|
Post by zaku on Sept 25, 2023 4:57:07 GMT -5
I've to add something about the last Secret Wars?
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 25, 2023 5:19:32 GMT -5
I've to add something about the last Secret Wars? Absolutely, let the conversation go where it will!
|
|
|
Post by wildfire2099 on Sept 25, 2023 6:48:34 GMT -5
BEFORE CRISIS ON INFINITE EARTHS
The so-called "Pre-Crisis Multiverse" consisted on an infinite number of worlds, separated by different "vibrational frequencies". This was caused by Krona, who tampered somehow the birth of Creation creating infinite universes. You can't change the past, but you can have multiple possibile futures ( like Kamandi's future and Legion's are both possibile futures of Earth-1). Let's talk about this one a bit. I would actually say the Legion was the "main timeline" future of Pre-Crisis Earth-1. It was pretty much accepted throughout the Silver and Bronze ages that the many interactions of 20th century characters in the 30th century and vice versa was the "norm". Mon-El would start in present day, and his millenium long Phantom Zone stay would directly culminate in his cure and ability to permanently join the Legion. The Legion would just be "called up" at times, Karate Kid would come back and have an extended stay in present day, etc. I think of Kamandi more as an "alternate" timeline concept...it was still canon, it was "knowable" in that he did interact with the more mainstream DC Universe occasionally, but not "time's straight arrow" if you will. I'm not sure if it's true for every version, but I always thought both Kamandi and Legion could easily be in the same timeline... if you're talking about the right era of the Legion. The Threeboot, for instance (which is MY Legion), talked about how they didn't know much about the 20th century.. why? The Great Disaster, that's why . Kamandi made a 2nd appearance in Brave and the Bold too, #157 I think? Kamandi ends up in Gotham somehow. (#120 is far better).
|
|
|
Post by rberman on Sept 25, 2023 10:00:32 GMT -5
And Supergirl dies in Crisis, because...of what again? I don't care about Monitor/Anti-Monitor/Uncle Monitor or any of that nonsense, if they weren't a villain on the Challenge of the Super Friends I could care less. The extra-story reason was that John Byrne was coming to DC to reboot Superman, and he wanted to lean on the "Last Son of Krypton" aspect. This is hard to do if there's also Supergirl, Supergoldfish, Kandor, and more, still hanging around. He also wanted to make it a bildungsroman of Clark Kent coming into his own, which means he didn't spend his time in Smallville as Superboy. So given that Supergirl needed to go, sending her out halfway through COIE gave Superman and the other heroes an opportunity for a big emotional moment. The cover of COIE #7 deliberately recalls John Byrne's famous image on X-Men #138. Granted, Pieta imagery is extremely common in comic books, but this one is closer than most. As for "Challenge of the Super-Friends," I was of an age to enjoy that as well. But kids five or six years later would inevitably have their own new generation of preferred villains in the Darkseid mold, like Anti-Monitor and Apocalypse.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 25, 2023 10:24:15 GMT -5
So what I take away from this thread so far...it's all Jack Kirby's fault. This little nuisance that Kamandi creates for the timestream...Kirby. A breed of Darkseid like villains...Kirby. And Byrne...because he destroyed the Superman Family.
|
|
|
Post by Slam_Bradley on Sept 25, 2023 10:29:07 GMT -5
I still don't parse the problem with Kamandi. It's a possible future. That's really all the explanation that's needed.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 25, 2023 10:31:51 GMT -5
I still don't parse the problem with Kamandi. It's a possible future. That's really all the explanation that's needed. Because we have to nerd out on it man! It can't be that simple...there must be clues, references, seeming contradictions. Sure it's a possible future...but which one? Should it be given a numeric suffix of it's own? Where does it go on the BIG flippin' universe chart??!!! This is important stuff Slam.
|
|
|
Post by Slam_Bradley on Sept 25, 2023 10:55:38 GMT -5
I still don't parse the problem with Kamandi. It's a possible future. That's really all the explanation that's needed. Because we have to nerd out on it man! It can't be that simple...there must be clues, references, seeming contradictions. Sure it's a possible future...but which one? Should it be given a numeric suffix of it's own? Where does it go on the BIG flippin' universe chart??!!! This is important stuff Slam. Oh...and here I just thought they were funnybooks that you were supposed to read and enjoy.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 25, 2023 11:01:49 GMT -5
Because we have to nerd out on it man! It can't be that simple...there must be clues, references, seeming contradictions. Sure it's a possible future...but which one? Should it be given a numeric suffix of it's own? Where does it go on the BIG flippin' universe chart??!!! This is important stuff Slam. Oh...and here I just thought they were funnybooks that you were supposed to read and enjoy. Wouldn't you have to crack them out of their slabs to do that? Is that even allowed?
|
|
|
Post by Slam_Bradley on Sept 25, 2023 11:04:51 GMT -5
Oh...and here I just thought they were funnybooks that you were supposed to read and enjoy. Wouldn't you have to crack them out of their slabs to do that? Is that even allowed? They do make better coasters for your drink when they're encased in plastic. But they don't absorb as much moisture. (I've never owned a slabbed book...what's the point?)
