in runs Sam, asking for her to be a tracker. Bad timing! • So! Lots of plot holes in this run of New Mutants, but overall, I like it. One issue of family drama in Rio followed by four issues of Roman adventure in the jungle and then one issue of wrap-up back in Rio. It’s a perfect “There and Back Again” structure: the journey into faerie and back again, complete with a tunnel to a lost world, witches, characters discovering unknown depth of power and courage, etc. Joseph Campbell should be proud.
|
|
|
Post by rberman on Jun 4, 2018 11:51:16 GMT -5
Well, color me super-confused about whether Bobby knows Latin. Remember this? I just got the final trade paperback of X-Treme X-Men to catch up on what Kitty Pryde was doing just prior to Joss Whedon's Astonishing X-Men run. Apparently Sam Guthrie and Amara are dating-ish, and we get this exchange when Amara arrives with Bobby Drake and Bobby DaCosta: Is this a plot hole? This issue (X-Treme X-Men #42, 2004) was written by Chris Claremont, for cryin' out loud! If he doesn't know that Bobby DaCosta's Latin knowledge was a plot point in New Mutants, then why do I? Three other things I noticed: First, Bobby and Skids are wearing the Grant Morrison-era X-jackets. Those were new with Grant, right? Also, Igor Kordey is on art, and he does not suck. It's not my favorite, and some of the faces are sometimes wonky, but it's head and shoulders above his rushed New X-Men work from a couple of years prior. And third, is Amara some kind of giant Amazon now? She's as tall as Sam! Edited to add: Oh, a fourth question. A major plot line in this X-Treme X-Men arc is the presence of a drug called "Rave" that enhances mutant powers substantially while clouding the mind. Why didn't they just call it "Kick"?
|
|