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 25, 2023 11:14:08 GMT -5
(I've never owned a slabbed book...what's the point?) Neither have I! In all seriousness, it's a good callout that no matter how much we debate the pre-Crisis Kamandi/Legion thing, they were explicitly represented at some point (again, this is specific to Pre-Crisis era) as being alternate futures, both with some canon interactions with 20th century mainstream characters. My only point in calling out the Legion future as the "mainstream" one was based on the tremendous volume of stories and how woven Legion lore is into the overall DC mythos, so much falls apart retroactively if that future did not come to be, but again I'm not trying to make some "technical" conclusive argument. Sorry for the rabbit hole! Anybody want to talk about Zero Hour?
|
|
|
Post by Slam_Bradley on Sept 25, 2023 11:28:41 GMT -5
(I've never owned a slabbed book...what's the point?) Neither have I! In all seriousness, it's a good callout that no matter how much we debate the pre-Crisis Kamandi/Legion thing, they were explicitly represented at some point (again, this is specific to Pre-Crisis era) as being alternate futures, both with some canon interactions with 20th century mainstream characters. My only point in calling out the Legion future as the "mainstream" one was based on the tremendous volume of stories and how woven Legion lore is into the overall DC mythos, so much falls apart retroactively if that future did not come to be, but again I'm not trying to make some "technical" conclusive argument. Sorry for the rabbit hole!Anybody want to talk about Zero Hour? Confessor has to have somewhere to live. I didn't understand Zero Hour when it came out.
|
|
|
Post by zaku on Sept 25, 2023 11:50:28 GMT -5
POST SECRET WARS (2015)Small premise: Before SW, Marvel had never had a mega-event where the universe was rebooted like DC's various Crises. The reasons were various. The Marvel universe was relatively young and therefore didn't have the same baggage as the Distinct Competition. Alternate Earths also existed in Marvel but until recently had never been as important as they were in pre-COIE DC. It was preferred to resolve any contradictions in continuity with ad hoc stories (or by ignoring them completely). So there was never (from their point of view) a need to create something like COIE. This changed with Secret Wars. Before that, during so-called "incursions", various universes had been destroyed (included the main Marvel Universe and the Ultimate Universe). Following numerous incursions across the multiverse, the remains of various realities have been fused together to create a new Battleworld. Each domain is the incursion point from that reality's destruction, as this is all that remains from each one. After the saga, the Marvel Universe is rebooted, with some important differences: - Some characters who had died before and during Secret Wars have returned to life
- Some characters (like Miles Morales) have become an integral part of the 616 universe
- Some characters originating from other universes (such as Old Man Logan) found themselves living in the 616 universe
- The Ultimate universe was destroyed, but the Maker (that universe's Reed Richard) survived with his memories intact.
- The multiverse was rebuilt without the incursions having occurred
- Not all universes have been rebuilt .
But the most important thing, from a cosmological point of view, is that current Multiverse is specifically an Eight Cosmos and the Seventh died with Incursions. This means that the entire order between the various abstract entities of the Multiverse (Living Tribunal, Chaos and Order etc etc) has been completely overturned. This has been the focus of some post Secret Wars series.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 25, 2023 12:37:42 GMT -5
I read the modern Secret Wars when it came out, but I mostly remember having a hard time following the series. It felt really jumbled to me. I was trying to find my collected edition just now to give it a reread but I think it's buried in an unsorted box.
In terms of outcomes, Miles Morales is the part I remember the most and liking, he's a great character.
I feel like Marvel kind of did a prior Crisis-type event with Inferno and then Heroes Reborn in the 90's, but obviously they quickly reverted after a year back to the status quo basically with Heroes Return. So maybe that was a "mini-Crisis".
Back on modern Secret Wars, my actual favorite "crossover" that really wasn't was Deadpool's Secret Secret Wars.
|
|
|
Post by Slam_Bradley on Sept 25, 2023 13:05:52 GMT -5
I read the modern Secret Wars when it came out, but I mostly remember having a hard time following the series. It felt really jumbled to me. I was trying to find my collected edition just now to give it a reread but I think it's buried in an unsorted box. So a typical crossover event.
|
|